I did intentionally avoid clarifying this (also, technically the US is a republic) because I was trying to paint in broad strokes — I don't think my point needed details to be convincing and so I didn't want to get bogged down in them. I'm happy for the clarification as a reply, though :) A better phrase, which I would have used if I'd thought of it at the time, would be "representative government".
Well, looking at the US at least, they weren't wrong.
Eg the German electoral system is also a bit messy, but seems to work well in practice. That might be a better yardstick to measure what voting can do, before we dismiss it.
(My favourite sortition variant right now:
- everyone can register as a candidate, if they want to - every voter can pick one candidate to put on their ballot - we select a few hundred ballots at random to fill up a parliament
For completeness sake, add some mechanism to handle a single candidate being selected by more than one randomly drawn ballot. Eg you could draw again, or you could give that candidate extra weight in parliamentary votes, or you could form a chain and add a person of the double-candidates choice to parliament, or you could have voters write down multiple candidates in order, and just pick a later one on the voters list etc.
Parliament can then select the executive, like it is already done in the UK or in Germany.)
The sortition system I sketched would still reward specialisation of labour, but there would be fewer threshold effects: if you convince thirty friends friends to ballot for you, you'd have a ten times higher chance to make it into parliament compared to only convincing three friends.
With voting you have threshold effects. In all but the smallest towns, getting thirty people to vote for you has exactly the same outcome as zero votes.
If you want a classic example, some of the Greek city states might count. Though keep in mind that many of the Greeks considered sortition (ie random selection) the hallmark of the democracy, and considered that voting would just lead to aristocracy or oligarchy.
The German Free Imperial Cities are an interesting object of study. And there's lots to be learned from eg China as well.