On leaving, we would leave our attraction 20 minutes prior to the end of our shift, walk back, get changed, etc, and then clock out.
Unions matter. I'm shocked that any union would allow off the clock work like that.
More likely the cause of the disparity -- because this is actually a difference between the companies -- is that Disney tries to maintain a certain image about the wholesomeness of their enterprise which isn't worth compromising to avoid paying 8% more to workers who still aren't really making altogether that much money, and they also charge enough of a premium to be able to afford it.
Some unions serve their members very well. Some are leeches. In either case they tend to stick together to raise their political power when possible.
> ... signed-out for the previous 15 minute interval when we left our game area.
This is actually the most surprising thing to me in your story. Usually the laws about rounding in time keeping state that the rounding must go the same direction. So if they round to the next interval on start, they should also be rounding to the next interval on end.
The reason why this is the most surprising part to me, is because that's a pretty cut-and-dry labor violation. Compared to the rest that would have to go through a court case like the one in TFA.
You got your till loaded with cash, counted it out, and walked to your register. All on the clock. When done, you took your till back, counted it out, and handed it back in. All on the clock.
I'm only writing this as a counter example - not every place was awful about it.
You say it's not a lot, but that's only because the job doesn't pay a lot and (I assume) it was short term.
Not to you, but it definitely added up to a noticeable amount for your employer.
Some unions are also just in the pocket of management. I have friends who are teamster organizers and they've told me some managers in some industries will actually request unions.
Here is an article I found that goes into this: https://www.labornotes.org/2002/06/corporatization-unions
I'm curious how you think this differs from traditional practices, generally i think of signing security clauses + political influence as basic union 101.
There've always been professional organizers as long as there've been unions. They're hardly "well-paid" by private standards.
It may be "union 101" to sign no-strike clauses but there are unions like the IWW that have always rejected them.
The only time you have to accept certain parts in your contract no choice is if they are mandated by the worker's council, which is voted for democratically by workers from and for a specific company and they can veto anything the company does or demand changes with a 50% share in board votes.
Generally, the union will not make the dues optional because that is how unions collapse in the US.
I honestly believe you on this point, but that is just so crazy that I'd be curious as to the turn of events that would turn out to the union selling out its soul so completely. Unless, of course, that was their intended goal. It just seems so antithetical to the theoretical principles of a union.
See, for instance, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/20/business/gm-fiat-chrysler...
> General Motors has accused Fiat Chrysler of bribing union officials to get a leg up on G.M. in contract negotiations, contending in a lawsuit that its competitor paid for the union’s negotiating team to have a $7,000 dinner shortly after concluding a labor agreement. Fiat Chrysler has called the suit meritless.
I think many are interpreting my comment as anti-union, which it was not meant to be. Unions can be coopted by management, but better to have some sort of worker council/representation than none at all.
It’s unsettled (in America) what’s the right answer to that, but an argument against it I’ve heard is: if you get a job and the employer agrees to pay for a 10 minute commute twice per shift, but you then move 30 minutes away, why should the employer be on the hook for that extra 20 minutes (40 per shift)?
And the moment they can no longer do that is when the clock stops, ie once you've finished getting out of uniform and left.
Even then it's generally that you travel unpaid to the office, then you are paid for the travel time from there to the job site.
And yes, commuting isn’t expected, but unless you’re living at your job, you have to commute. So, saying “a commute isn’t expected, but being on time is” doesn’t make sense.
Not to mention, there are times where an employer is required to pay for your commute. The biggest is travel that is required to do your job, such as a door-to-door salesperson. That could lead to: if a commute is practically required to do your job (your house to your place of work), why not pay for that?
I personally don’t have an opinion on this; I’m just playing devil’s advocate.
I sometimes wonder if despite the brutality of their tactics, did the mafia help the working class more than hurt it?
I'm half joking but if your union dues were higher you would have been paid for that hour :-P
Rhetorical question, but what the hell was the union doing while this wage theft was going on?
Any grievance? Usually resulted in us having to request a steward/rep from multiple counties away, who knew nothing about EMS and had our contract for reference. You would know more about what the issue was or why it was inappropriate that the union rep.
You'd usually have to "pre-game" and explain why a certain thing was appropriate or inappropriate because they were used to representing truck drivers with disputes about haulage, hours, etc., and had no idea about emergency medicine, or DOT provisions for emergency vehicles.
We eventually decertified (or rather, left the union).
The only unpaid time was the walk to/from the very back of the parking lot to the main office.
Every day the workflow was as follows:
The whole thing took 20 minutes and we would signed-in to start being paid at the next 15 minute interval from when we arrived at our game.When we checked out, we did the whole process in reverse but would be signed-out for the previous 15 minute interval when we left our game area.
All in all, we were losing 40-68 minutes of wages per day. Worse if there were long lines in the office or costumes or the cash office.
Of course, we were also only paid $6.15 an hour and had to pay union dues out of that, so in total, it didn't add up to much...