News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by semaj111 on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @11:45PM (#24289936)
I am looking forward to LEO satellite networks that are connected to the Internet. Won't be easy to suppres yoir people then.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by wmf on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:09AM (#24290315)
Except that distinctive Starlink antenna becomes an "arrest me" sign.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by kardos on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:32AM (#24290432)
Unless its disguised as something else
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by owl57 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @02:24AM (#24290656)
How do you disguise a radio transmitter? It's about as futile as disguising a searchlight.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by lb1lf on Thursday August 27, 2020 @02:58AM (#24290801)
While a transmitter is indeed to a first approximation a beacon screaming 'I'm here!', do keep in mind that these antennas are highly directional, and while there will be side lobes, you basically need to be in the beam path to even detect it's there - complicating matters significantly.

Besides, the antenna itself is rather small, and can be hidden inside just about any structure transparent to RF in the relevant frequency bands - say, a seemingly innocuous water cistern on the roof, for instance.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by baybal2 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @02:50AM (#24290765)
No so fast. China tried to crack down on VSAT terminal possession for years. Up to no, to a very little effect.

Brown trucks with gobs of antennas are the guys who are tracking them down, some Chinese 3 letter service.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by hansor on Thursday August 27, 2020 @03:37AM (#24291013)
1. Narrow beam antenna (such as satellite antenna) does NOT propagate signal arround it (OMNIdirectional antennas does that). It's almost impossible to detect it unless you fly directly over the beam. Think about it as laser beam.

2. It is possible to build verious kinds of covert antennas. Radio amateurs do that all the time. Just google the term "stealth ham radio"

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by owl57 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @03:53AM (#24291106)
1. Is it expensive for TLAs to deploy drones for exactly that if the practice becomes popular? They won't even need many actual detecting drones: if they look the same as regular surveillance drones, which are already up in the sky in times of unrest, people will probably hesitate to use their transmitters.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by wongarsu on Thursday August 27, 2020 @05:19AM (#24291622)
> Think about it as laser beam.

But if you shine a powerful laser beam into the sky it is visible from pretty far away. It's highly focused, but also gets scattered a lot by the atmosphere.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by hansor on Thursday August 27, 2020 @06:18AM (#24292057)
Think about it as inivisible laser beam in terms of beam width. We are talking here 2mm wave with very directional antennas - its very hard to detect it.

That's actually how spies send data back over the satellites:

>Unlike with SW signals, a radio signal to a satellite is very difficult to intercept and trace, as the waves are 'beamed' straight up rather than all around.

https://www.cryptomuseum.com/spy/rs804/index.htm

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by ajsnigrutin on Thursday August 27, 2020 @08:56AM (#24293177)
What? There's no way to send a 2mm (width) wave. Yes, parabolic antennas have very high gains in one direction, but they're far from '2mm' and far from 'invisible'.

A helicopter with the right equipment flying over urban areas would have an easy job finding them and even pointing out the approximate location (eg. a building) where they're located. If the antenna was inside a huge apartment building, it would be hard to find the right apartment, if the transmitter was turned off, but with single family buildings, it would be easy.

Ham radio operators hide and then look for hidden transmitters for fun, so it's not that hard, especially with a budget that is given to the police.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by hansor on Thursday August 27, 2020 @07:18PM (#24299767)
>There's no way to send a 2mm (width) wave.

You are very wrong sir. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2-millimeter_band

>A helicopter with the right equipment flying over urban areas would have an easy job finding them.

That is not true. Helicopter would need to fly RIGHT into such directional and tiny beam. Which is nearly impossible to do in huge city. Even when flying 2m next to it, you would likely not detect it.

That is the reason why CIA had so much problem with pinpointing Iridium satellite phones back in Colombia in the 90's.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by ajsnigrutin on Friday August 28, 2020 @05:29AM (#24302986)
2mm is the wavelength, not the effective width (think of a laserbeam) of the wave.

and yes, even with a laser (nanometer wavelengths) it's hard to produce a 2mm wide beam at a helicopter distance.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by NortySpock on Thursday August 27, 2020 @08:15AM (#24292876)
Put it in a (plastic) box shaped like something else?

"Yeah, that's my 'compost bin'"

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by dragonwriter on Thursday August 27, 2020 @08:22AM (#24292923)
That's a nice visual disguise but it doesn't do much to help when someone with radio direction finding gear starts looking for unauthorized transmitters on the frequency it operates on.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by chii on Thursday August 27, 2020 @03:37AM (#24291016)
if the gov't starts arresting people for accessing a satellite link, it's time to start taking up arms.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by iso947 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @03:42AM (#24291035)
Setting aside the US rhetoric, many counties already ban unlicesend satelite transmitters and people don’t “take up arms”

Even in the US, constitutional rights have been waved on a mass scale for 20 years. People only take up arms to defend te right to oppress downtrodden minorities.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by jiggawatts on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:02AM (#24290276)
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by mrtksn on Thursday August 27, 2020 @02:57AM (#24290795)
They will have to turn it off over countries that don't fancy free communication and are capable to get a projectile in LEO or have a market for electric cars.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by lb1lf on Thursday August 27, 2020 @03:11AM (#24290870)
-Given the cost of a StarLink satellite (I've no idea, but seeing as they will be launched in the tens of thousands, they can hardly be a gigabuck a piece), the solution to the first problem is simply to launch more of them.

It is probably cheaper to launch a StarLink bird than it is to blow it out of orbit. Think of it as a DoS attack on the launch batteries!

As for the second? I find that approach much more likely to succeed. Sigh.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by gruturo on Thursday August 27, 2020 @07:35AM (#24292604)
Shooting down another country's satellites is an incredibly bad idea.

First, it's one of extremely few actions actually likely to get you nuked or "liberated" - you just threatened one of the most valuable strategic advantages (even if it's just a civilian satellite, it wasn't yours, and militaries will consider their satellites under threat).

Second, in case you're not aware, the remains of the satellite now are a danger to any other object in that orbital plane, and this can trigger a cascade reaction and take lots of them down, making new launches impossible for many years. Look for Kessler Syndrome.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by adventured on Thursday August 27, 2020 @09:04AM (#24293248)
> Shooting down another country's satellites is an incredibly bad idea. First, it's one of extremely few actions actually likely to get you nuked or "liberated"

Nobody is nuking anybody else over satellites. Nukes will only be used in case of regime / home territory threat (eg if Russia were losing a conventional war, and NATO were pushing toward Moscow, Russia could throw down the nuke threat card and say stop or else), or in response to the use of a nuke.

If North Korea starts shooting down US satellites at some point, it would prompt a conventional military bombing response (which would attempt to neutralize their ability to launch rockets at US satellites), and possible full-scale war. It would not prompt a nuclear retaliation. There is zero interest - anywhere - in seeing millions of people die over some satellites.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by pepesza on Thursday August 27, 2020 @06:11AM (#24292004)
Think of Kessler syndrome. One can imagine that blowing (small) N of them would create a cloud of shrapnel posing danger for the whole network. Birds are on really low orbits, so it would clear after some time, but network might not survive this.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by ric2b on Friday August 28, 2020 @05:01PM (#24309890)
Starlink satellites are in decaying orbits, eventually they fall through the atmosphere and burn away.

They have some propellant to make adjustments and stay in orbit a bit longer but if you blow them up you just make the decay process quicker.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by onion2k on Thursday August 27, 2020 @07:00AM (#24292357)
are capable to get a projectile in LEO

The plan for Starlink is to have 12,000 satellites eventually. You'd need to shoot down quite lot a of them to block access to an entire country.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by pjmorris on Thursday August 27, 2020 @08:42AM (#24293061)
I know you mean Low Earth Orbit (LEO), but it got me wondering about Law Enforcement Officer (LEO) satellite networks.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by Ninn on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:09AM (#24290312)
It still will be for the state that has authority for the given provider.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by monadic2 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @03:15AM (#24290904)
Depends who has jurisdiction over the satellites.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by chupasaurus on Thursday August 27, 2020 @04:47AM (#24291421)
The points of connection to the Internet on Earth are major weak points in the system unless there would be thousands of those.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by AndrewBissell on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:09AM (#24290313)
The internet is a massive network created by the military with the objective of surveillance baked in from its earliest origins. The LEO systems being built now will extend that network to every last corner of the globe, and the companies building them will do the bidding of the governments at whose behest they're allowed to function.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by salawat on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:28AM (#24290411)
It wasn't surveillance.

It was providing a self healing command and control network capable of surviving a nuclear attack. It evolved into a Internetwork of trusted hosts to facilitate rapid information dissemination. It took a bunch of advertisers to turn it into surveillance nirvana by realizing that you could use http requests and your own portable sensor platform and in-house OS to rake in profit overwhelming.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by pmoriarty on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:53AM (#24290532)
Advertisers might have funded a lot of it and set the direction, but they couldn't have done it without armies of technology folk.

At least early on, the latter had the excuse of lack of foresight regarding the dystopia they were building, but for decades now it's been more than obvious to everyone and most of them are continuing to cobble together their own prisons and ours.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by btilly on Thursday August 27, 2020 @03:16AM (#24290908)
It was providing a self healing command and control network capable of surviving a nuclear attack.

That's a nice myth. But it wasn't so.

As https://www.internetsociety.org/internet/history-internet/br... explains, the idea of packet switching was invented twice. The Internet came out of the invention by Leonard Kleinrock at MIT. Separately Paul Baran and others at RAND had demonstrated that packet switching could be used to build a network to survive a nuclear attack.

Even though the Internet came out of military research, it was not designed to withstand nuclear attack. As can be verified by the fact that the early network had no redundancy, and neither computers nor the network were shielded from the EMP that a nuclear bomb could be expected to emit.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by salawat on Thursday August 27, 2020 @09:01AM (#24293219)
That's cute, but I've got primary sources who indicate otherwise. I'll take the word of someone who at one point maintained a list of every addressed machine on ARPANet and the proto-Internet once it went beyond a strictly DoD effort, over a blatant attempt at trying to rewrite history to fit their own narrative, thank you. It may not have succeeded at being what they set out to make, like most things in life, but it most certainly started out in that vein. The utility as a surveillance facilitator only came much later near the Oughts, particularly after a rather notorious event in mid September when the attempt to utilize the practice of intelligence fusion and total information awareness for law enforcement and national defense purpose got a huge boost in national popular support.

That's not to say there weren't earlier efforts to leverage networks for security purposes. I'm reminded of a tale of connecting FBI branches in the southern U.S. to facilitate case information sharing to close a series of cases involving a multi-state child and human trafficking ring in the Southern U.S. as well. Again though, that wasn't something bearing the character of "Hey! Let's 1984 these disgusting subhumans!" It was more, "Hey, seeing as our entire reason for existence is to work on crimes that cross State boundaries, doesn't it make sense that we should be able to keep the entire organization connected enough so that all our distributed branches can be kept up-to-date on what we've all found?"

Nothing controversial there. At all. Where things started getting controversial is where we started to take Lincoln's "tap the telegraph lines", an extreme wartime measure, and make it matter of fact through the establishment of the NSA/DIA. Where we started seeing the privatized Palantir's pop up, and seeing government agencies exercise or otherwise excuse investigative techniques they could not justifiably engage in themselves through delegation or voluntary action by private organizations.

It's these private businesses building datasets that never should gave existed that have outright corrupted things, and the at the time far more reasonable Third Party Doctrine that have driven things off the rails. Not the Internet itself.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by btilly on Thursday August 27, 2020 @04:02PM (#24297986)
That's cute, but I've got primary sources who indicate otherwise. I'll take the word of someone who at one point maintained a list of every addressed machine on ARPANet and the proto-Internet once it went beyond a strictly DoD effort, over a blatant attempt at trying to rewrite history to fit their own narrative, thank you.

So on the one hand a random internet stranger claims to have known someone important who said something.

On the other hand we have a history written by people including the author of the first paper on packet switching, the program manager at DARPA who authorized the project, the inventor of TCP/IP and so on and so forth.

I'll believe the paper that I cited.

Packet switching can be used to build networks that are resilient in the face of disruptions, whether natural or manmade. That is where the myth of "designed to survive a nuclear war" comes from. But the original Internet was designed using packet switching to allow computers to freely talk to each other without having an insane number of dedicated circuits kept open.

That said, I agree with you that it was not designed for surveillance. But I disagree on the timeline. While the response to 9/11 certainly stepped up the level of surveillance to an insane level, all evidence is that ECHELON had been tapping the Internet long before that.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON for more. Also note that ECHELON predated the internet, and to them it was simply another telecommunications network.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by weruiojkl24 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @02:21AM (#24290642)
Nah. It took a whole bunch of incompetent users who gave away their integrity for a few likes and pet videos.

Pretty much same thing as complaining about bad leaders when the sheeple putting in the bad votes is the actual problem.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by renewiltord on Thursday August 27, 2020 @02:37AM (#24290709)
While you're sitting on the Internet angry about their incompetence they're in bed with their partners laughing at cats.

Who really is the loser here.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by salawat on Thursday August 27, 2020 @09:12AM (#24293320)
Those who don't plaster their personal information also do the same. However, most cannot help but fall for the bait and switch of giving up info they never even knew was collected. Most people aren't even aware of EXIF, the difference between a User and a User-Agent, the multiple layers of attempts by organizations to assign unique identifiers to every entity they interact with, or the fact that society at one point pulled a total 180 on the idea of discretion in business whereby it became okay and commonplace to plaster information about your customers to other entities.

This was a very disjoint cultural shift in from the research I've done, and it was really pushed by only a handful of big names.

Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by ddorian43 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @02:52AM (#24290778)
Damn I need to increase my cat watching time.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by searchableguy on Thursday August 27, 2020 @05:00AM (#24291498)
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by trophycase on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:16AM (#24290349)
Yes it will be a sad day when there is nowhere on the globe you can go to be truly dark.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by Causality1 on Thursday August 27, 2020 @01:48AM (#24290515)
Starlink has no impact on this nor do any other internet provider. The first spy satellites launched in 1959. Don't carry electronics with you and you can be as dark as any spot on earth has been in the last five decades.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by wongarsu on Thursday August 27, 2020 @05:27AM (#24291677)
While you probably could carry a starlink antenna on a backpack, nobody forces you to (And it would be very inconvenient). They are much to big to be incorporated into smartphones or notebooks.
Re:Belarus turned off the internet – citizens hot-wired it by ajsnigrutin on Thursday August 27, 2020 @09:01AM (#24293224)
Boss: Vacation? Where are you going?

You: Camping, in the mountains, sorry boss, no signal there, I won't be accessible.

Boss: No problem.... here's a portable starlink antenna,... just in case... you know... if there is a bug in your code... or if we have a skype call with the clients... or if we need a bug fixed... haha.. you know, fixing bugs in the forest hehe.. well yeah... just have it connected during normal business hours, just in case... and check your emails while you're connected.. and slack... and CI logs... but otherwise, have a nice vacation, I hope you get some rest!