The end result will be that Unreal Engine, and all applications developed with it will be dead in the water on MacOS/iOS/iPadOS.
From the the legal filing:
>... when Epic sued Apple to break its monopoly on app stores and in-app payments, Apple retaliated ferociously. It told Epic that by August 28, Apple will cut off Epic’s access to all development tools necessary to create software for Apple’s platforms—including for the Unreal Engine Epic offers to third-party developers, which Apple has never claimed violated any Apple policy. Not content simply to remove Fortnite from the App Store, Apple is attacking Epic’s entire business in unrelated areas.
and...
>Apple stated that unless Epic capitulates, Apple will also block “[e]ngineering efforts to improve hardware and software performance of Unreal Engine on Mac and iOS hardware [and] optimize Unreal Engine for the Mac for creative workflows”.
PDF link: https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-v-apple-8-17-20-768927327...
The scary warning and convoluted workaround for running un–notarized apps is ostensibly to prevent non–technical people from compromising their computers. Now Apple is abusing that security mechanism for Business Reasons that have nothing to do with protecting users.
The fact that users can technically bypass it is a weak defense; if it’s an effective way to stop malware, it’s probably an effective way to prevent people from running Unreal Engine games as well.
Probably only one or the other. If Epic produces legitimate software that users have a legitimate reason to run, some of them will become accustomed to clicking through in order to run a legitimate program. Then, they will become more likely to click through on other programs: "Oh, they're probably banned for business reasons like Epic, not for security reasons like malware".
Apple is clearly hoping that is not the outcome, and that Epic simply loses as close to 100% of their Apple-based customers as they reasonably can.
On Windows, at least, the “Run anyway” button is merely behind the “More information...” link.
As far as I'm concerned, Mac openness is just a cat that got out of the bag, before anyone knew they could produce a _mint_ from rent seeking walled garden platforms. I find it highly unlikely Apple is not looking to correct this mistake on Mac, even if it's done so gradually that by the time the pull the trigger, no one even bats an eye.
I would not be shocked however if at some point they switched to developers having to buy special Macs to have this capability, and normal Macs would cease to be able to turn off secure boot and SIP and would require code signing/store distribution universally.
[1]: https://developer.apple.com/programs/security-research-devic...
A ragtag band of devs all banned-for-life from Apple’s stores could put together a new app-engine or game-engine that other devs use as the basis for their app and provided that those apps don’t break the rules about undocumented APIs or malware (and no-one in Apple’s higher-ups gets suspicious...) then those apps will appear. I don’t believe Apple has any way to automatically ban or delete all apps that use the same third-party libraries by using their macOS Notary system or iOS Certificate revocation system - they’d have to inspect every published app-package individually (granted, this would be automated, but you know what I mean).
You right click it and select “Open”...
Almost all MacOS users even the non-technical types encounter this at some point unless they go 100% Mac App Store which almost no one does if they have a job.
I gave up on catalina when I couldn't install little snitch without a network connection.
(Apparently there's a way, but I don't know it - it wasn't csrutil)
You use a pavlovian adequation mechanism on your users for some time, labeling as "dangerous", until you completely ban the thing.
By then users wont miss.
I´ve never used anything Apple by this same reason. Apple seems to think that once you by one of their products, they own you.
Its not just inappropriate, for me its pretty scary and humiliating.
Its like that girlfriend or boyfriend who thinks it owns you, and want to say what you should dress or if you can hangout with our friends.
It dont get it how people can be ok with this kind of stuff (as this is just one example) and later just say it snarkly as if it was your kid being naughty, where actually it can have severe consequences if they can get away with it, and future generations wont even argue because its already normalized for them.
Sounds like Apple will rather teach young consumers to ignore security warnings.
(`spctl` does not, in fact, disable it completely.)
I don't think thats an option on newer MacBook Pros any more.
It's incredibly scummy and inappropriate, but I would put it more along the lines of an attack-ad than an outright ban.
Edit: Now, one thing that isn't totally clear is whether or not devs who have their own developer accounts, and use Unreal Engine to target iOS, can still make iOS builds. If not that's a much bigger deal, though the fundamental issue would still lie with iOS, not macOS.