News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by mattzito on Friday August 07, 2020 @10:44AM (#24082402)
Hi folks - my name is Matt, and I lead the "Presentation & Ideation" product team inside of Google/G Suite, which includes Classic and New Sites. This project has been in the works for a while, so I'm happy to answer questions or take feedback here or you can email me at zito@(the google). Obviously my opinions are my own.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by naetius on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:26PM (#24084390)
Hi Matt,

thanks for the AMA-like availability, really appreciate it.

One question from me: how would you pitch "new Sites" for a potential new customer willing to use it, but afraid his/her/their content might not last the next "modernization" sweep?

In other words: would you try to sell new Sites to a customer that values - and worries about - long term visibility of his/her/their content? If no: what is new Sites' value proposition, in terms of target market?

Thanks again.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by unixhero on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:23AM (#24082855)
Hi,

Why do you (your team) really have do do this?

This is digital destruction. It's not about the features you shipped in 2008, and what those look like to a 2020 audience. It's about the content(!) which is part of the human creative endeavour.

Thanks for taking questions.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by mattzito on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:39AM (#24083047)
I think this is an interesting point - I will say that the vast vast majority of these sites (unfortunately I can't disclose the number) have not received edits or even visits for more than two years. To me, archiving those sites doesn't feel like destruction, it feels like backing up unused content and protecting it for the user. From our research, a lot of users don't realize that these sites are still published, and in some cases don't want this content out there in the world. I think it's relevant that people should have control over their own information and what is live on the web.

That being said, I hear the feedback, and I'll talk to the team about what we might be able to do, within legal and privacy constraints, to protect published sites.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by cyphar on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:56AM (#24083281)
Sadly, this mentality reminds me a lot of the great GeoCities purge of 2009. Have you considered partnering with the Internet Archive to back up any publicly-accessible classic sites which you plan to purge?

Whether or not a site has had visitors recently isn't a fair measure of the importance of those sites -- for instance, there were examples of digital shrines in GeoCities and Yahoo still decided to eradicate them all. It was only thanks to projects like the Internet Archive that we haven't lost that period of internet history just to free up some disk platter space.

EDIT: I also am struggling to understand what this means:

> To me, archiving those sites doesn't feel like destruction, it feels like backing up unused content and protecting it for the user.

What does "archiving" mean here? Will the sites still be accessible or not? Is "archive" here a euphemism for "delete" -- in which case, how is it not like destruction and how is it like a "backup"? I'm not sure most people would consider "rm -rf" to be a backup strategy, but it definitely does have very good storage density.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by csours on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:23PM (#24083644)
There's a big disconnect between technological work and emotional work. If I make myself a digital scrapbook online, it may not have many visitors (or any) just like a scrapbook may sit on a shelf for years without being touched; but the emotional impact when you do pick it up again is huge. Kind of like comparing a scrapbook to a best seller novel.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by mattzito on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:57PM (#24084060)
"Archiving" means that each site will be converted into an HTML export and placed in their Google Drive, and a separate copy will be converted to a new site and placed in a draft (unpublished) state in their Google Drive. They can choose to republish that new Site, or take the HTML export and move it to a new platform of their choosing.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by prepend on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:12PM (#24084233)
And thus taking it offline.

My concern isn’t that the files don’t exist any more,I think it’s nice to zip it and add it to the owners gdrive, my concern is that the files are no longer accessible on the web. So all the links are broken, no longer in search, etc.

This seems like a much larger issue than archiving and it would be cool to hear how you all decided to take the sites offline.

Is it a cost issue? I imagine hosting a billion static sites shouldn’t cost much.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by dwheeler on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:30PM (#24084438)
> I will say that the vast vast majority of these sites (unfortunately I can't disclose the number) have not received edits or even visits for more than two years

I'm having a hard time understanding why that would justify deleting that information forever. If anything, that suggests that providing static access would be enough and nearly zero-cost. Storage costs are a fraction of what they were.

I do a lot of searching for computer-related historical information, e.g., looking for rationales of "why something happened". Once information is destroyed it's often impossible to recover. No one might look at it for 30 years, and then there's only one retrieval but it was an important retrieval.

We've had a tremendous loss of recent information. This isn't the only example, but it's an important one. I'd like to see information retained, not lost.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by bachmeier on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:37PM (#24084512)
> From our research, a lot of users don't realize that these sites are still published, and in some cases don't want this content out there in the world.

I had forgotten about my Google site until seeing this posted. The last update of any kind was early 2013; most content was from 2011 or earlier. Some of the information on the site is wrong, a lot irrelevant, and worst of all, someone might not find my real site because of that one. I'd much prefer a dead site stop working to leaving it out there.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by freehunter on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:55PM (#24086370)
Now imagine your the opposite of that. You know is the site exists, and all the info and links are still accurate and still directs customers to your business. And then it disappears through no fault of your own.

I mean.. if I don’t use my Facebook account anymore I wouldn’t expect Facebook to delete everyone else’s profile?

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by teach on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:10PM (#24083465)
My anecdata agrees; I received the email and _vaguely_ remember maybe having done this at some point. Certainly it's nothing I want to keep, whatever it is.

Yet when I visited the Classic Sites Manager it shows nothing. ("0 owned by you" and 0s all the way down the rest of the suggested filters.)

False positive, maybe? The email sounded like y'all were pretty certain: "We’ve identified that you own one or more ACTIVE classic Sites."

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by mattzito on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:25PM (#24083665)
Possibly? It's possible that the emails were sent on a data pull at some point, and in between data pull and emailing, you deleted the classic site. Or potentially there was a wire crossed somewhere. I apologize for the extra email either way - if the Classic Sites Manager shows no sites, you are good to go.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by Apocryphon on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:50PM (#24083982)
Are you at least designing New Sites in a way to make them easier to archive and preserve, after they are scrapped in 2032?
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by rhizome on Sunday August 09, 2020 @06:45PM (#24103603)
That would be a feature, so it needs to provide some kind of benefit to someone's career in order to be implemented. This is only for launching the feature, and maintenance is still unlikely.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by brajesh on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:44AM (#24083111)
I’ve about a dozen Google sites which are just an embedded Google form with a custom script at the back.

I tried the conversion tool on a dummy site and it opened a Google doc. I am not sure how an HTML page with embedded Google form with a script will be converted to new Sites.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by mattzito on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:02PM (#24083364)
If you're comfortable, can you ping me on email at zito@? It's possible the custom script is the issue, but I'd be happy to take a look.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by tuyguntn on Friday August 07, 2020 @10:56AM (#24082527)
how are you going to compete with MS office suite or similar, in any enterprise solution space if Google has bad reputation with product maintenance and shutting down products so fast?

UPD: I assume Google Sites has lots of customers (we were one of them)

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by laurencerowe on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:07AM (#24082651)
Any chance of supporting arbitrary static sites behind a login screen? You can almost do it with a Google cloud storage bucket but you have to put it behind a load balancer for https and the IAP login gate is not supported for bucket backends making it unsuitable for intranet sites.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by mattzito on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:25AM (#24082902)
It's a good question - I know we looked at the possibility of a cloud storage bucket, but there were some technical challenges there (possibly what you describe). Do you want to shoot me an email at zito@ and I can try to find someone to answer that question?
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by prirun on Sunday August 09, 2020 @03:41PM (#24102265)
I have a Classic Site for Hashbackup.com. The pages are very basic text, with some bolding, italics, font face/size changes.

Every page in the zip backup, no matter how simple, is around 59K because of all the Javascript Google wraps around simple text. My plan is to convert everything to some flavor of Markdown, but parsing this mess is not going to be exactly easy.

I appreciate that the goal of this backup was to allow me to host it "as is" somewhere else - with no possibility to edit it, which seems rather useless.

What would be really nice is to also get a zip file with some simple Markdown pages that include user editing (font sizes, bolding, etc), without everything being wrapped in Google's Javascript.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by weejewel on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:35PM (#24084482)
Hi Matt. Last time I checked the new Sites didn’t have per-page permissions for a G Suite organization. Is this still the case?
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by EamonnMR on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:14PM (#24083509)
Do you have a plan to offer backups to the Internet Archive/etc?
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by easton_s on Friday August 07, 2020 @06:05PM (#24086906)
When are we getting an API for new sites?
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by rurban on Friday August 07, 2020 @10:53AM (#24082494)
Hi Matt, What was the rationale for this project? The joy of destruction?
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by mattzito on Friday August 07, 2020 @10:59AM (#24082555)
Classic Sites has been around for a very long time (since 2008), and we've been working to make new Sites a better, more modern, more maintainable place to create and host websites. The vast majority of users are choosing to create their sites with new Sites, and the vast majority of current classic sites receive no edits and no traffic.

We first announced this gradual plan in 2017, with an update in 2019, and now we're providing the detailed plan. The goal was to provide adequate notice for people to figure out whether migration, export, or deletion of their classic sites makes the most sense.

EDIT: to the multiple people that are highlighting that 12 years is not a long time, I should clarify. I agree that 12 years in Internet time is not a long time, but it is a very long time in "how websites work" time.

One of the big challenges in the website builder space, something that Google. Wix, Squarespace, have all dealt with - is that when a user publishes a website, there's an expectation around the fidelity and look-and-feel of that website. The data model and architecture for how you represent a rendered page, how you render embedded content, all are very dependent on how browsers work at that time, and the maintenance of those things can become very challenging.

There was a big shift about ~7 years ago, moving away from a "pixel perfect" layout/raw html approach (Wix, Old wordpress, SQSP 5, Classic Sites), to one where there's some sort of grid-and-box approach where the render is responsive, there's reflow, there's padding and spacing and styling relative to the browser experience. It separates out content from layout to a certain degree in a way that is much more future-proofed and modern. This is how Wix ADI, Squarespace 6+, Wordpress Gutenberg, and new Sites work.

For all of those transitions, there was a platform shift, that required a complete rework of how the system works. My point about "12 years" was that the model of how classic Sites works is 12 years old, and new Sites was intended to match the modern way of how websites are built and delivered.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by Wowfunhappy on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:39AM (#24083041)
> Classic Sites has been around for a very long time (since 2008), and we've been working to make new Sites a better, more modern, more maintainable place to create and host websites.

In this particular case, with Google Sites, maybe the decision was totally justified, I don't know. But, as a general trend across the technology industry, this type of explanation really bothers me, and I think it speaks to a serious mindset problem.

The fact that X is old and Y is new is not a reason to replace X with Y. Hammers are old, but they're also exceedingly useful tools. Users are familiar with how hammers work, and companies have become good at manufacturing them.

The question should be whether the new tool is better than the old one, and if it is, whether it's so much better that forcing every user to re-learn the new tool will be worth their while. And even then, it's worth asking why some of the largest companies in the world can't let both tools coexist, perhaps with the older one kept semi-hidden to avoid confusing new users.

Anyway, sorry for picking on you, I appreciate your willingness to pop into a somewhat-hostile thread. :)

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by mattzito on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:57AM (#24083295)
It's very fair feedback - I updated my response to highlight that the reason is not that classic sites is old, and old is bad, and new sites is new, and hence good. It's more that the way websites are built and rendered changed fundamentally ~7 years ago, and classic sites just doesn't match the way that needs to work today. All of the major website builders have tried to find a path from "raw html" to "content management system" and been unable to, and had a platform split at some point.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by dwheeler on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:36PM (#24084497)
No, I'm sorry, that's just not so.

A website maintained with raw HTML still works just fine on modern web browsers. In fact, it works much better. Web pages built with some CMS systems often take 5-20 seconds to load, while the "raw HTML" sites load in fractions of a second. In fact, the speedups continue; JavaScript parsing is slow, while HTML parsing is fast, and HTML compresses like magic. So a "big" HTML file is transferred and displayed in remarkably fast time.

I wouldn't use raw HTML in all cases, but I also wouldn't use a fancy CMS in all cases.

It's okay to use different platforms for different purposes.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by Robotbeat on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:21PM (#24083612)
I just transitioned my sites, and I really dislike the reflow and mobilification of the websites. Makes it much less useful, especially on smaller screens. Stuff (like side bar info) is hidden away behind hamburger menu buttons instead of immediately visible in a compact format.

This mobilification is a fad, and like many fads it will, too, disappear and have to be replaced (requiring many work hours) because ultimately it’s less usable especially for largely static content. There’s no option to keep a similar look and feel. “Mobile first” has been forced upon us and is now, with reflow, “mobile only.” Imagine if Arxiv required PDFs to be replaced by mobilified versions? So annoying and impractical.

Really disappointed. Google made a bunch of work for themselves just to reduce the usability of older web pages.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by Bjartr on Friday August 07, 2020 @03:10PM (#24085432)
Why not leave it up to the authors of a site to decide if it needs to be rebuilt in a new system. That people's daily usage of the web is different today does render content written for the older paradigm valueless.

Google's misson is "to organize the world’s information and make it universally accessible and useful". Dropping sites on the cutting room floor because information in them isn't in a convenient format does not make that information accessible or useful.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by msla on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:14AM (#24082732)
> Classic Sites has been around for a very long time (since 2008)

Anything I can say would only detract from this.

This is modern Google.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by gtfoutttt on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:48AM (#24083155)
Amen. 12 years is not long in anyone's eyes except for SV.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by stickfigure on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:59PM (#24084085)
Then should I assume you're reading this on IE7?
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by m4rtink on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:26PM (#24086092)
12 years is not a long time even just by enterprise software standards. The RHEL/Fedora Anaconda installer Git history goes back to 1999 (was CVS initially and then imported to Git) and that's just when tracking was first used, it existed many years before that.

Also RHEL support lifecycles are 11+ years, so for RHEL 8 released in 2019, that's a commitment to ~2030 right here and there & with doing this for many years for the past releases proving the point.

No wonder the most critical stuff (Bank, Stock exchnages, etc.) run on RHEL and not on some half baked Google stuff that will get deprecated from under them at a moments notice.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by fermienrico on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:06AM (#24082639)
Externally, as you know, Google‘a reputation hasn’t been great when it comes to maintaining their services.

What should have happened is to turn Classic Sites (and new Sites) itself into Squarespace competitor.

I just see this as a massive failure of vision and execution.

Why didn’t they improve classic sites and added yet another product called Sites? May be I am seeing some internal politics surface as fragmentation of product line.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by mattzito on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:19AM (#24082807)
Fundamentally, classic sites works differently than new sites. It's basically not possible, for example, to make a classic sites website mobile responsive. That's a table-stakes feature for website builders today.

To your Squarespace comparison, Squarespace went through a similar transition - Squarespace 5 worked very similar to Classic Sites, and was replaced with Squarespace 6, which was a complete end-to-end rewrite.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by rhizome on Sunday August 09, 2020 @06:57PM (#24103665)
It's starting to sound like this "mobilization" process is the marquee project pushing this, if Google is still a "nothing gets done that won't result in a promotion" shop, which is another stereotype the company has built for itself.

Also, people have technical knowledge here, even if they've never been hired by someone as "the best of the best," or having graduated from a top 10 CS school, so handwaving "fundamentally works differently" is not actually likely to be the enlightening description you might hope it would be.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by dwheeler on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:40PM (#24084542)
> It's basically not possible, for example, to make a classic sites website mobile responsive.

Huh? Did that 10 years ago. Perhaps we have a different definition of a "classic site".

To me a "classic site" is another name for a static site, that is, a website where the HTML to be served is pregenerated. Static sites are now coming back, not going away. But I always assumed that a website should reflow.

Perhaps when you say "classic site" you mean "site that assumes that all users have the same display size". I agree that such classic sites are nonsense today. But they were always nonsense. At no time was there a guarantee of any particular screen size for HTML, and it's always been easy to write HTML that just reflows. If you do that, your site works just fine.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by dragonwriter on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:47PM (#24084604)
> Perhaps we have a different definition of a "classic site".

GP didn't say “classic site” they said “classic sites website”. You seem to be interpreting that as intended to be a somewhat redundant and mispunctuated rendering of “classic site’s website”, but given that the context is a discussion for the shutdown of Google’s classic Sites in favor of only supporting Google’s new Sites mode, I think that it's just a capitalization-omitted rendering of “classic Sites website”, that is, a website using classic Google Sites as opposed to new Google Sites.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by fermienrico on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:34AM (#24082991)
Yea, I think Google should continue to revamp things under the same product name. It is giving it a bad reputation for discontinuation of products left and right.

Could have called it Classic Sites 2.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by dragonwriter on Friday August 07, 2020 @01:48PM (#24084620)
The product name is Google Sites. With the introduction of the new configuration for that product in parallel, “classic” and “new” distinguished the available configuration. Classic now stops being the default and in a little over a year goes away, but the product (Google Sites) stays.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by globular-toast on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:19AM (#24082802)
12 years is a "very long time"? What is considered a "long time" or a "short time"?
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by rohan1024 on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:00AM (#24082568)
Why so rude? You can't blame OP for Google's decisions.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by rasz on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:01PM (#24083357)
Google is not sentient, someone inside Google decided to get a promotion by launching a "new thing", at the cost of deleting old content.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by BillinghamJ on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:07AM (#24082644)
As the product lead on the team, it likely is their decision (not to say that excuses rudeness though)
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by fermienrico on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:09AM (#24082674)
I don’t think it’s rude to tell people facts, this person is leading this effort.
Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by abstractbarista on Friday August 07, 2020 @12:14PM (#24083513)
It's interesting how some people talk. I run a server for free that people store things on. They become irate when I no longer wish to provide the free service. Is that reasonable?

My belief has always been "no". Google could kill off the entirety of GMail tomorrow, and I'd be disappointed, but totally understanding.

Re:Classic Google Sites shutting down by September 2021 by stallmanite on Friday August 07, 2020 @04:38PM (#24086197)
Are you a giant multinational that will need to convince people to store stuff on your server in the future? If not then this doesn’t apply to you so you can happily delete everything on your server.