Whether or not a site has had visitors recently isn't a fair measure of the importance of those sites -- for instance, there were examples of digital shrines in GeoCities and Yahoo still decided to eradicate them all. It was only thanks to projects like the Internet Archive that we haven't lost that period of internet history just to free up some disk platter space.
EDIT: I also am struggling to understand what this means:
> To me, archiving those sites doesn't feel like destruction, it feels like backing up unused content and protecting it for the user.
What does "archiving" mean here? Will the sites still be accessible or not? Is "archive" here a euphemism for "delete" -- in which case, how is it not like destruction and how is it like a "backup"? I'm not sure most people would consider "rm -rf" to be a backup strategy, but it definitely does have very good storage density.
My concern isn’t that the files don’t exist any more,I think it’s nice to zip it and add it to the owners gdrive, my concern is that the files are no longer accessible on the web. So all the links are broken, no longer in search, etc.
This seems like a much larger issue than archiving and it would be cool to hear how you all decided to take the sites offline.
Is it a cost issue? I imagine hosting a billion static sites shouldn’t cost much.
I'm having a hard time understanding why that would justify deleting that information forever. If anything, that suggests that providing static access would be enough and nearly zero-cost. Storage costs are a fraction of what they were.
I do a lot of searching for computer-related historical information, e.g., looking for rationales of "why something happened". Once information is destroyed it's often impossible to recover. No one might look at it for 30 years, and then there's only one retrieval but it was an important retrieval.
We've had a tremendous loss of recent information. This isn't the only example, but it's an important one. I'd like to see information retained, not lost.
I had forgotten about my Google site until seeing this posted. The last update of any kind was early 2013; most content was from 2011 or earlier. Some of the information on the site is wrong, a lot irrelevant, and worst of all, someone might not find my real site because of that one. I'd much prefer a dead site stop working to leaving it out there.
I mean.. if I don’t use my Facebook account anymore I wouldn’t expect Facebook to delete everyone else’s profile?
Yet when I visited the Classic Sites Manager it shows nothing. ("0 owned by you" and 0s all the way down the rest of the suggested filters.)
False positive, maybe? The email sounded like y'all were pretty certain: "We’ve identified that you own one or more ACTIVE classic Sites."
That being said, I hear the feedback, and I'll talk to the team about what we might be able to do, within legal and privacy constraints, to protect published sites.