But I would not hold my breath that this changes much after Corona. In 2019 the Fed tried quantitative tightening, which resulted in the December stock market correction, and a big overnight lending spike. From there they resumed QE (Which was one day supposed be a temporary measure in the great financial crisis). They did drop interest rates again in response to Corona, though. Not before.
J Powell already promissed rates would stay as low as they are for 2 years.
But right now the yields of the 10 year, e.g. are going below what a new issue should yield I believe.
Gold/Silver should lose some steam when the DXY goes up, or bond yields increase. (Both of which should also have a negative influence on stock and bond prices).
Also don't marry the idea of inflation to the CPI. There is asset inflation (think housing market and stock market), and inflation in certain products like food. But other things like transportation (perhaps of lower importance to poorer than for rich). It's not a black and white matter.
"Massive indirect unguided subsidies of money by the government."
Where the government does something directly, the results can be good. Look at Medicaid, which is generally thought to be the most cost effective form of health insurance that exists in the USA. The government overseas that directly.
But everywhere the government tries to offer end consumers a subsidy, so they can then try to use it toward some social goal, the result seems to be inflation.
If the dollar hyperinflates, where would people go? Crypto is obviously interesting, but gold is the supreme form of money that requires zero trust (while crypto is near trust-less, you still need to trust the cryptography to be secure).
[1] https://reuters.com/article/gold-cme/102-tonnes-of-gold-chan...
Gold hasn't always or everywhere been real money, I've personally worked on an archeology site where I sifted out a tiny shell bead with an even tinier hole punched in it so it could attached to a string like ancient Chinese coins and so on.
I once read a claim that J.P. Morgan said something like money is only worth the character of the person who wields it.
I feel more like interactions with other people are more precious than precious metals.
If the dollar hyperinflates, some people will go into bunkers. I'd maybe starve or hide... I don't have a plan, I'm way behind on stuff as it is.
"Gold Plated Tungsten Bars - Alibabawww.alibaba.com › ... › gold › gold plated tungsten 570 products - Alibaba.com offers 570 gold plated tungsten bars products."
The dollar is inflating right now, where are people going, besides gold? Why would the dollar hyperinflate?
As with stocks, the acronym TINA applies. As in, There Is No Alternative.
Yes, there are literally plenty of alternatives, but most of them have (dealbreaking) shortcomings.
As a very simple example of why this may be misleading, consider that house prices are not considered in the “basket of goods” that Americans buy, despite this being literally the most expensive purchase most people ever make.
The formula itself is also changed from time to time. If we were using the “old” formula, inflation would be MUCH higher (shadowstats.com for current numbers).
This is (widespread) mis/disinformation. The CPI carefully distinguishes between houses as capital goods and shelter/housing as something people consume. If you Google it, you will find that the equivalent rent for homeowners is incorporated in the CPI. Even if they ignored homeowners, the index would be very little changed if it was based on renters alone.
See https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-an...
In order to compute the CPI-U, the people doing the work essentially call up 14,000 people and, if they own a home, they ask them how much they would theoretically charge in rent if they rented their home out.
The problem with this is obvious - most people do not do rent income estimates for a living and so the numbers are often quite far from reality.
More importantly, people find it very difficult to estimate future interest rates and they fail to take into account things like the sunk cost fallacy (see: 2008 financial crisis, where people in crashing markets still guessed they would be able to rent their homes based on pre-crash prices).
There is also the issue of a negative feedback loop, where low interest rates lead to lower than expected inflation, because “house prices only every go up baby!” - or in other words, people are perfectly willing to accept $3000 in rent even if the mortgage is $5000 if the house is increasing by $8000 a month in appreciation. This appreciation is hidden from the CPI because only theoretical rent is considered. The net result of the negative feedback loop is the fed sees that inflation is low, so it thinks it can keep rates low too, which leads to asset bubbles like in 2008. (And, likely, in 2020 with stocks too...)
Separating housing as an investment from housing as consumption is obviously the right thing to do. But if it wasn't separated, it doesn't make sense it would add systematic bias in one direction. Prices go up, prices go down. Inflation would be pushed higher and then lower, relative to the "true" value.
They do survey people who rent as well as own, so they are measuring the market directly for that portion.
As far as the owners go, I think you're disregarding the fact that the specific houses that are not being rented do not have more authoritative rents. If you use actual rental data, then you have to have a model using assumptions to map one population to another, which seems fraught with potential problems.
The point of a survey is to collect survey data, and if they don't do it, then it is that much worse of a survey, because there is no 100% substitute.
Not 100%, but I bet doing something as simple as looking at the bank accounts of the selected groups in aggregate (over a long time period) and adding in things like tax returns could get quite a bit of the way there.
To be honest, I'm surprised something like mint.com or Personal Capital don't offer their own interest rate measures.
That is not actually what hyperinflation means.
> We already have extreme asset price inflation...
Sure, but we don't have asset price hyperinflation.
> In my opinion it is only a matter of time before people realise what is going on, start dumping their dollars/euros/pounds/etc., and use something else for their daily transactions and savings, probably crypto at first.
Dump the dollars for what? Most people have no savings, they have a monthly paycheck that goes right to expenses for the most part. That alone greatly limits the velocity of money and therefore the rate of inflation.
Those people that (rightly) expect inflation (not hyperinflation) have already piled into other asset classes.
Either way, there can't be hyperinflation without a commensurate increase in money supply, which can't be achieved just by people spending their money more quickly.
> It is worth noting that every fiat currency throughout history, without exception, has hyperinflated and collapsed to nothing.
That is untrue. Hyperinflation is exceptional. Inflation over a long time can erode a lot of the value, but that isn't hyperinflation and it's not necessarily a problem either.
Nitpick. It limits the potential increase in velocity of money. Spending your money as soon as you get it is pretty much as fast as possible. The reason why there is little inflation is that these people don't have enough money to buy all the things they want to buy, meanwhile someone else is sitting on a fat stack of wealth and wondering what to do with it.
What follows is that people lose trust in the currency and convert their currency into assets that cannot be taken away. This is hyperinflation. The "currency based" economy shrinks and there is less wealth to extract from it. Since there are a lot of fixed government expenses the amount of money that needs to be printed grows exponentially.
I$ = inflation dollar
The economy = the part of the economy that still uses I$
Inflation dollars are equivalent to dollars (I$ = $) in the beginning.
The economy is worth $1000 and has I$1000.
Government doubles money supply by printing I$2000. (100% inflation)
The economy is worth $1000 and has I$2000. I$ = $0.5.
$500 worth of value has been extracted but it circulates in the economy.
Hyperinflation begins: People start losing trust and put half their wealth into gold or something else.
The economy is now worth $500 and has I$2000. I$ = $0.25.
The government still wants to extract $500 of value out of the economy so they need to print money at a much faster rate than before.
Government quadruples money supply by printing I$6000. (300% inflation)
The economy is now worth $500 and has I$8000. I$ = $0.0625.
$375 worth of value has been extracted.
More people stop using the currency which means the economy shrinks again forcing the government to become even more aggressive.
Right now the central banks are following strategies that eventually demand every penny back that they have handed out. If inflation happens they can easily reverse their policies.
There are plenty of definitions, just none that are universally accepted.
It’s similar to “recession”, which in the USA means two quarters of negative GDP growth but isn’t a universally agreed definition.
Colloquially, in the USA, “hyperinflation” refers to Average price increases of over one hundred percent per year for a “basket of goods”.
I actually have a blog post https://cryptm.org/posts/2020/07/09/alt.html where we create a minimum variance portfolio using gold and the S&P 500. And even though gold has high volatility and poor returns, this approach generates a higher risk adjusted return than the S&P 500.
Especially in an age when bonds are no longer countercyclical, gold is an attractive component of a portfolio.
https://jamanetwork.com/journals/cardiology/articlepdf/27689...
I won't touch the market with a stick because it's going in the opposite direction to the economy. There has to be a correction coming. I know there aren't good alternatives, interest rates are so low, etc. But I still think there's a correction coming, that's my two cents.
However, couldn't this be a sign that people are getting ready for if/when the current financial system fails?
Even barring a catastrophic nosedive in the level of civilized trading, regular people aren’t equipped to store gold in their homes. The problem of securing such holdings isn’t something the average Joe will be able to solve well, and he knows it.
The issue with doing that, is it is an insurance policy and not a immediately liquidate-able asset that can be traded in seconds. I think it is a sound strategy to take possession and store enough gold that in the event of a reset you can reestablish yourself. It is the closest thing to a guarantee that, that portion of your wealth will carry over into what comes next, in the unlikely possibility that it happens in your lifetime.
I don't know if I buy that. Show me how I can guy a commodity on the market and have it delivered to my house. And the guarantee that process will work when the global financial system starts imploding. For the vast majority of people holding gold, their holdings are only on paper, and that's all they'll ever be.
If I'm stocking up on items with physical value to hedge a complete economic collapse, I'd rather have butane lighters, buckets, vacuum sealed sugar/salt/grains, water storage, and ammo.
Also for myself personally, I purchased a simple test kit that most jewelers use. It is an electronic test kit that is very accurate for gold and platinum and when I look to reallocate some of my wealth to gold I buy scrap gold and test it. The kit was about a $200 investment but It allows me to buy the gold at a deep discount (deeper if it is not 24K) under the spot price for the day, you can melt it with a propane torch, that can be purchased from Home Depot and they make plenty of bar molds. It takes me about 5-10 minutes effort (short of procuring the gold) to turn scrap into bars. But if one does not want to go thru the effort, it's pretty easy to buy gold bullion at the spot price for the day + shipping, even on ebay there are plenty of reputable sellers. I don't trade in millions of dollars in gold and I have yet to liquidate any that I hold as I only hold about 3% of my total wealth in gold and I try to keep that pretty stable. Again I view it as insurance, not an investment, that being said if I liquidated it all today, it would have turned out to have been a pretty good investment.
Do you write a letter to your broker asking, "Dear, Schwab, I have $1000 in a gold ETF and shit is crazy now! Can you please have one of your customer care folks briefly stop stocking up on water and food, use a generator to turn your servers back on and verify I have that security? Then please deliver the equivalent amount of physical gold to my address via the postal system which is partially working? Thank you and look forward to continuing business with you!"
Point is, if you ever really need the physical gold behind the security it will not be available. To me, that makes the security worthless.
When society collapses gold will be completely worthless as well.
I don't see why not?
I have never had a break-in, but if I did I'm sure I could hide a few kilos well enough that a regular burglar would never find it.
Either way, my gold is in a bank vault, which seems safe enough, but I honestly would not be too worried storing it at home.
Not on their own, but once they've found you, they've found the gold.
They could set up a trusted storage facility to hold the gold in a vault for them. It isn't that hard to imagine. They could call it a "bank" if they really wanted to be traditional.
Just because you don't feel like being imaginative doesn't mean that people won't be when large amounts of money are on the line. People are downright ingenious when it comes to securing their wealth.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-markets-saft/saft-on-weal...
>perhaps fearful of confiscation by a successful enemy or a government tax on capital, a plan that was mooted in Britain in 1920 ...
Hard asset confiscation, in the US case of gold, has been mooted, passed into law, and enforced:
There is no difference except that in a crisis gold will retain its value, and the stacks of paper money will only remind you of the better days.
Now, of course neither of them is optimal. The best way of maintaining your purchasing power is with a competent government. But that is even more rare.
Most consumer gold trading is done in grams, tenths quarters and half an ounce, outside of numismatic (old real gold coins, not bullion) due to its insane cost, it's easier to move assayed grams@$50 than $2000 single ounce coins for "regular" people. Also because it's easier to fake in larger ingots and XRF devices are very expensive, smaller assayed quantities move fast and are traded heavily.
Most/all Federal Reserve Banks have a "Money Museum" attached to them. They will have $1 million in one dollar bills, which is a cube approximately 3 or 4 feet on each side. They will also have $1 million in twenty dollar bills, which fits on a 2-3 foot in diameter table, stacked perhaps 12 inches high.
Lastly, they will have $1 million in one hundred dollar bills, which fits in smallish suitcase that's probably less than twice the size of your stack of gold and weigh hardly anything at all.
They are really interesting - you should definitely go to your nearest one when you can, not least for the free shredded cash they give out; you can have the most baller confetti at your next party.
Also, IIRC, gold quickly lost its trading value in post WW2 Germany because, uh, you couldn't eat it.
If you are storing a million 'dollars' in assets then you are not storing a million 'dollars', you are storing assets currently valued at one million dollars OR also 500oz of gold.
Does that mean dumping money into Vanguard or something else?
But unless we are in global civilization ending circumstances gold is good longterm bet, physical gold though.
If solar flare wipes out all electronics, your 100tons of gold in Switzerland are meaningless.
Assuming you’re talking civilian tossed back to the Bronze Age. Whoever has access to the vault might make use of the gold in such situations, but ownership is unlikely to be tracked back to people in another city etc.
Now, if you personally want to store physical gold that’s a different bet. Though personally storing significant amounts of valuables like that has plenty of obvious downsides.
Crikey. What performance counts as good in your eyes? Gold has been a pretty rewarding investment for the last 20 years. I think the median annual performance for the last 20 years has been something like 10% in USD (worthless metric for an investor I know, but the point is that most years are very solid up years). That is a pretty reasonable performer in my low-risk book. 2010-2014 represented an unusual bad time to buy gold in a decade long trend of great years to buy gold.
In terms of actual return it depends when you pick your start and end date; but the fact that we sometimes have major crisis was always totally predictable and the major governments responses have been reasonably predicable. The only surprise at the moment is the specific fact that it is a pandemic and in 2020. The price pattern on the charts is not surprising.
Now it’s currently above the historic average so you do get 1% real returns from 1900 to 2020. But, stop in say 2010 and things look even worse.
There are extended periods when gold absolutely crushes everything, and periods when it is totally flat (or worse). In the long run, yes, it is a poor investment because it is an inert metal. But for certain periods of time it is absolutely a great alternative to bonds and equities.
As to gold having positive returns in some window, sure but if you can time the market you can make money investing in anything. It’s doing the timing that’s difficult not looking for windows in historic data.
Exactly. The 20 years range is cherrypicked for to make gold look good, it doesn't generalize.
If you had bought stock (and reinvested dividends) at the top of the market in 2008, you would've been better off with stock today. If you had bought gold at the top in 2011, you would've been better off with stock today. If you had bought gold at the bottom in 2008, you would've been better off with stock today.
Really, the only times where gold would've outperformed (to date) in the last 50+ years is around the time of the dotcom bubble and the last ~2 years.
Realistically though, you're going to buy the market at its highs and lows, you're going to exit at some point when you need to, so it's highly subjective.
Sure. And a horrible investment over the last 40 years. You’d still have a negative return if you bought in 1980.
Gold doesn't do much over a century, it's main property of interest is that it sits in an inert fashion wherever it is left. I'm not too surprised on worried if it has a near-0 return over 50 years.
I don't actually believe it has a positive return over the last 20 years either; but most people don't accept my "the inflation rate is meaningless, stop referring to it to value real returns" argument so I usually don't bother mentioning it.
In a normal environment it will not outperform.
That said, I don't know how much the gold price is affected by gold ETF vs physical transactions.
[1] example of gold coins that are very popular with easy liquidity: https://catalog.usmint.gov/coins/precious-metal-coins/gold/
[2] example of liquidity via ebay sales: https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_nkw=gold+eagle+co...
[0] https://www.royalmint.com/invest/bullion/discover-bullion/ca...
It all went well for him until he started a payroll company to do the same thing in multiple states.
https://www.fff.org/2013/12/09/the-u-s-vs-robert-kahre-a-hor...
That said, I'm mainly playing with a hypothetical here. I'm highly skeptical the system will outright fail simply because the majority of the wealth (and thus power) belongs to those with a deeply vested interest in not letting it fail and there's generally not much power owned by those who actively want it to fail. Fiat has worked this long, so why not longer?
When the chairman of the Federal Reserve becomes a prepper, then you know it's time to find a shelter.
For total meltdown SHTF scenarios soap, alcohol, cigarettes, chocolate, and maybe seeds are much more practical as barter currencies.
Even without SHTF scenarios, physical gold is a poor store of value because selling physical gold to a broker is an expensive business.
A lot of prestige gold coins are sold at a price premium which brokers will just ignore when buying from you. Even on weight alone, you're very unlikely to get anything close to your purchase price unless the price has gone up by at least a double figure percentage.
The real question is how bad the Covid recession/depression is likely to get. If you're assuming there's a depression-scale downturn then "paper" gold makes more sense than a lot of other investment classes.
There are many, many scenarios other than Business-as-usual and Mad Max. Look at how hyperinflation has played out historically. In Argentina in 2001, imported things like medicine became very expensive. People sold small amounts of gold for fiat when these kinds of expenses came up.
Depends on what you mean by food. If you have enough time, food can be multiplied. One potato, properly handled, can turn into a field of potatoes. One walnut, properly handled, can turn into a forest.
I think the idea behind an apocalypse bunker is it will remain unsafe to go outside / farm using solar power for a few months to a couple of years but not forever.
I agree. You have to start farming at some point.
It's guaranteed not to happen in the short to mid-term.
Rising interest rates during a recession when the economy is massively over-leveraged and even the low-interest debt can barely be serviced would result in an even greater wave of defaults.
Low interest rates and QE are here to stay. The dollar will depreciate significantly, easing the burden of debtors and making American labor more competitive. Good for exports, bad for people who earn a dollar salary.
Gold appreciating (in dollar terms) is just a side-effect of this development.
You can have high interest rates, but if the market believes you are going to increase the money supply, that may not be enough to stop depreciation. That's why debt monetization through QE without QT is such a dangerous game.
Interest rates in the US right now are higher in the Eurozone, yet the dollar has depreciated against the Euro.
Lastly, while it is possible that the dollar will not depreciate against other currencies, currencies will still depreciate against assets.
The upwards trend of 2020 is due to Covid-19. There will be a correction when that crisis ends.
Krugman's first piece post 9/11 was about how getting to rebuild a skyscraper was somehow going to be a tremendous economic stimulus, as if the loss of so many knowledgeable and wise people being murdered all at once didn't occur to him... AT ALL!
In college I read the NYT everyday, thought it was the best paper in the world. Then one morning I opened my copy to see a full color photo of my rapist attached to a hagiography of how she had been elected to public office.
Now the NYT CEO is still Mark Thompson, who got the job because as Director-General at the BBC he covered up Jimmy Saville's... I don't have a word for it yet.
Walter Duranty won a Pulitzer for using the NYT to cover up Stalin's genocide of Polish people so that American media didn't seriously cover it until the 1980s.
Don't get me started on how many people with Gilead financial ties are acting as if financial incentives might somehow statistically significantly effect their behavior because it seems to just give me sleep deprivation.
He represents everything that’s wrong with government excesses and theft of its citizens via inflation.
50 years ago an ounce of gold was $35/oz. Today that very same 1 oz gold coin is at $2000.
That is, the price of gold in 1970 was highly distorted. It was not a market price. You can't use that price as your starting point.
And since the world is progressing in a direction of depletion of natural resources, the next deep recession might be the last.
We have seen many recoveries after many recessions, but there is no guarantee that there is a recovery. Sooner or later the earth will be in such a bad condition, that it will be impossible to recover.
Gold has been rising steadily for years, interest rates have been low for years. That's a lot of excess liquidity already in the market, it's just exacerbated.
Coronavirus disappearing from the news won't make all that excess liquidity disappear.
Gold and other assets will drop when that excess liquidity is removed through rate hikes and QT.
When will that happen? My money is on "never".
"After all, the price of gold soared from 2007 to 2011... So why did gold soar? The main answer seems to be plunging returns on other assets, especially bonds, which were the product of a depressed world economy."
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/13/opinion/goldbugs-for-trum...
So we should expect the price of gold to rise while the pandemic is out of control. Once the coronavirus is defeated, we should expect the price of gold to fall.