News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by Qasaur on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @07:34AM (#24059627)
Krugman in his usual arrogance neglects to consider the price and indeed monetary history of gold. It is and always has been "real money" and most people either consciously or subconsciously trust gold more than the pieces of paper we call money, and its price is not a reflection of people chasing returns but rather people having less faith in the current monetary system (which is backed by nothing). The record physical delivery orders at Comex proves this [1].

If the dollar hyperinflates, where would people go? Crypto is obviously interesting, but gold is the supreme form of money that requires zero trust (while crypto is near trust-less, you still need to trust the cryptography to be secure).

[1] https://reuters.com/article/gold-cme/102-tonnes-of-gold-chan...

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by daodedickinson on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @07:58AM (#24059839)
There have been plenty of stories of hollow gold bars and, true or not, they've been trending again lately.

Gold hasn't always or everywhere been real money, I've personally worked on an archeology site where I sifted out a tiny shell bead with an even tinier hole punched in it so it could attached to a string like ancient Chinese coins and so on.

I once read a claim that J.P. Morgan said something like money is only worth the character of the person who wields it.

I feel more like interactions with other people are more precious than precious metals.

If the dollar hyperinflates, some people will go into bunkers. I'd maybe starve or hide... I don't have a plan, I'm way behind on stuff as it is.

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by Qasaur on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @08:04AM (#24059881)
There have absolutely been cases in history where other forms of "money" have been used, but in a long enough timescale of a civilisation, gold and silver are organically adopted as money due to their unique properties that make them suited for it. Fiat, shell beads, and other forms of currency are exceptions to the rule.
Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by daodedickinson on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @08:16AM (#24059953)
I dunno, I feel like Potosí being the highest population city in the Spanish Empire in the 1600s, even larger than Madrid, even though its elevation was about 13,000 feet, even though Denver's elevation is only about 5,000 something feet high, suggests an inorganic impetus, an illogical fetish for silver
Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by perl4ever on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @08:13PM (#24066968)
https://www.popsci.com/diy/article/2008-03/how-make-convinci...

"Gold Plated Tungsten Bars - Alibabawww.alibaba.com › ... › gold › gold plated tungsten 570 products - Alibaba.com offers 570 gold plated tungsten bars products."

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by lottin on Thursday August 06, 2020 @02:52AM (#24068707)
The fact that gold has historically been used as money in some places doesn't mean it's money now. Money is a commodity that is used as a medium of exchange. Today, gold is not used as a medium of exchange, i.e. most people are not paid in gold and don't buy things with it. Therefore gold is not money.
Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by gridlockd on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @07:42AM (#24059706)
> If the dollar hyperinflates, where would people go?

The dollar is inflating right now, where are people going, besides gold? Why would the dollar hyperinflate?

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by baconandeggs on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @07:55AM (#24059812)
Because the dollar is the reserve currency of the world, it will hyperinflate if and when the international community begins transacting en-masse in other currencies or even in gold, and dumping us bonds. Then all those dollars outside the US, which are most dollars, will go back to the US and hyperinflate. This could happen if the current instability in the US continues.
Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by blaser-waffle on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @10:57AM (#24061517)
> where are people going, besides gold?

As with stocks, the acronym TINA applies. As in, There Is No Alternative.

Yes, there are literally plenty of alternatives, but most of them have (dealbreaking) shortcomings.

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by ivalm on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @06:07PM (#24066148)
CPI is fine...
Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by alasdair_ on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @06:24PM (#24066267)
CPI is also a measure that is altered over time by groups with a vested interest in keeping “inflation” low.

As a very simple example of why this may be misleading, consider that house prices are not considered in the “basket of goods” that Americans buy, despite this being literally the most expensive purchase most people ever make.

The formula itself is also changed from time to time. If we were using the “old” formula, inflation would be MUCH higher (shadowstats.com for current numbers).

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by perl4ever on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @08:24PM (#24067039)
>house prices are not considered in the “basket of goods” that Americans buy

This is (widespread) mis/disinformation. The CPI carefully distinguishes between houses as capital goods and shelter/housing as something people consume. If you Google it, you will find that the equivalent rent for homeowners is incorporated in the CPI. Even if they ignored homeowners, the index would be very little changed if it was based on renters alone.

See https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-an...

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by alasdair_ on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @10:25PM (#24067612)
I’m aware of that. The problem with equivalent rent is that it’s seldom actually equivalent.

In order to compute the CPI-U, the people doing the work essentially call up 14,000 people and, if they own a home, they ask them how much they would theoretically charge in rent if they rented their home out.

The problem with this is obvious - most people do not do rent income estimates for a living and so the numbers are often quite far from reality.

More importantly, people find it very difficult to estimate future interest rates and they fail to take into account things like the sunk cost fallacy (see: 2008 financial crisis, where people in crashing markets still guessed they would be able to rent their homes based on pre-crash prices).

There is also the issue of a negative feedback loop, where low interest rates lead to lower than expected inflation, because “house prices only every go up baby!” - or in other words, people are perfectly willing to accept $3000 in rent even if the mortgage is $5000 if the house is increasing by $8000 a month in appreciation. This appreciation is hidden from the CPI because only theoretical rent is considered. The net result of the negative feedback loop is the fed sees that inflation is low, so it thinks it can keep rates low too, which leads to asset bubbles like in 2008. (And, likely, in 2020 with stocks too...)

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by perl4ever on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @11:36PM (#24067911)
You're saying sometimes people estimate equivalent rent too high and sometimes too low. How is that an argument that inflation is systematically underestimated, let alone that home prices are ignored?

Separating housing as an investment from housing as consumption is obviously the right thing to do. But if it wasn't separated, it doesn't make sense it would add systematic bias in one direction. Prices go up, prices go down. Inflation would be pushed higher and then lower, relative to the "true" value.

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by cameldrv on Thursday August 06, 2020 @04:22AM (#24069085)
Perhaps, but it's also not a good measure of the market. When the BLS wants to measure the price of other consumer goods, it goes to a store and sees how much something costs. When goods change, it makes quality adjustments. This would be the equivalent of walking down the street and asking people "how much can I pay you for your jacket?" It's a very strange way of measuring the price for something when there is a perfectly well functioning rental market.
Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by perl4ever on Thursday August 06, 2020 @08:03PM (#24076671)
> It's a very strange way of measuring the price for something when there is a perfectly well functioning rental market.

They do survey people who rent as well as own, so they are measuring the market directly for that portion.

As far as the owners go, I think you're disregarding the fact that the specific houses that are not being rented do not have more authoritative rents. If you use actual rental data, then you have to have a model using assumptions to map one population to another, which seems fraught with potential problems.

The point of a survey is to collect survey data, and if they don't do it, then it is that much worse of a survey, because there is no 100% substitute.

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by alasdair_ on Friday August 07, 2020 @02:54PM (#24085258)
>The point of a survey is to collect survey data, and if they don't do it, then it is that much worse of a survey, because there is no 100% substitute.

Not 100%, but I bet doing something as simple as looking at the bank accounts of the selected groups in aggregate (over a long time period) and adding in things like tax returns could get quite a bit of the way there.

To be honest, I'm surprised something like mint.com or Personal Capital don't offer their own interest rate measures.

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by imtringued on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:23AM (#24069369)
The problem is that consumer prices aren't rising. Right now whatever the central bank/government is doing is only affecting mortgages, student loans (more of a government thing) and stocks (through QE). None of the money is actually going into the "real" economy.
Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by Qasaur on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @07:59AM (#24059842)
Hyperinflation is the phenomenon when people wake up and realise that real estate and prices rising is not a function of real prices increasing but rather their money losing value. We already have extreme asset price inflation (not to mention the rapid expansion of the monetary base). In my opinion it is only a matter of time before people realise what is going on, start dumping their dollars/euros/pounds/etc., and use something else for their daily transactions and savings, probably crypto at first. It is worth noting that every fiat currency throughout history, without exception, has eventually hyperinflated and collapsed to nothing.
Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by gridlockd on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @10:41AM (#24061290)
> Hyperinflation is the phenomenon when people wake up and realise that real estate and prices rising is not a function of real prices increasing but rather their money losing value.

That is not actually what hyperinflation means.

> We already have extreme asset price inflation...

Sure, but we don't have asset price hyperinflation.

> In my opinion it is only a matter of time before people realise what is going on, start dumping their dollars/euros/pounds/etc., and use something else for their daily transactions and savings, probably crypto at first.

Dump the dollars for what? Most people have no savings, they have a monthly paycheck that goes right to expenses for the most part. That alone greatly limits the velocity of money and therefore the rate of inflation.

Those people that (rightly) expect inflation (not hyperinflation) have already piled into other asset classes.

Either way, there can't be hyperinflation without a commensurate increase in money supply, which can't be achieved just by people spending their money more quickly.

> It is worth noting that every fiat currency throughout history, without exception, has hyperinflated and collapsed to nothing.

That is untrue. Hyperinflation is exceptional. Inflation over a long time can erode a lot of the value, but that isn't hyperinflation and it's not necessarily a problem either.

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by imtringued on Thursday August 06, 2020 @06:04AM (#24069585)
> That alone greatly limits the velocity of money and therefore the rate of inflation.

Nitpick. It limits the potential increase in velocity of money. Spending your money as soon as you get it is pretty much as fast as possible. The reason why there is little inflation is that these people don't have enough money to buy all the things they want to buy, meanwhile someone else is sitting on a fat stack of wealth and wondering what to do with it.

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by imtringued on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:49AM (#24069503)
"High" inflation is what happens when a government needs money badly but can't acquire more debt. The final option is to just print money. Once there is a precedent of printing money it will be considered a valid policy tool and abused shortly after to expand the government budget. Printing money is actually extracting value from the existing economy. E.g. when you double the amount of money in circulation through printing you essentially steal 50% of value from the rest of the population.

What follows is that people lose trust in the currency and convert their currency into assets that cannot be taken away. This is hyperinflation. The "currency based" economy shrinks and there is less wealth to extract from it. Since there are a lot of fixed government expenses the amount of money that needs to be printed grows exponentially.

I$ = inflation dollar

The economy = the part of the economy that still uses I$

Inflation dollars are equivalent to dollars (I$ = $) in the beginning.

The economy is worth $1000 and has I$1000.

Government doubles money supply by printing I$2000. (100% inflation)

The economy is worth $1000 and has I$2000. I$ = $0.5.

$500 worth of value has been extracted but it circulates in the economy.

Hyperinflation begins: People start losing trust and put half their wealth into gold or something else.

The economy is now worth $500 and has I$2000. I$ = $0.25.

The government still wants to extract $500 of value out of the economy so they need to print money at a much faster rate than before.

Government quadruples money supply by printing I$6000. (300% inflation)

The economy is now worth $500 and has I$8000. I$ = $0.0625.

$375 worth of value has been extracted.

More people stop using the currency which means the economy shrinks again forcing the government to become even more aggressive.

Right now the central banks are following strategies that eventually demand every penny back that they have handed out. If inflation happens they can easily reverse their policies.

Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by qubex on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @02:02PM (#24063652)
There’s no actual definition of ‘hyperinflation’ that I’m aware of in the macroeconomic literature, beyond it being a quantitatively large value of inflation. What you purport to be the discriminante (economic agents’ perceptions, presumably households’?) isn’t actually tenable either, since famously “you need two cretins to make a transaction” (a buyer and a seller, both of whom think they’re getting a good deal).
Re:Gold price rises above $2k for first time by alasdair_ on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @06:31PM (#24066325)
> There’s no actual definition of ‘hyperinflation’ that I’m aware of in the macroeconomic literature

There are plenty of definitions, just none that are universally accepted.

It’s similar to “recession”, which in the USA means two quarters of negative GDP growth but isn’t a universally agreed definition.

Colloquially, in the USA, “hyperinflation” refers to Average price increases of over one hundred percent per year for a “basket of goods”.