News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by Traster on Monday August 03, 2020 @06:49AM (#24036189)
I'm sorry but I'm finding it very difficult to see how this isn't straight up propaganda from the BBC.

>The number of deaths from coronavirus in Iran is nearly triple what Iran's government claims, a BBC Persian service investigation has found.

This is false. There is a very important distinction between confirmed deaths due to coronavirus, and deaths of people who may have shown some coronavirus symptoms. One is clearly an undercount, one is clearly an overcount and they aren't measuring the same thing. So to publish on your state broadcaster a story deliberately mis-representing that fact is a bad move.

The data even shows that the confirmed coronavirus deaths track proportionately to suspected coronavirus deaths - actually showing that it's highly unlikely that the numbers are being manipulated.

If you go here: https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/ the UK government gives the exact same measure that Iran uses as their official number.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by DanBC on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:27AM (#24036394)
The UK government also has the ONS data measuring excess mortality (the most accurate numbers) and these are freely easily available online here: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthan...

Does Iran have similar numbers easily available? (Obviously, these don't have to be in English.)

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by knolax on Monday August 03, 2020 @04:27PM (#24042953)
Why would you expect a country under international sanction to make their data easily available to some random Westerners? Maybe with researchers but I really don't see how it would benefit Iran to spend resources on a website accessible by Joe Shmoe in England.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by pasabagi on Monday August 03, 2020 @06:59AM (#24036248)
To be fair, the BBC is about as independent as your average non-state media company, and definitely less entangled with the past five governments than anything owned by Murdoch.

That said, it is a bit awkward, given the UK's own undercounting.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by tankenmate on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:25AM (#24037447)
The BBC also reports on the UK's undercounting, so it doesn't appear to be playing favourites; but a deeper independent investigation would be needed. Also, the BBC has News Watch which is an independent group within the BBC that responds to and tracks criticisms of its output.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by pmachinery on Monday August 03, 2020 @10:59AM (#24038506)
> The BBC also reports on the UK's undercounting, so it doesn't appear to be playing favourites

Does it refer to that as a "British government cover-up"?

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by justicezyx on Monday August 03, 2020 @12:52PM (#24040136)
Right, there is always a use of "mistakes" and "cover up".

It's like they always believe authoritarian leaders are much competent than democratic leaders, any mistakes in authoritarian nations must be cover-up.

Meanwhile, they also believe authoritarian nations are bound to collapse, because their leaders capabilities are eventually not a match to the complexity of managing the state.

Then, why isn't this the moment where the authoritarian leaders over reached their capabilities?

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by tankenmate on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @06:32AM (#24048545)
Well the ONS (which is a part of the UK govt) has been detailing the all cause mortality rate and detailing how and why those numbers differ from the official PHE numbers. The ONS releases its findings to the press, and the BBC is just one of many that report on these figures.

As far as I am aware there is no such thing happening in Iran.

So in the case of the UK the BBC is saying that UK govt response has been poor, and in the case of Iran that there is a "cover up". I would have thought that was bordering on a reasonable job of reporting the facts.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by plouffy on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:19AM (#24036337)
I'm struggling to see how this article is awkward for the BBC. It's not as though the BBC has not reported the situation in the UK: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-53592881 .
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by seamyb88 on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:13AM (#24036312)
> To be fair, the BBC is about as independent as your average non-state media company, and definitely less entangled with the past five governments than anything owned by Murdoch.

Absolutely not true. From propagating the idea that life-long advocate of equality, Jeremy Corbyn, is antisemitic, to sending well-fed journos out on boats to chase migrants (never people, migrants) around asking them what they want, the BBC is a Conservative mouth-piece.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by pasabagi on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:14AM (#24037339)
I dislike the BBC as much as anyone, but I think the fact is, they are neither anybody's mouthpiece, nor do they have any particular agenda. Simply, it is staffed by well connected, wealthy people who live in and around London, and as such, represents their views - warts and all.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by nickcox on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:55AM (#24036553)
Not to mention _literally_ portraying the chancellor as Superman. [1]

[1] https://www.thenational.scot/news/18620765.bbc-slammed-portr...

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by phatfish on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:31AM (#24036858)
And Corbyn was Lenin. I think that tells you all you need to know about the BBC.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/jeremy-corby...

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by mhh__ on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:33AM (#24036874)
Find me one instance of the BBC directly calling Jeremy Corbyn an antisemite.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by ceejayoz on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:13AM (#24037316)
Why would anyone do it directly when you can just insinuate? "Critics say..."
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by mhh__ on Monday August 03, 2020 @12:16PM (#24039644)
So you can't.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by ceejayoz on Monday August 03, 2020 @12:23PM (#24039738)
Correct. You have slain the strawman! Congratulations.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:18AM (#24036741)
BBC seems to get about as many accusations of left-wing and right-wing bias: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_BBC

...which in my book means they must be doing something right. Their reporting certainly seems less rabidly partisan than pretty much anything in the US.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by phatfish on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:39AM (#24036944)
Fence sitting does not automatically make you right. Half way between two falsehoods is still wrong.

For the BBC they HAVE to keep the government happy to continue to exist, or they will be legislated away. Same as any other state owned broadcaster.

Although the threats from the current government against the BBC seem empty. Why would they destroy the most successful government controlled media operation in the world?

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by fault_lines on Monday August 03, 2020 @08:56AM (#24037128)
The right controls the non-government media organizations just as well, what's the difference? The BBC is harder to control because it legally is supposed to be impartial.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by andybak on Monday August 03, 2020 @10:05AM (#24037913)
I find it comforting that both the left and the right in the UK is convinced the BBC is hopelessly biased against them. They must be doing something right.

(I'm being slightly flippant - I am aware how it's possible to be wrong on both counts. However I do think calling the BBC a "Conservative mouth-piece" when many on the right of the Tory part think the BBC is left-wing and beyond repair is a little unfair)

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by flir on Monday August 03, 2020 @01:47PM (#24040940)
The BBC are biased towards the status quo - left-leaning social policies, right-leaning economic policies and a (currently) Conservative government.

The right-wingers get upset about social pieces, the left-wingers get upset about economic and political pieces. But it's not even possible or desirable to be utterly unbiased, so one of our broadcasters being "the voice of the Establishment" doesn't seem like that bad a thing to me. It's not like other broadcasters aren't avaiable.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by fault_lines on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:06AM (#24037235)
The right wing in the UK has been inserting their own people into top BBC positions for years. The BBC has a history of working with the security services to deny employment to anyone 'too left wing'. Some of the most well known faces on the BBC are Conservative supporters - Nick Robinson was chair of the Oxford University Conservative Association, Andrew Neil was the editor-in-chief of the Conservative supporting fascist rag The Spectator and remains chairman of its publisher. Its function over the last 10 years of government has been increasingly, and highly visibly, to propagandize for the Conservatives and smear the left.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by pasabagi on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:12AM (#24037311)
I'm aware of this, which is why I said 'about as independent', rather than 'independent'. I think the point is, the BBC is representative of a certain group of people, many of whom are from the same milieu as parts of the conservative party, and parts of the labour party.

However, that could be said of most (all?) large media organizations in the UK.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by jibbit on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:02AM (#24036261)
This is government data that says 451,024 people tested positive and the figure they released was 278,827. Are you reading the same article?
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by Traster on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:26AM (#24036383)
Okay, so let me lay out why I'm suspicious of those numbers in the context of the article. The paragraph before that states:

>The number of deaths from coronavirus in Iran is nearly triple what Iran's government claims, a BBC Persian service investigation has found. The government's own records appear to show almost 42,000 people died with Covid-19 symptoms up to 20 July, versus 14,405 reported by its health ministry.

Now those two things aren't the same - the number of deaths of people who could possibly have had coronavirus isn't the same thing as the number of deaths of people who were actually confirmed to have coronavirus. The first is a quite expansive definition which is what the BBC is using, and the second is the number the Iranian regime publishes. And that second definition is a perfectly reasonable thing to publish, it's what the UK publishes and reasonable people know that's likely to be an undercount.

Now, given that the BBC is already comparing apples to oranges, comparing the suspected cause of death with confirmed. Let's look at the claim you're quoting.

>The number of people known to be infected is also almost double official figures: 451,024 as opposed to 278,827.

So what I'd want to see, before I took the second quote seriously, is a defintion of what the numbers refer to.

Because if you read it in context, that sounds to me very much like it could be the BBC is doing exactly the same thing again, comparing the official figures which are the number of people actually tested confirmed cases, with the unofficial figures, which are simply people presenting with symptoms but not comfirmed.

Testing capacity is a worldwide issue, but apparently with Iran we're going to try and literally tie this to the Iranian revolution.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by tankenmate on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:45AM (#24037657)
But obviously there is a spectrum, some countries (like Belgium) have very little difference between their all cause mortality rate and their reported rates due to effects (not just direct) of the crisis.

Other countries (and going by this report that would seem to include Iran) are heavily underreporting to the tune of 60%.

And then obviously you have countries that are somewhat underreporting like the UK, where they have reported covid deaths of approximately 46 thousand, but excess deaths of 64 thousand giving an approximate underreporting in the order of 25+%.

As to the revolution, it's not likely the cause as merely another example of a tightly controlled society that is sensitive to criticism; a reflection of their fear of "losing control".

"Beware of him that would deny you access to information, for in his heart he dreams himself your master."

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by pvaldes on Monday August 03, 2020 @10:46AM (#24038374)
> government data says 451,024 people tested positive... the figure they released was 278,827

I don't know if the data were faked and I assume that everybody is applying "creative accountability" here. Not only in Iran. Is a political thing.

... but this is not so strange as it seems.

People can pass the test more than one time. As immunity is so short lived, each patient could test positive, then negative and then positive again, an "undefined" number of times. This should count as one patient, two events. I assume that each positive has a second try at least to assure that is not a false positive

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by mc32 on Monday August 03, 2020 @12:23PM (#24039733)
Whether he’s credible or not is debatable, of course, but the Iranian President himself announced 25MM infections[1] in Iran. Health officials downplayed the number. So there’s that.

[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-iran/i...

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by zaroth on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:17AM (#24037371)
All the COVID tracking is essentially propaganda. Like calling a marathon at Mile 5, but even worse, because there really isn’t just one metric that can tell you how you’re doing.

Sweden, for example, was pilloried because their policy had them run their marathon through all up-front. Now they get to essentially return to life as they once knew it, having never had to strictly lockdown like what you see in Australia right now.

So it’s not just death rate, because you have to adjust for whether you can reasonably say you’ve finished the race, or whether your running on a treadmill at Mile 1 just hoping the race gets “canceled” (effective vaccine in widespread deployment) before you run out of stream.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by mensetmanusman on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:37AM (#24037582)
Yep, I cringe when the media talks about ‘covid cases’ instead of noting that the only way to properly compare is with per capita testing statistics in hand.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by newacct583 on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:09AM (#24037268)
> One is clearly an undercount, one is clearly an overcount

In practice they're both very likely undercounts. In the developing world, many people die from illness without ever having been seen by a health care professional at all, or counted as anything.

It will be years before we have a good model for real infection rates and excess death statistics.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by scottlocklin on Monday August 03, 2020 @10:46AM (#24038366)
Significant numbers of excess deaths are really, really easy to count. No complex model needed.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by newacct583 on Monday August 03, 2020 @02:26PM (#24041445)
In the industrial world, sure. In Iran? I really doubt it. And even given good morgue and hospital reporting, there are confounding factors: we're dying more to covid but less to other causes due to the lockdowns. Or alternatively some conditions are harder to get treatment for and less likely to be well-diagnosed, etc...

I think I stand by "years" until we have a good consensus model for how the pandemic spread and what the effects were.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by scottlocklin on Monday August 03, 2020 @05:45PM (#24043826)
I'm pretty sure Iranians can count dead people, and they absolutely count as "industrial world." I've known a few Iranians in my day, and they didn't strike me as particularly incapable of things like counting the dead. People could do this before computers and heavy industry. You tend to notice dead bodies; they smell bad.

That's really all you need; a historical time series of dead people. Frankly, the US, Europe; it's the only data for Covid I look at any more because the rest of it is politicized and site specific, and a changing process over time.

For example:

https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps/

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/covid-data/covidvi...

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by newacct583 on Monday August 03, 2020 @06:25PM (#24044197)
That's a specious interpretation of what I said, and frankly paints it in a racist manner that's more than a little offensive.

Obviously Iranians "can count". What developing nations don't have is a way to get all the dead COUNTED. Some old guy dies in a little village with little to no government services: who's job is it to "count" that death? How do you get that entered? Do you just trust cousin Farhad when he tells you at your office in slightly-larger-village three days laters? How do you know that's not the same death as this other person called in? The names are spelled differently, but maybe that's just a mistake?

Be serious here. Running a government is a hard problem. If it were easy, we wouldn't even have "developing" nations at all.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by parshua on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @05:15AM (#24048139)
Iran is an industrial country. That's why Venesuela's economy crumbled after a year of sanctions and Iran's has endured decades: They produce a huge amount of their needs locally. It also has the most sophisticated healthcare system in the Middle East. It may not be as good as Western Europe, but it competes, or may exceed, the eastern Europe. To understand where Iran stands, you can consult [1] and get surprised that its output is not only more than the whole ME combined, but exceeds some countries in Europe.

[1] https://iranian-studies.stanford.edu/sites/g/files/sbiybj619...

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by scottlocklin on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @10:05AM (#24050068)
> What developing nations don't have is a way to get all the dead COUNTED

This is one of the most ridiculous, preposterous and ... bigoted assertions I've heard all day: of course the Iranians can count the dead. They were probably capable of it 2500 years ago under Cyrus. They're certainly capable of it today[0]. You realize the Iranians make stuff like cars[1], aircraft[2], and have successfully hacked "advanced" US stealth drones[3], right? And you think they can't count dead people?

[0]https://irandataportal.syr.edu/census

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automotive_industry_in_Iran

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_Aviation_Industries_Organ...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93U.S._RQ-170_incid...

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by tptacek on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @10:56PM (#24056854)
In reality, where we can just look these statistics up rather than attempting to derive them from first principles based on axioms like "can build a car", Iran is one of a handful of countries with particularly low-quality death statistics. Regardless of how good Cyrus was at this, Iran's modern-day statistics are even lower than their upper-middle income status would predict. Maybe it was easier when there were fewer people living there.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by scottlocklin on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @11:15AM (#24061727)
Presumably you have some citation to back up "particularly low-quality death statistics" for the Iranians. I see no indication this is true, other than some people don't like the implications of what their death statistics say. It might be true, mind you: but citations needed.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by tptacek on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @12:37PM (#24062736)
You presume correctly.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by m3kw9 on Monday August 03, 2020 @01:21PM (#24040587)
Wouldn’t be surprised there is incentive to undercount as much as they can.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by amiga_500 on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:55AM (#24037776)
You cannot trust the BBC on the big stuff where the UK has policy interests.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by james412 on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:58AM (#24037811)
You can't trust the BBC whatsoever since they started trying to compete with commercial media a few years ago. "BREAKING: Iran is evil! UP NEXT: beach babes who like to grow moustaches" Total shitshow
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by GordonS on Monday August 03, 2020 @02:16PM (#24041305)
Yes, BBC news has gone way, way downhill over the past 10 years or so. Titles have gotten more and more click-baity, and the subject matter more and more pointless and/or designed to cause outrage. The language of writing definitely changed too - you shouldn't need to read a dictionary to read an article, obviously, but it's like they're writing for a target market of either 7 year olds or imbiciles.
Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by amiga_500 on Monday August 03, 2020 @02:21PM (#24041377)
There is the whole dumbing down thing, sure. But the main issue is that the BBC is ultimately state TV.

The UK establishment have influence on the stuff that really, really matters. Corbyn is a great example. The BBC accumulate political capital on smaller stuff that is unbiased, then spend that to keep people who want systemic change that impacts vested interests.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by chiefalchemist on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:17AM (#24036328)
> There is a very important distinction between confirmed deaths due to coronavirus, and deaths of people who may have shown some coronavirus symptoms.

Yes. Correct. Agreed.

If that's the measuring stick the USA has been overcounting. Healthcare has been authorized by the CDC to count suspected but unconfirmed (i.e., no test) as positives.

Add in the fact that healthcare facilities are compensated more for Covid-19 case, and most of those facilities are for-profit...what could go wrong?

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by DanBC on Monday August 03, 2020 @07:30AM (#24036408)
No, they're undercounting.

You can't get away from the piles of corpses, and only a small number of these are explained by the increases in other deaths.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by chiefalchemist on Monday August 03, 2020 @10:30AM (#24038177)
No. They're not. The tradition and standard of comorbidies has been _completely_ abandoned.

It's absolutely unscientific to say that ever death with C19 present was caused by C19. That's not how it works.

The fact that this ruse has been normalized doesn't make it right.

The truth is, at this point, the data is in such shambles that it can't be used to produce accurate information to drive intelligent decisions.

That's what we've been seeing, and continue to see. Believe what you want but the absence of comorbidies should be a red flag. Either you see the danger in that slight-of-hand, or you dont.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by DanBC on Monday August 03, 2020 @10:53AM (#24038444)
How many corpses are there? How did they die?

If you're claiming they died of cancer or heart attacks or cardiac arrests or stroke you still need to explain why there are so many more than normal.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by chiefalchemist on Monday August 03, 2020 @11:57AM (#24039374)
The smartest thing for me to recommend is to find someone who understand comorbidies and how they have traditionally worked in healthcare, cause of death, and so on. They'll explain it quicker than I can. You're also more likely to listen to someone you know.

That aside, you're assuming that any incremental death can be attributed to Covid and only to Covid. That's a false and unscientific assumption. Futhermore, in a country with the obesity rate of the USA's it's foolish to believe that Covid is the only thing leading to death. There's a reason it's called morbidly obese.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by DanBC on Monday August 03, 2020 @12:01PM (#24039432)
> The smartest thing for me to recommend is to find someone who understand comorbidies

I have, which is why I talk about all cause excess mortality.

https://blog.ons.gov.uk/2020/03/31/counting-deaths-involving...

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthan...

https://www.ft.com/content/a2901ce8-5eb7-4633-b89c-cbdf5b386...

> You're assuming that any incremental death can be attributed to Covid and only to Covid.

No I'm not. I'm asking you what you've read that makes you believe what you're saying. Support the claims you're making.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by vonmoltke on Monday August 03, 2020 @11:00AM (#24038510)
> Healthcare has been authorized by the CDC to count suspected but unconfirmed (i.e., no test) as positives.

Do you have a source for that? I have heard or read no such thing, and can't find any claims of such. If anything, the claims I see are of the CDC undercounting infections.

> Add in the fact that healthcare facilities are compensated more for Covid-19 case

Again, do you have a source for that? Many states are covering all costs not borne by insurance, but I have not seen anything to indicate any COVID premiums being paid.

> and most of those facilities are for-profit

No, most of those facilities are non-profit.

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by chiefalchemist on Monday August 03, 2020 @11:52AM (#24039285)
"In cases where a definite diagnosis of COVID–19 cannot be made, but it is suspected or likely (e.g., the circumstances are compelling within a reasonable degree of certainty), it is acceptable to report COVID–19 on a death certificate as “probable” or “presumed.”

https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvss/vsrg/vsrg03-508.pdf

Now before you say "Well, it's not that many" the truth is, you can't. We don't know. The data collection is sloppy, inconsistent, etc. But if you can find a CDC report that addresses this and breaks it out (read: transparency) then I would like to see that. Please share.

For the second:

https://www.factcheck.org/2020/04/hospital-payments-and-the-...

Re:Coronavirus: Iran cover-up of deaths revealed by data leak by chiefalchemist on Monday August 03, 2020 @11:53AM (#24039305)
Most hospitals and nursing homes aren't for-profit?

Do you have a source for that?