I disagree. The size of the fanbase is surprising, and so is the implication of this behaviour
I would argue that while US fans are more profitable in aggregate (first two terms) the reason the NBA sides with China is due to the 3rd term.
Chinese fans are vastly more sensitive to perceived "anti-Chinese" policies, whereas most US fans don't care one way or the other.
Therefor the NBA's position is very predictable. If you want the NBA to care, you have to convince US NBA fans that this political stance is worth not spending money on. Good luck with that because the NBA fans I know, don't care at all.
Só what? Why should that dictate what letters I can or cannot put o the custom jersey I buy myself and pay with my own money?
Critics are right to hold the NBA’s feet to the fire for this kowtowing behaviour. A lot of people are unaware of the degree to which China is extending its influence into Western countries.
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/aug/07/china-bans-win...
You can easily buy Winne the Pooh toys, books, and entertainment in China. There’s even a huge Winnie the Pooh ride in Shanghai Disney.
The article was about caricatures and the movie, which both were definitely and verifiably censored and suppressed. (As usual, the bans are unevenly and arbitrarily enforced.)
You talk about toys and books, which are not a problem.
Because the PRC will cut them off if they allow this, and the USA won't if they don't. And, so, serving the interest of capital says “knuckle under to the PRC”.
This is also why Hollywood movie studios do the same thing, and all kinds of other industries.
A neoliberal international order where major players are totalitarian corporatist states is a disaster for liberty, even beyond the ways a neoliberal international order is with all “democratic” capitalist participants.
‘Free Hong Kong’ has no racial or ethnic slurs or any profanity.
I wonder if I can buy a jersey that says “Free Uyghurs”. Where’s the line?
I think it's healthy to remind people, from time to time, how Hollywod (e.g. Tencent), the NBA, and other American institutions have sold themselves to CCP money.
Americans are used to others having to tiptoe around their sensibilities, and now they're finding out what adhering to a foreign culture's value system is like.
Always seemed quite the opposite to me, so much so that the most ardent opposition to "American sensibilities" is from inside America itself.
One is about the sensitivities of the people buying, one is about a government forcefully taking over a country and that government stopping you from saying anything about it.
When someone makes statements calling all American racists against non-whites they forget millions of non-white American people they casually toss aside to make their point. In this day and age can we move past that the false premise that all Americans are white?
The NBA, together with the stars taking the merchandise contracts need to admit that they have zero problem with racism, genocide, rape, and slavery as long as it's not their own people and as long as they can profit from it. I think the public would respect them more if they did that.
It's a dog eat dog world, and Lebron's gotta eat.
I, like many Americans, will always prefer democratic elections, rule of law, due process, right to bears arms in self defense, and free speech over government imposed "stability" any day.
Which seems a bit ironic
Although maybe that isn't what you actually believe. Maybe just how you happened to write
If we wanted to, but I think it's unnecessary for this conversation, we could compile a list for the terrible things that China and the US have done, and both list would be horrific.
There would be two significant differences between the two lists at the moment: The US military is much more active outside its own claimed borders The Chinese government is much more active suppressing speech and thought.
I do not believe these differences are due to any moral superiority on either side - that would be a rather remarkable claim.
The people run over by tanks in Tienanmen, arrested for political dissent in recent years aren't Americans, they are Chinese people pushing for a more open society, a desire for fairness is not an American quality it is a human one. As federal agents abduct protesters of the streets in Portland, it should be clear - abuse of power is not a Chinese failing, it's a human one. I think the there is a very good case that the difference between the lists of Chinese and American atrocities is simply a description of the differences in power and accountability of the two governments. There are plenty of good reasons to fear that both governments would like to expand their power and reduce accountability to look more like a hybrid of the worst of both.
Your last sentence takes something that's real - white racism and assumptions of cultural superiority, and elevates it to 'the real problem', I think you're close, but you've missed a bigger picture. A Chinese friend of mine told me about breaking in to hysterical laughter as a child when first hearing about white supremacy, a the story as she tells it now (ironically) is that her reaction was 'what idiots, don't they know the Chinese as the superior race!'
Identifying with a group is deliciously pleasurable, identifying with a nation, with it's flags and songs and strong military even more so, and puts us in a vulnerable position, in which powerful people can use that identification, to weave an overly simple myth about our country that blinds us to complexity. Free speech, ending military aggression won't kill China or America, but it will destroy the power and fortunes of some within those countries.
When we engage in tit for tat whataboutism in these forums, we are averting our eyes from the flaws in our own countries, and advancing the fortunes of the greediest and most destructive people in our societies.
https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/07/business/houston-rockets-nba-...
Then with an NBA focused on expanding its international fan base and Yao Ming, popularity grew even more.
How is basketball different from almost any team sport in this regard?
Edit: Japanese comic “slum dunk” has a huge cultural impact to those were born around 90s. NBA starts broadcasting to China around 95, Jordan, Iverson, Kobe became super idol since then. Not to mention Yao Ming. Also China team sports is pretty weak, only volleyball and basketball stands out(China’s soccer team suck, tell that to any Chinese and they will agree lol)
Most countries have rappers now, emulating the style.
If there's a village out there that doesn't buy American cultural products, there is someone whose job it is to sell it to them.
Quick wiki research:
There have been regular Houston Rockets games that had over 200 million viewers from China. The super bowl has about 100 million in comparison.
At the scale we’re talking about, this will become a recurring issue across many industries as you simply can’t deny the power of the Chinese market.
The distribution of American cultural exports is far reaching.
Gangsta rap came to Greece in 1997... [0]
Basketball is a quite popular sport internationally, unlike the 2 other big American inventions: baseball and football.
Only a handful of countries outside the US have professional baseball leagues[1]. And other than Canada I don't know any country that has a professional football (gridiron) league.
Korea has baseball leagues.
Mexico has football, Japan, Brazil, China and Poland.
American Basketball vs. Chinese Hardball: Guess Who Won https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/13/world/asia/china-nba-cens...
NBA Stars Study Hollywood’s Playbook in China https://www.wsj.com/articles/nba-stars-study-hollywoods-play...
NBA, 'South Park' episodes spotlight Hollywood's China dilemma https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-hollywood/nba-south...
‘South Park’ creators issue mocking ‘apology’ after China reportedly bans sitcom https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A1KCVj_v0ik
Band in China https://southpark.cc.com/full-episodes/s23e02-band-in-china
It's interesting how China is turning the globalist policies of developed countries into power. The government bans a cartoon character due to memes and suddenly lots of huge companies start censoring themselves out of fear. The US may have freedom of speech but it doesn't matter if China is the bigger market.
Protip: this is the covert part. Who convinced you that's what's happening? Riling up Americans to make a lot of noise about how "China is totally getting one over on us, we swear" makes it realistic and keeps those things in China as sources of American cultural osmosis. If Disney or NBA "took a stand" then they would get the boot just like South Park did once Matt & Trey took the fall (and ton of free publicity) to prove that possibility is real.
For what it's worth I also absolutely see e.g. TikTok as the same concept in a slightly different domain and operating in the other direction. I don't know where I stand on "banning" it in America since the idea does offend my inner libertarian but China already set the precedent there many many times over.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-10-09/china-s-5...