Former options market maker. We regularly got incredibly detailed data requests from regulators following corporate actions. Everyone who made money got scrutiny. Anyone who made money who wasn't similarly profitable before is almost automatically punted to their broker's compliance department, who will put in several hours of investigative work by default.
One of the most consistent knowledge gaps between professional and amateur traders, I've found, is the underestimation of how advanced and pervasive insider trading / market manipulation surveillance is.
> Anyone who made money who wasn't similarly profitable before
WSB is one offs and gets investigate. Other market players have historical data showing they are not one hit wonders. Like someone who hits 5/17 is different than one who hits 1/21
It's something you know intellectually, but MAN it's wild to see it in action.
The price of Tesla would plummet by 75% for at least 30 mins while the mess was sorted. If it dropped to 500, you could make 500k easily without very much risk of being detected. Then switch directions and buy calls. Easy money. Or get 5 friends to but 1 put each. Not that hard and pretty undetectable.
Can you please explain to us how all-knowing and how all-powerful the SEC / gov is?
Given the SEC only has a staff of 4600 employees?
How advanced and how pervasive are their technologies?
Any examples?
And 4,600 is just the number of employees at the SEC — there are legions of employees at the relevant institutions who work on data compliance.
Someone who buys a few million in puts just before hacking twitter is indistinguishable from some random robinhood user who decides it's time to go all in on puts because of a wsb post.
Lots of people have had the idea that the SEC/FBI/etc. can never catch them. Right up until they go to prison.
Of course, insider trading among well connected hedge fund managers and our unaccountable financial elite is indeed pervasive and goes by without being prosecuted all the time, but it's fair to assume yesterday's hackers aren't in this protected class.
And a lot of those non-prosecutions involve either (a) civil fines, (b) the compliance department censuring or firing the relevant employee, or (c) the Feds backing down from a fight with a big white shoe defense firm. None of that applies to these Twitter hackers.
Any stats/evidence to backup your claim?
Because anyone could just buy a crap load of $0.10 options marked a week out, wait a few days, then tank the stock. It would look like you got stupidly lucky, I have no clue how anyone could connect that to the twitter event directly. Especially since it’s not like you’ll be the only one that “won the lottery”.
(Tesla isn’t a great stock for doing this though because their IV is so high that the premiums are crazy expensive)
The more standard deviations you go into profitability, especially over one trade, the more likely you'll be to get the stink-eye.
From that point, if someone raises a flag, it's just a matter of seeing whether they've been implicated in anything else. It's why departments that seemingly have no reason to have intel access are hooked into classified networks - precisely for this kind of data sharing.
Precisely why you would be caught.
So you would investigate this poster for insider trading? There are thousands of posts like this each week.
For these people buying $10,000 out of the money contracts on a random ticker is completely normal and still legal. So tipping somebody like that off would certainly hard to correlate.
Is your position outsized relative to other punters in the OTM weeklies market? Most people don't bet the farm on one big lottery trade because the risk of ruin is too great.
Will there really be that many people who time things as well as you do and haul in a bonanza payout as though they had perfect foresight? A lot won't even be watching the market for the 5 or 10 minutes your rumor moves the stock, and of those who are, a lot of them will hang on for moar gainz.
Basically you can use not that much money to buy unlikely to be profitable options and make an actual crapload of money - and it would look identical to just being lucky.
The thing is 90% of people don't trade options themselves, and 99% of people don't do random fd plays. If you tipped off someone from WSB then they'd likely get away with it - that's what they do. Tip off a family member who has never traded options before, well....
Time is also a factor here. It's possible the hackers here were afraid their insider would chicken out. If they were afraid of that, they don't have time to setup a realistic looking brokerage account, transfer money and do some trading to make it all look good. That type of setup would take weeks or even months. If you sign up and the first thing you do is go all in on TSLA puts shortly before this happened you're gonna be on a list of suspects.
(This is assuming that the hackers did not have control of the time window in which they had elevated access.)
Yes, but of those people, a lot of them probably have a history of buying TSLA puts because they are generally bearish on the stock. Or a history of buying calls on HTZ. And they've lost a lot of money in the past over this, because TSLA keeps going up and HTZ keeps going down.
In other words, I can look at all buyers of HTZ and TSLA stocks and most likely eliminate those with histories of buying puts or calls on these stocks.
So now I have a smaller pool of people who suddenly bought HTZ or TSLA puts/calls. Of those, I can probably eliminate anyone with small positions. This isn't worth risking for a profit of a few thousand dollars. Sure I can get a few friends together to invest from their accounts, but the more people i involve, the more i risk. Plus, i can't just do family members or friends who live nearby (unless i'm in a major city), because it'll look strange if a group of people who are related or live close to each other are running the same trades at the same time.
So now they have whittled it down quite a bit. So i bring in the FBI and I start investigating my much smaller list and I target it towards people with computer savviness. It's can probably eliminate accountants and many others who most likely don't have skills to hack twitter. So it's a smaller group of people and the chances of getting caught are no longer so small (not to say it's impossible to get away with it though).
It's not comparable to something like the Hertz thing which drags on for weeks or the TSLA run-up which has been going on for months. Imagine filtering for trades that happen within a specific 120-second window. Then filter by people who have atypically large volume during that window. It's not a long list.
Also, you could filter for new traders and traders overly invested in TSLA. Giving the rather mediocre execution (i.e. single Bitcoin address), I doubt the attacker had a lot of time and capital upfront to hide in these masses.
Lastly, stock market transactions can be paused and are reversible - there's a good chance of a circuit breaker hitting or a reversal happening with that blatant market manipulation.
Keep in mind that a lot of the SEC's enforcement breadth comes from brokers' compliance departments. Any time anyone makes an unusual profit around corporate actions, the SEC basically requires a thorough investigation by the broker's compliance staff.
> I highly doubt that the SEC wouldn't put the required resources into this
I doubt they would not -> I think they would
The SEC would be extremely motivated to find these people to make an example of them so others think twice in the future.
Not sure I agree they'd have investigated thousands of people.
Because prosecuting Elon Musk requires going up against top tier defense lawyers and proving things like "Musk tweeted this with the intention of impacting his stock's value" or something.
With hackers, you can use the financial stuff to target the hackers, and then either (a) prove the computer crimes or (b) use the computer crimes and the surrounding stock sales to prove intent. You also don't have to go up against a legal defense better funded than some militaries.
You and I and yesterday's Twitter hacker are not in this class.
Given that he said "buy the stock" and "short the stock", options leverage may be the missing puzzle piece for the author.
When communications are hacked, the market typical figures it out in a matter of minutes. Anyone wishing to capitalize on a Twitter hack would have to have perfect timing to exit their trade.
If someone was trading options of a similar volume all day every day before and after the hack, they might be able to blend in. However, once you filter down on the number of people who caught windfalls in the narrow window of time between the hack and when the market reversed and then filter further for people who invested atypically large amounts on that particular trade, it's not as short of a list as you suggest.
As of today, Hertz trading volume is around 5 million, while Tesla volume is around 13 million.
I still think the OP is underestimating the risk of getting caught though.
- Any head of state is communicating directly with the press at all times through their comms department and/or they themselves commanding the focus of the press.
- Any specific company targeted, as soon as the movement in their valuation occurred, would be able to blast out the truth via PR Newswire that the specific claims were untrue and the result of a hack.
I think in this case since the correction would occur so quickly the number of trades executed made by retail would be pretty easy to sift through, and you’d undergo heavy scrutiny, even if you had an established trading history that explained your position taking.
A retail investor would be very easy to catch, basically. On something like this, I’d imagine enforcement would be a federal priority. The data available to law enforcement on matters like this is voluminous and it would only be a matter of time. Lack of enforcement is usually just a resource constraint or low prioritization. You’d have to have a much more complex plan than just taking and exiting a market position.
The only conceptual framework I can fit the idea of getting away with hacking twitter accounts to move the market and successfully exiting would be an institution with billions of positions moving fluidly in a predetermined way to align with the information seeded by the twitter posts for a short period of time. But why would anyone do that right now when all the investment banks have close to record revenue? Just 5 months ago, investment banks were in a rough spot. Now they are raking in this market recovery with little effort. I don’t know why you’d expose yourself to prison for a one time gain that would be limited because the institution needs to it make it obvious this occurred so you cannot extract maximum return.
1. The attacker has enough capital to load up on HTZ calls or TSLA puts.
2. The attacker has been planning this for a while.
3. The attacker is a US citizen
If any of those is not true, it changes the risk/reward considerably.The money one is easy. Even if you get a bunch of call options for free, and if you manage to temporarily push TSLA down 10% (unlikely), then you still need $900,000 in working capital in order to exercise enough of those options to be able to dump them later for a $100,000 gain.
#2 and #3 adjust the actual risk of the operation. #2 because shoving the money around quickly gives a clearer signal for the SEC to pick up on, and #3 because triggering a whole bunch of extra KYC red tape risks getting even more hounds on your trail.
BTC does have to be turned into fiat. But I can only assume, based on how rarely people who conduct ransomware scams and the like seem to get caught, that bitcoin laundering is a solved problem.
Furthermore, professional black hats tend to have business expenses that can be paid in bitcoin so they don't even need to convert all of it.
Not true, you can sell to close back into the market without exercising. This is what most options traders do.
Also you can easily get them for "free" in a manner of speaking, if you use something like a bull put spread. You sell a naked leg of the position that pays for the purchase of the other leg.
Doing this anonymously would be much harder, but that's not what you were suggesting.
It's likely you could continue to narrow things down via KYC data; location, past trading history, etc.
Sell a call spread, buy a put spread, do a diagonal calendar...
The more relevant question is "does the SEC employ people aware of the various techniques available", to which the answer is "of course".
There are certainly some strong employees as well, but they have only so much time.
An objection that, while true, doesn't impact "will they go after Bitcoin scammers" much. If anything, it's precisely the sort of thing they'd prefer to do over fighting with industry.
If you don't leave evidence for a targeted inspection against you, it wouldn't help them to be able to narrow it down to "you probably did it" if they couldn't clear the "reasonable doubt" hurdle.
Regulators already surveil and request records in respect of trading activity following corporate actions. No warrant needed.
There's nothing to hide after the fact. Dump the burner computer you used for the hack when you're done and never log in to the accounts, VPNs and VPSs you used again.
That you have the money is an open and legal fact, so you don't have to conceal anything really.
That's what efficiency looks like. Each transaction took a small amount of time, the clerks processed each one efficiently and had little downtime between them. Each clerk was maximally utilized, and the DMV was fully utilized all day.
A DMV where you could walk into at any time and a clerk was available to help you immediately would be incredibly inefficient: it would have too many clerks who were being paid to stand there not working. Convenient, yes, efficient, no.
Yes, one can find examples of incompetence and inefficiency if one looks, but one can find the opposite as well. I think a blanket attitude of government == inefficient incompetence is an unhelpful one, and a major part of how you get DMVs that deserve the purgatory comparison.
You might be the only trader taking investment advice from Taylor Swift, but plausible deniability is all you need
One of the advantages of using BTC for this attack is that as a stateless currency, fewer states are willing to dedicate resources to pursue people getting their BTC defrauded out from under them.
Like what? Any proof?
How many crimes out of 100 do you think are actually caught and prosecuted by the FBI?
https://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/news/national-international/...
In this case, someone trying a major stock market manipulation would have drawn a lot of org resources. And given that even without those resources, it appears the dragnet may be closing in on them (https://krebsonsecurity.com/2020/07/whos-behind-wednesdays-e...), it would have likely been a bad call to try actual stock manipulation with their hack.
Any efforts to defer that (using a patsy with an established trading history, buying longer-term options, buying them earlier) cuts into your margins, and may well not work (since again, you've got to be the first one out since you know it's a momentary dip).
[1] - Remember, you know this is a momentary dip because you know the hack is going to get discovered soon, but the other investors don't know where the bottom is.
Also, I suspect that if the hack had occurred during market hours, Twitter execs would have aggressively shut down the entire site. I imagine the hacks were intentionally timed to start after the markets closed to maximize the window for bitcoin payments. Twitter stayed up, so if that was the strategy, it seemed to work.
Synchronize intent in one online bubble. Make it look like banal, random, distributed behavior via Robinhood transactions.
Mom, dad, grandma, and grandpa sat on the couch shouting impotently at Dan Rather.
The kids are shouting about all that behind their backs and figuring out how to leverage information technology from age 5 at a different scale than 30 years ago, to coordinate
Feds would first filter the list of traders who have clean backgrounds and narrow it down to anyone who haven't been trading the stock for a while and they will review anyone who have withdrawn their cash quickly.
Unless you have been doing years of planning, planting clean evidences, you would stand out from the crowd.
This is utterly clueless.
Finally, people (apparently even the "informed" crowd here) greatly overestimate the difficulty of identifying individuals or actions in massive systems that are effectively recorded and completely surveilled, and they underestimate the resources of the feds. It's usually not that hard to whittle down to a handful of actions, and even if there are hundreds it only takes a tiny bit of taxpayer money to comb through it by hand.
It just requires having capital already and trading the indices.
Not if the perpetrator already participates in a cryptocurrency economy.
And even if the individual wants to convert to government currency, do you think that's a big hurdle in post Soviet states, or for state-sponsored attackers?
> The big issue with all of these is that it’s very difficult to participate in the stock market anonymously. The SEC has all sorts of monitoring in place to catch more common forms of insider trading and fraud and you can guarantee that they would conduct a long, thorough investigation into a hypothetical hack-based market fraud. Unlike Bitcoin transactions, wire transfers and stock purchases can be reversed after the fact, and the exposure and risk go way up when you’re actually working with US dollars.
But this is divorced from reality. In reality you'd be one of thousands of people holding HTZ calls or TSLA puts in your Robinhood account. You could make a huge payday and be indistinguishable from the crowd. With the crypto scam, one person will eventually have to turn this BTC into fiat. With market manipulation, you've made thousands of retail investors indistinguishable from yourself rich. Which one sounds like a better idea?