News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by wendyshu on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:14PM (#23812376)
Not just arrested but tortured, as we've seen with the two Canadian Michaels and the British Simon Cheng.

Edit: British-employed not actually British

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by nabla9 on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:33PM (#23812544)
Chinese government is constantly challenging the validity of foreign passport if the person is ethnically Han Chinese. Governments must apply diplomatic pressure go get their citizens free.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by razakel on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:16PM (#23812942)
This is also something Iran does - in theory someone can renounce Iranian citizenship, but it never really happens.

Essentially, if your father is Iranian, you are Iranian, even if you were born outside Iran, and you must go to Iran to request renunciation - which can be denied, and is hardly inviting for someone criticising the regime.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by alex_anglin on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:51PM (#23812707)
The Michaels are not ethnically Chinese.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by ur-whale on Sunday July 12, 2020 @02:42PM (#23813663)
> if the person is ethnically Han Chinese

How do they ascertain that? DNA testing?

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by aembleton on Sunday July 12, 2020 @03:54PM (#23814251)
Probably just by looking at them.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by Aperocky on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:58PM (#23812767)
Simon Cheng apparently were on British mission to gather intel and were called a spy by BBC, also, he is not British.

Check out the BBC interview:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_2TzuNsZDM

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by wendyshu on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:02PM (#23812806)
Oops, thank you.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by dehrmann on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:03PM (#23812817)
Aren't the Michaels just retaliation for Meng Wanzhou?
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by jszymborski on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:27PM (#23813022)
"just" retaliation... this makes their detention arbitrary. After Meng Wanzhou was arrested (and placed under house arrest in her multi-million dollar Vancouver mansion), the Chinese government arbitrarily picked two high-value Canadians (an entrepeneur and a Candian diplomat) and threw them into solitary confinement, interrogating them 24/7 in shifts, and giving ostensibly no access to lawyers/representation.

Oh, and by the way, you don't need to be a diplomat or entrepeneur to be picked up. They do it all the time [0].

You can read more about Spavor and Kovrig, the Canadians detained in solitary confinement in China for over a year, here: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/politics/article-michael-kov...

[0] https://torontosun.com/news/national/123-canadians-detained-...

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by mytailorisrich on Sunday July 12, 2020 @02:53PM (#23813747)
It's difficult to determine whether it is arbitrary (in the legal sense) because the Chinese government does not communicate on these issues and the Canadian government will obviously not want to spill any beans.

What is plain to me is that a Canadian guy who can live in China at the border with North Korea, can run a business there, and personally knows Kim Jung Un is not just any "entrepreneur"...

Likewise we cannot know exactly what "diplomat" means for someone stationed abroad (including Afghanistan, and Beijing).

I'm not defending the Chinese government but these 2 guys were clearly not arbitrarily picked, it's a little disingenuous to claim that they were.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by jszymborski on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:07PM (#23823689)
> I'm not defending the Chinese government

Strange, because this comment, as well as the vast majority of your comment history, expressly come to the defence of the CCP.

Being an entrepreneur nor a diplomat is not probable cause for an arrest, and the opaqueness of the CCP on all their criminal cases is by design for this very reason; it's a smoking gun, not a smoke screen.

You're right that these two weren't entirely arbitrarily picked, they chose two people high-profile targets as you normally would in a hostage situation.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by wendyshu on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:06PM (#23812846)
Indeed -- and who knows what China will retaliate for next.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by CountSessine on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:13PM (#23812904)
“just”?
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by im3w1l on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:40PM (#23813134)
Most people want to avoid being retaliation.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by runawaybottle on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:46PM (#23812657)
Well Canada really defied China by arresting Huawei CFO and (could then extradite to US). China is really in a weird coldish war with the West, especially when you throw in England defying them with sanctuary for HKers.

They must be getting pissed, curious how things could escalate.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by eloisius on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:53PM (#23812725)
“Defying” implies that they are in some kind of authority over whether another country offers an immigration path to willing immigrants. No one is defying them here. They are acting outside the bounds of whatever legitimate authority they have, and have been doing so for some time. They are being checked.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by runawaybottle on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:02PM (#23812815)
Oh sure, I used the word with some attempt at seeing things from their perspective. China has been mostly seen as a rational amoral actor in the global stage, but it’s entirely possible over time their perspective is taking on a, you know, authoritarian shape.

‘You don’t just arrest our business leaders’, there’s a lot of face to save there.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by tristor on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:58PM (#23813267)
I don't think there's a time in living memory for most people on HN when China wasn't authoritarian. If anything, they've become more relaxed in the last 3 decades, but we're seeing them more recently re-exert authority.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by genoapol on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:22PM (#23812980)
Western citizens have to recognize the hypocrisy of these stands eventually, don't they?
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by hungryhobo on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:21PM (#23812439)
I would say only 1 Michael, The other one sold drugs in a country that specifically banned drugs
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by mthoms on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:38PM (#23812585)
This is incorrect. The two Michaels have been accused of spying. You're thinking of a third Canadian Robert Schellenberg. His punished was suddenly changed from 15 years in prison to a death sentence after a recent retrial.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-53104303

https://globalnews.ca/news/5257482/robert-schellenberg-death...

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by nicholas73 on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:17PM (#23812943)
IIRC, Schellenberg requested re-trial to try to take advantage of the politics despite that a re-trial had the possibility of increasing the penalty to death penalty even without political motivation. That is, he gambled and lost.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by hungryhobo on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:55PM (#23812737)
Ah my bad
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by kolanos on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:42PM (#23812625)
It appears the two Michaels were suspected of espionage? [0] The Canadians sentenced to death for drug smuggling were different people. [1]

[0]: https://www.cnn.com/2019/03/04/asia/china-canada-kovrig-spav... [1]: https://www.cnn.com/2019/04/30/asia/canada-china-death-sente...

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by wendyshu on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:26PM (#23812484)
Good point, committing a crime there is an especially bad idea.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by alex_anglin on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:53PM (#23812726)
Isn't the point of arbitrary arrest that the crime is figured out afterwards, if at all?
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by 0x8BADF00D on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:06PM (#23812851)
Sort of. In many Asian countries, the rule of law is very weak or nonexistent. This means you will eventually come into contact with the police - usually for the purpose of extorting a bribe from you.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by genoapol on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:24PM (#23812998)
Don't bring drugs into Asia and expect to have a good time. This is one area that being ignorant of history can get one executed.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by poiuytrewqa on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:34PM (#23812548)
Why there's a country where doing a crime is a good idea? I can recall that also US still have capital punishment for example
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by justwalt on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:39PM (#23812600)
I’d imagine it’s far easier to be sentenced to death there as opposed to the US.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by poiuytrewqa on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:46PM (#23812667)
To be honest, as European I think China and US are pretty similar in many ways (propaganda, law enforcement etc).

So said each country has their own problem but if anybody focus more on resolving their internal problem before teaching everybody how to live would be better.

In this forum is very hard to discuss anything serious that doesn't follow the prevalent opinion that you get down votes without reason.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by Karunamon on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:00PM (#23812794)
You're probably attracting downvotes because comparing China (show trials, double jeopardy, arbitrary and whim-based penalties) to the US when it comes to capital punishment is not even remotely accurate.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by petre on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:39PM (#23813125)
The US has a police brutality problem, not a fair trial issue like China. And yes, long prison terms, a private for profit prison system and the death penalty in some states.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by kolanos on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:59PM (#23812780)
> To be honest, as European I think China and US are pretty similar in many ways (propaganda, law enforcement etc).

As a non-European, non-American and non-Chinese I find this utterly confused line of thinking depressing. It is clear Europeans are subject to their own propaganda in this regard.

[dead]
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by tristor on Sunday July 12, 2020 @02:02PM (#23813300)
Even if you acknowledge that a global hegemony lead by the US currently exists, it certainly has not "for the past few centuries". Value judgements on whether that hegemony has been a net positive or net negative for the world, aside. I'd say your viewpoint of the world is not based on reality.
[dead]
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by dang on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @03:01AM (#23842152)
We've banned this account for using HN primarily for political/ideological battle. Please don't do that.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by kolanos on Sunday July 12, 2020 @02:54PM (#23813762)
The U.S. (1865) and Britain (1833) abolished slavery before China did.

> Slavery in China has taken various forms throughout history. Slavery was abolished as a legally recognized institution, including in a 1909 law fully enacted in 1910, although the practice continued until at least 1949. Illegal acts of forced labor and sexual slavery in China continue to occur in the twenty-first century, but those found guilty of such crimes are punished harshly.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_China

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by boruto on Sunday July 12, 2020 @03:54PM (#23814252)
Briton still holds colonies to this date. As a citizen of former colony[India] its laughable when you say slavery was abolished in 1833 because people in my country were treated no better till our independence.

Edited.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by kolanos on Sunday July 12, 2020 @04:12PM (#23814373)
> As a citizen of former colony [...] because people in my country were treated no better till our independence.

Same could be said about the United States.

But unless you specify which country you're referring, I'll leave it there.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by poiuytrewqa on Sunday July 12, 2020 @09:49PM (#23816398)
I'd say we've to read both sides then.

> The practices of slavery and human trafficking are still prevalent in modern America with estimated 17,500 foreign nationals and 400,000 Americans being trafficked into and within the United States every year with 80% of those being women and children

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contemporary_slavery_in_the_Un...

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by TinkersW on Sunday July 12, 2020 @03:14PM (#23813924)
You do understand that much of the news you read about the US is wildly exaggerated?

Having traveled and met various young Europeans they were often suffering from amazingly ignorant ideas about life in the US(particularly the Germans).

One couple was scared they might get shot while traveling along coastal California. Surprise, gun violence is not evenly distributed, most Americans don't encounter any gun violence.

Police violence? Never seen any except on TV. Weird hu?

Seems to be plenty of propaganda in your own news media, why do you think you are equating China & USA?

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by poiuytrewqa on Sunday July 12, 2020 @09:40PM (#23816359)
The same problem you're referring to is also true for news regarding China. Have you ever thought about it?

I've traveled for an extended time in both US and China and as you say you hardly get shot on a trip in California you also will not get arrested just for holding a foreign passport in Shanghai

As far I'm concerned I felt much safer in China for many reason that I'm not here to explain.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by mytailorisrich on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:10PM (#23812886)
Leaving the discussion on right or wrong aside, the 2 Canadians were not targeted at random and were clearly on a Chinese government list of foreigners with close links to foreign governments' agencies that the Chinese let operate "at their pleasure". A bit like when e.g. Russia arrests and expels/imprisons Western spies the US/UK immediately know which Russians on their soil to target in the same way in a tit-for-tat response.

There are plenty of Canadians and Americans in China, including students, language teachers, expats, etc. and I don't think that they face any particular danger as long as they don't make waves. "Without explanation" (as per the article) is not the same thing as "at random".

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by jlokier on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:19PM (#23812952)
There's a big difference between:

- Expelling people back to their home country where they are still free as a form of diplomacy

versus

- Imprisoning, torturing and passing the death sentence as a form of diplomcy.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by mytailorisrich on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:25PM (#23813007)
That's besides the point. The point is that this is tit-for-tat retaliation that targets specific people whom we don't know the whole story about (You can try to set up a business at the border with North Korea and to get to know Kim Jung Un like one of the Canadians arrested... I doubt you'll get far). This does not tell you anything about life in China as a Canadian.

Edit in response to jlokier below: I think everyone with a bit of common sense understands what "making waves" means when travelling abroad, and especially when travelling to China (or any country with an authoritarian regime). Be respectful, don't challenge officials, don't get involved in politics, don't make strong political statements on sensitive topics. When you're a guest somewhere, behave like one.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by jlokier on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:37PM (#23813103)
The point is that the retaliation is life-destroying levels of severe, and "making waves" is extremely vague. Something nobody knows if they themselves are thought to be doing.

I visited china about 10 years ago, on a working trip. Nothing to do with government, just a very mundane bit of electronics we were collaborating on. While there I asked what I thought were innocent questions about ordinary life and politics, and it became clear that people there did not feel safe answering some of those questions.

To this day I don't know if that counts as "making waves".

These days, I would not feel safe returning to China for work. I recently turned down an excellent job opportunity that would require very occasional trips to China, because it seems just that bit too much of a risk at the moment.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by CountSessine on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:16PM (#23812941)
But this is the same faulty reasoning that led the press to underestimate the danger of covid19. The probability of arbitrary and unbounded detention and torture is very small, but the change in personal utility would be so terrible that you have to consider the risk profile of travelling to China to be similar to wingsuit-skydiving or exposure to radiation.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by mytailorisrich on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:21PM (#23812965)
I think the faulty reasoning is to assume that the arrest of these 2 Canadians means that Canadians are not safe in China. This is FUD. As said, this overlooks who these 2 Canadians are: There are apparently hundreds of thousands of Canadians in China and the 2 arrested clearly have links to the Canadian government and/or intelligence agencies.

The probability of being mugged and shot in the US is probably higher but I don't see articles telling people to stay well clear.

[dead]
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by dirtyid on Sunday July 12, 2020 @06:28PM (#23815293)
Other Michael is buddy-buddy with Kim Jong Un and operated NGO with North Korean dealings. Like when China retaliatory arrested Canadian Garrats who operated a Coffee shop in a prefecture level city on the border of China/North Korea in response to Canada extraditing a Chinese spy to US. No country is going to confirm their spies, but these are pretty obvious hints. Ex-diplomat/NGO is also typical spy cover in China - the country cracked down on foreign NGOs a few years ago with NGO laws packaged with counter-espionage and national security legislation. Both Michaels were also picked up by Ministry of State Security (national security), it was exceedingly clear messaging on day one, months before official chargers, that these two were picked up on espionage in retaliation. There's nothing particularly baffling that a surveillance state which compromised every CIA asset in country 10 years ago knows where foreign intelligence assets are. As someone who follows the space, Chinese retaliatory arrests are calibrated to separate diplomacy and commerce, hence arresting spies and (threatening to) execute drug dealers. Spies because historically spies have no rights, Michaels are fortunate that ICJ ruled spied get consular access last year, so there maybe some movement on that. Regardless, until they start detaining random expats there on business or travel, this is pretty much business as usual. That said, Canadian intelligence assets should GTFO out of the country, because if anything China has under-retaliated for Meng. They arrested 6 Japanese when Japan detained a Chinese fishboat captain over Senkaku. There will be more pressure coordinated with different phases of Meng's trial.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by mthoms on Sunday July 12, 2020 @08:47PM (#23816023)
For the most part I was unable to decipher your comment. At least insofar as to how it provides any evidence whatsoever that either of the men are spies.

All you seem to have said is that one of men is involved with North Korea (a close China ally, so I'm not sure how that supports your argument) and that "NGO is typical spy cover in China".

Hardly compelling.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by dirtyid on Monday July 13, 2020 @12:03AM (#23817034)
1. The Michael's fit the profile for spies that operate in China to a T. One Michael is ex-diplomat working at NGO, another works in NGO affiliated with NK and a source of NK information. Hint: Chinese officials with access to NK aren't the ones soliciting him for insights.

2. China has proven record to exposing spies domestically, seen in 2010 CIA debacle where every CIA asset in the country was compromised.

3. China doesn't detain expats arbitrarily. That's what western media tells their useful idiots to spread FUD. There are hundreds of thousands of expats in China, they don't need to waste time detaining innocent people. Just like how the drug dealer being executed has trafficking priors in Canada.

4. Ergo the Michael's were most likely spies, Chinese surveillance tech has only improved since.

Obviously, China is opaque on this issues so there won't be smoking gun proof. But people who watched this space for along time can connect the dots, and in fact did so immediately, before official charges were levied. One would need compelling evidence to demonstrate why they aren't spies, i.e. Canada doesn't spy on China or China doesn't have the capability to expose Canadian spies. But many people can't seem to accept China is a rational geopolitical actor who retaliated intelligently instead of randomly kidnap expats for shits and giggles.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by mthoms on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:31PM (#23825265)
Edit: You know what, after looking at your post history, I'm not interested in a response. Nor will I respond. That's because your entire post history (as far back as I went) consists exclusively of vehemently defending China on a wide array of topics. That's a bit of a red flag (pun intended).

Original post:

1. Sorry but "fitting the profile" is not compelling evidence. Of course they will pick people who "fit the profile". It's incredibly naive of you to think otherwise.

2. Since we don't know what percentage of spies they've caught I don't know how you can say they have a "proven track record" and therefore they are likely spies. What is their "proven" success rate exactly? What percentage? Can you provide citations?

I'm only vaguely familiar with the CIA incident you describe but - doesn't it follow simple logic that the CIA would support and encourage the narrative that all their spies were caught? Come on. Use your head.

3. It wasn't arbitrary. That's been established. As you said they "fit the profile" and served a political purpose.

4. Ergo nothing. The only "evidence" you've offered is that they "fit the profile". Laughable.

>One would need compelling evidence to demonstrate why they aren't spies

Wait what? Really? Is that how your version of justice works? The CCP has a proven history of lies and manipulation probably unparalleled in the world. I'm flabbergasted that you'd give them the benefit of the doubt without any evidence.

>But many people can't seem to accept China is a rational geopolitical actor who retaliated intelligently instead of randomly kidnap expats for shits and giggles.

You're intentionally conflating rationality with justifiability. They acted in their own self interest, which (by definition) is indeed "rational". Nobody disagrees that they made a smart (and wholly expected) chess move. The question is whether the move was justified.

None of the amateur armchair spymaster opinions you've offered come close to proving the move was justified. You've offered no compelling evidence other than "China wouldn't do that!" and "they fit the profile". Please.

Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by petre on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:23PM (#23812988)
At least Russia, the US and the EU expel each others' spies as opposed to imprisionment and torture. Tourture is even illegal and punished bt law in the EU, which adhers to the human rights charter.
Re:US citizens warned they face arbitrary arrest in China by FpUser on Sunday July 12, 2020 @02:20PM (#23813447)
They expel spies who are under diplomatic cover. Otherwise they get arrested and jailed. Well after that there is a hope that imprisoned spies could get exchanged.