News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by haolez on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:40PM (#23793327)
I'm from São Paulo and I'm embarrassed about this decision. Brazil's labor laws treat the "workers" as stupid people, unable to negotiate good terms by themselves. It's much better for them to have an intermediary - the government! - to handle this, and then pay 50% of everything that you make in taxes for this wonderful protection. It's ridiculous.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by gnulinux on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:21PM (#23793876)
What a strange comment.

> Brazil's labor laws treat the "workers" as stupid people

This has nothing to do with stupidity, intelligence or anything like that. This has to do with leverage. A multi-national giant corporation like Uber has a lot of leverage over Brazilian workers. If Uber treats them like figurative slaves and gives them too little money, workers have very little they can do against this. It is government's responsibility to protect people from this power imbalance. Yes Uber should have a freedom to charge/pay whatever market accepts and workers should have freedom to negotiate their own benefits. But at the same time Uber needs to implement a minimum care for their workers, and if not government should be able to enforce them to do so.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by devtul on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:56PM (#23794299)
Drivers are not bound in any way to Uber, Uber won't send slave hunters if they leave the app.

If people continue to drive for Uber, doesn't that mean the app is still a net positive for them, or do you believe people would pay to work?

Your comment is a great example of what the parent comment is saying, the belief that people are too damn dumb and they need protection.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by karpierz on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:45PM (#23794860)
I believe that people will take deals that don't benefit them. But that's not the point here. The numbers are made up, but say Uber makes 10$ per ride and the driver makes 10$ per ride.

If the drivers get together, they might be able to negotiate 15$ per ride, leaving 5$ per ride for Uber. However, it might be hard for the people to do that, so the government can step in to improve conditions for riders by negotiating for them as a block.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by AnthonyMouse on Friday July 10, 2020 @03:05PM (#23795078)
All of this labor theory only applies when you're negotiating with a monopolist. Otherwise the company already has thin margins as a result of needing to compete with other companies -- remember all that stuff about Uber losing money? -- and there is little more they can give you without trading it against something else you want, like flexibility or number of hours.

The primary way they could pay drivers more is by charging higher fares. But then there is lower demand for rides, so they need fewer drivers, so some of the drivers lose their jobs. If you think that's a good trade off then take it now -- quit and go do something else. It will cause the remaining drivers to be able to command higher compensation.

Everybody wants to be the one to get paid more and not the one who loses their job, but some of them will necessarily be wrong.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by gpderetta on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:34PM (#23794737)
You do not really have an option if all options are bad. And less bad options will be outcompeted by worse options.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by AnthonyMouse on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:58PM (#23795000)
> And less bad options will be outcompeted by worse options.

This is by definition the opposite of what "outcompeted" means.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by gpderetta on Friday July 10, 2020 @05:37PM (#23796804)
The option is bad from the employee point of view, bit the company, having smaller expenses can outcompete its competition.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by AnthonyMouse on Friday July 10, 2020 @07:55PM (#23798031)
That's true in the market for e.g. rides, but then that's good, customers get lower prices. Meanwhile their competition in the market for labor is mainly the likes of Walmart and Starbucks. There is no plausible mechanism for Uber to "outcompete" Walmart by offering cheaper rides because Walmart isn't in that line of business to begin with.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by _jal on Friday July 10, 2020 @03:03PM (#23795057)
> or do you believe people would pay to work?

Given that people fall for scams that take money in return for a fake promise of employment, yes, I do.

Aside from that, what is your limiting principle? Where is the power imbalance line between an employer and employee too much for this principle to bear?

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by controversy on Friday July 10, 2020 @03:19PM (#23795229)
It doesn’t exist. The people would stop working for the employer. They would work in other business. Perhaps work for those in direct competition to The Employer. The Employer would go out of business.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by darwinwhy on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:01PM (#23795738)
This is the kind of libertarian drivel I thought would be out of fashion by now. This isn't the naive early 2000s internet anymore. In the real world labor markets are not perfectly competitive, from non-compete clauses, to no-poaching agreements, to skillset mismatches, to a dozen other major factors increasing employer market power.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by _jal on Friday July 10, 2020 @05:18PM (#23796595)
This listing overlooks one of the biggest imbalances that lots of folks seem to overlook: employer monopsony. There are big chunks of the country where one dominant employer effectively controls employment, either directly or indirectly through the ability to pressure suppliers. Piss off the wrong person and you have a problem.

Of course, people born in those places can theoretically vote with their feet, although most people seem to find that much easier said than done.

https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/default/files/pag...

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by controversy on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:11PM (#23795875)
You’re right. The government puts restrictions on businesses that give established entities a competitive advantage. The government could end non competes. Some have. I’m not for no government. I’m for government of, for and by the people. Corporations are not and never will be people. They are contracting entities.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by Avicebron on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:46PM (#23796268)
Except rampant inequality enforces the power imbalance between the prospective employer and employee. Even without protection from competitors, established players will crush or absorb competition.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by dennis_jeeves on Friday July 10, 2020 @05:27PM (#23796700)
Who enforces the non-compete clauses, to no-poaching agreements ? - The govt. Remove the enforcer and not many employees will honor a non-compete.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by controversy on Friday July 10, 2020 @05:52PM (#23796970)
I said I don’t call for the abolition of the government. I want to reign it in. I want it to focus on a smaller set of regulations.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by dennis_jeeves on Friday July 10, 2020 @08:47PM (#23798353)
We are essentially on the same page. I was specifically responding to 'darwinwhy' . Infact I want employees to break non-compete agreements if they can get away with it because of it's somewhat inherent unfairness.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by lhorie on Friday July 10, 2020 @03:25PM (#23795311)
Disclaimer: I work for Uber and I'm brazilian. Opinions are my own, etc.

What the GP is criticizing is that they see this as a power move to increase government income through taxes. The underbrush is that this money is then stolen by corrupt government officials (it's common perception in brazil that that's just the way the brazilian government works).

In this light, Uber is just the sucker-du-jour who gets to be "screwed over" in the latest corruption ploy.

Uber's perspective in this type of matter is that there are a large number of drivers who don't do ridesharing full time or even on a consistent part time basis (for example, one's free to do it once or twice ever). An apt comparison might be someone who sells stuff on craigslist - yes you can do it full time, but people often do it for just extra cash, without considering it a "job" per se. So you can see why Uber might not like to restrict driving opportunities only to those who are willing to commit to a full-time employment arrangement.

With all this said, I'm all for having drivers who are effectively working full time hours to be able to earn a reasonable income. I'm not too familiar w/ the state of lobbying in Brazil, but my understanding is that Uber is going to be lobbying in the US for a third employment category and one of the talking points of that proposal is to work towards income improvements for drivers. The position that drivers are not employees goes both ways: if they are considered Uber's clients, it behooves that Uber should do its darn best to provide the platform with the best payouts in the industry, lest drivers would flock to a better paying competitor.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by ldec on Friday July 10, 2020 @03:11PM (#23795146)
>workers should have freedom to negotiate their own benefits

This is likely where the comment of laws treating the workers as stupid people comes from - Brazilian labour laws are very rigid with an amazing amount of restrictions around negotiating different benefits, working hours, etc. If, however, you earn a higher salary then you fit into a different category of labour laws and are allowed more flexibility. The thinking seems to be "if you earn under this amount you probably didn't receive a good enough education to know what is good for you". Sometimes that may be true, but it is a very dangerous line of thinking.

[dead]
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by devtul on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:48PM (#23794214)
If you think it only makes sense to hold conservative values if you are rich, it only means you don't know what you are talking about.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by gcbw3 on Monday July 13, 2020 @05:29PM (#23825768)
when conservative means conservation of the oligopoly, then yes.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by lvass on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:08PM (#23794460)
That's uncannily accurate in an entirely different manner. Many Brazilians "dream" they will become millionaires if the marxists get in power again, due to hyperinflation.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by ianmobbs on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:49PM (#23794232)
They're just doing what they've been told is best for them by Bolsonaro, the same way the largely-impoverished American South votes for Trump. (I assume it's a similar voting block in the UK for Johnson but I haven't looked it up)
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by vidarh on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:50PM (#23793462)
Where are you getting 50% from? Everything I can find suggests tax rates in Brazil are below those of most OECD countries, and well below the OECD average for example, and the full tax wedge (which includes employer contributions) average for OECD for every category they report on is below 50% [1].

[1] OECD numbers are available from OECD's Taxing Wages 2020 report: https://www.oecd.org/tax/taxing-wages-20725124.htm

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by d0100 on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:17PM (#23793820)
The 50% is calculated from all benefits (vacations, etc). For a large company and hourly wages, it can go up until 95%.

Source: http://www.guiatrabalhista.com.br/tematicas/custostrabalhist...

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by mrep on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:32PM (#23794020)
Don't know how accurate this website [0] is but it shows a 68.17% employment cost versus 31.42% for sweden [1]. Wow that is a lot if it's true.

[0]: https://papayaglobal.com/countrypedia/country/brazil/

[1]: https://papayaglobal.com/countrypedia/country/sweden/

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by zorked on Friday July 10, 2020 @03:01PM (#23795038)
If you look at the spreadsheets you will see, for example, the 13th salary included as overhead. It's not overhead: it's part of employee income and goes directly in their pocket.

The 95% figure is for hourly employees and counts worst-case expenses over their raw hourly rate. In every other country vacations (including weekends!) are just counted as employee income and in that spreadsheet it's accounted as some sort of tax. Every country's overhead rate would go up if you accounted things in this absurd way.

The FGTS is a really stupid scheme that should die but ultimately goes into the employee's pocket, so it's also a form of income and not a tax. (It's a kind of mandatory savings account.)

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by vidarh on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:50PM (#23794234)
The person I replied to argued 50% of a person income would go to tax:

> and then pay 50% of everything that you make in taxes for this wonderful protection

For non-salary labour costs to make up a large amount relative to salary is a very, very different argument.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by controversy on Friday July 10, 2020 @03:27PM (#23795336)
Sweden places the tax burden on the individual not the corporations. Their Corp tax rat is 21%. The same rate that the Republicans pushed for in the tax change. The difference is the average citizen is taxed at 48% vs the US average of 21.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by vidarh on Saturday July 11, 2020 @07:25AM (#23801263)
Total tax wedge (which includes taxes paid by the employer) for an average Swedish citizen without children is ~43%. For one with children it is lower.

Total taxes paid by the employee for an average Swede is closer to 25%.

The highest marginal rate for someone on an average salary in Sweden is around 48% for the total tax wedge, but someone on the average is not paying that marginal rate.

For the same categories the total tax wedge for the US is 24%, and the total tax ~18% (for comparison the marginal rate for an average earner in the US in the same category is 40.8%)

Source: OECD Taxing Wages 2020

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by walshemj on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:26PM (#23796043)
But does that take health care and other benefits into account ?
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by controversy on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:32PM (#23796110)
It takes into consideration health care.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by walshemj on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:35PM (#23796134)
Really I am not convinced - I know a UK expat (worked for Citi bank) and he was paying well over 15% just for heath care just for him - and his wife already had federal benefits (Something senior in the FBI)
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by csomar on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:58PM (#23793564)
You are looking at taxes. There is probably more taxes in the form of health insurance / retirement thing. It's incomparable to Europe since in most EU countries you probably get some coverage in return to the money you paid while, in third-world countries, health care is sub-bar or non-existent.

As for retirement, inflation will probably eat that.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by vidarh on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:08PM (#23793701)
The numbers I compared to were the "full tax wedge" numbers which includes social service payments both on the employee AND employer side on top of income taxes. I on purpose picked the category that gives the highest numbers in the OECD report, well above the numbers people will see on their tax returns in most cases.

I'm sure the commenter above was including something else, which is what I'm curious about, given that as far as I can tell the highest marginal federal tax rate I can find is only 27.5%, and average effective rates far lower, but I don't know what other costs people might incur.

If Brazil is in fact a higher tax country than most of the wealthiest countries in the world, I'd love to know more.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by aprdm on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:14PM (#23793775)
Brazil health care is actually decent, better than the American for sure.

Universities are also free.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by stephenfg on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:09PM (#23794461)
Regarding universities, they may be free, but the number of admissions is very, very limited. The competition is very harsh. In reality, most people who are able to get in are those capable of paying for very good schools or preparatory courses, and these courses can be very expensive [0]. Sometimes, people have to try for years before being able to join those universities [1].

When your family is very poor, this situation makes it impossible for the student to keep on trying. Sometimes parents can't keep paying for the preparatory course, or worse, the student may have to forfeit it's dreams of studying in favor of working and helping with household expenses.

As seen in [0], most people studying in free universities are actually in a pretty good financial situation.

Sometimes, people from very poor families manage to study for free, but this is rare and often newsworthy [2].

In my humble opinion, I don't think universities are really free. There are many financial costs associated with studying in a public university.

[0] http://www.brasil-economia-governo.org.br/2016/06/15/como-as... [1] https://g1.globo.com/pb/paraiba/noticia/2020/01/29/paraibano... [2] https://diariodonordeste.verdesmares.com.br/metro/estudante-...

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by hikarudo on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:31PM (#23794005)
Corporate taxes alone are 34%, one of the highest in the world.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by 0xfaded on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:42PM (#23794145)
Great! Corporate taxes hit both productive capital and labor!

Income taxes disproportionately hit labor in a world were capital is becoming more and more concentrated.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by vidarh on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:52PM (#23794258)
The person I replied to wrote:

> and then pay 50% of everything that you make in taxes for this wonderful protection

about employees.

I don't see how corporation tax is relevant to that.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by coldtea on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:48PM (#23793436)
>I'm from São Paulo and I'm embarrassed about this decision.

Strange, I'm from Europe and I'm proud of this decision.

>Brazil's labor laws treat the "workers" as stupid people, unable to negotiate good terms by themselves.

No, it just treats them as regular people that deserve the same rights as everyone, but which (as poor people in need of work and individuals) don't have the same negotiating power as a multionational employer to enforce them...

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by speeder on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:41PM (#23794824)
I am from São Paulo.

About our labor laws: They were created by a populist and fascist (I mean in the literal meaning, guy admired Mussolini) government, they are very, VERY, VEEEERY rigid and extreme, to the point Brazil has more "informal" workers than "formal", thing is, "informal" is just euphemism for illegal, basically the labor laws are so bad that most of the population work illegally.

I am 33, and I NEVER, had legal work, never found one, and thus for example I can't get unemployment benefits and many other rights.

Reason for that is these jobs are extremely rare, because it is ludicrously expensive to offer them, in some fields of all money a company spend in personel, 95% go to government (usually it is around 60%).

---

Now the second subject, is Uber relationship with Brazil, basically government so far been very hostile to Uber, and tries everything to screw with them, thing is, Uber (and competitors) here been a blessing, not just because it meant "cheaper cabs", but because it was only thing that could rid of Taxi Mafia.

Here in Brazil we have not only strong medallion laws, but often there are corrupt politicians in the Taxi Mafia, where they find excuses to not grant medallions legally, so they can sell them in exchange of bribes and favors, before Uber existed this got to a point where Taxi drivers would kill competitors on the street for some reasons, for example picking up passengers in an certain area without permission from the Taxi Mafia was a reason for that person to be killed.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by mateus1 on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:53PM (#23794936)
This is an dishonest and naive take at Brazilian labor laws.

We were the last country in the Americas to abolish slavery, only 60 years before Vargas created the framework to our current labour laws. Before that there were laws but they were seldom followed.

Of course the laws could use a reform (they are often confusing) but we have many good worker rights that we shouldn't give up.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by pcstl on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:57PM (#23794993)
Don't think he's being dishonest. Vargas was indeed a fascist, and I don't see what our being shamefully late to abolish slavery has to do with our labor laws being good or bad.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by mateus1 on Friday July 10, 2020 @05:00PM (#23796395)
This is barking at the wrong tree.

Brazil has tons of structural economic problems since its inception ever since the Portuguese came over. Saying the labor laws are to blame is completely wrong.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by pcstl on Friday July 10, 2020 @05:45PM (#23796897)
They don't help either.

Most of our labor laws are there for middle-class people to look at them and think "wow, aren't our labor laws great?" while most actual lower-class people can't get jobs that actually follow the labor laws because most people who employ them aren't able to both pay the bills and deal with all the financial obligations and regulatory uncertainty our labor laws create.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by adnzzzzZ on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:40PM (#23794821)
I'm from Brazil and Brazil is one of the most regulated places on Earth regarding labor laws and it costs the country a lot of productivity. You shouldn't assume that every country is like the average European country and thus what's good for Europeans will be good for the rest of the world.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by sgt on Friday July 10, 2020 @03:52PM (#23795636)
Exactly my thoughts as well. I think we shouldn't be so quick to pass judgement on decisions made in Brazil without hearing the various points of views. I get the impression is that there's a lot of bureaucracy and internal tension in Brazil. Is this getting at all better over time, or is it spiraling out of control?
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by pcstl on Friday July 10, 2020 @05:55PM (#23796998)
Spiraling out of control and accelerating. Brazil is dominated by very powerful interest groups, some of them corporate, some of them unions, which lobby for laws mostly in order to ensure they keep their power.

The unions keep wanting stronger labor laws, but these tend to apply in practice only to high-class workers in very unionized professions, while everyone else is lucky to even get a job at all, because the obligations our labor laws create are so insane that most smaller employers need to use legal loopholes just to be able to pay the bills at the end of the month (one of the most common ones is asking workers to open a personal company and paying their company for "services rendered" instead of the worker - labor courts hate this, but they know if they closed the loophole half of the country would be out of a job the next week)

The corporations keep trying to make labor laws weaker, but they tend to do so in ways that screw over the lower-class workers while the high-class, unionized workers are able to maintain most of their privileges.

It's a terrible situation. To make it worse, our legislative representatives and a large part of the electorate are very much infatuated with the (false) idea that our labor laws actually "protect" all workers, which makes it very hard to reform them. They are kind of a sacred cow to a lot of Brazilians. I don't see it getting better any time soon.

(I'm a US-raised Brazilian who currently lives in Brazil, by the way)

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by rafaelvasco on Friday July 10, 2020 @10:32PM (#23798972)
As a Brazilian I agree completely. You see, a story told several times is a very powerful thing. And Brazilian people have been told such a story by our government for so long that people not only don't realize how broken the system is, but they fight to protect it. To quote the best movie ever made:

"You have to understand, most of these people are not ready to be unplugged. And many of them are so inert, so hopelessly dependent on the system that they will fight to protect it."

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by jariel on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:53PM (#23794942)
"unable to negotiate good terms by themselves."

There's a massive power asymmetry between a mega international corporation and an individual.

It has nothing to do with 'intelligence' or 'competence'.

Surpluses go to the power. If employees had power, they'd be able to 'negotiate' better terms on their own, they never well.

At the 'low end' of the labour market, we have to have some kind of regulations or else they would get paid the 'bare minimum to survive' and an entire economy of accommodation, food, services would pop up around that system. Maybe like favelas?

So the issue is: 'where do we draw the line?' - which is really hard.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by Kaze404 on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:05PM (#23793646)
Please enlighten us on how you would negotiate "good terms" (as in, not being a figurative slave) with Uber.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by haolez on Friday July 10, 2020 @09:09PM (#23798477)
I'd work where it pays more. If Uber isn't this place, they will eventually be out competed.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by Kaze404 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @12:50AM (#23799600)
Do you think anyone in Brazil drives for Uber by choice? The Civil Engineers and Lawyers who can't find jobs in their fields? I have a friend who got a masters in Chemical Engineering 5 years ago and to this day sells cupcakes for a living. I know how nice it is to live in this neoliberal bubble of the free market, but I suggest you step outside and take a look at the reality of the country you live in.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by mrlala on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:06PM (#23795804)
>Brazil's labor laws treat the "workers" as stupid people, unable to negotiate good terms by themselves.

Hmm, ok that's quite a view. I would say that nearly all works are certainly unable to negotiate good terms by themselves.

The only workers that can negotiate their own terms are the small minority that are very highly skilled and in demand... laws like this are trying to help the vast vast majority who have NO power because the employer can just replace them with anyone else at the drop of a hat.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by AlexandrB on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:20PM (#23794593)
> unable to negotiate good terms by themselves.

I would love to see a single cite of a successful negotiation by a driver with ride-sharing services regarding matters of pay or pricing. Negotiation is not possible in contracts of adhesion.

Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by patgrdj on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:10PM (#23794482)
An example of Brazilian Mutt Syndrome where any foreign business/power/person/interest/whatever is more valued than the life or rights of a local.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by walshemj on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:24PM (#23796021)
You dont know labour relations in Latin America is more like the bad old days of the Pinkertons in the USA?
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by dzonga on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:23PM (#23794618)
wow!! slow down. you being from sao paulo, doesn't mean anything in the rights of workers. your comment would've been relevant, if you were an uber driver in sao paolo. but yeah gvt protections are very much needed in every country to protect the hoi polloi against corporations.
Re:São Paulo Labor Judge Rules Uber Must Pay Full Employee B... by TheSpiceIsLife on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:48PM (#23793437)
How do you reconcile this opinion with the idea that there is an inherent power imbalance between employer and employee.

Employers typically have way more financial and legal ability to negotiate themselves a better position versus one individual employee.