News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by sushshshsh on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:01AM (#23723581)
Over my dead body. Seriously, I lived in all kinds of apartments for 15 years and there will always be some kind of horrific nuissance no matter how hard everyone tries to be respectful of each other.

I'm all for increasing density, go ahead and build your buildings higher.

But don't do it at the expense of people who are willing to pay high premiums to have a small piece of land to avoid the noise, smell, polution, and crowding of apartments.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by pseudolus on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:07AM (#23723629)
The article is calling for the abolition of single-family zoning, not the imposition of zoning laws that mandate the construction of multi-family dwellings. Essentially, the author is a property rights proponent - if you own the land you should be able to construct whatever premises pleases you on it.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by TuringNYC on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:29AM (#23723820)
I'm a pretty big fan of high density housing, and in theory I like the idea of "if you own the land do what you want with it" but I saw the extreme end of this in a neighborhood where I lived. See for yourself (Google Street View below, do a 360 around the block)

Some thoughts: - 12story building next to 1story bungalow

- no mandate on 12story building to create parking per unit, so the entire block is flooded with cars trying to find places to park (also, this is the city, so many homes have no garage, you rely on street parking)

- tons of circling cars looking for parking all the time

- school not planned for the neighborhood. Sure, you built a 12story x 4unit = 48unit apartment, but there are no places in the school for the ~50 additional kids who suddenly appear. Yes you are guaranteed a seat in a school, but that could be 8 schools away and your kids can be in different schools depending on grade overflow levels

- giant garbage trucks (building-sized) coming and going into your otherwise quiet neighborhod

- giant A/C units pumping air for the whole building next to a 1story home

https://www.google.com/maps/@40.5783519,-73.9617788,3a,75y,3...

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by yohannparis on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:03AM (#23724608)
The developer will pay fees to manage garbage collection and school size increase when getting a permit. This is a city issue not a density problem.

Parking on the street is not a right but a public good. Everyone share, this has nothing to do with land owned per citizen. Raise the price of street parking. Again Parking is not a right, it's a commodity, and people should pay a market price for it.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by TuringNYC on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:04PM (#23725611)
>> The developer will pay fees to manage garbage collection and school size increase when getting a permit. This is a city issue not a density problem.

This map is from NYC. The neither the developer nor the permit increases the school size, the school is the same size it has been for decades.

Totally agree this is a city issue. I think the core problem is that everything needs to go in lockstep -- agreeing to, say, free-for-all zoning but handwaving all other problems as things the "market will solve" doesnt work because the solution doesnt come for years, or decades. For this to work, it all needs to happen synchronously. It clearly didn't, as evidenced by NYC's public school registration waiting lists.

A great solution I saw (same city) was when the developer built a public school for lease in the bottom floors of the high-rise to accommodate the influx of families. This is very, very rare in NYC though. Usually its a move-fast-and-break-things approach.

I also agree paid parking would solve the problem. But saying it "should" happen without joining it to zoning changes achieves nothing -- it just waves away the problem with a theoretically perfect solution. The zoning change would have been a great thing if it came with a long series of simultaneous changes in other policies from school size to paid parking.

This reminds me of a story from an acquaintance who was a dairy farmer. The jurisdiction passed a referendum mandating all eggs farmed would be free-range eggs. This tripled costs and raised the break-even price of eggs. The jurisdiction did not include on the referendum a restriction against importing non-free-range eggs. After the law went into effect, most voters who happily voted for the restriction continued to purchase inexpensive non-free-range imported eggs. My friend's egg farm went bankrupt. This could have been solved with a synchronous policy.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by troydavis on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:18AM (#23724736)
Your experiences make sense with such an extreme difference in uses. That said, in another comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23723331#23724541), cesarb made this point well:

> Abolishing single family zoning does not imply abolishing all zoning.

One can concurrently believe that some zoning is reasonable (or at least that some zoning is much less likely to have unintended effects), and also that single-family is unnecessary. As an easy example, in most jurisdictions single-family excludes duplexes and triplexes. Those don't have any of the problems you described.

SFH zoning is unique because it's so prescriptive about the allowed uses, it covers a huge percentage of residential land (https://www.seattletimes.com/business/real-estate/amid-seatt...), and it has a 75 year head start (current zoning is not what anyone would create anew today). High impact and little room to adapt to the actual market.

(Parking is its own challenge: https://www.vox.com/2014/6/27/5849280/why-free-parking-is-ba.... The root cause is that it's dramatically underpriced, so people have started to treat an extreme subsidy like a right.)

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by someguydave on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:37AM (#23723882)
The free market could solve the school and road and parking problems too.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by kanox on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:13AM (#23724207)
Not really, this seems like a textbook example of a property developer dumping negative externalities on the surrounding neighborhood.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by someguydave on Saturday July 04, 2020 @12:27AM (#23730117)
If the public schools were disbanded and parents could purchase appropriate schooling for each child then public schools would not be “dumped on”.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by baq on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:03AM (#23724113)
Please elaborate.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by geebee on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:26AM (#23723798)
Should you be able to trade your right to construct whatever you want in exchange for a legally enforced expectation that your neighbors will be similarly restricted in what they can build? Plenty of people would like to voluntarily enter that arrangement. Same with short term rentals - many people would like to trade their right to run a hotel out of their residence in exchange for a legally enforced expectation that they won't end up living next to a hotel.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by obblekk on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:29AM (#23723822)
Yes, but the law should enforce your agreement with your neighbors, not obligate you to form an agreement as it does today.

I think the biggest issue in zoning is the lack of a path to unzone something. If I convince all my immediate neighbors to let me build up (perhaps by giving them some equity in the new building) I should be allowed by the law to build. Today, even if my whole block wants to build up, we cannot.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by geebee on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:58AM (#23724073)
Yes, good point. I would support a more local regulation on much of this (same for Airbnb, I see no reason why people in the sunset should determine whether people in bernal can short term rent their properties).

Personally, I don't think you should have to get universal agreement either. Maybe a simple majority? Life does chance, cities grow to new borders, single family zoning that made sense a generation ago can be absurd later.

As for zoning vs private contract... well, for historical reasons, that's just how it works in older urban neighborhoods. That's the mechanism by which these property rights are decided. It's not ideal. But at my core, I do think the right to live in areas with certain building restrictions is a kind of personal property right just as real as the right to build whatever you want.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by kanox on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:03AM (#23724112)
> Should you be able to trade your right to construct whatever you want in exchange for a legally enforced expectation that your neighbors will be similarly restricted in what they can build?

This is an excellent point.

Zoning ensures you can buy a nice quite house which is surrounded by other nice quiet houses and they won't be suddenly replaced by high-rise buildings. For most people housing is their single largest asset and asking them to "just move" is not a particularly nice solution

Without legislated zoning this would still be possible but only in gated communities or similar. I'm not particularly familiar with US law in this area but local regulation seems to be a reasonable way to accomplish this.

Where I live a lot of people are complaining about the opposite problem: developers are constructing 7-story buildings in quiet areas, sometimes just outright replacing green spaces.

I personally live in a very crowded central area but still believe that suburban areas should be accommodated.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by someguydave on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:35AM (#23723867)
Should such an arrangement be subsidized by federal mortgage subsidy and federal road subsidies?
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by geebee on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:53AM (#23724027)
My answer? No. I'd support ending these subsidies.

There are a lot of factors here - property taxes are also sky high for new buyers, so it's a little difficult to consider this one question purely in isolation.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by jhauris on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:59AM (#23724580)
This is an excellent point, but I don't think that zoning laws are a good fit for that. Zoning laws can be changed (and often are) by a town council or other governing body regardless of what the land owners want. A permanent easement that can be put on one's own property that restricts what one can do on it is much more effective, and is exactly what you're talking about (trading a development right). In my state we have many properties that are covered by conservation easements; these are permanent easements attached to the property that prevent most development and grant some state tax relief. It also obviously negatively impacts land value, but it's voluntary on the part of the land owner.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by troydavis on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:39AM (#23723904)
> Plenty of people would like to voluntarily enter that arrangement.

This is still available as a covenant, which encumbers the property deed with restrictions on use. If a bunch of neighbors on a block decide to do encumber their own deeds, they can.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by alexandercrohde on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:05AM (#23724625)
Ridiculous. Completely hypothetical argument devoid of any real-world considerations.

Reducto ad absurdem -- A single crack-house can bring down the value of every house in the neighborhood by 100k or more.

Housing has huge externalities (traffic, parking, noise, crime, property values) and a lot of what makes a property a "good" property is having an area where those externalities are controlled so you can walk your dog safely at night.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by sys_64738 on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:39AM (#23724426)
Just no. Your ability to enjoy your land is you ability to enjoy the land around it. You want like for like in your neighborhood and don't expect sudden radical change. You don't want an apt complex right next door to your expensive house. I didn't pay the premium for that and suddenly don't want it invading my neighborhood. Zoning enforces consistency and if it sounds snobby then it probably is. People get tired of dealing with neighbors and the dramas and want space by moving to such zoned locations. They don't want to deal with new issues after the fact, either.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by jhauris on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:52AM (#23724515)
I enjoy living in a rural area and I understand your sentiment, but disagree with your reasoning. Somebody owns the forest behind me; as much as I like it, I don't feel right restricting what people can do with their private property. That's what public forest is for; it's land that is held in trust for all the people.

Obviously, I wouldn't like it if someone built a mall next door to me, but in a philosophical framework that includes land as private property (which is how I can own the little bit of land that I have and plant trees and garden on it), I have to accept that other people have rights on the land they own.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by ReptileMan on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:36AM (#23723874)
Building up can mess your neighbor sunlight and their expectation of privacy. Not that simple.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by kgermino on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:06AM (#23723616)
Abolishing single family zoning won’t do anything to prevent you from buying a single family house. The vast, vast, majority of houses will still be detached single family.

It’s just allowing the option to build an in-law unit and rent it out, or split the house into a duplex, or build a townhouse (houses with shared walls).

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by analog31 on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:35AM (#23723865)
It might just prevent you from living in it, for instance if it happens to be in between a discotheque and a pig farm.

What makes me nervous would be not knowing if my long term investment in a living space could be erased by some arbitrary use of the neighboring land. And individual homeowners would have no power against corporate owners of the land.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by cesarb on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:55AM (#23724541)
> > Abolishing single family zoning won’t do anything to prevent you from buying a single family house.

> It might just prevent you from living in it, for instance if it happens to be in between a discotheque and a pig farm.

Abolishing single family zoning does not imply abolishing all zoning.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by greenonions on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:27AM (#23724344)
Why is the government obligated to protect your investment? They aren't obligated to keep stock prices high, or to protect the companies land nearby.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by luckylion on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:31AM (#23724860)
> Why is the government obligated to protect your investment?

They are not. But they want people to invest, and people will not invest if they have no ability to predict the future circumstances. That's why governments try to create long-term systems and aren't running on mood swings.

Nobody will invest anywhere if all the parameters are up for redefinition every day. "Oh, you built your factory based on proximity to the high way and train line? Well guess what, those are lame, and we've decided to remove both because we want to be cool. We are not obligated to protect your investment."

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by greenonions on Friday July 03, 2020 @12:05PM (#23725147)
They will invest, they will just price in the risk. The same as any other asset. We don't discourage this behavior in other areas, so again, why do we protect house assets? This is especially striking with homelessness being such a massive issue. Why would we protect and inflate housing investments when so many are perishing on the street?
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by luckylion on Friday July 03, 2020 @03:00PM (#23726503)
> We don't discourage this behavior in other areas, so again, why do we protect house assets?

We don't? Pretty much anything the state is involved is specifically designed to be long-term. We absolutely don't want volatile systems, we want stability.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by analog31 on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:05PM (#23725616)
Making private housing investment less stable won't make public housing more stable.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by greenonions on Friday July 03, 2020 @02:15PM (#23726184)
Public housing was not mentioned. Making private housing more elastic will certainly reduce the amount who do not have an option that they can afford and that is legal.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by analog31 on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:03PM (#23725607)
I'd prefer to live in a society where the government protects the stability of some kinds of investments over reasonable time periods. A homeowner can't just pull up stakes every 5 minutes if living conditions drastically worsen. Yes I know there are people who live under those kinds of circumstances, and they're typically not very well off. There are also countries where the government has no influence on investment by virtue of being utterly powerless, and those countries aren't very well off either.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by salawat on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:32AM (#23724867)
Uh... Have you not been paying attention to the Fed recently?

I assure you, it may not be written down, but the level of protection of the stock market the government engages in Dr facto establishes the government is in the business of protecting long term private investment after a particular inflection point.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by greenonions on Friday July 03, 2020 @12:00PM (#23725097)
Of course I'm aware of the Fed. Do you think that the current market interventions are the best way to operate? In an ideal world, wouldn't the economy be much better off if it were able to sustain events like pandemics without interventions?

The guarantee by the Fed of asset prices will lead to more inequality as asset valuations are disconnected from their returns. Do we want this to happen? Same with the government interventions in zoning, is this what we want? It doesn't cost near as much to build a house or apartment as it is to find a place that you are allowed to. Do we want to continue to allow housing costs to be disconnected from what a house actually costs to produce?

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by ryanlol on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:19AM (#23724745)
You could just buy the neighboring land and only lease it out for purposes you deem acceptable.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by eplanit on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:44AM (#23723952)
Such "house as many as you can squeeze in" options will quickly turn neighborhoods into slums. The idea is planning for a certain density, and then not exceeding it. That way you can better plan for traffic, electricity and water usage, etc.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by yohannparis on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:05AM (#23724624)
What a poor argument!

HK, Singapore, NYC, Paris, and London are slums? The numbers of US tourist flocking them might say otherwise.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by eplanit on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:27AM (#23724816)
They contain some of the worst ones, yes. What a weak counterargument you make!
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by yohannparis on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:39PM (#23725883)
So: containing slums == slums... The density of those city is not contained in those slums.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by leetcrew on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:15AM (#23723698)
I'm sorry you've had such a bad experience with apartments. I find that if you pay extra for a new building in a neighborhood with a higher median age, there's really not much nuisance. I live in a small studio and I never hear or smell my neighbors.

I don't think anyone is talking about banning detached SFHs here; they merely want to remove the ban on building literally anything else. SFHs are quite popular, and whatever happens, I'm sure there will still be a market for them.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by ohples on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:10AM (#23723653)
I'm willing to make the concession that any urban area with > 100,000 should probably not have single family zoning.

Build your McMansion out int the boonies, just don't expect me to subsidize it with my tax dollars

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by seattle_spring on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:14AM (#23723693)
Seems like quite the strawman. A 1200 sq ft, or even 2000 sq ft home is not even close to a "McMansion", and a few miles from the urban core is not "the boonies."
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by omosubi on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:16AM (#23723706)
Not op but I'm still in favor of getting rid of subsidies for suburbs - they distort the market to benefit mostly wealthy homeowners to begin with.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by DudeInBasement on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:24AM (#23724798)
This guy has no idea how much those McMansions pay in taxes.

"Don't expect me to subsidize..." - said the Tax Cow

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by troydavis on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:29AM (#23723819)
> But don't do it at the expense of people who are willing to pay high premiums to have a small piece of land to avoid the noise, smell, polution, and crowding of apartments.

I think you may misunderstand what zoning does. Ending single family zoning doesn’t end single family houses, it just allows other housing types to be built as well. Many or most housing units would still be single family houses, with or without zoning.

This would remove the incentive to over-supply, not the incentive to supply.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by cheschire on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:03AM (#23723592)
Many folks felt the exact same about losing the Wild West to “civilization.”

Doesn’t mean you or they were wrong, but you’re most likely going to be plowed over by the machines of progress.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by jansan on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:24AM (#23723773)
By progress you mean population growth?
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by yellowapple on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:38AM (#23723892)
I think the title's a bit more provocative than the point I took from the article: that right now the premiums for that "small piece of land" ain't quite high enough due to that being specifically subsidized, and that we should remove restrictions preventing the construction of multi-family homes or residential/commercial hybrid properties.

My problem with apartments is that they ain't "mine". Not once has an apartment in which I lived allowed its tenants (myself included) to even paint the walls, let alone hang pictures with nails (gotta use those adhesive strips that absolutely suck) or mount a TV to the wall. And no way in hell would they allow me to do crazier things like putting Ethernet jacks and speaker hookups in the walls or replacing the light switches/fixtures (hell, most get uppity even if I change a burnt-out bulb) or putting in those fancy outlets with the built-in USB ports¹. Even if I were to "own" my apartment (i.e. as a condo) there's no way in hell they'd be okay with me swapping out the windows, or putting in better insulation, or installing a solar power system (and they'd probably still object to me ripping apart the walls to put in those Ethernet jacks / speaker hookups).

And then on top of all that, there are countless other things I can't do by nature of not "owning" the outdoor space, either. Shed? Nope. Barbecue? Usually not. Workshop? Not unless I'm lucky enough to have an attached garage². That DIY smelter I wanna build³? Hell fuckin' nope.

I feel like a happy medium (for me at least) between "stuck in an apartment" and "suburbia" would be townhomes or something similar: still "detached", but thinner and much closer together, with an emphasis on building vertical. Could even be on the same square footage of land, just thin and long instead of fat and square.

More critically, though, I strongly believe the distinction between "residential" and "commercial" zoning should be significantly blurred. Both in the sense of mixed-use buildings⁴ and in the sense of small business owners living where they work / working where they live (e.g. shop or restaurant on the first floor, and the owner lives on the second floor, as was once traditional).

----

¹: Though my previous apartment in Daly City did come with USB outlets, which was a pleasant surprise

²: Currently I am not so lucky, though the garage does have an outlet so as long as I don't draw too much down I might be able to get away with it

³: https://www.instructables.com/id/How-To-Make-The-Mini-Metal-...

⁴: I'm a strong advocate for underground parking + ground floor(s) for shops/restaurants + additional floors for apartments/condos or offices; even if apartments/condos ain't my cup of tea, I'd rather live in that sort of place than a building that's just apartments

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by emiliobumachar on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:00AM (#23724088)
That's orthogonal to density, isn't it? It's pretty common knowledge that very restrictive homeowner's associations are not rare for single family homes, mandating strict lawn grass standards and such.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by cultus on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:06AM (#23723620)
So the government should manipulate the housing market to benefit a small class of people who can afford single family homes in a place, even if it is detrimental the to vast majority?

If you want to live in a SFH, perhaps a dense urban core is not ideal for you.