News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by sesuximo on Thursday July 02, 2020 @04:38PM (#23717750)
It’s a little sad that we’ve retired the 747, the Concorde, and (almost) the A380. And we haven’t introduced anything cool :(
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by jrockway on Thursday July 02, 2020 @08:17PM (#23719604)
I don't think it's that disappointing. The airlines moved from larger flights to more frequent flights between more destinations. These days, you can miss a transcontinental flight and only be an hour late to your destination, because there are 15 flights a day instead of 2. You are also likely to be able to fly non-stop between any two city pairs. (I looked some up at random, and you can do things like Montreal - Casablanca nonstop instead of Montreal-Toronto-LHR-Casablanca; probably cutting your door-to-door time in half.)

Losing Concorde was unfortunate, but there were just too many limitations to make it viable. Flying supersonic means you produce a shockwave that breaks stuff on the ground, limiting it to flying supersonic over oceans. Flying supersonic means that you have to produce kinetic energy that goes up like the square of your speed, meaning you need more fuel, and you need more fuel to carry the fuel. It barely worked for JFK-LHR (relatively short distance, mostly over the ocean), and there just weren't other routes where it was viable. With no viable routes, it wasn't going to sell in any volume, and there is some critical amount of volume you need to justify the program (some fixed human overhead for every airframe project; if you sell 10000 of them, that rounds to zero, if you sell only 20 of them, that rounds to a lot).

Might be pessimistic but I don't think we'll ever see a supersonic airliner again. The sonic boom kills them. Those people that want to drill tunnels through the earth to get better-than-great-circle distances might be the future. But I'll probably be dead before anyone gets funding to do that.

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by noizejoy on Friday July 03, 2020 @12:07AM (#23720928)
> Those people that want to drill tunnels through the earth to get better-than-great-circle distances might be the future.

Might also get a little warm and you'd fight a lot of pressure, since you'd need to dig down about 1/3rd of the distance you'd want to save (assuming my elementary geometry memories aren't failing me). So to save 600km distance, you'd have to go down to a max depth of almost 200km. For context, the deepest bore hole drilled to date seems to be about 12km deep. [0]

So technology would have to improve a lot before global warming or the next meteor get us all.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kola_Superdeep_Borehole

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by jabl on Friday July 03, 2020 @04:47AM (#23722239)
If this SABRE hybrid rocket engine thing takes off (pun intended), then maybe we could have some kind of "semi-ballistic" long range flights?
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by vladvasiliu on Thursday July 02, 2020 @05:04PM (#23718067)
The A380 is as good as retired. Production was scheduled to stop in 2021 since 2019 [0]. It seems to have been advanced by the coronavirus crisis [1].

Air France has stopped flying the A380 [2].

[0] Airbus announces stopping production of A380 in 2021: https://www.capital.fr/entreprises-marches/airbus-annonce-la...

[1] Coronavirus gives the final blow to the A380 https://www.lefigaro.fr/flash-eco/le-coronavirus-donne-le-co...

[2] Air France flies the A380 for the last time https://www.lefigaro.fr/societes/air-france-fait-voler-l-a38...

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by kzrdude on Thursday July 02, 2020 @05:29PM (#23718271)
Stopped flying it? That sounds dire. Smaller planes, like the smaller airbuses, serve for 25-30 years, right, so why wouldn't the A380 serve them for longer?
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by gsnedders on Thursday July 02, 2020 @06:20PM (#23718780)
The economics were already marginal. You basically _have_ to fill the aircraft to justify its significantly higher operating costs over large twinjets today (and the fact that no airline has many means you lose many economies of scale). In addition, many of Air France's were some of the earliest airframes constructed, some of them non-standard compared with later aircraft.

With COVID-19 and an expecting reduction in travel lasting a number of years, all airlines are downsizing. An aircraft that's already marginal makes a lot of sense to drop, even it means letting it go while young. They're effectively getting replaced by the A350-900s Air France has on order which are _vastly_ more fuel efficient per passenger.

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by jabl on Friday July 03, 2020 @04:49AM (#23722253)
Any idea why the A380 is so fuel inefficient? It's a relatively recent design with modern engines etc., no?

(I've flown once on an A350. Very nice plane)

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by agurk on Friday July 03, 2020 @05:47AM (#23722584)
There are several reasons. A big one is having four jet engines rather than two. If you had two equivalent aircraft but one a twin jet the other a quad, the twin would have higher efficiency. With each extra engine you pay for it with more drag and reduced overall efficiency.

The engines on the A380 aren't actually that modern with the two options being 15-20 year old designs. One of the reasons it was discontinued is that no engine manufacturer was willing to make new engines for it, so they weren't able to produce a modern fuel efficient variant.

And it also makes limited use of composites in its design, so it's heavier than it would be if designed today.

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by jabl on Friday July 03, 2020 @06:55AM (#23722909)
> A big one is having four jet engines rather than two. If you had two equivalent aircraft but one a twin jet the other a quad, the twin would have higher efficiency.

One can make a good case for turbine engines having better efficiency the larger they are (less losses due to boundary layer friction etc.), so yes, if you have two otherwise equivalent aircraft I'd assume fewer bigger engines would be better. But here we don't have equivalent aircraft, as the A380 is bigger than, well, pretty much any other passenger airliner out there.

The A380 engines produce around 350 kN, which is slightly bigger than, say, the B787 engines. Admittedly the A350 engines are a bit bigger than that, but not by a huge amount. But the data seems to suggest both the 787 and 350 are much more fuel efficient than the A380?

So to make an equivalent comparison, one would take an engine, make a twin engine plane and a quad engine plane with that exact same engine. Naively one could expect the quad version to take twice the number of passengers or cargo, and have roughly the same fuel economy/seat. If not, why not? Which scaling laws are non-linear here?

> The engines on the A380 aren't actually that modern with the two options being 15-20 year old designs. One of the reasons it was discontinued is that no engine manufacturer was willing to make new engines for it, so they weren't able to produce a modern fuel efficient variant.

> And it also makes limited use of composites in its design, so it's heavier than it would be if designed today.

This explanation I can certainly buy. Also that the biggest turbofans are nowadays so large that a twin engine plane is already so big there's a very small market for quads.

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by gsnedders on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:15PM (#23725688)
Some of the problems with the A380 come from the wing design: it has an unusually narrow wing for its weight (out of a desire to remain within the 80m box), along with the shaping of the wing being optimised for a heavier, long A380-900 that never came to market. An unusually large proportion of the drag comes from the wing on the A380.

It's worthwhile looking at where Airbus proposed to improve the A380:

* Densifying the main deck (going to 11-across in economy, still with 18" wide seats). This _alone_ in a typical configuration gives a 9% fuel-per-passenger gain.

* They looked at new engines (derived from the A350, for example) which would provide a 5% fuel burn gain.

* Minor wing modifications (new winglets and slightly reduced wing twist) which would provide a 4% fuel burn gain.

* Longer maintenance intervals (so the aircraft spends more time in the air earning money rather).

Other differences include that it holds much less freight in its belly than a 777 (a much larger proportion of its hold is consumed with passenger luggage), so you lose freight revenue.

It's also worthwhile pointing out that engines are some of the most expensive parts to maintain on an aircraft, so by doubling the number of engines on an aircraft you make a very significant increase on maintenance costs.

At the same time, you have the 777X lengthening the 777 (and increasing capacity) while reducing fuel-burn per seat, a much more versatile aircraft (an A380 will never be profitable on the major of 777X routes!), and more fleet commonality.

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by stirlo on Friday July 03, 2020 @05:47AM (#23722580)
Dead simple. 4 engines instead of 2. Same reason the 747 is going away
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by sjagoe on Friday July 03, 2020 @04:30AM (#23722161)
At a guess, more demand for direct flights served by A350 and 787 and falling demand for hub-and-spoke flights served by A380.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by TylerE on Thursday July 02, 2020 @09:58PM (#23720346)
The 380 has many special issues, primarily that it is too big for most airports.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by ardy42 on Thursday July 02, 2020 @07:43PM (#23719358)
> The A380 is as good as retired.

Doesn't one of the Middle Eastern airlines (Emirates?) have good routes for it, so they can still use it heavily?

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by vladvasiliu on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:06AM (#23721179)
It's unclear what the situation for Emirates is. I would guess they're also hit by the drop in air traffic although they might be able to make the routes work with fewer people seeing how they have a lot of luxury offers.

According to the Figaro article, 8 of their 125 planes are still to be delivered. Maybe they could turn a profit by gaining a bigger share on their routes from other companies?

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by mantap on Thursday July 02, 2020 @04:42PM (#23717796)
I won't weep too many tears for the 747 but the A380 is seriously pleasant to fly on. It will be sad if it doesn't come back post COVID-19.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by ptmcc on Thursday July 02, 2020 @05:44PM (#23718414)
It didn't make economic sense for most airlines pre-COVID, and I doubt that'll change post-COVID. It was already in rapid decline.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by FabHK on Thursday July 02, 2020 @05:49PM (#23718474)
But it was a great plane to fly on for pax.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by fsckboy on Thursday July 02, 2020 @04:45PM (#23717839)
the 787 all-composite is very cool; it's just sad that it's too expensive to retool the rest of the product offerings.

And it's cool that Boeing figured out 20 yrs ago that point-to-point would kill hub-and-spoke (not least because it's a great way to fly) and very sad that Airbus wasted so much money and people's careers on an ego driven white elephant that Boeing already told them wasn't going to work, instead of using that money to push the real envelope.

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by Tiltowait-- on Thursday July 02, 2020 @04:40PM (#23717780)
The Concorde was done in by fuel prices, and because it was a small aircraft. I visited one in a museum and it was claustrophobic. Also nobody should be sorry that elites have to sit on long overseas flights just like we do.

The A380 was a boondoggle from the beginning, an attempt to outdo Boeing by having TEH BIGGEREST aircraft on the market. Having to rebuild airports to accommodate it wasn't a good idea.

The 747 is a 1960s design, for Pete's sake. How long were we planning on keeping it around?

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by jlcummings on Thursday July 02, 2020 @05:01PM (#23718034)
The B52 first was first rolled out for production use on 18 March 1954. The "...long-rifle of the air age..." -- Nathan Twining. It has not been manufactured since 1962. They are still in active military service, the ones that remain, and continue to see upgrades and evolving mission scope. 100 years of service is feasible.

Cost per flying hour of a modern B52: $70,000 [1]

1. https://www.airforcemag.com/article/re-engining-the-b-52/

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by gsnedders on Thursday July 02, 2020 @06:28PM (#23718855)
They also spend comparatively little time in the air. Compared with passenger aircraft where their return-on-investment strongly incentivises them being airborne as much as possible, military aircraft spend _a lot_ of time sitting around, either unused or in maintenance.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by imtringued on Thursday July 02, 2020 @05:23PM (#23718219)
It's very easy to upgrade a strategic bomber. All strategic bombers are prone to interception so the only way to stand out is by having a bigger and modern payload. You can see the same development with tank cannons. Bigger calibers aren't necessary. The Rheinmetall 120mm cannon can be upgraded by simply shooting modern munition.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by manigandham on Thursday July 02, 2020 @05:03PM (#23718057)
747 has been continually updated but the all modern airliners still have the same fundamental design.

> "Also nobody should be sorry that elites have to sit on long overseas flights just like we do."

Anyone can fly as long as they can pay for the ticket. First-class passengers subsidize economy seats for most flights, and new tech generally starts with wealthier early-adopters before it becomes accessible for everyone.

By the way, if you live in the West then you're an "elite" compared to billions. Let's drop the classism.

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by Scramblejams on Thursday July 02, 2020 @04:53PM (#23717942)
When I worked in aerospace I was told by a Boeing old-timer that he was sure Boeing only made the 747-700X proposal last as long as it did in order to force Airbus into making the A380 mistake, and that none of the Boeing insiders thought a plane that big would ever make real sense to spend money developing. Naturally I have no way to verify this, but it's a fun corporate strategy conspiracy theory.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by gsnedders on Thursday July 02, 2020 @06:35PM (#23718901)
I don't think there's any question that it was a response to the A380, and it's quite plausible they wouldn't have developed it without the A380. That said, compared with the A380 development the 747-8 will have been cheap to develop, and had an impact on the market as a whole even if it scarcely made much money.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by coin on Thursday July 02, 2020 @11:47PM (#23720850)
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by Tiltowait-- on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:53AM (#23723198)
It's pretty sad how Airbus defines themselves in comparison to Boeing, and Europeans define themselves in comparison to Americans in general. They don't have much identity of their own other than "screw you America! I'm the opposite of whatever you stand for!" It's so small-minded and petty, but unfortunately it's reality.
Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by mulmen on Thursday July 02, 2020 @06:03PM (#23718621)
> Also nobody should be sorry that elites have to sit on long overseas flights just like we do.

Or we could all be flying supersonic because of the economies of scale.

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by bobthepanda on Thursday July 02, 2020 @04:53PM (#23717944)
The 747 was updated recently: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_747-8

The major issue with the jumbo planes' (passenger) variants is that twin-engines now have significantly increased range, and have half the fuel consumption to boot. It's a lot easier to sell premium direct tickets rather than convince people to transfer onto a large cattle-class jumbo jet. Even pre-point to point, actually filling up a jumbo jet could be quite difficult, so now the death knell has been a long time coming, unless you're a Middle Eastern carrier operating the super-long-haul hub model.

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by hodgesrm on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:41AM (#23721324)
> The 747 is a 1960s design, for Pete's sake. How long were we planning on keeping it around?

Sometimes old designs are pretty good. The C-130 Hercules rolled out in 1956. It's still in service in the US and other air forces. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_C-130_Hercules

Re:Boeing quietly pulls plug on the 747, closing era of jumb... by hermitdev on Thursday July 02, 2020 @05:37PM (#23718351)
> I visited one in a museum and it was claustrophobic.

I also got to do a walk through in the Air and Space Museum over a decade ago. It's deinitely a tight space amd the seats were tiny. I'm not terribly tall, about 6 feet, and I had to hunch over to avoid hitting my head.