In other words, even if you own 10 rentals, you are probably wealthy, but the bank my still own a majority % of those assets.
If you're highly levered (as a smaller landlord), and funneling that income into retirement accounts protected from creditors (varies by state for IRAs, 401ks are federally protected), it's all upside with no downside. Heads, you walk away with appreciated real estate you eventually cash out of. Tails, you walk away from your investment properties while your retirement assets are protected with credit blemishes that are quickly forgotten by lenders. It is rare to be pursued by lenders in recourse states, as being (mostly) judgement proof and the option of bankruptcy are significant hurdles.
By "stripping equity" do you mean taking out home equity loans whenever possible? Or are there other efficient ways to strip equity?
Once you have enough properties to bump up against Fannie or Freddie GSE underwriting guideline limits (~10 properties), you transition into commercial lending, where you build a relationship with a bank and they lend against your combined portfolio.
EDIT: You can find more information regarding these strategies at https://www.biggerpockets.com/
It's not just free money. They're making money, sure, but considerably less than your calculation.
The building at the corner of Fillmore and Waller was bought for $1.05 million, 20 years ago. It has 6 retail storefronts and 18 apartments upstairs. Just one of the retail doors rent for $10000/month, or it did before this rent strangled the tenant:
https://hoodline.com/2020/04/cafe-du-soleil-shutters-after-1...
The building is assessed for $1.4m, so the taxes are around $15000/year (which the tenants pay under NNN terms) but the gross is probably well over $50000/month. And there's no landscaping, obviously.
These people are absolutely stacking cash. They are just parasites.
They are providing a service. You arrive in a new city with no money. Where will you live? The landlord is assuming the risk of owning and maintaining the building and all you have to do it put in a deposit.
The main reason they are "parasites" is prop 13. Without that, their building would be assessed at a reasonable level, and most of their profits would be property tax payments.
If you live in California, make sure to vote yes on the two partial repeals of Prop 13 this November:
https://ballotpedia.org/California_Property_Tax_Transfers_an...
https://ballotpedia.org/California_Property_Tax_Transfers,_E...
What service are they providing in their role as a landowner? Land (in the sense of it being in a specific location) doesn't require any maintenance or risk. It's also not like they created the land.
The majority of rent in SF comes from the land value, so this is the more relevant part to consider.
If you couldn't draw a rent from just owning land, the purchase price would go to essentially zero.
Another example I wrote in different comment:
> Let me give you concrete scenario of where the current system breaks down. Let's say I own an apartment building on the edge of town, and the city decides to build a new transit line to the community. Rents in my apartment building will go up; let's say by $100. Renters are willing to pay an extra $100 because they value living near a transit line more than the being far from one. But why should that extra $100 go to my pockets, while the government has trouble even paying for transit system? It's not like I was the one who built transit system, it was funded by the income taxes of the people who work there, and then built by the government.
This applies to all infrastructure spending of course.
In practice the percentage could be off, but the basic way the system works makes sense to me and I don't get the people who are sure that it's terribly wrong (whether because they are against taxes or against owning property).
Most infrastructure spending requires income taxes and transfers from the federal government, so clearly there is wealth transfer happening to the landlords.
You can dismiss it as anecdotal evidence, but I live very far away from SF, in a place built in the early 90s, within city limits, and it has not increased in value faster than inflation in all these years.
I don't doubt there are places where rent-seeking from land is not occurring. But we still need to address the places where it is a problem. And this will remain a problem as long as people require land to live, as long as centralization to cities keeps occurring (which we want more off, given its benefits).
My point is not that being a landlord has no risk or guarantees absurd returns. Rather, I'm saying that the returns from land do not come at all from the value that the landlord provides, so we should make sure those returns go back to the community that created them.
We tried that before, it was called feudalism. It's where the King owned all the land and the peasants were allowed a small piece of land to work and enjoy the fruits of their labor.
That system didn't work very well.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism
People own the land, they just pay a "user fee" of sorts to the commons.
Actually, the current situation is already like feudalism. Under feudalism, people other than the king also held land (the nobility). These landed gentry also drew the benefits of free rent, from the poor labourers.
Those with land currently can hold it indefinitely, extract a profit from it, and then pass it onto their children. That sounds a lot like the landed gentry under feudalism to me. The property tax tempers it slightly (which is why prop 13 is so bad), but it's easy to eliminate it all, while still keeping private landownership and market mechanisms for allocation (I definitely don't trust the government to own and allocate all land efficiently).
But it sounds like it introduced a lot of problems too.
In the case of a landowner, they need to put in no such work. They didn't create the land. All of the rent comes from the fact that they have a monopoly on a scarce good that cannot be produced further, and one that everyone needs. See Adam Smith [0] and David Ricardo analysis on rent for more on this (the Ricardo's law of rent is a really neat concept).
Now the fact that land and buildings are rented together complicates this a little bit, but this definitively applies to the rent that comes from the land.
Simply claiming two actions are equivalent because they both lead to lots of money is not a useful mental model. How you earn your money matters.
[0] - "The rent of land, therefore, considered as the price paid for the use of the land, is naturally a monopoly price. It is not at all proportioned to what the landlord may have laid out upon the improvement of the land, or to what he can afford to take; but to what the farmer can afford to give." — Wealth of Nations, Book I, Chapter XI
I mean, if I loan someone a million at 6%, I'm doing no work and collecting $60k a year!
Oh yeah, it's called risk. Similar to a landlord, the returns are in no way guaranteed.
Let me introduce you to some landlords who went bankrupt in 2008.
Land is a scarce resource with a fixed supply. If I want to rent land in SF, I don't too many options. And the demand is increasing, since everyone needs land to exist, and the population (at least in cities) is increasing. This gives the landlords a monopoly (see the law of rent: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_rent). In the case of loans, if I don't like your rate, I can simply go to a different lender.
Secondly, can you point out what we lose if the landlords doesn't exist?
If lending doesn't exist, there's businesses that would have started, but can not anymore, since they may not have enough capital to get off the ground.
If landlords don't exists, the land is still there, and we lost nothing, since land can't be created or destroyed.
> Let me introduce you to some landlords who went bankrupt in 2008.
My point is not that being a landlord has no risk. Rather, I'm saying that the returns from land do not come at all from the value that the landlord provides, which is not the case for lending, or other productive activities.
If landlords don't exist, people couldn't have a place to live unless they could purchase themselves. I think landlords are great - I can get a nice place to live and have none of the risk the landlord does. Property prices go down? I don't care. House burns down? I don't care. If I want to pick up and leave in a year? Great, here's notice. No real estate fees, paperwork, etc.
I think landlords offer a fantastic service.
> House burns down? I don't care.
You're conflating land rents and building rents. The "landlord", in their position as the building owner clearly provides a valuable service: the upfront capital/labour to construct the building and the maintenance. I'm not saying this shouldn't exists; it definitely should. They should capture all the profits that come from the rent you pay because of the building. My point is simply that they shouldn't be able to profit from the landownership itself.
> people couldn't have a place to live unless they could purchase themselves. > Property prices go down? I don't care.
The only reason land has a purchase cost in the first place is because you can extract a rent from it indefinitely. If land did not allow you to extract a rent from it in perpetuity [0], the purchase price would go to zero.
[0] - we can achieve this through a land value tax equal to the rent you could extract from the land.
This tax would obviously be higher in desirable areas, so there would still be a price mechanism to ensure that the land is allocated effectively. If I bought a parcel of land in North Beach, but then didn't use it productively, I probably wouldn't be able to pay the tax and I would have to get rid of it. Additionally, since the market value of land reflects its most productive use, it would incentivize using the land in the efficient use (ie. densely in a high value area, since that lets you split the tax over more people).
I'm not proposing we do away with rent as a concept. In the current situation, when you pay rent, you're really paying two rents combined.
The first rent corresponds to renting the land the building is on. This rent is why an equivalent apartment has a higher rent in SF than it does in Detroit or Houston.
The second rent corresponds to renting the building/unit itself. This rent is why a 2 bedroom apartment has a higher rent than a 1 bedroom apartment.
Now, the first rent is entirely uncorrelated with the value the landlord provides. It is essentially paid due to the landlord owning a monopoly on scarce good, which is only valuable due the community and government putting the effort to make the area valuable. Someone who owns land in downtown NYC didn't make it valuable, it became valuable because the government built the infrastructure to make the city livable, and the other residents made the city into a place where people want to live. Therefore, it's only fair that this rent goes to the commons rather than the landowner, where it can then be used to fund the government, rather than through other taxes.
What I propose is a land value tax equal to this land rent, so it is returned to the commons. The owner is still free to keep the rent from the building. This ideology is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism, and is pretty well supported from both an economic and fairness perspective.
And any one issuing any money to build anything won't be doing it unless it is profitable.
What you are against is basically profit. Unfortunately there is no way to arrive here(even with taxes) unless you can arrive at 0 inflation.
You now need a $1.4 million loan to live in an apartment.
I don't understand. If you buy a hamburger, you didn't create the hamburger. What does that have to do with whether you earned the money to buy it?
Not a fan of landlords as a rule but you are slicing your analyses of privilege way too thin.
Literally none of that matters in deciding who profits from land and who doesn't, and that's my entire point. The landowners in SF who didn't put this work in were still able to capture the rising value, and those in Detroit who did put all these effort in, didn't get anything to show for it.
Land doesn't rise in value because the landowner put in effort to raise the land value. The community and the government increased the value through building a city people wanted to move to (through building public transit, art scenes etc.). Why should the landowner capture that wealth?
Also, your tax point is moot, because California caps property taxes at essentially the level you bought the property at, so all the gains are free.
> the city you chose turns into a boomtown it’s good luck you have not earned
Yes, this is exactly my point.
Let me give you concrete scenario of where the current system breaks down. Let's say I own an apartment building on the edge of town, and the city decides to build a new transit line to the community. Rents in my apartment building will go up; let's say by $100. Renters are willing to pay an extra $100 because they value living near a transit line more than the being far from one. But why should that extra $100 go to my pockets, while the government has trouble even paying for transit system? It's not like I was the one who built transit system, it was funded by the income taxes of the people who work there, and then built by the government.
I guess my question to you is, why are we so attached to this system? As I pointed out, almost all economists agree that land rents "not at all proportioned to what the landlord may have laid out upon the improvement of the land". So why do we want to push forward a system where the reward is completely uncorrelated by the value you provide? Isn't that antithetical to capitalism?
Edit: To address your points about engineers, I'm not claiming that engineers do "real work" or "if you get rich in a liquidity event you earned it". I'm simply stating the reality of the fact that engineers actually produce something (code), while landlords don't (what could they even produce, more land???). If my landlord didn't buy the land I live 20 years ago, it would still be there, no worse for wear.
Let's have some perspective - that's why there are property taxes. Now, maybe the property taxes are too low, but the fundamental issue is recognized by society and the mechanism exists to balance things.
I don't get the impression that the issue is completely recognized by society though. We see articles all the time in the news about how the real estate market is going up. Clearly, most landowners currently have an expectation that they should get some return on their land ownership.
That's why so many advocate for restrictions on building in their communities.
I'm not saying it can't be a local, situational problem, I'm saying it's not a universal fundamental wrongness in the way society is structured.
It's like, a certain number of heart attacks happen each year. We may see a trend in heart disease over time. There could be some environmental reason for it. But extrapolating the current trend indefinitely and drawing the conclusion that there is something fundamentally wrong about the human heart's workings that requires a new mechanism is probably excessive.
The supply of land is fixed, but the population (demand) increases, so the land owners have an structural advantage in that sense.
If we go by your logic, we must also ban reading books, exercise, good relationships etc.
Pretty much any investment including things like education work very similar to land investments. There are only fixed college seats, is it fair to everyone?
Firstly start with understanding you can't give any thing to any one they don't want to earn. At the same time you can't stop people from going after these things and earning them.
I mean, most of us are just typing and talking. It’s not exactly laying bricks.
Don’t get me wrong, real estate is a great investment, just not quite that great.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism
[0] - But let them keep all the rent from the building, since they built it with their own capital and labour.
I'm sure there are other good models too.
The problem they recognized was if they had indefinite landownership, and they could pass it onto their descendants, given that they're a small island nation, within a few years, all the land would be owned.
After that, future generations would have no more land to buy, and those who are lucky enough to be born to landed family would be able to charge rent those who didn't have the privilege to be born to a family with property.
I think the government also wants to allow property owners to be able to profit somewhat from the growth of the value of their property, since 80% of the population owns property in Singapore.
Now, I agree that these 2 goals are in conflict, and tax policy would be the better fix. But I guess their approach does at least fix the problem somewhat.
Singapore has government substantiated condos that are quite good. You have to be a citizen to get the benefits, but if you can benefit from it, someone working min wage can buy a decent place to live.
And that $1.05M invested 20 yeas ago in the stock market? They would have doubled their money with none of the headache.
Heck, the crappy apartment complex I lived in in the peninsula that was built in the 1960s was worth close to $9m and it only had like 8 small apartments.
Assuming all the units are under rent control, it might not be worth much more than $2M.
A good example is my place in SF. 3 unit building in a very desirable neighborhood. If the place was empty? It would likely fetch $5M based on square footage.
With 3 tenants who have been there 10 years and have rent control? My realtor tells me they base it on cap rate and with only $7000 in rent being collected, the landlord would be lucky to $1.5M for it.
The incentive wasn't there for her to make a large capital expenditure on maintenance because the land appreciation was what she was banking on and rental demand was such that she could always rent the apartment.
While this example is extreme I've seen similar deferred maintenance behaviors repeated over and over again by the most successful (read: largest portfolio holding) landlords.
[0] - Except property taxes, but CA caps their increase, so if you've owned the property for a while now, the tax isn't in line with the rent you can charge.
But when he got out only eight years later, his family "loaned" him a bunch of money to start up Everest properties.
But yes, in reality, he is probably still in control of both.
Part of the fascination for me is that the Reddy headquarters is this absurdly tacky mansion[1] in Kings County, in the middle of nowhere, surrounded (at arm's length) by abject poverty. Supposedly a branch of the family is the most successful vascular surgeon in Hanford (this makes ~zero economic sense) but the giveaway is that according to public records all of the Raj tax bills are mailed here. So it's really the seat of their weird real estate empire.
1: https://www.google.com/maps/place/1751+Muscat+Pl,+Hanford,+C...
Wow, that’s allot of concentrated wealth. Anyone have some insight on these fine folk?
If each landlord owns 100 apartments renting for $4k each(average) that’s $400k a month gross. That’s allot of potential venture capital money to capture monthly, over $20M in five years.