Re:San Francisco apartment rent prices are dropping fast
by mensetmanusman on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @10:46PM
(#23709421)
Poor reasoning, if the land has value, some would sell and convert to cash for other investments. Tax policy can fix this.
Re:San Francisco apartment rent prices are dropping fast
by neilparikh on Thursday July 02, 2020 @12:16AM
(#23709960)
Some would, yes. But the land value would be high enough that most people trying to enter the market wouldn't be able to afford the costs of buying property. Under this approach, the government can sell property at a subsidized rate to new buyers once it reverts back to them.
I think the government also wants to allow property owners to be able to profit somewhat from the growth of the value of their property, since 80% of the population owns property in Singapore.
Now, I agree that these 2 goals are in conflict, and tax policy would be the better fix. But I guess their approach does at least fix the problem somewhat.
The problem they recognized was if they had indefinite landownership, and they could pass it onto their descendants, given that they're a small island nation, within a few years, all the land would be owned.
After that, future generations would have no more land to buy, and those who are lucky enough to be born to landed family would be able to charge rent those who didn't have the privilege to be born to a family with property.