News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by flyt on Friday March 25, 2011 @05:56PM (#2370517)
Don't worry, if Apple acquires them (like they did their last company, Lala) then Gruber will suddenly realize how revolutionary the idea is.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by raganwald on Friday March 25, 2011 @06:25PM (#2370604)
Do you have a refutation for the articles's words? Or is this simply an Ad Hominem? Compare and contrast to http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2370547, which is just as scornful but also logical.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by danilocampos on Friday March 25, 2011 @06:37PM (#2370637)
I'm with you, but stand by my claim that if Adam Lisagor had shot an ad for Color, Gruber's tone would be entirely different.

Here's another post about a photo-taking application earlier this week:

http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/03/22/everyday

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by raganwald on Friday March 25, 2011 @06:45PM (#2370666)
Interesting, however I would point out that Gruber isn't reviewing the app, he's reviewing the founder's quoted claim that the app is a data collection play.

Personally, I disagree with Gruber: Facebook and Foursquare seem to be evidence that people will gladly give up their personal data in exchange for a "social" experience. But whether Gruber is right or wrong is not the point I was responding to, it's whether Gruber would hypothetically like the app if it was hypothetically bought by Apple.

This is irrelevant to what he's saying now. Even if he does like everything Apple does and does hate everything Apple doesn't do, appealing to his bias is the textbook definition of an Ad Hominem:

  An ad hominem, short for argumentum ad hominem,
  is an attempt to link the validity of a premise
  to a characteristic or belief of the opponent
  advocating the premise.
If he's wrong, we can attack his argument directly. How can we have a meaningful discussion about what he might say if some hypothetical future acquisition takes place? Worse, what if he's right now and would be wrong if he did change his mind after some hypothetical future acquisition?

In that case, dismissing him because of his bias might rob us of a valuable insight.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by baddox on Friday March 25, 2011 @06:58PM (#2370698)
flyt's comment is not an ad hominem argument, because flyt is not trying to link the validity of the premise (that Color's funding was the result of their data mining potential) to a characteristic of its advocate (Gruber's pattern of Apple apologetics).

In fact, the way I read flyt's comment is that flyt actually agrees with Gruber, but is predicting that if Apple were to have something to do with Color, Gruber's cynicism would disappear.

Unless I'm misunderstanding flyt, this was in no way an ad hominem argument.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by ellyagg on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:24PM (#2370780)
Ah, these "that's not ad hominem" comments you read in every single thread that points out ad hominem get so tiresome.

It most certainly is ad hominem. The premise of Gruber's post is approximately that, based on the latest information we're learning about it, there's something distasteful about Color or its value proposition to consumers. The original commenter seeks to discredit Gruber's implied argument by suggesting he's an Apple apologist, that his industry analysis is not based on facts at hand but by inherent biases. This is right in the sweet spot of ad hominem. Just read the first few paragraphs of the Wikipedia entry on ad hominem to confirm.

Regardless, it's certainly poor form and disappointing to see so highly upvoted.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by metellus on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:57PM (#2370864)
Except he's not trying to discredit Gruber. He's pointing out that Gruber is able to be unbiased because the product isn't owned by Apple.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by ThomPete on Saturday March 26, 2011 @01:29AM (#2371434)
Huh? So when the product is owned by Apple he is unbiased?
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by lotharbot on Saturday March 26, 2011 @03:20AM (#2371560)
No. The opposite of this.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by shasta on Saturday March 26, 2011 @08:54AM (#2371964)
Converse
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by marshray on Saturday March 26, 2011 @01:02PM (#2372565)
I love you guys.

(You really should do "Who's on first?" sometime. :-)

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by jonursenbach on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:22PM (#2370771)
He already reviewed it, and panned it then as well.

http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/03/24/color

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by kelnos on Friday March 25, 2011 @08:10PM (#2370902)
"Nice domain name, though."

I wonder how much that cost them...

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by chibimagic on Friday March 25, 2011 @08:21PM (#2370923)
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by jsb on Friday March 25, 2011 @08:13PM (#2370910)
I disagree. Everyday is a part-time collaboration by 4 people that hasn't taken on funding, let alone $41M worth. And Everyday has a business model that doesn't mine data about you: it's $1.99 on the app store.

So, I guess it's like Color in that it uses pictures, except that it's different in just about every other way.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by bugsy on Sunday March 27, 2011 @04:32AM (#2374543)
Very cool app.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by macrael on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:09PM (#2370727)
Besides the fact that those two apps involve the taking of photos, they couldn't be more different. I don't think Gruber's like of one and dislike of the other can be seen as any kind of hypocrisy.

I'm also curious what how his response (or others') would have been changed had Lisagor shot an ad for them. But, as a data point, Gruber hasn't linked to at least one of Lisagor's ads. (The 3D one for jawbone: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=exm981pbrJg)

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by baddox on Friday March 25, 2011 @06:53PM (#2370684)
flyt's comment is certainly an attack on Gruber, but I wouldn't call it an ad hominem argument since flyt isn't attempting to discredit Gruber's reasoning by proposing a flaw in Gruber's character.

In fact, I don't think flyt is claiming that this wasn't the reason for Color's funding. flyt seems to merely be noting that, while Gruber sounds cynical and disapproving in this post, Gruber would probably approve of and attempt to justify the product if Apple were to acquire Color.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by raganwald on Friday March 25, 2011 @06:57PM (#2370697)
That had occurred to me, and I was going to suggest that it is semantically equivalent to claiming that John's mother wears army boots. Possibly true, possibly false, but irrelevant and off-topic.

However, I assumed (possibly incorrectly) that somebody would suggest that insulting the author in a thread purportedly discussing the author's words is an indirect way of discrediting the words.

I could be wrong, in which case I would suggest that such a comment is not contributing to the discussion.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by baddox on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:08PM (#2370725)
If a comment is not contributing to the discussion, then down-vote it. A non-contributing comment is not the same thing as an ad hominem argument. Also, an attack on someone's character is not the same as an ad hominem argument.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by bugsy on Sunday March 27, 2011 @04:33AM (#2374546)
The entirety subthread about "is it ad hominem or not" is useless meta noise that has nothing at all to do with the main post. Folks, please just say no before creating such a subthread, or responding in one. The original very brief comment was related to the main topic and was a fine, if possibly cynical remark. It represented a view that had not been expressed. It was conversational in nature, such as someone might observe during any reasonable discussion of this topic. It did not need several pages of deconstruction. Comment deconstruction and analysis belongs in an academic literary journal, not here. Thanks.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by mcantelon on Friday March 25, 2011 @11:29PM (#2371263)
The credibility of a source is relevant. If the National Enquirer posts commentary on a matter, you're likely to take it less seriously than commentary from The Economist.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by raganwald on Friday March 25, 2011 @11:39PM (#2371275)
Why? If they write something obviously false, then I can refute it directly.

The time I question someone's reputation is when they appeal to authority themselves. For example, if I were to write "I've been in business for twenty years, take it from me that where startups are concerned, _____," then it's perfectly appropriate to point out that I haven't worked in silicon valley.

After all, my reputation is part of my argument, so questioning it is questioning my argument. Other than that, if I say something about business, arguing that I boast of being a Socialist says nothing about whether my words about business are useful. If you "take them with a grain of salt," you are the one who may be missing out.

This principle is not new to HN. Paul Graham wrote about it explicitly in his essay "How to Disagree:"

http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html

Have a look at what he has to say about DH0, Name calling, and DH1, Ad hominem. You may not like the National Enquirer, but if they were to write about a startup, it should be possible to disagree with their suppositions without resorting to questioning the piece solely because they published it.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by Rantenki on Saturday March 26, 2011 @12:18AM (#2371339)
Actually, I am just plain less likely to read it, but I agree with your premise.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by jgruber on Saturday March 26, 2011 @12:19AM (#2371342)
Funny, I can't seem to find the article where I said much of anything about Lala, post- or pre-acquisition by Apple, let alone the one where I claimed they were "revolutionary".

Please let me know the URL for that piece.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by statictype on Saturday March 26, 2011 @02:47AM (#2371531)
Could you link to your HN profile from Daring Fireball (or something equivalent)? I'm having doubts about whether you're actually John Gruber or not, if only because you would have used 'gruber' instead of jgruber (gruber is still available from what I can see). Would be nice to have it cleared up once and for all.

And if you're not John Gruber of Daring Fireball, then please remove the lies on your profile page.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by jad on Friday March 25, 2011 @06:52PM (#2370682)
As of about 6:50 PM EDT, this ad hominem attack on the article's author has almost as many upvotes (56) as every other top-level comment on this thread combined (67).

Sad.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by baddox on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:05PM (#2370716)
As of 6:05 PM Central time, at least three people have used the phrase "ad hominem" incorrectly. Unless flyt was attempting to discredit Gruber's premise (which I don't think is the case), the argument is not ad hominem.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by GHFigs on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:53PM (#2370852)
Are you suggesting that disparaging the author without attempting to discredit their argument is somehow better? I ask because I'm really not understanding what drives your pedantry or the apparently resounding agreement with it that voting readers have expressed.

Frankly, the Hacker News I want to read is one where the top comment is not a personal attack, regardless of whether people agree on whether it qualifies as ad hominem argument.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by neutronicus on Friday March 25, 2011 @08:55PM (#2371009)
100% agree with you.

An "irrelevant personal attack" and an argument that relies on one are equally undesirable to me.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by baddox on Saturday March 26, 2011 @01:28AM (#2371433)
I'm only suggesting that disparaging the author alone doesn't constitute an ad hominem argument.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by coderdude on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:58PM (#2370865)
It's a popular phrase around here. It seems like people can barely contain the urge to play the "ad hominem" card. It's regurgitated all the time on HN. Same with:

  -"Straw man"
  -"Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity"
  -"A bad workman blames his tools" (this one is on the rise)
I'm sure there are many others I'm missing. Even HN has memes.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by stanleydrew on Friday March 25, 2011 @09:13PM (#2371042)
"The plural of anecdote is not data" is another.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by jarin on Friday March 25, 2011 @11:03PM (#2371212)
- Dunning-Kreuger Effect
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by ugh on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:42PM (#2370822)
You are correct but it is still sad to see that this irrelevant attack is so popular.

How is this comment interesting? It’s not about what Gruber is discussing, it just attacks and doesn’t even provide evidence for its assumption.

Such comments are not uncommon and I hate them with a passion. A snide, short remark, picking up a popular sentiment without any attempt of providing evidence for the same (“The New York Times has a liberal bias anyway.” – “Fox News is filled with fascists!”) — that’s just spam as far as I’m concerned.

Whether or not services where the user is the product can be valuable for the same is a very interesting question and you could write 1,000 word essays about it — but instead this crap made it all the way to the top.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by lukeschlather on Friday March 25, 2011 @10:28PM (#2371159)
The article in question is a snide, short remark. I don't know why anyone would come to this thread expecting reasoned discourse.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by ugh on Friday March 25, 2011 @10:37PM (#2371175)
I don’t think HN should aspire to have comments of merely equal quality to the source material.

Why exactly do you think that subpar articles must automatically lead to bad discussions? That’s far from a given for me. The topic – users as products – is certainly interesting and touches on a whole host of issues that are traditional HN lore, from Google’s business model to startup monetization.

As I said, eloquent 1,000 word essays that emphatically disagree with Gruber’s position are certainly possible. Instead there’s spam.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by raganwald on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:29PM (#2370793)
It all depends. Sometimes these attacks on the character or reputation of the argument are indirect ad hominem arguments. Consider a fictitious debate between a Christian and a Muslim politician about whether or not to strip Americans of even more civil liberties.

The Christian candidate listens to the Muslim candidate make a point, then says loudly and clearly, "Folks, he's a Muslim!"

He doesn't say "And therefore he's wrong," but nevertheless it is rhetorical device for discrediting his opponent and getting the audience to ignore his point.

Wikipedia calls this Ad hominem abuse:

  Ad hominem abuse (also called personal abuse or personal attacks)
  usually involves insulting or belittling one's opponent
  in order to invalidate his argument, but can also involve
  pointing out factual but ostensible character flaws or
  actions which are irrelevant to the opponent's argument.

  This tactic is logically fallacious because insults and
  even true negative facts about the opponent's personal
  character have nothing to do with the logical merits of
  the opponent's arguments or assertions.
http://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Ad_hominem
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by baddox on Friday March 25, 2011 @09:34PM (#2371076)
It sounds like you are suggesting that flyt thinks that Color's funding has nothing to do with the potential for user data mining, and thus disagrees with Gruber and much of the Hacker News community. I think you are wrong.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by dpe82 on Saturday March 26, 2011 @02:06AM (#2371481)
So does that mean that the comment has social proof and is thus more likely to be valuable? Discuss.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by mambodog on Saturday March 26, 2011 @02:34AM (#2371516)
Useless and irrelevant comments such as this one, along with it's many replies, contribute to signal-to-noise degradation of the discussion section of many popular HN posts. Maybe collapsible comment threads would help to mitigate this.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by pavel_lishin on Saturday March 26, 2011 @03:21PM (#2372918)
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by gumbo on Sunday March 27, 2011 @09:53AM (#2374968)
I agree with you. Those comments thread should be collapsible. And we need a way to see only new comments.