Frankly, the Hacker News I want to read is one where the top comment is not a personal attack, regardless of whether people agree on whether it qualifies as ad hominem argument.
An "irrelevant personal attack" and an argument that relies on one are equally undesirable to me.
-"Straw man"
-"Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity"
-"A bad workman blames his tools" (this one is on the rise)
I'm sure there are many others I'm missing. Even HN has memes.How is this comment interesting? It’s not about what Gruber is discussing, it just attacks and doesn’t even provide evidence for its assumption.
Such comments are not uncommon and I hate them with a passion. A snide, short remark, picking up a popular sentiment without any attempt of providing evidence for the same (“The New York Times has a liberal bias anyway.” – “Fox News is filled with fascists!”) — that’s just spam as far as I’m concerned.
Whether or not services where the user is the product can be valuable for the same is a very interesting question and you could write 1,000 word essays about it — but instead this crap made it all the way to the top.
Why exactly do you think that subpar articles must automatically lead to bad discussions? That’s far from a given for me. The topic – users as products – is certainly interesting and touches on a whole host of issues that are traditional HN lore, from Google’s business model to startup monetization.
As I said, eloquent 1,000 word essays that emphatically disagree with Gruber’s position are certainly possible. Instead there’s spam.
The Christian candidate listens to the Muslim candidate make a point, then says loudly and clearly, "Folks, he's a Muslim!"
He doesn't say "And therefore he's wrong," but nevertheless it is rhetorical device for discrediting his opponent and getting the audience to ignore his point.
Wikipedia calls this Ad hominem abuse:
Ad hominem abuse (also called personal abuse or personal attacks)
usually involves insulting or belittling one's opponent
in order to invalidate his argument, but can also involve
pointing out factual but ostensible character flaws or
actions which are irrelevant to the opponent's argument.
This tactic is logically fallacious because insults and
even true negative facts about the opponent's personal
character have nothing to do with the logical merits of
the opponent's arguments or assertions.
http://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Ad_hominem
Sad.