News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by danilocampos on Friday March 25, 2011 @06:37PM (#2370637)
I'm with you, but stand by my claim that if Adam Lisagor had shot an ad for Color, Gruber's tone would be entirely different.

Here's another post about a photo-taking application earlier this week:

http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/03/22/everyday

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by raganwald on Friday March 25, 2011 @06:45PM (#2370666)
Interesting, however I would point out that Gruber isn't reviewing the app, he's reviewing the founder's quoted claim that the app is a data collection play.

Personally, I disagree with Gruber: Facebook and Foursquare seem to be evidence that people will gladly give up their personal data in exchange for a "social" experience. But whether Gruber is right or wrong is not the point I was responding to, it's whether Gruber would hypothetically like the app if it was hypothetically bought by Apple.

This is irrelevant to what he's saying now. Even if he does like everything Apple does and does hate everything Apple doesn't do, appealing to his bias is the textbook definition of an Ad Hominem:

  An ad hominem, short for argumentum ad hominem,
  is an attempt to link the validity of a premise
  to a characteristic or belief of the opponent
  advocating the premise.
If he's wrong, we can attack his argument directly. How can we have a meaningful discussion about what he might say if some hypothetical future acquisition takes place? Worse, what if he's right now and would be wrong if he did change his mind after some hypothetical future acquisition?

In that case, dismissing him because of his bias might rob us of a valuable insight.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by baddox on Friday March 25, 2011 @06:58PM (#2370698)
flyt's comment is not an ad hominem argument, because flyt is not trying to link the validity of the premise (that Color's funding was the result of their data mining potential) to a characteristic of its advocate (Gruber's pattern of Apple apologetics).

In fact, the way I read flyt's comment is that flyt actually agrees with Gruber, but is predicting that if Apple were to have something to do with Color, Gruber's cynicism would disappear.

Unless I'm misunderstanding flyt, this was in no way an ad hominem argument.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by ellyagg on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:24PM (#2370780)
Ah, these "that's not ad hominem" comments you read in every single thread that points out ad hominem get so tiresome.

It most certainly is ad hominem. The premise of Gruber's post is approximately that, based on the latest information we're learning about it, there's something distasteful about Color or its value proposition to consumers. The original commenter seeks to discredit Gruber's implied argument by suggesting he's an Apple apologist, that his industry analysis is not based on facts at hand but by inherent biases. This is right in the sweet spot of ad hominem. Just read the first few paragraphs of the Wikipedia entry on ad hominem to confirm.

Regardless, it's certainly poor form and disappointing to see so highly upvoted.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by metellus on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:57PM (#2370864)
Except he's not trying to discredit Gruber. He's pointing out that Gruber is able to be unbiased because the product isn't owned by Apple.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by ThomPete on Saturday March 26, 2011 @01:29AM (#2371434)
Huh? So when the product is owned by Apple he is unbiased?
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by lotharbot on Saturday March 26, 2011 @03:20AM (#2371560)
No. The opposite of this.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by shasta on Saturday March 26, 2011 @08:54AM (#2371964)
Converse
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by marshray on Saturday March 26, 2011 @01:02PM (#2372565)
I love you guys.

(You really should do "Who's on first?" sometime. :-)

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by jonursenbach on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:22PM (#2370771)
He already reviewed it, and panned it then as well.

http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/03/24/color

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by kelnos on Friday March 25, 2011 @08:10PM (#2370902)
"Nice domain name, though."

I wonder how much that cost them...

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by chibimagic on Friday March 25, 2011 @08:21PM (#2370923)
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by jsb on Friday March 25, 2011 @08:13PM (#2370910)
I disagree. Everyday is a part-time collaboration by 4 people that hasn't taken on funding, let alone $41M worth. And Everyday has a business model that doesn't mine data about you: it's $1.99 on the app store.

So, I guess it's like Color in that it uses pictures, except that it's different in just about every other way.

Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by bugsy on Sunday March 27, 2011 @04:32AM (#2374543)
Very cool app.
Re:At least now we know why Color really got that funding by macrael on Friday March 25, 2011 @07:09PM (#2370727)
Besides the fact that those two apps involve the taking of photos, they couldn't be more different. I don't think Gruber's like of one and dislike of the other can be seen as any kind of hypocrisy.

I'm also curious what how his response (or others') would have been changed had Lisagor shot an ad for them. But, as a data point, Gruber hasn't linked to at least one of Lisagor's ads. (The 3D one for jawbone: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=exm981pbrJg)