However, I see no value at all in protecting calls to violence or protecting speech that is intentionally designed to deceive or manipulate.
Additionally, attributing and contextualising information must be allowed.
Finally, many scientific matters are settled (such as that climate change exists, that there was systemic discrimination of PoCs even long after abolishment of slavery and that Earth is not flat).
Stating that those debates are settled and that trying to "reopen" them does not do any good must be allowed.
The right thinks the left is trying to manipulate people and the left thinks the right is trying to manipulate people.
Also, why wouldn't I be able to talk against climate change? I know it's real but that's besides the point I'm trying to make. Why should I be stripped of that right? To me, it sounds like when you couldn't speak about religion or have any kind of doubt. Not only it's bad because it pure censorship but it creates a precedent to ban speech against what some people think it's settled.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/When_the_looting_starts,_the...
EDIT: To be precise why I'd disagree with that, promoting self defense advocates violence, but still has value to pretty much everyone. This is controversial because of the current climate, but saying it has no value is false.
Congratulations - you just allowed the South to secede and defanged every rousing political speech ever. You also prevented entrance of USA in WWI (media played huge role there)
By your definition in this day and age a leader cannot use social media to gather support for a war.
Yup.
And who is it that decides when a scientific matter is "settled"? You? Trump? Zuckerberg? Bartolomeo Spina [0]?
>Stating that those debates are settled and that trying to "reopen" them does not do any good must be allowed.
With this single sentence you have highlighted the entire problem with this approach. "It is a settled scientific matter that Earth is the center of the universe and trying to reopen this debate will not be tolerated" is stunningly similar to what Copernicus was told.
0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicolaus_Copernicus#Controvers...
This could even create a business opportunity for new social networks with different moderation policies. That could backfire and create even stronger echo chambers. Imagine a social network that prohibits content in support of prochoice for abortion. The site administrators could simply argue that the issue has been settled and prolife is the only moral stance.
One key effect here too: Even if being among other people doesn't turn them away from climate change denial, it can ground them in reality in other areas better.
I mean, if you got new empirical data to show that the overwhelming evidence is wrong and earth is in fact flat, please do submit a paper and get some feedback from the scientific community.
What I believe is harmful is to present worldwide scientific consensus on one hand and granny's gut feeling on the other hand as equally valid opinions - and then conclude that a topic is "disputed". This happens a lot in social media.
Like all ads, 90% of selfies etc?
Yup.
> 90% of selfies etc?
Dammit, you got me there! Alright, I'll make an exception for selfies.
So if I want to send content to 100 people, and all 100 people add me to an approved list well my content will get through
That is not how these social media systems work
Part of the problem with FB, Twitter, Youtube is that they are closed inoperable systems, a problem that doesnt hamper email.
Things like real name policies also suppress speech. If a law were in place preventing Facebook censorship, it would also need to prevent deplatforming and facebook deciding who can and cant use its platform. Blocking speech they dont agree with, is different that blocking all speech from a speaker that sometimes says things Facebook doesnt like.
There is also the issue of the newsfeed ranking algorithm itself. Is deranking something more than a thousand posts deep the same as censorship? They can basically control the spread of information, by allowing people to post it, but not allowing it to rise up the ranks. If said ranking exerted preference or bias, and applied to everyones feeds and all their groups, facebook can control the conversation without traditional censorship. At the same time, algorithmic news sorting basically IS the product, and thats what people go to it for.
And that's the whole issue. Spam filtering should not be irreversibly bundled with the provision of an e-mail account. It can be a separate service, that you can opt-in to at your pleasure, or choose a different supplier to do your spam filtering. It could even be a plugin in your web-browser, automating the now manual "mark as spam" and "undo mark as spam" functions.
Why would this comment be flagged?
It's a reasonable statement, Twitter handles have replaced phone numbers in the age of online discourse. Telling someone to join a fringe social network is like saying people we can ban people we don't like from using the telephone because ham radio exists.
https://wireless2.fcc.gov/UlsApp/UlsSearch/searchLicense.jsp
One example of a community being labeled as right-wing extremists (or worse) is Gab.ai. Another Example is Zerohedge's comment section.
Was anyone doxxed for using these platforms? I don't know. I do know those platforms have been deplatformed.
There seems to be a concerted effort to label Facebook a place where extremists gather, lots of people virtue signaling about how they're not using Facebook because it's so toxic and full of Nazis. It's only a matter of time until it's a sin just for using Facebook.
Same here with the opposite point:
The government intervening and controlling private companies that distribute information is proven to bring down democracies. It literally constantly happens all around the world.
These are private companies that enable citizens to communicate with each other, and should be regulated as such (as little as possible).
The difference is not ownership but concentration, and on the network you have network effects on a scale never before seen. We have no problem with people not being able to say or read what they want in email because it is a federated system that anyone can join through any provider. If Facebook or Twitter were just an open protocol, the users could decide for themselves who to subscribe to, managing their own "safety". But instead, we have giant, centralized organizations being accused of bias from every side because they wield so much centralized control over information.
So, when companies are small, they should be able to say or not say whatever they want. As they get larger, they gradually surrender the power to regulate their own users. They can stay small, or they can release control--their choice. The can open the protocol and become just one provider in an open protocol (like email), and if they have fewer than, say, 10M users, they can totally offer the "service" of blocking incoming and outgoing info for those users who want it done for them, and those who think "no, thanks, I'll decide for myself whose feed to subscribe to" will be able to do so via other providers.
Therefore, FB would love to have a legitimate external authority, e.g. the government, mandating what's allowed or not. Unfortunately, no one is willing to do that dirty work, and thus forcing Facebook to do it themselves.
(Granted, I've simplified the matter quite a bit here by saying "Facebook, as a business". Facebook is also a collection of individual employees who have their own beliefs and do shape FB in their image.)
Maybe we could just start with regulating The Internet as common carrier instead of an "information service".
Anyone who is disappointed with the content of the "speech" they see on a particular "network" (a website/endpoint), should study the case of Usenet. Disprove this hypothesis: Unmoderated "public discourse" on a computer network has a tendency to descend into a sewer.
The only difference today in terms of this phenomena is the number of users of the "network" (website/endpoint) or computer network (internet).
Maybe "networks" used for communication need to migrate to "mesh" instead of "hub and spoke". Perhaps websites were not meant to have billions of pages and be called "networks".
A stream of sewage can still be shined into liquid gold by a sufficiently intelligent client, that chooses what to ingest and what to ignore.
"For the purposes of Section 230 immunity all platforms shall moderate content in a manner that conforms to the 1st amendment of the US Constitution as if they were a government agency. Any platform that chooses to suppress, moderate or take down 1st amendment protected speech shall be considered publishers of all user generated content and loose the liability protections granted by this section"
Once you are a platform (FB, Twitter, Google, Reddit, etc...), you should only be allowed to "censor" things that are illegal.
(For the latter, perhaps we should pretend that Google isn’t already mostly spam.)
This would certainly apply to cases such as Amazon, where the bigger they got, the more helpful they would have to be to small competitors instead of putting them out of business.
Let me ask you a question. What if the big 3 grocery stores in town decided not to sell you groceries unless you stop doing an activity they consider distasteful but is otherwise legal? Would you still be OK with it?
Companies like these cannot be trusted to moderate neutrally and are a threat to society due to their size. Their organizational cultures can be taken over by a vocal/fanatical minority, and then weaponized against those outside their tribe. And this is exactly what has happened - for example consider this leaked video of Facebook moderators (https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2020/06/23/facebook_...), talking about deleting people with MAGA hats by flagging them for “terrorism”.
If America doesn't crack down on Google's, Facebook's and Twitter's ability to "moderate" (censor) content at their discretion (today!), Western democratic society will come to an end. Sooner rather than later.
These services are utilities, sometimes monopolies, and must be regulated as such.