News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by utopcell on Thursday June 25, 2020 @06:41PM (#23646600)
I'm very curious to see this transition to ARM play out. There is a lot of software that will now be compiled for ARM that can potentially be used in open-source projects on much more cost-effective boards. Music (VST) plugins come to mind.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by grawprog on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:59PM (#23647222)
The thing about arm that's always troubled me, which I only see talked about infrequently, is the way it's licensed vs x86_64 chips. Arm chips are licensed in such a way that allows for a multitude of different proprietary configurations that all are essentially arm chips, but locked down at the whims of the manufacturers.

I understand power usage is a big concern these days, but I can't help but feel this aspect of arm is greatly overlooked and that the push towards arm devices is also partially inspired by the ability to lock down chip designs to a greater capacity than x86_64 chips.

Just look at the existing fragmentation among arm powered devices as is. I don't really like the thought of what an arm powered future could look like.

I really wish I could remember what video it was, but I remember years ago watching the ceo of arm present a new chip with built in emulation technology, that theoretically, would have allowed multiple operating systems to run at once or something. I remember the person talking to him asked if he forsaw this as the future, and he just laughed and said oh no, no manufacturers would never dream of allowing this and furthermore they'll likely use this technology to further specialize and lockdown their chips.

It may be personal bias, but since then and other things i've learned about arm, I've just had this lingering unease as to what them gaining dominance would mean to general computing.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by Xixi on Thursday June 25, 2020 @09:35PM (#23647860)
The thing with x86_64 is that Apple/Amazon/Google/Samsung/Fujitsu/etc cannot license it. There are only two corporations with x86 licenses granted by Intel: AMD and VIA. These licenses are not transferable, and a even a badly managed acquisition could result in the license being revoked.

So moving out of the x86/x86_64 world is really a no-brainer: why would all the electronic giants keep paying for x86 when they can get out of the de-facto duopoly? It seems that they are settling on ARM (Amazon Graviton, Fujitsu A64FX, Apple A12Z, etc.). It could have been another architecture, but it couldn't be x86_64.

On the other hand, there are other architectures besides ARM and x86: RISC-V, OpenSPARC, etc. Maybe one of these would be better for developers who don't want to deal with the ARM landscape fragmentation.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by DaiPlusPlus on Thursday June 25, 2020 @10:06PM (#23647988)
Why does x86 need a license anymore though? Any patents on x86 and its extensions right through to the first-gen Pentium 4 chips released in 2000 will have expired by now. Creating a clean-room implementation of an existing ISA doesn't necessarily mean you need a license - it's basically the same thing as reimplementing the Java VM specification: no royalties to Oracle required! (...for now).

I do appreciate that the x64 is more recent and will still be patented to heck - but there's only 3 more years until the first of those expire, methinks.

PAE for x86 means that programs needing more than 4GiB of main-memory can be run without needing a true 64-bit ISA - and PAE won't be patented anymore as that was introduced around 1995.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by mkl on Friday June 26, 2020 @07:00AM (#23650635)
Yes 64 bit is probably impossible, as there will be new patented features in pretty much every model coming out, so most of your instruction set would be stuck 20 years out of date. I think there's not much point in new 32 bit x86 processors now, as there are low power SBCs that would cover most uses (unless you need old proprietary x86 software, but then just buy a PC second hand).
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by classichasclass on Friday June 26, 2020 @01:33AM (#23649001)
Don't forget OpenPOWER. The Power ISA is royalty-free.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by grawprog on Thursday June 25, 2020 @09:50PM (#23647921)
>The thing with x86_64 is that Apple/Amazon/Google/Samsung/Fujitsu/etc cannot license it. There are only two corporations with x86 licenses granted by Intel: AMD and VIA. These licenses are not transferable, and a even a badly managed acquisition could result in the license being revoked.

I don't disagree with you, but is that really a world developers or even consumers want? A world where each device manufacturer creates their own chip based around arm's processor designs that's incompatible with the next device's chip despite being virtually identical?

You're right, as a corporation looking to make money off all aspects of everything, it's a no brainer. For everyone else, it's a worse situation than the processor fragmentation of the 80's and early 90's.

X86_64, amd and intel, took advantage of the situation of the time and provided a somewhat standard, though controlled by them, processor design that allowed tons of individuals and companies to flourish. Moving to yet another highly controlled set of fragmented platforms is a step back to the 80's.

Ideally, we should be moving forward towards a system that provides a universal set of instructions licensable by all, without allowing licensees to restrict their implementations.

There's a lot of problems with our current paradigm but backpedaling to an even more controlled and fragmented platform is not the solution.

I really believe open hardware is a serious issue that's only starting to be addressed, meanwhile big established players are making their moves to stop it.

Arm is a big established player, one of the biggest, they may not be as forward facing as Microsoft or Apple or google, but damn does that company have a huge influence on everything.

Widely adopted open standards for hardware that does not encourage proprietary licences on basic chip design is a definite no brainer on the way forward.

The hurdles that need to be crossed though are greater than with software. Real tangible goods that require manufacturing require tons of overhead and complexity. This challenge is something I feel is the open source idealogy's next great obstacle and overcoming it will open computing so much more than even open source software has for the world. But, only if people has a whole come together and work towards it by not accepting anything less.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by pabs3 on Thursday June 25, 2020 @10:26PM (#23648088)
People seem fine with not being able to install the OS of their choice on iPhones, televisions and robot vacuums. So it seems unlikely that software compatibility is that important in that space. The manufacturers will just compile their code for the chip in question, move on to the next device and do the same thing. Of course there will be the ARM SBC corner for devs to play in.

Your vision of an open ISA like RISC-V winning is something that I mainly see benefiting manufacturers making closed hardware, not people who want general purpose hardware for running general purpose operating systems. For example Western Digital and nvidia are going to be using RISC-V as part of every SSD/HDD and GPU, but we will not get to run our own code on them. There are also hardware vendors selling RISC-V microcontrollers, but nothing that could run Linux or BSD, even SiFive only has Arduino-level boards out (they had Linux-capable ones but don't seem to be making more of them for sale). Eventually there might be a RISC-V entry in the SBC market, but I think ARM is still going to own that market for a long time.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by rjsw on Friday June 26, 2020 @07:41AM (#23650882)
Saw this [1] a few days ago. Looks like Microchip are going to use RISC-V to produce a SoC+FPGA product, their competitors use ARM for their products.

[1] https://www.crowdsupply.com/microchip/polarfire-soc-icicle-k...

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by fiddlerwoaroof on Thursday June 25, 2020 @09:41PM (#23647883)
X86, as I understand, has the advantage of a fairly widely implemented ISA that specifies all sorts of things about how other things on the motherboard communicate with each other and with the CPU
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by 737maxtw on Thursday June 25, 2020 @10:30PM (#23648113)
> specifies all sorts of things about how other things on the motherboard communicate with each other and with the CPU

That used to be true, but I dont know how true it is now.

Once upon a time, ISA and ATA were both wired right to the bus.

By the P3/Athlon era everything was probably on a super-io controller and or south bridge, but that communication towards the northbridge/CPU was over PCI or ever fancier links.

But the clear cutting point to me is EFI. Most of the standards in how things communicate on older PCs was more based on the IBM BIOS. Early clones couldnt exist until that was nailed down. But... EFI replaces all of that with a new abstraction.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by fiddlerwoaroof on Friday June 26, 2020 @12:58AM (#23648845)
I’m not a hardware person, really, but—even with EFI—my understanding is that x86 motherboards all implement standards that specify how the motherboard’s features can be accessed from software in a way that is fairly uncommon in ARM/MIPS/etc.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday June 26, 2020 @02:29AM (#23649286)
Basically correct; the key bit is that x86 usually has a bus that can be enumerated by the OS. So you boot, and the OS can look around and see what hardware it has (and where it all is). On most ARM, the OS boots blind and you have to tell it (usually via device tree) what devices are attached and where.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by vertex-four on Friday June 26, 2020 @04:01AM (#23649769)
There's a spec for putting a device tree in an ARM chip's rom, the problem being that it's often wrong in some way, requiring device-specific corrections.

Note, however, that there's a lot of "quirks" and similar device-specific corrections for x86 as well. These get presented to Microsoft by the manufacturer, and Linux gets to reverse-engineer them.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday June 26, 2020 @05:32PM (#23657292)
> There's a spec for putting a device tree in an ARM chip's rom, the problem being that it's often wrong in some way, requiring device-specific corrections.

I was aware of being able to have ex. u-boot pass a device tree file to the kernel at boot time; are you talking about that, or something more generic?

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by fit2rule on Friday June 26, 2020 @09:41AM (#23651836)
Architecture is one thing, availability another. ARM is a lot more available on the global market, from multiple foundries.

What I think is interesting is what this will do to the low-power x86 front, not just in terms of technical innovation but also availability. I'm perfect content building for x86, if it becomes as-available as the raspberry-pi class of devices ...

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by rrmm on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:11PM (#23646840)
If I were a user in the music/film industry I would be worried if I depended on Apple.

Apple has shown pretty clearly they see themselves as a consumer electronics and services company above all. If all the "professional" users who rely on Logic or FC or Apple in general jumped ship, Apple wouldn't likely notice it in their bottom line (loss of mindshare not withstanding). They have no vested interest in catering to these users and have produced hardware intended for them as an afterthought. The high cost of hardware and absence of middle tier products that make sense for these users is just icing on the cake.

"Professional" users of Logic or FC have little leverage to affect the course of Apple one way or another (unlike a more focused company whose business model is catering to these groups).

On the other hand Apple pro users do have a long history of being abused by the company so they might be alright with it in the end.

Anyway, I'd be looking for an out if I were them.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by samatman on Thursday June 25, 2020 @09:02PM (#23647652)
I think this is completely backward.

To a first approximation, Apple only cares about video producers, software developers, publishers, and musicians, in their Mac strategy. In approximately that order.

The only reason developers are on that list, is because XCode is how software gets written for the rest of their platforms; the dominance of Macs as personal workstations for Valley-style development is only a side effect of that.

These users provide a halo for everyone else. A college student might spend an extra $1000 on their laptop because they want to moonlight on some beats, or have a YouTube channel, that sort of thing.

I remember seeing this disconnect when the new Mac Pro was released and many here dismissed it as too expensive. Someone who works in CGI came around to say that, no, $50,000 is a normal amount of money to spend on their workstations and that their company was ecstatic to be able to keep working with macOS.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by fiddlerwoaroof on Thursday June 25, 2020 @09:45PM (#23647896)
Yeah, unless you’ve actually priced out business-class setups, the Mac Pro’s pricing seems crazy.

I’ve repeatedly found that the “Apple Tax” is at most something like $500: other companies tend to advertise configurations that I wouldn’t buy, and when I tweak them to match my requirements, their price is not notably different from a Mac

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by rrmm on Friday June 26, 2020 @02:55PM (#23655584)
If you price like for like sure. My issue is usually that I almost never do. I usually fall into needing something akin to a mac mini but slightly bigger. The last mac pro I bought was a dual-G4 model when the gap between the mac pro and lower end models didn't seem so severe. (Although I obviously do not represent a sizeable demographic of the market).

For Apple, not catering to every particular consumer whim/need out there is just smart business. But for the consumer, that is just another weakness of the mac ecosystem.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by fiddlerwoaroof on Friday June 26, 2020 @04:13PM (#23656442)
If you include the iMacs (e.g. the iMac Pro), I think there aren’t really all that many gaps in the product line, spec or price wise. It’s mostly that you can’t necessarily get the machine you want in the form factor you’d like.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by hakfoo on Saturday June 27, 2020 @04:50PM (#23664588)
That's sort of a deal-breaker for a lot of use cases. Think of all those small corporate desktops out there which are beefier than a Mac Mini and wired to cheapo VGA-only 19" LCD monitors because finance isn't going to pay to replace a working screen. The iMac form factor is never gonna compete there.

And of course the neglected "I just want internal drives or expansion cards" demographic. I;m not sure if the cheese grater design fixes it, but with the trashcan Mac Pro, there were plenty of configurations where the equivalent Dell/HP/Lenovo workstation was one clean self-contained box stuffed with PCI-e cards and SATA/SAS drives, and the Mac Pro was an angry squid of Thunderbolt, USB, and power cables to feed an array of external drives and devices.

I understand that their brand is based on seamless design and we-make-the-decisions-for-you presentation, but it feels like there'd be an opportunity for them to use a small-scale clone program as a market research tool.

Have it sell the form factors that Apple won't. The long-whined-for xMac. Units with servicable/cleanable designs for embedded markets. A mini-ITX Mac mainboard you can fit into existing kiosk/appliance designs. A rebranded Toughbook running MacOS. Something in a huge rackmount/server cube case that you can fit with a dozen internal drives. Frankly, I'd envision it as a wholly-owned operation, that charges over-the-odds prices. If people are still willing to put their money where their mouth is, they can claim epiphany and make an Apple version of the same design. If not, they can declare the business a failure, shutter it in a year, and start over next time they want to trial a product.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by whywhywhywhy on Friday June 26, 2020 @06:52AM (#23650599)
>Someone who works in CGI came around to say that, no, $50,000 is a normal amount of money to spend on their workstations

You'd still be crazy to spend it on a Mac Pro unless you had very specific MacOS needs. Building a threadripper multi-Nvidia GPU PC is going to outperform it in any meaningful way with a modern CGI workflow.

OS starts to matter very little when it's a choice of seeing almost a finished image in almost real time which is what you get with CUDA backed rendering engines VS having to still chug away on CPU.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by lproven on Friday June 26, 2020 @10:36AM (#23652425)
I submit that it's not just about performance.

Both Linux and Windows still take a _lot_ more maintenance than macOS. If you have a room full of creative video artists, who are not techies, then you want them to have maximum productive up-time. You do not want to have to employ a small army of system support techies to keep those boxes running.

I used to work on a PC magazine in the West End of London. The mag was about Windows PCs, and was written on Windows PCs, but it was laid out on Macs. I supported both, and the servers and the network.

The PC side of things needed more than 10x as much support.

That's not materially different even today.

Secondly, it's not just about the boxes and their OS. It's also about the apps. A lovely fast sleek Linux distro is no use at all if it doesn't run the apps you need... and if those apps only run on one vendor's kit, or even just run best on that vendor's kit, then that is the kit you buy.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by whywhywhywhy on Monday June 29, 2020 @11:35AM (#23678531)
I get that but it is about performance when we reach the magnitudes GPU rendering is over CPU rendering.

This isn't 20% faster, it's the difference between seeing the image in almost finished form and interacting with it with real time responsiveness vs having to wait minutes for an image. [1]

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gf_P1G_wbK8&t=0m33s

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by rrmm on Friday June 26, 2020 @02:57PM (#23655606)
I can believe that. What sort of support did the non-mac systems mainly need compared to the mac systems?
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by rrmm on Thursday June 25, 2020 @11:06PM (#23648274)
I dunno I guess I've been around a lot of people who fall in the middle, that's a place that Apple doesn't cater to. By the middle I mean, small studios (one or a few people). Their high-end stuff certainly caters to higher-end professional markets.

What's more the way they've handled their software (Logic, transition to FC X) doesn't seem like professional users are foremost on their mind.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by berkut on Thursday June 25, 2020 @09:55PM (#23647940)
Most of high-end VFX is on Linux these days anyway... And a lot of the GPU stuff is CUDA, so nvidia only...

I know for certain that many VFX software companies aren't too happy about OpenGL being deprecated and Vulcan not being supported on recent MacOS releases.

IMO it's going to depend quite heavily on the demand for high-end VFX software on MacOS as to whether they bother with ARM ports if the MacPro does move over...

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by pjmlp on Friday June 26, 2020 @03:11AM (#23649530)
Speaking of VFX, while everyone here jumps of love with Vulkan, big names like OTOY are already using CUDA (for OctaneRender), because Vulkan does not provide what they are looking for.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by p1necone on Thursday June 25, 2020 @09:06PM (#23647681)
(From my perspective) Apple needs to keep up the appearance of being a "pro" brand - a large part of their marketing to non professional users relies on it.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by flir on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:59PM (#23647223)
It seems to be such short-term thinking to me. They became a desirable brand because creatives both used and recommended them.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by nitrogen on Thursday June 25, 2020 @08:26PM (#23647418)
I'm currently in the market for a pro NLE. In the mockups I've seen of actual workspaces on some NLE websites, not a single Apple logo was seen (but other logos were).
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by easygenes on Thursday June 25, 2020 @06:44PM (#23646619)
Isn’t the music industry still reeling from Catalina? Lots of 32-bit audio software out there not getting updated.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by 867-5309 on Thursday June 25, 2020 @06:49PM (#23646659)
anyone making music with a 4GB RAM ceiling is asking for a headache
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by amiga-workbench on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:02PM (#23646773)
I don't think its full DAW's that are kaput, its plugins and VST's that are no longer working.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by fit2rule on Friday June 26, 2020 @10:19AM (#23652230)
Can confirm, this has been deadly for those of us who have carefully curated a set of VST's in projects over the years .. there are songs I cannot open any more, alas .. until I find replacements for some of the synths. Well, its a forced upgrade, but nevertheless .. sad ..
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by qchris on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:11PM (#23646847)
For what it's worth, I believe that the RPi4B now also has an option for 8GB RAM.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by sixothree on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:26PM (#23646941)
And the 32 bit os can access it all (just not per process).
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by FractalParadigm on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:49PM (#23647130)
The joys of PAE.

For what it's worth, there are 64-bit distros available for the Pi4. IIRC Raspberry Pi OS (formerly known as Raspbian) has been fully 64-bit since the release of the 8GB model, and I know Ubuntu Server offered a 64-bit image for some time before that.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by tyingq on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:46PM (#23647108)
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by Zardoz84 on Friday June 26, 2020 @04:25AM (#23649879)
Umm... So then making music on a 1MiB machine should be impossible ?
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by Symbiote on Friday June 26, 2020 @05:29AM (#23650202)
Here's the original Lemmings soundtrack from the Archimedes version (i.e. the machine under discussion). The game probably ran with 1MiB RAM, certainly it would have worked with 2MiB: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QwXthGJfHLc

That is the sound from the internal speaker. The computers were also popular for MIDI control, even being chosen by professionals for this, though I can't find a video.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by imtringued on Friday June 26, 2020 @03:26AM (#23649606)
What if that limit only applies to individual plugin processes?
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by qmmmur on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:02PM (#23646777)
VSTs are already really easy to compile for ARM and iPads have been ubiquitously supported for a long time now.

https://iplug2.github.io/

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by Roboprog on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:08PM (#23646815)
VST? Is that like an AU?

Kidding, but since you mentioned iPad...

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by qmmmur on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:27PM (#23646954)
Well the caveat is that the code for a VST could be easily compiled for an ARM target and the result would be an AU.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by lukeh on Friday June 26, 2020 @04:19AM (#23649855)
It would just be a VST built for ARM, no? They’re different plugin interfaces.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by qmmmur on Thursday July 09, 2020 @10:01AM (#23780312)
Depends really. Something like iPlug2 (https://github.com/iPlug2/iPlug2) would allow you to write code once and compile to all these targets.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by rbanffy on Thursday June 25, 2020 @06:53PM (#23646697)
> There is a lot of software that will now be compiled for ARM that can potentially be used in open-source projects on much more cost-effective boards

Mac software will continue to rely on proprietary APIs. Software that didn't is most likely already ported.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by qppo on Thursday June 25, 2020 @07:09PM (#23646822)
VST3 and AU plug-ins have been running on ARM for a decade.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by utopcell on Friday June 26, 2020 @12:26AM (#23648710)
Point me to the ARM Line 6 Helix Native then. Of course it is possible to compile for ARM, but mainstreaming the architecture at the level of Apple implies that all the big players will be building for ARM.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by fit2rule on Friday June 26, 2020 @09:38AM (#23651810)
>Music (VST) plugins come to mind.

There have been multiple attempts to build an x86-based VST host, over and over.

It will be about 1000x easier to do, if everyone builds for ARM.

However! ARM DSP/synthesis is fraught with minefields. One mans ARM is not a SHARC, etc.

It should be noted that there are already mainstream synth manufacturers shipping ARM platforms .. and there is no virulent unruly lunatic fringe like the synth lunatic fringe, btw.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes was the first desktop to use the ARM... by bashinator on Thursday June 25, 2020 @11:03PM (#23648269)
Don't audio applications tend to use a ton of floating point? I thought that was one of the few areas where x86 still has a significant advantage.