News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by tech-historian on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @10:49AM (#23628461)
Serious questions: Are the people that work at Facebook proud to work there? What is morale like inside that place? When someone asks you what you do, and you say "I work for Facebook," what is their typical reaction?

Not trying to be snarky. I'm genuinely curious how these perceptions/feelings might have changed over the past few years.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by erikw on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:09AM (#23628729)
I too am curious about the internal motivations of people who work for Facebook. Something I've noticed about myself is that I would be okay with working for a US defense contractor, ie a company which makes machines that literally kill people, yet I could not picture myself working at Facebook. I struggle to square this morally, because I also believe that defense contractors have a greater net negative impact on society than Facebook does, but there is something "icky" to me about Facebook.

I used to commute with a group of folks from Facebook, Oracle, and Amazon, and none of them seemed to have any moral qualms about their employers. My buddy from Oracle invited me to apply to work on his team, and in explaining why I couldn't consider working at Oracle, I mentioned some recent terrible thing Oracle had done in the open source community. His response was that Amazon contributed even less open source (which I believe is true). So I think in the end, the internal justification is "Yeah, maybe I'm contributing to something immoral, but it's less immoral than X & Y".

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by esperent on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:25AM (#23628960)
> I would be okay with working for a US defense contractor, ie a company which makes machines that literally kill people

The thought of working for a company like this makes me feel physically ill. Soldiers can at least feel like they are working to defend a country they believe in. Weapons companies will sell killing machines to anyone with money. Few things in the world make me feel the visceral disgust that these companies engender.

By contrast Facebook is icky ... In the sense that there's one naive greedy idiot pulling the strings and he refuses to accept the damage he's causing. Weapons companies and the people who work for them know that their killing tools are sold indiscriminately and will end up in the hands of tyrants and terrorists across the world.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by ardy42 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @04:49PM (#23633698)
> The thought of working for a company like this makes me feel physically ill. Soldiers can at least feel like they are working to defend a country they believe in. Weapons companies will sell killing machines to anyone with money. Few things in the world make me feel the visceral disgust that these companies engender.

Not really. Even if I had the money, I don't think I would be allowed to buy a fully-armed F-16.

Even (foreign) governments typically have to get their purchases approved for export, and that approval is not automatic (e.g. https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/denmark-suspends-saudi-we...).

IMHO, there can be little moral distinction between being a soldier and a weapons maker. If it's OK to be a soldier to defend a country you believe in, then it's OK to make weapons to allow those soldiers to destroy enemy forces as effectively as possible. If the former is OK, but the latter is somehow not, then you're basically condemning your soldiers to defeat and possibly unnecessary death.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by eanzenberg on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:52AM (#23629398)
What damage is Zuck causing again?
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by adamsea on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:06PM (#23629639)
Damage to society by denying the role - via inaction, if nothing else - the company he leads plays in coordinated campaigns of deceit and disinformation aimed not just to undermine public discourse but also the functioning of democractic government itself (via targeted political advertising and misinformation).

Which isn't to say that moderation at Facebook's scale is an easy problem - it's not. And balancing freedom of speech with some degree of accountability and acknowledging empirically verifiable truths is difficult.

But, buy the ticket, take the ride. He's a billionaire. FB makes oodles and oodles of money. They just don't want to do it because it would cost them money.

Eventually laws will catch up, in one way or another, and the same way other media outlets are (imperfectly) regulated, new-media outlets such as FB, Google, etc, will be as well, IMHO.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by phkahler on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:37AM (#23629163)
>> I would be okay with working for a US defense contractor, ie a company which makes machines that literally kill people, yet I could not picture myself working at Facebook.

Maybe I can help clarify because I share that view. Making weapons for defense contractors keeps you at some distance. Presumably we need to be at war (or today's equivalent) and engaged with an external enemy to use those weapons - at some level the use is justified by serious issues or threats. What facebook does is not justified by anything other than pure profit motive. Would you work for a company making weapons that indiscriminately kill people in your own country just for profit? Probably not.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by ethbro on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:20AM (#23628885)
Clear definition of mission is important. For external and internal consumption.

The US military has a pretty clear mission, however you feel about it.

Facebook: "Give people the power to build community and bring the world closer together.” [0]

I'm not sure what actionable guidance I'd be able to draw from the above.

[0] https://techcrunch.com/2017/06/22/bring-the-world-closer-tog...

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by cmdshiftf4 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:34PM (#23630137)
>none of them seemed to have any moral qualms about their employers.

Should they be expected to?

In my opinion, there's little morality, let alone shared morality, left in society. I'm not personally going to place expectations on people's morality with regards to their employment when almost everything has become a moral quandary at this point.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by humanrebar on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:50PM (#23630476)
There is shared morality, just not universally shared morality. The people marching right now share some morality. As do the folks complaining about mandatory mask rules. We may or may not agree with them, but there is shared moral logic.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by lwb on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:21PM (#23629889)
I am. Morale is good, took a minor hiccup recently but has pretty much recovered by now. When I tell everyday folk that I work for Facebook, the reaction is usually, "wow, cool!" and if they're tech minded, they might ask a few questions about the tech stack we use.

Most people at Facebook believe that FB is good for the world, Zuck is a good leader, and that we are working to address dubious ethical decisions made in the past. Sure, FB itself may be a bubble, but HN is even more of a bubble :)

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by humanrebar on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:54PM (#23630539)
I wouldn't trash someone's employer in a mixed social setting. That would be rude, including on social media, regardless of what common behavior is these days.

I might have interesting questions for a sibling or close friend though, assuming we had that kind of relationship.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by 0xy on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @09:48PM (#23636009)
Most people aren't hyper-partisan ideologues that boycott companies based on their political censorship policies, that's why.

Also, by boycotting FB as a developer you're reducing your earning potential considering FB is the top of the compensation pile.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by bavell on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @04:14PM (#23633313)
For better or worse, this pretty much confirms what I expected.

"The Kool-aid here sure tastes great!"

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by mk4p on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @10:56AM (#23628533)
Funny you should ask - I just saw this:

> You don’t realize the heavy conscious and mental burden that comes with being a Facebook employee until you quit

https://twitter.com/sebmck/status/1275363680767537154

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by listenallyall on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:10AM (#23628730)
Probably could replace "Facebook" with just about any company in that sentence. Having to uphold "company values", live by some boss's petty rules, take HR initiatives seriously, etc, is pretty much universally frustrating.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by ardy42 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:22AM (#23628915)
>>> You don’t realize the heavy conscious and mental burden that comes with being a Facebook employee until you quit

>> https://twitter.com/sebmck/status/1275363680767537154

> Probably could replace "Facebook" with just about any company in that sentence. Having to uphold "company values", live by some boss's petty rules, take HR initiatives seriously, etc, is pretty much universally frustrating.

Eh, I don't think so. This is the second tweet in that thread:

> Imagine not being complicit in social disorder and political interference. It’s pretty nice. Imagine not being ashamed to tell people where you work. Even better.

I work for an (old, non-SV) company with a pretty decent workplace culture, while I don't like some things about it, the company's products and values are OK and eye-rolly "HR initiatives" can be pretty much ignored if you choose. I don't feel any "mental burden" or shame for working here.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by ethbro on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:28PM (#23630023)
I can attest to the difference. I've worked in consulting and directly for companies, both more and less evil.

There is a palpable difference from company culture to culture.

If you work at a place where (a) you disagree with your company's ethical and moral standards and/or (b) you feel purported standards rarely influence actual decisions, then there are absolutely companies not like that.

Sure, you still have to deal with HR stuff, anti-union posturing, and sharp business practices. But fundamentally, it feels different.

I'd say most companies can be binary classified into "value their values" or "ignore their values".

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by ForHackernews on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:16AM (#23628819)
Nah, most companies just want their employees to do their jobs. It's only these Silicon Valley cults that expect everyone to drink the koolaid about "values" and center your personal identity around your job.

If you don't believe this, go get a job at a lumber yard or a warehouse or something.

Related reading:

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/558867.Disciplined_Minds

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/34466958-bullshit-jobs

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by cmdshiftf4 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:25PM (#23629957)
>It's only these Silicon Valley cults that expect everyone to drink the koolaid about "values" and center your personal identity around your job.

I can't understand why you're being down ranked for what is objectively the truth.

I've a long career inside and outside tech and this is consistent with my experience. Tech companies are uniquely toxic in the sheer volume of koolaid you're expected to digest to merely maintain your job there.

A tech company not filled to the brim with HR crap would be a breath of fresh air at this point.

Maybe many here simply haven't worked outside of tech?

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by listenallyall on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:28AM (#23629008)
You don't think there's a severe mental burden associated with having to clock in and out, reprimands for being 6 minutes late, only being allowed to visit a doctor if it's on the health plan's list, few opportunities for advancement, work quotas, can't leave early to pick up a sick kid from school, etc etc?

Not to mention most warehouse workers don't make nearly enough to have the luxury of quitting.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by paulgb on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:15AM (#23628809)
Not all companies equally, though, and I think that's the point here.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by lopis on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:02AM (#23628613)
There was a comment here from someone working in a company (strongly hinted that it was Google or Facebook) where they described that basically most people are aware that lots of what they do is terrible for the web and humanity in the long term, but they have a culture of pretending they are creating something good for the world and patting each other on the backs. And since their pockets are being lined with good money, medical, etc, it's hard to leave.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by pesenti on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:06AM (#23628662)
I have answered part of your question before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19036507

Happy to answer more.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by tech-historian on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:45AM (#23629293)
Thanks for your perspective here.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by WhompingWindows on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:30AM (#23629027)
Can you explain why you think FB's products are good for the world? Do you think Donald Trump would be President without FB?

Edit: Apparently someone downvoted this comment within 60 seconds...this seems contrary to HN's ethos. I asked a general question with a specific example; is someone triggered by the words "Donald Trump"? This is pushing a legitimate question about FB's effect on the world down into the gray...is that a good thing?

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by pesenti on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:42AM (#23629248)
I am an immigrant in the US. My family uses FB products (FB App, WhatsApp, Portal) to stay in touch across the world. It really improves our lives.

It doesn't mean I believe everything that's done on our products is good for the world, but I do believe the good outweighs the bad by a wide margin. A big part of my job is to make sure that this margin increases.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by WhompingWindows on Friday June 26, 2020 @12:42PM (#23653991)
It's great that you get to keep in touch with your family! Is there not any other product, owned by a more ethical organization, which could do the job? Also, more generall, is it even possible today to have such a product developed, if FB will just use its lobbyists and power to ensure it can buy that competitor and bend it to Zuckerberg's will?

How do we weight and balance the damage done by FB to our social discourse and elections, vs the benefits your family and many others have enjoyed?

HN commentary: Is anything I'm writing downvote worthy? Do you think my original comment (or this one) is incendiary or doesn't make the dialogue more nuanced and developed?

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by rainyMammoth on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:54AM (#23629426)
I really don't see how by a wide margin Facebook products can be a net positive to the world. They are a net NEGATIVE and probably by a huge margin (if you could quantify it, probably destroying more lives than a lot of defence contractors). Facebook:

- Disrupt democracy all over the world,creating divisive political lines between us.

- Destroys the mental health of millions of teenagers that spend hours on Instagram comparing their lives with the fake lives of other people. An epidemic of mental health is directly linked to Instagram/Facebook

- Make us lose Billions of hours scrolling through a feed of nonsense just to display some ads.

Facebook is a huge net negative to the world. The only justification that I can see working for them is selfish money. Call it what it is, don't come up with some nonsense Koolaid around the product being a positive to the world.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by 0xy on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @09:53PM (#23636045)
I'd rather people get their political news from other people on Facebook or WhatsApp groups than highly corrupt hyper-partisan news organizations that serve the interests of their billionaire founders exclusively.

Mainstream media has done more to disrupt democracy than Facebook. Whether it's:

- Lying about Iraq WMDs that eventually lead to tens of thousands of casualties (New York Times)

- Lying about Russian hacks of critical US infrastructure (Washington Post)

- Lying about the standards of immigration facilities (AP)

- Lying about innocent victims of assault during the riots (NPR)

- Threatening to ruin someones life through doxxing over political GIFs (CNN).

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by bryan_w on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @05:56PM (#23634321)
You have to understand that the average FB user's experience is

- log on

- see pics of niece/family

- message their buddy about that thing this weekend

- see funny cat video

- log off

To that person, FB provided a lot of value with none of the downsides you're talking about. I don't think I'm friends with a single person who even follows DT's page, so this whole ordeal means nothing to them.

Could people communicate via other websites? Sure, but it's easy enough to just use FB.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by WhompingWindows on Friday June 26, 2020 @12:46PM (#23654054)
Is that the average FB user's experience? It seems to me there may be a bi-modal distribution, I'm sure many people you know use it like that...but many others are pulled into bad habits and negative thoughts due to prolonged exposure.

"The average US adult spends 38 minutes per day on Facebook. 16-24-year-olds spend a median of 3 hours a day on social media. Internet users spend an average of 2 hours and 22 minutes per day on social networking in 2019.May 19, 2020"

Source: https://review42.com/how-much-time-do-people-spend-on-social....

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by rainyMammoth on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:47AM (#23629314)
I know a couple. The answer is simple: Money. Facebook pays way above what other tech companies pay (a 6 year of experience senior engineer in Menlo Park can easily make 600k/year). There is also a sense of pride coming from back in the days when Facebook was still seen as a very exclusive and wonderful place to work at.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by bradlys on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:08PM (#23629669)
600k/yr seems a bit far fetched for six years of experience. levels.fyi is one source that I think would contradict the easiness of that goal.

Facebook pays in line with what other top big public tech companies pay. You could go to Google or Netflix and expect similar comp.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by 0xy on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @09:50PM (#23636021)
It is far fetched, but Google and Netflix cannot match FB. FB beats Google at every level, on average.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by dingaling on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:26PM (#23631008)
Not being facetious, but what to the devs do all day to earn that?

Their core functionality, Find a Friend, is pathetically limited and naive. Why can't I search for ( cohort of near my age who went to my school ) or ( everyone called Bob who is one or two hops from Alice and lives in Bigville )?

Or even search a friend list by some criteria instead of scrolling through 1200 names.

Frankly it sucks.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by askafriend on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:41PM (#23631222)
> Why can't I search for ( cohort of near my age who went to my school ) or ( everyone called Bob who is one or two hops from Alice and lives in Bigville )?

They had this feature a couple years ago. It was called Graph Search and did exactly what you're suggesting (and even more impressive than that). They shut it down fairly quickly because it was a huge privacy and security issue as well as an incredibly abusive feature at their scale.

Building products in a system as complex as FB is not as straightforward as adding features just because you can or have the talent to do so.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by rainyMammoth on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @01:54PM (#23631409)
Most devs in bigTechs micro optimize very little things (ie, cogs in the machine). It makes sense only at a scale where those micro-optimization can pay for themselves.

I'm not sure how you stay sane working on those micro-issues though.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by greggman3 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:32PM (#23630093)
I don't want to excuse anything facebook does that's bad and do take some effort to be less tracked. I have FB blocked in one browser profile and I have all but FB blocked in another and many other things.

That said, my experience using Facebook is mostly positive. I see what my sister is up to, my mom, my aunt, several friends and acquaintances. Facebook messenger is by far my most used communications service.

I have taken step to keep it that way. I get no news of facebook. I've joined almost no groups. I unfollow anyone who gets too political, that has included a couple of close friends who I want to follow but they jsut can't stop posting politics several times week or even day so "unfollow".

I run FB Purity in the browser can block a bunch of stuff but I don't have that option in the FB app and for the most part I don't notice too much crap in my feed.

In other words, AFAIK it's mostly a positive in my life and the life of my friends. If I worked at Facebook I'd certainly be proud of how helped people stay in touch and organize group events.

I'm not excusing anything bad they do. Just suggesting I suspect many people have a mostly positive experience or they'd quit.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by mathattack on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:04AM (#23628638)
The folks I know there don’t have issues. The adtech folks would otherwise be at other adtech companies. The product managers would otherwise be at other large tech companies. Nobody is 100% clean, and I don’t see many folks in Silicon Valley struggling with their conscious.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by neya on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:04AM (#23628636)
In Singapore, most of them are actually proud. I've been to their office a bunch of times and in fact, people treat it as something super prestigious, especially considering the office space is really nice with a beautiful view of the Marina. Sometimes, their employees will sound extremely arrogant and even look down upon you if you don't work for another equivalent giant (like Google Singapore).

I guess different parts of the world have different moral standards. It is the way it is.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by bathtub365 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:12AM (#23628760)
Singapore itself employs a surveillance apparatus against its citizens so I'd expect the cultural norms there may be affected by that.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by maurys on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:25AM (#23628954)
Culturally, yes, prestige and a known company is probably more helpful in Asian countries.

Another perspective is that I take the money, help support my extended family and community and feel like a net positive contributer.

Concerns with how social media is affecting relationships and corporate bullying are less real to me personally than the people I meet day to day who I can support.

Again, not arguing about which perspective is right, but yeah there are other ways to look at one's situation.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by nailer on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:18AM (#23628847)
In terms of not moderating public conversation, I would /absolutely/ be proud of Facebook's stance here.

Compare this to Twitter, where a similar large amount of political discussion takes place, but mentioning that the law will be enforced is considered a 'threat' whereas actual death threats and doxxing are not.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by greatwhitenorth on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:15AM (#23628817)
You can ask this question about most of the for profit businesses. Apple (Foxconn), Amazon(Warehouse issues), Microsoft(ICE), just a few examples. How many of those who are against Facebook are still using Apple products or buying from Amazon. You can't pick and choose your ethics.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by staticassertion on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:18AM (#23628851)
> You can't pick and choose your ethics.

Yes you can? I think X is OK, I think Y is not OK. I can even be a hypocrite about it, because X and Y may be fundamentally related, or share a source.

The ethical issues with Facebook could easily be seen as independent from the ethical issues with those other companies.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by spfjefe on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:19AM (#23628867)
I have quite a few friends who have worked and still do work for Facebook. I used to know someone who worked on their "security" team that truly had some frightening powers re: privacy, but with the excuse that it's ok because of stories of saving some kidnapped child's life, or helping track down someone with terrorist connections because they had Facebook messenger on their phone so they could pinpoint their exact location and report it (along with message history) to the police.

I know a guy who worked on a content moderation team and has been severely psychologically affected as a result. Like, he's not the same guy anymore. But he still works there and doesn't seem to consider taking any other job. I think it's because once you've seen all sorts of horrific images and have knowledge of heinous acts going on in the world after you're put in a position of policing them, you feel like the problem is bigger than yourself and your needs are secondary. It's sad, though.

I've never heard any of the people I know talk negatively about Facebook in any way, especially not a "wow, I can't believe I work for these people." There's always a focus on the good they're doing, and how the good outweighs the bad. After Trump got elected, there was all sorts of talk about how Facebook is bringing people together with feminist and anti-trump groups, ignoring the other facts. When Zuckerberg was testifying to Congress over privacy issues it was all about how he's being misrepresented and Congress doesn't understand the internet.

Only recently have I detected some small dissatisfaction from someone who has worked at FB for 7+ years, but instead of jumping ship entirely they switched to working for a different Facebook owned brand.

But I hear the pay is great, benefits are great, stock options are great, and the Facebook kool-aid is a mighty potent drink.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by elicash on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @10:56AM (#23628540)
Here's some info about favorability ratings of Facebook and its changes:

https://www.axios.com/exclusive-poll-facebook-favorability-p...

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by shultays on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:31AM (#23629048)
I saw a more snarky comment on this topic which still makes me smirk: "Hopefully one day they will see the little skull icons on their hats and ask the question 'are we the baddies?'"
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by cmdshiftf4 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:36PM (#23630195)
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by zeroonetwothree on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:07AM (#23628691)
I could ask the same about working for the NYT.

https://slatestarcodex.com/

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by 0xy on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @10:14PM (#23636178)
New York Times: Lied about Iraq WMDs and helped get tens of thousands of people killed.

Facebook: Won't censor your political enemies enough.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by bzb3 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @10:55AM (#23628512)
Why would they be unhappy or ashamed? Not everybody shares your views of politics.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by Enginerrrd on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:02AM (#23628611)
Because ethics =/= politics and I think it's a pretty universal judgement that Facebook has done some ethically dubious things in the past, and not much has changed from the policies that led them there in the first place.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by bhupy on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:08AM (#23628705)
Okay but ethics isn't universal either. There is no objective moral framework.

"Not everybody shares your views" == "Not everybody shares your ethics".

Let me try and steel-man this for you: if you believe in classical liberal principles of free speech, then you might probably be "proud" to work at FB, as well as of Zuckerberg's stance.

Here's a better articulation of that: https://stratechery.com/2020/zuckerbergs-choice-zuckerbergs-...

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by sneak on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:15AM (#23628803)
Ethics and morals are not the same thing. Morals are not universal.

Ethical frameworks were created specifically to be an objective standard.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by bhupy on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:17AM (#23628842)
> Ethical frameworks were created specifically to be an objective standard.

Yes, and there are many ethical frameworks. You and I may subscribe to different ethical frameworks, and that's entirely a function of our morals.

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by _bxg1 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:17AM (#23628841)
Facebook and the like have directly driven a huge increase in worldwide division and polarization. And faced with that fact they've continued their course full-steam-ahead. I don't know of any moral framework where that isn't a negative for society. Some on the economic-right might argue it isn't Facebook's problem to worry about because something something The Market. But even they wouldn't say the full picture is a good one, and wouldn't deny the logic that working for the company, in practice, ends up contributing to that outcome.
Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by bhupy on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:25AM (#23628945)
I really encourage you to try and construct the strongest counter-argument to yourself so that you might at least be able to empathize with why someone might be sympathetic to Facebook's current stances without jumping to the conclusion that they are cartoonishly evil. Remember that everyone is "the good guy" in their own story.

The moral framework where Facebook "isn't a negative for society" is the one that says that a free society should be able to openly express itself, and insofar as there is a high degree of polarization/division, it's because society itself is divided, and the free expression simply exposes that. In other words, how do you know that Facebook caused the polarization? How can you definitely conclude that Facebook isn't simply a mirror on society, and that society was already divided to begin with?

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by _bxg1 on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:56AM (#23629458)
> the conclusion that they are cartoonishly evil

> The moral framework where Facebook "isn't a negative for society" is the one that says that a free society should be able to openly express itself

I wasn't making any such grand claims. I intentionally scoped my argument to "Facebook has increased division in the world" and "increased division is bad", in an effort to keep it as non-subjective as possible.

> In other words, how do you know that Facebook caused the polarization?

I didn't have to look very far; Facebook did the study itself, internally, and executives directly chose to ignore it: https://www.theverge.com/2020/5/26/21270659/facebook-divisio...

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by bhupy on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @12:09PM (#23629685)
> I didn't have to look very far; Facebook did the study itself, internally, and executives directly chose to ignore it: https://www.theverge.com/2020/5/26/21270659/facebook-divisio....

While this is indeed a compelling data point, I want to point out 2 things:

1. We have no way to verify the validity of the methodology, since the study is opaque to us.

2. We have no way to verify the veracity of the results, since the study is not peer reviewed.

And while you didn't have to look very far, perhaps if you look even a little farther, you'll find that there are conflicting studies (in published peer reviewed research):

"We combine nine previously proposed measures to construct an index of political polarization among US adults. We find that the growth in polarization in recent years is largest for the demographic groups least likely to use the internet and social media. For example, our overall index and eight of the nine individual measures show greater increases for those older than 75 than for those aged 18–39. These facts argue against the hypothesis that the internet is a primary driver of rising political polarization." [1]

"Contrary to conventional wisdom, my analysis provides evidence that social media usage reduces mass political polarization."[2]

"After conducting a detailed analysis of recommendations received by each channel type, we refute the popular radicalization claims. To the contrary, these data suggest that YouTube's recommendation algorithm actively discourages viewers from visiting radicalizing or extremist content."[3]

So this is by no means conclusive, and very much debatable. To repeat: the most charitable argument for "being proud" to work at FB is if you believe in classical liberal principles of free speech, and don't believe that social media itself creates polarization/division, it simply reveals it.

[1] https://www.nber.org/papers/w23258

[2] http://rubenson.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/barbera-tpbw....

[3] https://arxiv.org/abs/1912.11211

Re:Ad Boycott of Facebook Keeps Growing by tech-historian on Wednesday June 24, 2020 @11:00AM (#23628591)
Facebook is in Silicon Valley and I'm willing to bet most of its ranks are very liberal.