News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by xwowsersx on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:08PM (#23604593)
Not trying to start a flame war, but as an Android user I can't help but find it shocking and funny that something this basic is a headline in 2020
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by MR4D on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:43PM (#23605310)
A few things to note about Apple & Apple users:

1 - Apple doesn't focus on "first". More often, they are usually focused on a better integration of something than being first. Obvious exceptions include things like 64-bit phone chips, but usually not first.

2 - most Apple users (note that I am saying users, and not developers or power users) prefer it that way. They prefer simplicity over raw power - sort of the revers of a linux command line user.

3 - Even the power users tend to like something that keeps them in the Apple camp. For me, it's the ecosystem an approach to privacy and security - I can help my parents be safe easier on an iPhone/iPad/etc than I could on an Android phone.

4 - For many (most?) people, the apple email app is better than most alternatives. Personally I run gmail, outlook, and apple, and prefer Apple in most situations (not all, but most). Think of this as "I can't believe that Lexus doesn't have an electric car yet" - most Lexus users don't really care because they are happy with the product as is. Would some subset prefer it? sure, but not enough to outweigh the reasons they bought the Lexus in the first place.

5 - I'm not an Android user, but I agree - it is a funny headline in 2020.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by xwowsersx on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:07PM (#23605745)
Oh I totally get all of this and I agree that it's fair to characterize Apple's bent as being UX at the expense of user freedom and that many people _specifically want_ this, but at this point it's overstated as applied to some of these features. For example, default browser - Apple doesn't need Android's complicated system whereby you choose whether this app opens up links of a certain type always or just this once, etc. Apple could just have a setting where you choose your browser. Unless I'm just naive, this should add no overhead in terms of UX. Same applies to email client.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by MR4D on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:47PM (#23606411)
I wonder[1]. Not disagreeing, and I'm not a systems programmer, so I can image that there are aspects of things to make something truly secure[1] that you have to chase down all these rabbit holes.

I look at OpenBSD and see how long it takes them to do something fairly "simple", and use that as a guideline for security development integration timeframes. Of course, OpenBSD isn't backed by a trillion dollar company either.

Oddly, I fall into the Mac + Linux camp. I love using MacOS (yes, even Catalina works for me), but I love that doing development/server stuff on Linux is so clean. What both do for me is minimize the brain clutter (and that's one reason I can't grok the idea of doing server development in Xcode).

[0] - I don't think you're being naive. Also, being a fan of guys like Krebs on Security makes me realize that doing this right is not so much hard as it is painstaking.

[1] - no, I definitely don't think iOS is totally secure, but I think it's harder to screw up as a user than competitors.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by DevKoala on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:21PM (#23605978)
I do it for the privacy. Google auctions user data to third parties for micro dollars on their ad exchange.

https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/www.google.com/en...

Apple has no such business.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by saagarjha on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:23PM (#23606002)
Being able to change your default apps has nothing to do with privacy and everything to do with platform control.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by DevKoala on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:26PM (#23606048)
I stick with Apple for the privacy. There are features on Android I wish to use, but I can’t bring myself to use an Android phone or putting the effort of cleaning it from all of Google’s trackers.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by shawnz on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:46PM (#23606396)
What do you do about all of Apple's trackers?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by DevKoala on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:03PM (#23606631)
Apple doesn't surface the information they collect to third parties. If you are talking about in app advertising tracking, I reset my tracking advertiser ID pretty often too.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by shawnz on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:11PM (#23606713)
And what information does Google surface to third parties besides the tracking ID (which can also be reset easily on Android)?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by DevKoala on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:26PM (#23606927)
In the Ad Exchange, Google surfaces the full url, geo, and all browser identifier information under the RTB protocol.

When tracked through apps, Google is equally open. Apple tries its best to combat tracking, but most apps will still do their best to jump through the tracking contention measures.

https://9to5mac.com/2019/02/07/app-screen-record-apps-remove...

I'd say, always be vigilant of the apps you install. I often check my http request logs to see my phone activity.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by sudosysgen on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:41PM (#23606318)
You can just flash your phone with LineageOS. Takes about an hour, and you're done.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by swagonomixxx on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:47PM (#23606405)
What about all the apps that need the "Google Play Services" libraries?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by codethief on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:55PM (#23606517)
There's always MicroG and the MicroG-infused version of LineageOS:

https://microg.org/

https://lineage.microg.org/

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by sendilkumarn on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:30PM (#23606967)
jc! but isn't microg also requires us to enable some level of Google Play Services?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by codethief on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:13PM (#23607490)
Well, MicroG is meant to be a drop-in replacement for closed-source Google libraries on your phone (i.e. Google Play Services / Google Services Framework) but obviously it will still have to connect to Google servers if needed (although you're able to control for what purposes). For instance, push notifications for apps often use Google's Firebase Cloud Messaging platform and MicroG allows the user to still receive those notifications in the absense of Google Play Services / Google Services Framework.

I suggest you have a closer look at the MicroG website where this is explained, too: https://microg.org/

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by sendilkumarn on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:52PM (#23607868)
Cool :) I am using openGApps but I think it does not have this flexibility I will switch over to microg :)
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by sudosysgen on Monday June 22, 2020 @09:21PM (#23608993)
I personally use microG and disable all of the features that call home to Google, except for those anonymized by microG. Works flawlessly, except for some apps that don't work but are easily replaced.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by freehunter on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:47PM (#23607206)
So instead of trusting the hardware or OS maker you’re trusting a random third party?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by AnthonyMouse on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:02PM (#23607391)
It isn't a random third party, it's a specific third party with a better privacy record than the hardware or OS maker.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by sudosysgen on Monday June 22, 2020 @09:22PM (#23609004)
You can build LineageOS yourself if you want. The procedure is on their website. Then you can also read the code to make sure nothing funny is going on.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by asjw on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:18PM (#23606822)
> I stick with Apple for the privacy.

The problema Is if you stick with Apple hardware there is no OS alternative

you're stuck with what the dictator (benevolent or not) decides

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by freehunter on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:48PM (#23607215)
That’s the point. Some people like that and are willing to pay extra for that.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by heydabop on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:45PM (#23607169)
Google auctions the promise of showing ads to relevant users. Google would be eliminating themselves as a middle man service by selling the data they've curated.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by neya on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:45PM (#23606380)
Apple does listen to your intimate conversations though.

https://www.mirror.co.uk/tech/apples-siri-listens-users-inti...

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by pseudalopex on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:54PM (#23607290)
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by diminish on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:29PM (#23606121)
apple sells users to apps and gets 30% cut.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by DevKoala on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:35PM (#23606221)
Can you provide a link? Is this the cut they take for their App Store? If so, that isn't even in the same scale of selling your browsing history. For example, if I knew your cookie, and had access to the Google Ad Exchange, I could get your full browsing history as seen by Google trackers.

The third parties know how to tie your cookie to your other information through identity graphs.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by shawnz on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:05PM (#23606643)
And what if you had access to the iCloud servers, where Safari history is stored without end-to-end encryption (unlike Chrome sync which is encrypted end-to-end)?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by DevKoala on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:14PM (#23606764)
I and any other third party can buy their way into the google Ad Exchange, but nobody can buy their way into iCloud's servers; for example, China had to ask Apple to create a segregated iCloud to support iOS in China.

It is possible that the US government has some snooping contract with iCloud, but they are definitely not the party I am trying to protect myself from. I am trying to protect myself from businesses using my data to influence my politics, lifestyle and purchases. Look into the business of companies like Liveramp, to see the kind of data exchanges that Google helps proliferate.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by shawnz on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:17PM (#23606811)
Do you have a source that third-parties are able to see that data in Ad Exchange?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by DevKoala on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:31PM (#23606978)
Read into the RTB protocol. With every Google pixel, all of the information obtained by the HTTP request + publisher appended data is passed to Google and auction to advertisers.

https://www.iab.com/guidelines/real-time-bidding-rtb-project...

Full disclosure: I work for one of these third parties. Safari/Firefox are the hardest browsers to track. Google extended the deadline for killing cookies which probably netted us another year worth of easy revenue before we have to start start relying on first party tracking.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by shawnz on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:36PM (#23607744)
Of course they send that information... it is just the information that the advertiser would get anyway when you see their ad. Do they send the tracking cookie though, even before you buy?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by DevKoala on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:46PM (#23607824)
The RTB protocol describes the message that goes along with each bid request. So that is the information that all third parties participating in the auction receive as long as they are listening.

To participate in the auction you don't need to win or even bid; you pay an upfront cost for listening, buy a seat in the ad exchange. The whole thing is dressed as an ad-exchange, but it really is a data exchange. If you win the auction you get to serve your own pixel to tag the user, corroborate the data from the auction, etc.

There is a lot of value in winning and ad impression beyond the ad impression itself, but just by listening you can build advanced models of people's browsing patterns, and if you want tie the data with the information from another identity graph, you only need to win one identifier once and serve both pixels, your party's and the third party (cross cookie syncing). This third party identity sync historically happens at the client level, the browser in this case. However, in the future it will happen at the backend level, first party.

PS: Google is not the only exchange btw. There is APPNEXUS, Rubicon, PubMatic, etc.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by shawnz on Monday June 22, 2020 @07:15PM (#23608073)
> If you win the auction you get to serve your own pixel to tag the user, corroborate the data from the auction, etc.

That's not a scenario specific to real time bidding though. You could also just buy a regular ad and do that.

> if you want tie the data with the information from another identity graph, you only need to win one identifier once and serve both pixels, your party's and the third party (cross cookie syncing).

How can you associate the data from bids you didn't win to the data you get from ads that you did win and serve? Even with cookie syncing that doesn't necessarily reveal when a past/future bid opportunity matches a user you already know (unless you bid on it and win)

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by DevKoala on Monday June 22, 2020 @08:32PM (#23608678)
> That's not a scenario specific to real time bidding though. You could also just buy a regular ad and do that.

With a regular ads (ad words), you don't get to target based on cookie, geo, or other identifying characteristics in real time. Through programmatic ad exchanges you can do it in real time since every auction contains all the information to perform the targeting and enhance your models; the cookie, the url where the ad was going to be displayed, the browser characteristics, etc (read RTB for that).

> How can you associate the data from bids you didn't win to the data you get from ads that you did win and serve? Even with cookie syncing that doesn't necessarily reveal when a past/future bid opportunity matches a user you already know (unless you bid on it and win)

Associating between auctions and wins is simple, they share the same id. You listen to a different stream for bid result notifications. Moreover, your own embedded pixel will give you the information upon impression.

The key here is that the auction, what you get by just listening, comes already with all the information; if you listen enough, you can build the full browsing history of the cookies you track. Using this information you can build models to predict where these specific cookies will go next, and show them ads or alter the publisher context they are exposed to in order to route them where you want to route them. B2C marketing and political propaganda services are all about that.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by shawnz on Monday June 22, 2020 @09:19PM (#23608975)
If it's the case that the auction provides bidders with the cookie even if they don't win, then that is indeed concerning.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by DevKoala on Monday June 22, 2020 @10:10PM (#23609258)
It is the case.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by diminish on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:30PM (#23606972)
apple's business model is selling its users as hostages to app developers.

- it's bad for app developers with 30% cut

- and bad for users as every app becomes +30% more expensive (like Hey app)

- good for apple.

in apple app ecosystem you're the product as the user.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by minhazm on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:52PM (#23607266)
This is exactly the same for Android though. Both Google Play and Apple App store charge 30%. And they both also drop the 30% to 15% for subscriptions after 1 yr.

It's estimated Apple did about $50 billion in App Store revenue in 2019, and $30 billion for Google Play store.

Now consider that about 80% of Apple's revenue actually comes from hardware, not software or people's data.

But 70% of Google's revenue comes from ads. It's insane to me that you think that in Apple's ecosystem you're the product. The product in Apple's ecosystem is their hardware and they charge for access to users.

Google does exactly the same thing, except without the regard for your privacy. Google's entire business model is selling access to its users.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by dimator on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:40PM (#23607106)
This is what-aboutism at it's finest. Changing default apps has nothing to do with privacy. How did you connect the two other than "but what about..."?

In fact, forget about Android, every OS pretty much ever has allowed for changing default apps. This is strictly about control, and this current move is strictly about throwing EU regulators a slight curve ball.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by lordgrenville on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:22PM (#23604898)
I'm a pretty happy MBP user, but any time I have to use my partner's iPhone I'm blown away by how frustrating and opaque iOS is.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by ponker on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:42PM (#23605301)
People get used to things. I feel the same way about picking up an Android. People who live in New York and people who live in Nome probably would find the other’s lifestyle frustrating and opaque.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by mbreese on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:50PM (#23605436)
I was recently at a party when one person asked someone to take a photo with their phone. They were the only ones there with an Android phone. Not a one of the rest of us could figure out how to do it quickly. The stress of needing to be quick might have also played a part. I’m sure I could figure it out without the pressure, but in the moment, it was impossible to figure out what button did what.

I think someone just took a picture with their own iPhone and sent it via email.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by wlesieutre on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:57PM (#23605568)
By the same token, if you don't own an iPhone there's no way you'll find "Swipe over on the lock screen to quickly access the camera" because there's no visible indication that it exists.

Nor would you know that swiping down from the battery meter might give you a camera shortcut, or that pulling down on the home screen icons gives you the search box.

So you'd probably be hunting through the home screen icons on a borrowed phone to find where they put the camera app.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by mbreese on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:27PM (#23606067)
I don't know... my lock screen has a camera icon always visible. When you tap it, you get an isolated camera mode that only shows you photos taken in that session. That's the standard screen now, so I think Apple is doing okay on the discoverability front (for that specific use-case -- possibly the only case where something is discoverable in iOS).

But I still don't know how to take a picture on an Android phone. I have no idea what the Android virtual buttons mean or what they do at all. With similar logic, my wife still has an iPhone with a physical home button because she doesn't like my (now old) iPhone with the "swipe up" home motion. She doesn't really want to learn how to use a new (ish) gesture.

And while I'm on a roll... I also don't understand the buttons on Playstation controllers, preferring the direct lettering of the Xbox or Switch.

We are all ultimately creatures of habit.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by panopticon on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:21PM (#23606863)
> my lock screen has a camera icon always visible. When you tap it, you get an isolated camera mode that only shows you photos taken in that session. That's the standard screen now, so I think Apple is doing okay on the discoverability front (for that specific use-case -- possibly the only case where something is discoverable in iOS).

Huge discoverability hiccup with that camera button on the lock screen: you have to tap and hold the camera button to get into the camera (not long, about 1 second). The first time I picked up my partner's iPhone to take a picture for her, I just about pulled my hair out trying to get that button to do anything. I tapped it about a thousand times before she got frustrated and showed me how to operate it.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by jonny_eh on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:52PM (#23607267)
It's to prevent the phone accidentally unlocking. But your experience does highlight a big problem. They should show a message when you "frustrate" tap explaining what you should do.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by wlesieutre on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:27PM (#23607648)
> my lock screen has a camera icon always visible. When you tap it, you get an isolated camera mode

Maybe they screwed this up on home-button iPhone models but got it right on the X and newer?

Here's my lock screen: https://i.imgur.com/tyOYZXW.png

I don't see anything resembling a camera icon that I could tap. I can swipe sideways to get to the limited-session camera, but only because I happen to know that shortcut exists.

It's not as if the 4" SE is too small to fit a camera button on the screen, but there isn't one. Unless I turned the button off and forgot about it, but I can't imagine Apple offering that sort of UI customization.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by lorenzhs on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @06:01AM (#23611861)
It's almost invisible against your background photo, but at the very bottom, there are a bunch of dots just like on the home screen, except the rightmost dot is a camera icon. It's not a button you can tap, it's an indicator of what is on the page to the right. It's the same on my 7. World's most subtle indicator.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by NightlyDev on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:01PM (#23607376)
With android it varies. Samsung has a camera icon on the lock screen by default that you just use, so that is very easy to figure out.

By default, quickly doubletapping the power button also opens the camera, screen on or not.

Gesture navigation is also better on Android, but this is probably because iOS never had a back button.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by dublin on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:41PM (#23606319)
Apple makes things insanely opaque at times too: I hate to admit it, but I cursed Apple for years for removing the search function from iOS (which used to be predictably located in the left-of-home desktop/icon pane). It was literally several years after the change before I accidentally swiped down from the middle of the home screen (who the hell thought that was a reasonable control?) and discovered that search wasn't gone, it was just so well-hidden that it took years to accidentally stumble across it. (This wasn't helped by Apple's opinionated approach to UI design, which led me to believe that in their minds, removing search functionality was exactly in line with Ives, et al's then-new "flat" design philosophy of form trumping function. FWIW, finding text on a web page in Safari is another UI abortion...)
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by WorldMaker on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:32PM (#23606168)
> By the same token, if you don't own an iPhone there's no way you'll find "Swipe over on the lock screen to quickly access the camera" because there's no visible indication that it exists

There is though: that side (right) of the lock screen has a tiny camera icon at the bottom on iOS. You can long press that icon directly and open the camera, but it also sort of teaches you that sliding is quicker. (Though it's not entirely consistent because the icon on the other side, for quick access to "flashlight", doesn't help teach you that sliding that side opens the "Today" widget screen.)

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by wlesieutre on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:37PM (#23607752)
Am I missing something? I don't have a button for the camera or for the flashlight.

https://i.imgur.com/tyOYZXW.png

It's not for lack of space on the screen, but maybe Apple got lazy with designing for older phones and just deleted it. Once upon a time I think the camera was indicated better.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by shawnz on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:34PM (#23606195)
My lockscreen on Android also has a camera icon, and when I tap it it says "swipe icon for camera"
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by jonny_eh on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:53PM (#23607284)
At least it educates the user.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by xwowsersx on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:29PM (#23605043)
Same. Happy MBP user, just seems like iPhone users are still asking for table stakes.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by pmontra on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:28PM (#23606098)
A friend was driving and gave me her iPhone and asked me to answer to an SMS. It was 2011. I couldn't find a way to do it. She had to guide me as I do with my parents. I had a Galaxy S2 back then and a number of dumbphones and Symbian devices before it.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by zuppy on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:44PM (#23606366)
I honestly don’t understand what you were unable to do. You had to open the sms app and reply... Maybe there was something that has changed and I’ve forgotten about.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by ogre_codes on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:51PM (#23606455)
It's a struggle to see this as a sincere comment. Was it that hard to tap in the text box and hit reply?

Lots of legit gripes about iOS, but C'mon.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by egypturnash on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:17PM (#23604781)
iOS finally gets homescreen widgets mixed with the icons, too! But you still have to deal with everything wanting to flow up to the top left, god forbid you should arrange things for easy access to your thumb or to look nice around your background.

I've been on iOS for years and yeah, this is comedy.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by notJim on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:20PM (#23605961)
I'm still waiting for iOS to steal Android's notification system which has been vastly superior forever. People who've only ever used iOS think I'm crazy when I say this, because iOS notifications are so useless they can't imagine what a useful version would be like.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by setr on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:56PM (#23606529)
I'm on android, and I really have no idea what you're talking about -- they're both fairly useless. What apps do anything notable with notifications beyond reply-inline function? Which iphone's have had at least since last year, when I dropped off it

Though I'm on samsung so they might have customized useful features right out (they do have the neat notification bubble thing + non-fullscreen apps, but it doesn't seem to be fully developed -- lots of small bugs -- so I'm assuming that's non-standard android).

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by grishka on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:39PM (#23607081)
I'm a loyal Android user since smartphones became a thing. I do own an iPhone because I had to write some cross-platform code on one of my jobs, but I can't fathom using iOS in part because of how laughably useless the notification system is. It could as well not have any, it won't make a difference. Notifications disappear when you unlock, badges on icons are always there with some arbitrary numbers on them, notification center shows something from last year but not the notification you received a minute ago, and the best part: some "notifications" are modal alerts that pop up right in your face when you least expect.

And they have the audacity to call this the world's most advanced mobile OS.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by panopticon on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:17PM (#23606807)
Yeah, I just switched back to iOS last year after being on Android for ~5 years. The notification coalescing and types of actions you can take right from the notification blow iOS out of the water.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by grishka on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:31PM (#23606989)
Startup idea: make an app that contains empty, transparent widgets of all possible sizes. Sell it for $1. Make millions.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by jonny_eh on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:54PM (#23607299)
Apple would never allow that on their store.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by egypturnash on Monday June 22, 2020 @09:16PM (#23608954)
Yeah I basically had the same thought.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by g-garron on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:12PM (#23604661)
Android gives one more freedom here and there, but tracks you more. At the very end we are tied to Google or Apple, and that is bad.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by ragnese on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:14PM (#23604719)
1. We don't really know what Apple is or isn't collecting from you.

2. You can run de-Googled Android and still do the important 80% of things that a smart-phone is good for.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by jjcon on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:31PM (#23605093)
1. Sure we do, they spell it out very clearly here: https://www.apple.com/privacy/

2. I beg to differ. A completely de-googled phone is not only extremely difficult to achieve but about as useful as a 2009 blackberry. Yeah it runs and will maybe let you check your email with 5+ hours of work just to get push notifications running but it is so completely impractical for anyone that doesn’t want to devote serious amounts of time to it. With Apple you a good balance of privacy and utility imo.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by ragnese on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:51PM (#23605463)
My intention here isn't necessarily to tell you what to use or buy.

1. There is nothing legally binding here, as far as I can tell. Apple software is almost entirely closed source. Zoom told us they were encrypting our stuff, too. I know that Apple can't get away with too much because of their size, but I have a very strong distrust of big tech companies that I'll likely never shake because of the disgusting track record silicon valley has toward privacy and short-sighted profit-making. Take this text for example: "Apple can’t read your iMessages while they’re being sent between you and the person you’re texting." What does it mean that it can't see them while they're being sent? Can they see them once they're at rest? Is this just innocent vagueness of the English language, or sneaky shit? Similarly, they say they can't see your location in Maps. They make no promise with the browser. In fact, they don't promise they aren't snooping on 100% of the stuff in Safari- they only say they try to protect you from other companies tracking you.

2. I don't disagree with you. And I'm just kind of a Luddite because I just don't care if I can run SnapChat or whatever on my phone. I can browse the web with a solid, privacy-respecting, browser (Firefox) with all of the privacy addons I want. I can use that browser to access the things I care about. I do use a closed-source navigation app, unfortunately, but it isn't Google and doesn't require Play services. I lock down its permissions as best I can. I use Signal for most of my messaging needs, which works fine. The one thing I actually do miss is ride-sharing apps when I travel. That's a major inconvenience. But some shitty game or social media app whose entire purpose is to track you (whether you use/trust Apple/Google's OSes or not...)? No thanks, anyway. In fact, I think there's another point in here that most of these apps are tracking the hell out of you, regardless if you trust your phone's OS.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by jjcon on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:20PM (#23605967)
> Is this just innocent vagueness of the English language, or sneaky shit?

They use simple language to make it not seem like legalese - If you want the tech details see the white papers they have linked.

> What does it mean that it can't see them while they're being sent? Can they see them once they're at rest?

No messages are end to end encrypted by default

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303

> they say they can't see your location in Maps. They make no promise with the browser

Apple Maps doesn’t have a browser version, just and iOS and Mac OS app. Additionally see above link, all location and search history is end to end encrypted - maps searches (and other location based events that cannot be encrypted due to server side processing) are not linked to your Apple ID.

> In fact, they don't promise they aren't snooping on 100% of the stuff in Safari

Again see above link, safari history and tab sync is also end to end encrypted

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by ragnese on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:55PM (#23606511)
I wasn't being clear with the maps-browser comment. I meant that they make no promise that they aren't tracking your location outside of the Maps app.

It's great that they claim to end-to-end encrypt their stuff. And after the FBI standoff around the San Bernardino shooters phones, I recommend that my friends and family use Apple because the options for most humans are between Windows and macOS on PCS, and iPhone and (stock, OEM) Android for phones. They definitely talk the talk and appear to walk the walk. We can never truly know, though.

I know there's no point in arguing further. I fully acknowledge that I have less objective reason to believe that Apple is tracking me than you have to believe that they're not. But all of my friends thought I was the crazy tinfoil hat guy in the period between the signing of the U.S. Patriot Act and Edward Snowden. And after that... they still think I'm the crazy tinfoil hat guy. Maybe I'm a broken clock and was right once, or maybe Silicon Valley is full of corporate scumbag liars and maybe companies lie about their encryption (Zoom) and about their stance on privacy (Facebook). Maybe Apple is the lone shining beacon of privacy in SV. Maybe.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by saagarjha on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:25PM (#23606039)
> Apple Maps doesn’t have a browser version

It can, however, be integrated via the JavaScript SDK. DuckDuckGo uses it, for example.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by scarface74 on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:23PM (#23606007)
There is nothing legally binding here, as far as I can tell. Apple software is almost entirely closed source.

So is everything that makes Android, Android -- Google Play Services. Not to mention all of drivers.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by ragnese on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:43PM (#23606348)
Everything except for the Android part, sure.

But you're definitely letting perfect be the enemy of good if you think that closed-sourced drivers means that e.g., a closed source web browser doesn't increase your privacy attack surface.

Life is full of choices between imperfect options. And security/privacy is always qualified with "from whom". Sure, closed source drivers are not ideal and I am more vulnerable to privacy attacks from state actors. But why should my response to that be to just willingly give all of my personally identifiable information to Google, Inc?

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by scarface74 on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:47PM (#23606403)
You mean the “Android parts” that Google keeps abandoning for their own closed sourced versions?

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/07/googles-iron-grip-on...

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by ragnese on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:57PM (#23606547)
Yes, that's what I mean. But you're moving the goalposts. I, too, fear that there will not be a usable, open source OS for smartphones in the near future. But that's not what I said above and it's not what you appear to be arguing.

Today, AOSP is absolutely open source. You're acting like it's not.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by scarface74 on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:14PM (#23606753)
And absolutely useless for any company that wants to sell a phone outside of China without Google Play Services. Most phones run with Google’s closed source equivalents not the unmaintained AOSP versions.

You don’t know what the apps on your Android phone is doing because they all interact with Google Play Services. Most phones don’t even use the open source dialer.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by ragnese on Monday June 22, 2020 @07:09PM (#23608010)
That's all true and fine. But is there anything I said that hints that I'm a company trying to sell an Android phone without Google? If not, what are you refuting exactly?

I said that we don't know what Apple software is doing because it's all closed source. You then spent the last several replies trying to convince us that the same is effectively true of Android. It's not. You know how I know? I'm writing this reply from a Pixel 2 running LineageOS without Google Play Services. Is it a pain in the ass to do this kind of setup? Yep. Do I miss out on TikTok? Probably (I don't want it, so I don't know if it requires Play Services). Is it closed source? No.

In any case, refuting my claim that we can't trust Apple by arguing that we also can't trust Google doesn't actually refute a thing.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by scarface74 on Monday June 22, 2020 @07:52PM (#23608345)
So you can have a completely open source version that is a pain in the ass and can’t run many Android apps. Congratulations?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by ragnese on Monday June 22, 2020 @09:08PM (#23608892)
I'm not looking for a pat on the back from you. Again, all I said was that you (mostly) don't know what closed source software is actually doing. I have yet to understand how in the world you disagree with that.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by scarface74 on Monday June 22, 2020 @09:26PM (#23609031)
Have you personally audited every piece of code on your phone?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by ragnese on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @06:17AM (#23611978)
Of course not. And even if I did, there's no chance I could catch every possible bug or issue or exploitable issue. But, like I said several replies ago: life is full of choices between imperfect options. I try to choose the less bad choice as often as possible.

If you wanted to spy on your users, would you honestly risk publishing your source code? Let's be real.

Next obnoxious, low effort, trolling, question?

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by bad_user on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:19PM (#23604834)
Do you have some evidence on how Android tracks you or is this just a guess?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by jjcon on Monday June 22, 2020 @03:35PM (#23605161)
Just go see for yourself: https://myactivity.google.com/

Location, web searches, app usage etc etc. Try turning all tracking off and your phone becomes a brick. Google Assistant no longer works, google maps can no longer remember where your home and work are (cause that can’t happen on device for some reason). Top it all off and you’ll get constant pop ups asking you to turn it back on.... not fun.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by bad_user on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:19PM (#23605947)
Yes, I know about the Google profile, it's transparent and I turned Google's app activity off. My Google profile is right now empty.

That's not Android.

Let me repeat the question — how does Android track you?

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by jjcon on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:23PM (#23606011)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman

That’s virtually every android device in existence. Just because someone degoogled an android once as an experiment doesn’t mean it becomes the new definition of what android is.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by bad_user on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:27PM (#23606075)
I am familiar too with the "No true Scotsman" fallacy, I don't necessarily see how it applies here.

Dare I ask what the point is?

---

I am not talking about de-Googled Android. Turning off web/app activity in your Google profile is not equivalent with de-Googling your Android.

I am asking how does Android, Google's Android distribution not anything else, tracks users?

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by jjcon on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:33PM (#23606184)
> I am asking how does Android, Google's Android distribution not anything else, tracks users?

And I am saying it is a pointless thought experiment to separate Google from Android. Next you’ll say it’s the hardware that is android, not the software and ask how the hardware directly tracks users.

Edit: Read my original comment again, you are changing the subject. I haven’t said anything remotely conspiratorial, Google is open about their tracking in android. My point is that Google tracks you on android and if you turn it off your phone becomes crippled and in many cases for no reason except that google wants to make it as painful as possible to turn off data collection. Data collection is their business model after all.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by bad_user on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:41PM (#23606323)
OK, let me put it another way ...

iOS too ships with Google as the default search engine and just like on iOS, you can pick a different default on Android too. In fact Android has always allowed for changing all meaningful defaults, not something you can say about iOS. And in fact the world's leading Android makers, like Samsung, all of them ship with different defaults except for the Search engine (we're talking browser, email application, etc).

And all desktops actually ship with a browser that default to a search engine that tracks your searches, including Microsoft's Edge and their integration with Bing Ads. And Google is in fact the most transparent about what they track.

So if your answer is the Google Profile, which is transparent and can be turned off, then it's a pretty shitty answer. Unless you can point to implementation details in Android proper, all of this is just a conspiracy theory, similar to anti-vaxxing.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by anoncake on Tuesday June 23, 2020 @08:48AM (#23613138)
Android is commonly understood as Android with Google stuff as pre-installed on most phones. As opposed to AOSP.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by underwater on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:48PM (#23606422)
> google maps can no longer remember where your home and work are (cause that can’t happen on device for some reason)

This is such a user-hostile product choice. Google will happily let me favourite a place but refuse to create work and home labels.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by lern_too_spel on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:03PM (#23605674)
That's not Android. Those are Google apps. They would track you just the same if you ran them on iOS or any other OS, and you can turn them off very easily.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by Mediterraneo10 on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:11PM (#23605811)
This is not limited to just those with Google Play Services installed. Even nearly pure AOSP builds like LineageOS still default to Google’s DNS servers, wifi gateway checks, and SUPL server, and replacing those defaults with privacy-respecting alternatives has been made harder due to changes that Google pushed into AOSP.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by bad_user on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:23PM (#23606013)
Google Play Services provides valuable services that need a backend component.

I asked for evidence that Google tracks you in nefarious ways via Android.

Am I being tracked when using their DNS servers, which are otherwise very valuable for people suffering from DNS-level banning of websites?

And what do you mean by "privacy respecting"?

Words are cheap. I hope the privacy respecting apps and services you use can guarantee that either via technology (encryption, open source, reproducible builds), or via contract (and a ToS that can be changed on a whim for a free service isn't a contract that can protect you).

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by Mediterraneo10 on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:11PM (#23606717)
> I hope the privacy respecting apps and services you use can guarantee that either via technology (encryption, open source, reproducible builds)

This is what the F-Droid repository is all about. But again, Google has insisted on changes to AOSP that will shortly make it much more difficult for ordinary users (i.e. those who cannot use the command line) to make use of such free and libre offerings.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by lern_too_spel on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:24PM (#23606026)
You can replace them much more easily than you can on iOS, and you don't even need to install a third party ROM. You can turn SUPL off entirely on any Android phone out of the box, while you cannot on iOS.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by lern_too_spel on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:06PM (#23605731)
On the contrary, iOS actually tracks you far more than Android. This is just marketing-driven conventional wisdom that doesn't hold up when you take even the most cursory look at it. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23329646
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by CharlesW on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:14PM (#23605853)
You're citing your own claim, but it doesn't look like anybody's buying it.

Here's an actual study: https://www.tomsguide.com/us/android-privacy-vs-iphone,news-...

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by lern_too_spel on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:16PM (#23605895)
You are comparing default apps privacy and saying that is OS privacy. I specifically pointed out data collection in the OS (that you can't turn off) that make iOS far worse than Android for privacy.

Your paper also compares the amount of data sent to Google for an Android device using default apps vs. an iPhone using default apps and shows that the latter sends much more. That's not a very useful comparison. If you compare how much each device sends to Apple, the Android device would win by a landslide, though again, that is not a useful comparison.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by CharlesW on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:35PM (#23606217)
> I specifically pointed out data collection in the OS (that you can't turn off) that make iOS far worse than Android for privacy.

I think this claim is even more absurd when constrained to "default apps". But I'm listening—citations welcome.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by lern_too_spel on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:27PM (#23607647)
I gave you a link. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23329646

Which part of it my assertions did you have trouble following? I'll quote it below in case you have trouble following the link, but I worry this might violate a repetition rule:

iOS having better privacy is a myth. iOS sends your location to Apple every time any the GPS is used, and you can't turn it off. You cannot install apps on your phone without telling Apple which apps they are, and if you want to develop your own apps for your device without having to reinstall weekly, you have to hand over payment information.

Stock Android devices from nearly any vendor do not suffer from these problems, and reputable vendors do even better (like in this case, where even voice transcription does not send data off device).

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by scarface74 on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:22PM (#23605989)
I find it equally shocking that if I bought an Android phone three years ago, that any new feature Google introduced would be absolutely useless to me without buying a new phone....
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by vinay427 on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:30PM (#23606133)
This misses the point in my opinion. Android doesn't depend on Google for much of its functionality, unlike iOS with Apple. For example, I can install a command line-style launcher, animated wallpapers, alternative app stores, and other non-Google features without any rooting or other unapproved modifications because Android as a platform is far more flexible. With unapproved modifications, I can also bypass Google services entirely and depend on the open-source community.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by scarface74 on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:35PM (#23606223)
As long as you ignore those unimportant security updates....
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by vinay427 on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:53PM (#23606489)
Sure, that's definitely a worthy point that I gladly agree with, although it's a different point. I would maintain that older Android devices generally feel less out of date, feature-wise, than iOS devices of a similar vintage because far fewer features need to be handled by the core OS.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by scarface74 on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:10PM (#23606707)
Yeah. Tell that to my son who had a Moto G before he “upgraded” to my old iPhone 6s (introduced 2015) that was 3 years older. The Moto 3 was always touted as a good midrange phone. It might have felt better “feature wise” if he had toyed with it, but Android hardware just doesn’t age well. I can’t imagine burdening it with more features from third parties.

Btw, the iPhone 6s is still running the latest iOS version.

Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by lolsal on Monday June 22, 2020 @06:20PM (#23607569)
For what it's worth as a long time Apple user, I don't have any use for this feature. I think Apple knows this, which probably contributes to they have punted it for so long. shrug
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by monadic2 on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:43PM (#23606358)
There’s no accounting for the priorities of large corporations.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by RIMR on Monday June 22, 2020 @04:32PM (#23606171)
Yeah, I've never owned an iOS product. I am aghast that this basic limitation has existed this entire time.
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by smittywerben on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:26PM (#23606923)
How do you SSH on android?
Re:iOS 14 will let you change your default email and web bro... by twicetwice on Monday June 22, 2020 @05:29PM (#23606953)
Termux is a pretty much full-fledged linux userland in an app. I've run a Node.js server from my phone and connected to it from my laptop. I've written code in vim. I've ssh'd into many a server. All in Termux. It's the best.