News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by andy_ppp on Thursday June 18, 2020 @11:19PM (#23570606)
When Tim Cooke went on about services I didn’t realise he meant stealing 30% of other people’s. Seems insane to me this racketeering is legal, I actually think people should be jailed for behaviour like this...
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by redwall_hp on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:08AM (#23570874)
Is there even a legal term for this sort of captive market scenario? Antitrust laws seem close in spirit, but people decades ago apparently couldn't have anticipated the sort of vendor lock-in that has become commonplace in the smartphone space.

It's like you had two paper mills that dominated the market, and they wanted to claim a percentage of every novel, newspaper, etc. printed on the paper they produced. Oh, and you can't use that paper you bought to write erotica or other things the company disapproves of.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by bduerst on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:51AM (#23571076)
It's hard because most analogies fall apart when you look at the users having already paid hundreds of dollars just for the hardware up front.

You could compare it to Costco, where you have to pay just to get into the store, where Costco sells their own labels side-by-side with the competition. The big difference is Costco doesn't force you to pay with costco credit cards at the cash register.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by krrrh on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:14AM (#23571202)
In practice though most people I know do use a Costco branded credit card since it doubles as your membership card.

Costco (Canada at least) also only allows MasterCard for credit card payment. Prior to that it was exclusively Amex.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by bduerst on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:18AM (#23571220)
Which is fine - that's still the consumer's choice. It's a bit different if Costco took away that choice.

Even then it's not the same because you don't own the Costco store like you own your phone.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by eloisant on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:58AM (#23572141)
I think it's pretty much a textbook case for the antitrust laws. Now the only missing parts is the political will for Congress and US government to move forward.

Unfortunately since the MS antitrust trial, they've missed opportunity after opportunity to prevent monopolies or oligopoly of Big Tech companies so they might pass here as well.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by Spooky23 on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:19AM (#23570934)
The only unique thing is the scale. There’s nothing that Apple is doing that your grocery store, Ticketmaster venue, or mall owner isn’t.

Seems like a weird hill to die on for an email app to me. The market is saturated.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by jld on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:49AM (#23571065)
It's like having only two grocery stores in town, and your kitchen is only able to cook food from one or the other.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by scarface74 on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:40AM (#23572026)
Or three console makers....
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by andy_ppp on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:22AM (#23571949)
Because ripping people off by rent seeking is common it’s okay? It’s not okay to steal other people’s work when them building things for it means you sell more iPhones. Apple have this stuff completely backwards, stop there from being an App Store at all and see how many iPhones are sold.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by Spooky23 on Friday June 19, 2020 @10:54AM (#23575109)
You’re putting words in my mouth.

How would you write the rules to get what you want? It’s a complex question.

I used to always buy Mancini roasted red peppers for salads and sandwiches. My grocer did a strategic sourcing exercise and now carries a house brand and some other brand. Should they be compelled to carry Mancini?

WalMart requires that vendors be able to fill orders on tight timescales. If you can’t, your out. Is that ok?

Costco requires that I pay them to shop there. Is that ok?

My wife owned a mall kiosk, and part of rent was a cut of the gross. Is that ok?

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by scarface74 on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:40AM (#23572025)
All retailers “rent seek” by that definition.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by andy_ppp on Friday June 19, 2020 @04:17AM (#23572274)
Sure, but you can only visit one retailer. If there was store competition let Apple charge what they like...
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by scarface74 on Friday June 19, 2020 @06:11AM (#23572939)
Google and Steam both have potential competitors and they both charge 30%
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by andy_ppp on Friday June 19, 2020 @11:59AM (#23575753)
They don’t charge on top of services the way Apple does do they?
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by scarface74 on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:32PM (#23576821)
Yes Google has in app subscriptions.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by andy_ppp on Saturday June 20, 2020 @07:28PM (#23588340)
Do they force you to use their in app subscriptions in the way Apple is? Can I still use my own subscriptions servcie - in fact I know the Answer because Spotify and Hey were not complaining about the Google Play Store.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by anoncake on Friday June 19, 2020 @07:24AM (#23573274)
Google doesn't meaningfully have potential competitors. Alternative stores are severely limited, e.g. they can't update apps in the background.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by scarface74 on Friday June 19, 2020 @08:00AM (#23573475)
Is that a bad thing? If I’m using an alternative to a the App Store, I definitely don’t then want an app to be able to run arbitrary code from a server.

But we have an alternate universe where users can install outside of the official store yet hardly anyone takes advantage of it.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by anoncake on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:50PM (#23576240)
> Is that a bad thing? If I?m using an alternative to a the App Store, I definitely don?t then want an app to be able to run arbitrary code from a server.

If you like updating manually, don't give the store you use permission to do it manually. Why are you running software you don't trust anyway!

> But we have an alternate universe where users can install outside of the official store yet hardly anyone takes advantage of it.

See the post you replied to.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by scarface74 on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:00PM (#23576379)
That’s the beauty of the App Store. I don’t have to to trust the app maker, just the operating system.

How do you know which app makers to “trust”?

Epic?

https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-fo...

Zoom?

https://www.zdnet.com/article/zoom-defends-use-of-local-web-...

Google?

https://support.google.com/chrome/thread/15235262?hl=en

https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/30/googles-also-peddling-a-da...

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by anoncake on Saturday June 20, 2020 @01:38AM (#23581979)
The latter is just a great argument why alternatives to Google's app store shouldn't be able to do their job.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by camgunz on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:49AM (#23571062)
Yeah, it is technically a cartel.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by stephc_int13 on Thursday June 18, 2020 @11:36PM (#23570691)
It could be even worse, when those things are left unchecked they tend to increase over time.

I've seen that with Handango (they raised from 30% to 40% and then 50%) and they went bankrupt when the App Store launched.

Same story with the phone operators, their margins was in the 50% range.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by fomojola on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:10AM (#23570888)
I'll echo this: 30% is terrible, till you consider the alternatives. Before the app store it was 3 month lead times via a broker to hopefully get in front of a carrier rep who would usually go "meh" and send you packing. If they liked it, they'd take (if you were lucky) 50% with holds of up to 3 months on payouts.

Can't say I'm a huge fan of the 30% haircut, but I get to push my product directly to millions of people in a week and get paid monthly? What a time to be alive.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by kalleboo on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:30AM (#23571617)
Before switching to a smartphone I used a J2ME Twitter client on my Sony Ericsson. You paid through PayPal and downloaded and installed a JAR file manually. It wasn't very convenient, but at least direct sales were an option. It was similar on the Palm and Symbian side of things.

Apple not allowing side-loading seems like the main issue.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by mathnmusic on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:02AM (#23571131)
> 30% is terrible, till you consider the alternatives

Only in the Apple iOS land. If I don't like Google Play's revenue cut, I can list my app on any of a dozen or so alternative stores (Amazon, F-Droid etc) and all Android Users can install my app. Same story on Windows, Linux and even Mac devices.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by rusticpenn on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:51AM (#23571403)
"all Android Users". IS it possible to get these alternative stores without rooting?
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by OkGoDoIt on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:11AM (#23571876)
Yes. You’ll get a whole bunch of scary warning messages from the operating system warning you not to do it, but to my knowledge all android phones allow you to. It’s possible that some corporate management software might prevent this, not sure. Also there are more and more android APIs which are baked into Google Play Services, which is another can of worms entirely. Still, Android is significantly more open to sideloading than iOS.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by perryizgr8 on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:45AM (#23571712)
Yes it is just another app.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by scarface74 on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:41AM (#23572038)
See how that works out in practice.....
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by eloisant on Friday June 19, 2020 @04:03AM (#23572184)
That works very well for services where the app is not the main product... Like Hey.com. They do their own market and don't need the "visibility" of the app store.

They would be pretty happy if they could have a link on their site to download the iOS apps, for their customers.

If Apple still wants to review every app that can be installed, they could propose an option to be in the App Store but unlisted - then the fees goes down to 2 or 3%, just like a credit card fee. But they won't, because they can get away with shaking businesses 30% so they'll keep doing it until someone forces them to stop.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by stephc_int13 on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:35AM (#23570998)
There are no alternatives today.

And I am perfectly aware that the situation was even worse before the App Store.

In fact, by all means, Apple created a viable ecosystem for a huge number of independant developers and that's great.

Still, 30% is not justified, and this is not Apple hate, Google and Valve are on the same boat.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by threeseed on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:59AM (#23571116)
Don't forget about retailers, supermarkets, ecommerce sites etc.

If you are shocked that companies take a fee for distribution then wait until you see how things work in the real world.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by shaan7 on Friday June 19, 2020 @01:16AM (#23571209)
> If you are shocked that companies take a fee for distribution then wait until you see how things work in the real world.

That is not a good analogy. Supermarkets, retailers etc charge a fee from the vendor because that is their primary source of income ("bread and butter", if you may). In the OP's case, the "supermarket" is an iPhone device which the user has already paid a premium price for.

EDIT: bduerst covered this already https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23571076

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by scarface74 on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:43AM (#23572048)
So a company is only allowed to have one revenue source?

Grocery stores also have slotting fees.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by shaan7 on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:35AM (#23572754)
Depends on how you define "allowed". EA was "allowed" to charge extra money for unlocking key Star Wars characters even after you paid in full for Battlefront II. So, the idea is less about what is "allowed", but rather where the line is drawn between justified commercial profit and monopolistic/bad behavior*

> Grocery stores also have slotting fees.

Again, the whole point I'm trying to make here is that comparison to grocery stores just doesn't work (because of reasons mentioned in the first comment)

* English is not my first language so I'm having trouble finding the perfect word.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by eloisant on Friday June 19, 2020 @04:07AM (#23572217)
Proportionally to the revenue, the cost of running a supermarket is much higher than running the App Store.

Having stock costs money, you have to decide what to stock and take a loss if you can't sell it, nothing is automated so you need more staff...

It's really apple to oranges.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by cultofmetatron on Friday June 19, 2020 @08:35AM (#23573827)
100 years ago, diabetes was a terminal illness. Gouging prices on insulin is still a dick move.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by eloisant on Friday June 19, 2020 @04:11AM (#23572241)
You can distribute Android software without Google, and you can distribute PC games without Valve. You have a choice.

You don't have a choice to distribute iPhone software.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by eru on Friday June 19, 2020 @05:48AM (#23572822)
> You don't have a choice to distribute iPhone software.

Just broaden the market to software in general or even just software for mobile phones and tablets. Then you have a choice again. iOS's market share is below 50% even in the US, and much lower globally.

(I have both iOS and Android devices, and I specifically like that Android's Firefox allows add-ons like uBlock Origin. Apples doesn't allow those.)

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by davidwhodge on Friday June 19, 2020 @02:43AM (#23571702)
Agree with the app store being better than anything that preceded it. That said, it's not 2008 anymore and Apple should adapt.

What happens in reality is developers either capitulate and / or sneakily separately contact their users and get them to pay through another payment processor.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by andy_ppp on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:25AM (#23571966)
I don’t get why either case 30% or 50% is right? It’s actually having the best app ecosystem that sells more phones, imagine for a second there was no App Store, how many iPhones would be sold.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by threeseed on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:30AM (#23570981)
> It could be even worse, when those things are left unchecked they tend to increase over time.

App Store has been around for over a decade.

The percentage has actually decreased.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by stephc_int13 on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:56AM (#23571105)
When? Source?
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by threeseed on Friday June 19, 2020 @12:57AM (#23571109)
In 2016, Apple reduced subscriptions to 15%.

https://www.businessinsider.com.au/apple-changes-app-store-r...

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by OkGoDoIt on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:13AM (#23571896)
And nearly every app pivoted from a buy it once model to a pay monthly/annually model. Absolutely made the state of iOS apps worse for end-users :-(
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by scarface74 on Friday June 19, 2020 @03:43AM (#23572054)
It pivoted because there isn’t a way to do upgrade pricing.
Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by stephc_int13 on Friday June 19, 2020 @10:54AM (#23575105)
That's not a reduced margin on IAP, that's a different serrice with a different model, and 15% is only after a (quite high) threshold.

Very few mobiles games can be sold using the subscription model.

Re:Apple gave me the Hey treatment back in 2014 by jojobas on Thursday June 18, 2020 @11:36PM (#23570695)
Yet people are queuing and fighting to be stolen from.