You could compare it to Costco, where you have to pay just to get into the store, where Costco sells their own labels side-by-side with the competition. The big difference is Costco doesn't force you to pay with costco credit cards at the cash register.
Costco (Canada at least) also only allows MasterCard for credit card payment. Prior to that it was exclusively Amex.
Even then it's not the same because you don't own the Costco store like you own your phone.
Unfortunately since the MS antitrust trial, they've missed opportunity after opportunity to prevent monopolies or oligopoly of Big Tech companies so they might pass here as well.
Seems like a weird hill to die on for an email app to me. The market is saturated.
How would you write the rules to get what you want? It’s a complex question.
I used to always buy Mancini roasted red peppers for salads and sandwiches. My grocer did a strategic sourcing exercise and now carries a house brand and some other brand. Should they be compelled to carry Mancini?
WalMart requires that vendors be able to fill orders on tight timescales. If you can’t, your out. Is that ok?
Costco requires that I pay them to shop there. Is that ok?
My wife owned a mall kiosk, and part of rent was a cut of the gross. Is that ok?
But we have an alternate universe where users can install outside of the official store yet hardly anyone takes advantage of it.
If you like updating manually, don't give the store you use permission to do it manually. Why are you running software you don't trust anyway!
> But we have an alternate universe where users can install outside of the official store yet hardly anyone takes advantage of it.
See the post you replied to.
How do you know which app makers to “trust”?
Epic?
https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-fo...
Zoom?
https://www.zdnet.com/article/zoom-defends-use-of-local-web-...
Google?
https://support.google.com/chrome/thread/15235262?hl=en
https://techcrunch.com/2019/01/30/googles-also-peddling-a-da...
It's like you had two paper mills that dominated the market, and they wanted to claim a percentage of every novel, newspaper, etc. printed on the paper they produced. Oh, and you can't use that paper you bought to write erotica or other things the company disapproves of.