News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by slg on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @09:15PM (#23472823)
Just to be clear, is this a closed source application that I am supposed to install to modify my OS and the only contact information for the people who made it are Steam accounts? And the primary motivation for installing this software is that I don't trust the multinational corporation that could lose hundreds of billions of dollars if they inappropriately abuse my privacy? But of course I trust Barnacle, Vegetorius, and Janeyris.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by oddlama on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @09:23PM (#23472864)
While I get your point, I think when using Windows, the majority of ibstalled software will be closed source. And most, if not all of them have been granted the same level of priviledge a some point during installation.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by slg on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @09:34PM (#23472922)
That is fair. I would be lying if I said I never installed potentially dodgy software from the internet. My primary problem here is the motivation behind the software.

The reason this software exists is fundamentally about a lack of trust. We don't trust Microsoft with the level of data that Windows 10 collects. That is a perfectly reasonable position to have. However if that is your opinion, it seems frankly bizarre to trust these nameless developers who have zero accountability for this software. Microsoft is at least accountable to the law, the stock market, and their customers. There is hundreds of billions on the line if they screw you over. If Barnacle screws you over, the only thing on the line is their copy of Ultra Street Fighter IV.

Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:21AM (#23474494)
* the law, the stock market, and their customers*

In that order. We are last. In fact I'm not even a customer anymore, I haven't paid for an update to Windows since Windows 8 was released.

Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by bproven on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @10:03PM (#23473122)
Yeha I agree, considering it is free why not open source it to alleviate those concerns?
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:24AM (#23474518)
Open source comes with a cost to the developer. There was an interesting discussion about it on HN a couple of months ago.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by prophesi on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @09:27AM (#23476737)
It's possible to set up your repo to have issues disabled, which will get rid of the majority of FOSS's costs.

When it comes to privacy/security tools, it makes sense to make it open source, since they usually are given an insane amount of privileges to modify your machine.

Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by romanovcode on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @06:07AM (#23475481)
Majority of applications do not require UAC access allowance as well so those are not a problem.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by nvr219 on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @09:21PM (#23472854)
Yeah... this is the kind of thing I'd have installed in the '90s but not today no sir
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by xook on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @10:43PM (#23473349)
This particular statement is sobering in an unexpected way. How the times change wrt software and personal sovereignty.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by bastardoperator on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @09:28PM (#23472892)
I thought it looked like a fake GitHub page on mobile too. It has some distinction but you’re right, it’s suspect. Steam, LOL.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by DaiPlusPlus on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @10:32PM (#23473297)
And their logo is too similar to Stardock's - I thought this was an actual Stardock product to begin with (because this is exactly the kind of program Stardock would make). I downloaded it, but I won't install it - there's something fishy about this whole thing.

There's no reason for this program to not be open-source - especially if it all it does is tweak the registry and apply GPO settings.

Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by prepend on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @09:23PM (#23472863)
What more do you need beyond their press kit?
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by CawCawCaw on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @11:13PM (#23473531)
Fortunately for you the whole thing is written in unobfuscated .NET so the source can be easily recovered.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by lvs on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:41AM (#23473988)
Why couldn't they just put up the source then? A closed-source privacy tool is quite the contradiction.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by userbinator on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @09:52AM (#23477005)
I wish people would stop thinking of open-source like it's some sort of panacea. The Ken Thompson Hack should be enough proof that what really matters is what gets run, not what the source code says.

For decades, the Windows community thrived with mods and such, all without source code.

If you have an unobfuscated .NET binary you pretty much have the source, and it will be honestly what it says it does.

Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by prophesi on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @10:00AM (#23477076)
It's not a panacea, but it's objectively better than closed-source. Thank you for pointing out that the binary is unobfuscated.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by lvs on Friday June 12, 2020 @05:19AM (#23497475)
Straw man. Nobody said it's a panacea.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by lanisik655 on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:40PM (#23479100)
correct.

Шt amazes me that people blame WPD for closedsource, but they themselves use shutup10 :facepalm:

Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by lanisik655 on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:38PM (#23479073)
sure sure, shutup10 - closed source (with Obfuscated DLL inside), Microsoft partner :3
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by fsflover on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @03:51AM (#23474907)
> corporation that could lose hundreds of billions of dollars if they inappropriately abuse my privacy

In fact they are already doing this, most probably breaking the GDPR.

Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by userbinator on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @10:09PM (#23473157)
This sort of paranoic fearmongering is exactly the sort of propaganda that pushes society towards that authoritarian corporate dystopia in which trust is forced by those in power, and which you have no control over. We are slowly losing our freedom to choose even whom to trust, thanks to this idea that these "multinational corporations" are somehow deities.

You highly underestimate the skill of the community, and how it only takes one person to find out and spread the news if something is amiss. Source isn't needed, and doesn't tell the whole story anyway. (See: Ken Thompson Hack.)

the multinational corporation that could lose hundreds of billions of dollars if they inappropriately abuse my privacy

The corporation which has lawyers and knows exactly how to spin their spyware to carefully evade such laws?

Windows 10 would clearly be considered spyware 10 or even 5 years ago. Yet somehow Microsoft has convinced the general public that it isn't, and we are supposed to still trust them?

Edit: downloaded it to take a look. Appears to be written in easily-reversible .NET and not even obfuscated, so go ahead and analyse it yourself if you don't trust it. (If it was obfuscated, that would make my suspicion jump.)

Edit2: looks like people still think I'm wrong - go look at the binary yourself instead of blindly downvoting just because you don't want to do the thinking yourself. The more power you let them have, the more they will abuse it.

[dead]
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by Hawxy on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @11:05PM (#23473485)
> So yes, Microsoft has publicly said if they detect a music track that may have been downloaded 'illegally', they will 'package it and all your info and send it to the feds'. It isn't spyware if you partner with the spies.

This was just part of the clickbait fearmongering that spread across various news and conspiracy sites before W10's release. From what I recall, it was to do the content clauses surrounding OneDrive/Office 365 (ie, you can't use OneDrive to host your illegally acquired content) that people somehow assumed would apply to their local documents. Microsoft made the privacy policy wording a lot clearer after that and have said numerous times that they really don't give a damn about your local files.

> Microsoft decided to go into the data business with Win10.

The advertising subsystem in W10 is actually pretty well isolated to the Windows Store and your Bing web searches, and it doesn't involve your personal information (just keyword/demographic based targeting). Your telemetry data isn't used for adverts. Microsoft Ads as a whole doesn't really make a ton of money for Microsoft so they don't invest a lot into it.

Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by catalogia on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @10:30PM (#23473287)
It's not fearmongering to question the low standard Windows developers and their users seem to consider routine. That Windows users have chosen to accept Windows becoming spyware is just another manifestation of that same problem, not a refutation of it!
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by userbinator on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:16AM (#23473863)
It absolutely is fearmongering when you default to assuming maliciousness/bad faith just because the author is relatively unknown. There's nothing deep/unusual about what this program does, and I assure you that if it was created with malicious intent, it would not remain undiscovered for very long.

That Windows users have chosen to accept Windows becoming spyware

The developers of this, and others, are clearly fighting against it.

Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by catalogia on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @01:09AM (#23474150)
The developers of this program are asking windows users to install proprietary freeware from anonymous developers. This exemplifies Windows software culture, the very same culture that made Windows users compliant enough to tolerate Windows 10 in the first place. The developers of this software, in choosing to make it proprietary freeware, are reinforcing this culture.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by harrygeez on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @10:54PM (#23473423)
I don't know any companies in this day that doesn't collect users' usage and analytics. Very few do better by making it opt-in
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by vezycash on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @10:53PM (#23473416)
Knowledge comes before acceptance. Apart from those of us who live on tech sites, normal users would be completely clueless.

Even among those who know, only a fraction would be bothered enough to take action.

Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by catalogia on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @11:43PM (#23473679)
Many Windows users may not know there's a better way, but I can hardly think that's an excuse for developers writing proprietary freeware for Windows. Surely they've heard of open source at some point, they just don't give a damn.
Re:Windows Privacy Dashboard: GUI for Windows 10 Privacy Set... by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:26AM (#23474527)
the low standard Windows developers and their users seem to consider routine

Compared to just about every SaaS product?