This sampling would have a (possibly slight, but still unknown) bias towards people who are isolating less (who you would expect to then have a higher than average percent positive for antibodies, assuming isolating is helpful).
I don't think anyone knows whether or not this is a more representative sample than the stanford study.
(which wasn't always clear to me before since I initially predicted that this will take years to work out)
All of these numbers are inline with what experts have been saying and modeling for more than a month. We will be dealing with this for at least another year. We will cycle through policy to loosen up and close back down a little. In the best case for NYC they are 1/4th of the way to herd immunity in numbers. With the drop in transmissions, this might be 1/8th of the way in terms of time. There will be more deaths in the future than have been recorded so far.
Look for the bright side in things, but zero cases is a pipe dream.
With most endemic viruses, antibody incidence is somewhere around 30-50% I believe, but I haven't seen any modelling for what covid is expected to do specifically.
The CDC reports that flu has an IFR of ~.13% in the US (61,000 deaths out of 45 million cases). That makes 0.5% roughly 3.3 times worse, not 10.
Also, herd immunity does not require 100% having positive antibodies, it will show an effect on Ro starting around 65%.
that's not what herd immunity means, unless we isolate those spreaders so they don't get in touch with "non-spreaders"
I think they're saying that people who go out and spread the disease will quickly catch it, recover, and be unable to catch it and spread it. That relatively small group of people who are refusing to self isolate, will gain herd immunity, causing the virus to die out in that group of people, preventing them from giving it to the non-spreaders that have been at home the whole time.
Whether or not it will work out that way, I don't know.
You can also do a separate phone survey in addition to surveying the test participants. Questions like "Do you think you have had COVID?" and "How many times per week do you leave the house?". If the responses for the test participants vary significantly from the phone survey participants, you can try and weight your data accordingly.
There's also literature that suggests that you don't discard outlier values in the actual responders as they may help approximate the non-responder population, i.e., the non-outliers represent typical responders while outliers are more likely to represent non-responders [1]
[0]https://www.warc.com/content/paywall/article/jar/research_no...
[1] https://bmcmedresmethodol.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186...
f(N, P): (1 - ((1-P)^N)) / P
For a large P you're right, but as P gets very small (let's say that in any given trip you have a 0.01% chance of being sampled) then the increase in likelihood of being sampled approaches N times as much (in this example, it would be 6.999 times as likely). Of course, this assumes they're taking measures to ensure no one gets sampled twice.
That said, even if it's overall 0.6%, that is still 6x higher than flu, and higher than H1N1 which had a CFR around 0.1 for areas with adequate health care. (much higher when there was not adequate care, but that is not dissimilar to Covid.)
So no matter what, no one should be walking away from this study saying "See it's no big deal! Just the Flu/Cold etc!"
As to NYC deaths, many people currently infected will die in the future. You can make various estimates to account for this but a reasonable first approximation is to double current deaths based on NYC’s infection curve vs South Korea’s.
>"The overall case fatality rate as of 16 July 2009 (10 weeks after the first international alert) with pandemic H1N1 influenza varied from 0.1% to 5.1% depending on the country."
[0] https://www.cebm.net/covid-19/global-covid-19-case-fatality-...
Whenever I have gone or brought my kids when sick, they perform the test to rule out any potential need for antibiotics. When I asked, they said it's systematically reported to the the CDC as part of their flu surveillance system, whether positive or negative. That surveillance network is significantly more robust than a survey.
(Sorry, couldn't resist).
For NY, assuming it’s evenly distributed, that would translate into 13.8% of 20 million = 2.8m symptomatic flu cases and 3,753 deaths.
COVID appears to be significantly more prevalent (roughly twice as prevalent in just 3 months as flu gets all year despite incredible efforts), and roughly 2-3x as fatal.
Why would you think that SARS-CoV-2 would not be more prevalent than the flu? The fact that we have no natural immunity, combined with how virulent it is, indicates the endpoint infection rate will be significantly higher than an average flu season.
"In the U.S., for example, in recent years about 8.3% of the total population get sick from flu each season, a CDC study found; including people who carry the flu virus but show no symptoms, that estimate ranges to up to 20%."
The endpoint percentage of fatalities is a multiple of the infection rate times the fatality rate. Both numbers are equally important.
We've been hearing the "10% hospitalization" and low-single digit CFR numbers for months. At 20% prevalence, the NYC actually had 1.7 million cases, 36,723 hospitalizations, for a hospitalization rate of ~2.1%.
https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/index.html
And on the page specifically for 2017-2018 season, they have different numbers still;
"CDC early estimates indicate that more than 900,000 people were hospitalized and more than 80,000 people died from flu last season."
https://www.cdc.gov/flu/spotlights/press-conference-2018-19....
I agree 100% it will be significantly more prevalent, due to the nature of the virus combined with the total lack of natural or vaccinated immunity.
However, it's not clear at all what our "drastic action" is achieving, aside from 20 million unemployed and trillions of dollars spent trying to hold everything together. 20% prevalence doesn't exactly speak volumes towards the efficacy of social distancing.
But, it’s important to keep things in context, another year lists 9.3 million symptomatic infections and 12,000 deaths. The average year is well below peak years.
So, at least in NYC, SARS-CoV-2 is as prevalent today, if not more prevalent, than a bad flu season, and it’s not done yet.
It's no coincidence that the city that shows a much higher prevalence also experienced a much more acute infection, straining their medical infrastructure. That isn't evidence that social distancing doesn't work, it's evidence that the infection was already well on its way before social distancing was implemented there. NYC was the canary in the coal mine that triggered social distancing across the US, and as a result the experience in NYC has not been repeated elsewhere. Aside from the results, which should speak for themselves, the epidemiological connection between R0 and the prevailing rate of social interaction is clear, which is why it's accounted for in the models.
As we can see, NYC did not particularly flatten their curve, and they did not see excess deaths due to lack of available care. They already hit the endpoint prevalence that you would see with the flu in a very bad year.
It’s not clear how much further SARS-CoV-2 would go naturally — the S curve doesn’t ever go to 100%. But more importantly, without a vaccine, which we won’t see for 12-18 months, we are going to find out exactly how high the S curve goes.
We have a small degree of control over exactly when that happens by burning extremely large amounts of money. So, when do you want it to happen? Now, while flu is at its nadir, or after spending $10 trillion dollars perhaps we can see the final surge during the peak of the next flu season?
The fact is that there isn’t actually a known treatment for COVID, and even with treating the symptoms (invasive ventilation) 80% of people in the ICU will die. This isn’t a disease for which “flattening the curve” makes particular sense. That would require there actually be an effective treatment.
I'm pretty sure all the family members of the people who died would regard their loved ones as "excess deaths". Your technocratic language ascribes no value to the lives lost, in which case of course the actions seem excessive. For people who don't value the lives of others, it would be hard to understand all the fuss.
This isn’t a disease for which “flattening the curve” makes particular sense. That would require there actually be an effective treatment.
This is a self-contradictory statement. The whole point of flattening the curve is to buy time to develop exactly those effective treatments. It is also possible to flatten the curve to an extent that there are fewer deaths under it, and based on the continual downward revision of the IHME model fatality estimates, that appears to be exactly what is happening.
Excess deaths is a term of art to describe a number of deaths over a baseline. It can be used in general, or specifically, as I was using it, to describe the repercussions of an overloaded health care system. Here, for example, is a Sky News story from today using the term in its headline. [1]
I think you owe me an apology, but I won’t hold my breathe.
“Flattening the curve” is absolutely not intended to buy time to develop a cure or vaccine. The timeline over which the economic devastation of flattening the curve can be sustained is measured in weeks not 12-18 months.
The purpose of flattening the curve is to be sure there are the necessary number of hospital beds and ICU beds to provide effective treatment. If effective treatment can not be provided it leads to “excess deaths”.
Bad projections based on a 10% hospitalization rate and based on assumptions that ICU ventilators wouldn’t kill 80% of patients, have led to disastrously bad public policy which is causing untold suffering throughout the country. This suffering, which many people seem to be blind to, is notably self-imposed rather than natural, and through logical and reasonable interpretation of factual data we can stop this suffering.
This is very much unlike the suffering caused by people who are dying from COVID, for which unfortunately we have no effective cure or treatment, and for which it is not reasonable to assume we will develop one in the timeline of this current pandemic.
This is the key takeaway from “flattening the curve”. It cannot and will not decrease the total number of people who are ultimately exposed at this stage of the pandemic. Once the health system capacity is high enough to handle the number of cases coming in with effective care, continuing social distancing causes extraordinary damage without any benefit.
Since effective care at this point has proven to be both simple and extremely scalable (non-invasive ventilation, antibiotics, and frequent repositioning) the resource curves for effective care are extremely larger than projected, back when they were based on availability of ventilators.
Simply put, the data has changed, and it’s time to update the policy. It’s extremely incompassionate to do otherwise.
[1] - https://news.sky.com/story/amp/coronavirus-englands-excess-d...
You are correct that social distancing and flattening the curve protects the health care system from overloading. That doesn't mean that it is the only purpose, or effect. If we took a poll among health care policymakers about the benefits of flattening the curve, I'd be happy to bet any amount you'd like to wager that "buying time to develop effective treatments or a vaccine" would be on their list.
This is the key takeaway from “flattening the curve”. It cannot and will not decrease the total number of people who are ultimately exposed at this stage of the pandemic.
This is just mathematically untrue. There is clearly a point where the curve is so flattened that the number of deaths under it is less than a baseline "no action" scenario. If we could somehow get everyone in the US to truly isolate for three weeks, the virus would die out entirely. So clearly there is a spectrum of actions and their corresponding outcomes. The number of infected (and dead) is not a fixed number with only the duration of the outbreak changing.
If your premise were simply that the current measures are unsustainable, I couldn't agree more. Fortunately, those measures have bought us the time to take more focused, informed action based on the latest data. In a crisis this fast-moving, every day is time to update the policy.
Also, is this particularly good news? Using the raw numbers from the headline and the deaths from here https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data.page we can make coarse fatality rate estimates. I assume population of NYC is 8,400,000.
10290 / (.212 * 8.4e6) = 0.6%
Including probable deaths (which makes the death count line up more closely with excess deaths)
15411 / (.212 * 8.4e6) = 0.9%.
So it seems consistent with a IFR of 0.5%-1%. However, this doesn't account for the lag between antibody presence and death. Also, we don't know what bias sampling from grocery stores introduces, it could affect the results in either direction. Hopefully, New York releases a paper so we can get more accurate estimates.
It's good to see a prevalence study with presumably less flaws.
I think that is still scientifically debatable, good overview: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2239380-will-the-spread...
Certainly it is still transmissible in hot countries.
On the other hand, I can see the additional environmental UV saturation and vitamin D having a noticeable effect.
Even a small decrease in environmental persistence should help, given its infectiousness.
That said, science is enamored with significance levels, p-values, etc. Most people just do that because that's what they've learned, and think that's how it should be done. They don't think it comes from Bayesian inference, where you put a very low prior probability of a drug being useful (because the very vast majority of chemicals we could put in our bodies are either harmful, or have harmful side-effects). In this case, the Bayesian prior is that common colds in general become less prevalent during the Summer, and Covid19 is caused by a coronavirus, which is related to viruses causing the common cold. The burden of proof should be lowered many, many times, but I nobody who did these statistical surveys did that, because this is a total no-no in the field.
So, I'll state my conclusion, after reading your link: the infectiousness of Covid19 is more likely than not to decrease in the Summer, based on the studies that were performed. It will not decrease to zero, so that does not contradict your statement that it is transmissible in hot countries.
MERS is also a coronavirus and does just fine in the warm climate of the middle east. I hope that warmer temps slow the spread, but it's far from certain.
Maybe Africa and Brazil are faking the numbers, but Australia most likely not. Only 76 deaths so far. Argentina has recorded only 159 deaths.
You could say this is only circumstantial evidence. My point is that we are not trying to prove things "beyond any reasonable doubt". We are trying to form the most informed opinion. And there are quite a few factors that point in the direction of reduced infectiousness during the Summer. Schools closed? Check. People away for vacations? Check. More UV light which kills airborne viruses? Check. People having more vitamin D in their bodies? Check. Air more humid, so the tissue inside your nose is better protected? Sure thing. Better immune systems due to less stress due to the ambient light? Sure thing. Etc, etc.
You can question any of these things. But in a Bayesian framework they tilt the scales little by little. But that's just me.
[1] https://news.google.com/covid19/map?hl=en-US&gl=US&ceid=US:e...
It looks to me like you are cherry picking data, and wrapping it up to appear objective. Looking at “case” numbers from countries with poor heath systems is especially misleading. Australia could be an outlier. Jakarta and Istanbul are better proof that temperature is not that important.
My prior is that I have seen lots of people use the “temperature” argument because they want to believe it, which trumps your prior, wink.
Edit: Note that science is mostly about finding counter-examples to a hypothesis. Jakarta is a good counter-examples to the hypothesis “Covid is not much of a problem in hot temperatures”. Istanbul was not (it is actually tepid there in March). And this brings up some other counter-examples: https://thehill.com/homenews/coronavirus-report/494428-trump...
My point is that the infectiousness will decrease in the summer because of these factors. There isn't much reason to think there is anything special about it being Summer.
Finally, it's a very tenuous link between common cold prevalence and coronavirus.
Compared to many other countries, Germany has likely confirmed through testing a higher proportion of its total number of cases in the country, lowering the reported fatality rate.
In countries where testing is less widely available only those already showing severe symptoms get tested disproportionately, so confirmed cases are more likely to be fatal even if they get good hospital care.
However, we should remember that this is probably a mild overestimate, as the study population was assembled from those who were out and about (shopping at the grocery store, etc). People who are more strictly staying home -- and thus less likely to have been infected -- wouldn't be included in the survey.
This one's from a different company (BioMedomics) and it was a random test of people pulled straight off the streets. Happened at an entirely different geographical area (Chelsea, Massachusetts) as well. I don't want to be too optimistic but there are some signs that we are heavily under-counting the actual number of cases (at least in the US).
https://www.bostonglobe.com/2020/04/17/business/nearly-third...
If the real infection rate is still low throughout the population, a random sampling will not lead to reliable results (you could also toss a coin).
Although the article is in German, it is worth to have a look on the graphic in the middle of the page, it should be understandable.
https://www.sueddeutsche.de/gesundheit/corona-test-antikoerp...
I'm not seeing that, at least not from what I've seen. Whether false positives skew results significantly is highly dependent on how accurate the antibody test they used is (in addition to how large a subset of the population is positive).
This guy has an interesting visual tool that helps you to see how much a study could be affected. [1] Also, he says "Here's an interesting relationship. When a test with 95% sensitivity and 95% specificity is applied to a population with <5% prevalence of disease, MOST of the patients with positive tests are FALSE POSITIVEs." I.e., positive rate shows up as greater than 10%, when it's actually less than 5%.
Do we know the sensitivity and specificity accuracies for the antibody tests used in NY?
You'd like to think they know what they're doing. But this Bayesian stuff can be tricky, especially if they're rushing something through (esp. regarding testing of accuracy of the antibody tests themselves). And the California studies, although they seem to have some competent people behind them, seem to inflate/exaggerate the lower bound of uncertainty in their projection. [2]
[1] https://sites.google.com/view/tgmteststat/home
[2] https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2020/04/19/fatal-flaw...
Besides, generally if a virus is less fatal than previously expected, it means it's more contagious, meaning that much harder to get to herd immunity.
Good news would be things like: evidence the virus has mutated into something less severe; evidence of an anti-viral treatment that improves outcomes for everyone so it's not as big a deal to catch it; evidence that community spread has halted in an area and the boundaries are controlled so people in that area can feel secure they won't catch it; evidence of an impending vaccine.
Is this good news just because we're finally establishing that people have caught it once can't re-catch it for now? I guess I can see that as good news but that is so expected that it's more like it would be horrendously bad news if we found evidence that recovered people didn't have antibodies. But generally I don't really see what policy impact this has, other than identifying a pool of workers that can go work in meat-packing factories without fear of catching it again.
And as you pointed out, if the study came back with an infection rate of 50%, I am not sure I would consider that good news either. That means it would be nearly impossible to isolate vulnerable populations. So while a 50% infection rate would mean the IFR is lower, it also means opening things back up and only isolating the vulnerable would not work to protect them.
Unfortunately 21% is a long way from 70%, and it's taken a massive amount of death to get to that point.
The point I was trying to make, was that for the 'open back up' crowd, they are arguing that the IFR is similar to the flu, and only vulnerable populations are really impacted. So they say we should open up and just keep vulnerable population in lockdown. But they are ignoring the implications of the R0 value in their argument. i.e. if the IFR is really as low as they think (and consequently, the infected population is as high as they think), then nothing short of a total lockdown (or very aggressive testing and contract tracing) would stop vulnerable populations from getting infected.
The spread starts to slow before that point. If you're walking around infected and 20% of the people you come in contact with cannot catch it from you, 20% less people are going to catch it, no matter how much you cough on them.
It's good news because it strongly suggests that mortality is much less than previously suspected. There were numbers floating around from anywhere between 10% to 3% a few weeks back. A mortality rate < 1% is very good news because it means fewer people will die in the long run.
Mortality remains pretty much as suspected already two months ago:
“Based on these available analyses, current IFR estimates10,11,12 range from 0.3% to 1%. Without population-based serologic studies, it is not yet possible to know what proportion of the population has been infected with COVID-19.”
https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/situati...
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-0822-7
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.05.20031773v...
0.5% to 1% has been the most plausible for at least a month, and this NYC study seems to exactly line up with that.
“Globally, about 3.4% of reported COVID-19 cases have died. By comparison, seasonal flu generally kills far fewer than 1% of those infected.”
https://www.who.int/dg/speeches/detail/who-director-general-...
In reality, the WHO number was just confirmed deaths divided by confirmed cases, which was of course almost completely meaningless.
if they did the hospitalizations would rise as well
one reason the hospitalizations are falling has less to do with the numbers of cases and more with doctors ability to better tell who might need it.
Because “people who both use Facebook and don't automatically discount every ad or other solicitation on Facebook not from someone they personally know, especially if it invokes a major news story, because of the risk of it being a scam looking to steal personal information or do something similarly nefarious” are not representative of “people”.
No, if valuable advertising demographics didn't do that, Facebook wouldn't make money. Valuable advertising demographics and representative samples of the general population are very different things.
That doesn't make any sense. Ads can make plenty of money even if they're only seen by women, or people between the ages of 30 and 70, or people in zip codes divisible by 3.
The obvious fix is to not tell people the results of their own tests. Not sure of the ethics/consequences of that approach.
This cohort would skew younger and wealthier, which correlates with better preexisting health and fewer risk factors, and would exclude populations who systematically left the city, or who have known heightened risk factors.
Comparing the death rate overall with the infection rate of this skewed sample would be likely to greatly underestimate the actual death rate of the virus.
Still biased but probably better than anything so far.
Suspect the Bay Area is moving towards what Korea is doing. Intense testing and contact tracing.
Friend who works at a biomedical corp says scuttlebutt is they're separating their workforce into groups based on critical need and how well they can work remotely. Workers like him not expected to return to work onsite until next year.
Not sure how well having the Bay Area do one thing, and large chunks of the rest of the country dash to herd immunity is going to work.
Of course, our case count is so high right now. If you get Rt down to a miraculous 0.5, it's like 180 days before you can get to the point where contact tracing is effective. And you probably don't achieve an Rt of 0.5.
In the Bay Area, almost no one has died of coronavirus so the infection rate should be next to nil.
and 2/1000 people * 1% IFR => 20%
From my understanding they are not hit any harder than other groups, they are just way more visible.
EDIT: typo
Widespread mask usage doesn't happen in NYC, same as the rest of the U.S. It's very recent this is practiced in the U.S., whether voluntarily or by order of a handful of local governments. And in my local area where it's not mandatory I only see about 3 in 4 using masks.
NYC has a culture of yelling.
Compared to California, NY locked down much later and did it in slow, incremental steps.
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.08.20056929v...
and
Percentage of people dead is not.
We are getting closer and closer to the flu fatality rate.
from 5% to 3%, then 1% now 0.5% - smart money (and common sense) would bet that the rate will continue to drop,
I would expect that people living in healthier environment than NYC will fare even better. No way NYC IFR is the upper bound for the rest of the country. You could just as well expect it to be 10x higher than other places.
the flu rate is 0.1%, thus we already hit the order of magnitude.
Roughly 0.2% of everyone in NYC has already died of COVID-19. So 0.2% is pretty close to a hard lower bound on the IFR for COVID-19.
And I don't think anyone serious suggests every NYC resident has had COVID. I don't think anyone seriously suggests even half of NYC has had COVID.
That all said, my point is that we don't know the bounds. Period. It could be higher. It could be lower. That is why I said it is conceivable. Probably it is about that value in most places. I am interested in where the data falls.
Look, I agree that I don't know. Just trying to get that uncertainty in the counter claims, as well.
Consider, from all that we have seen, elementary schools could get 100% infection rate on the same population size that NYC nursing homes have and not see the number of deaths they have had. It is not controversial that the IFR is dependent on how many people over 60 you have in your population.
To drive that home some, here in WA, fully 92% of the deaths have been in people over the age of 60. It is quite ridiculous how deadly this is if you are older.
The point on the lower bound of 0.2% is informative. I did not know that.
There are huge error bars on that ratio, because "the population of NYC" is not something easily defined, and the death count (at this time) includes a lot of "excess deaths" that almost certainly have nothing to do with the virus (e.g. untreated cardiac arrest).
And Ioannidis? He was quite certain that the CFR was going to be a little higher than 0.1%. Yes. CFR, not IFR. So he's off by two orders of magnitude.
In his stat article he was saying it is conceivable if we didn't know about it we wouldn't have been able to even detect it in the death numbers after it ran its course (he has since walked that back).
Even the other day after his serology preprint he was saying it doesn't seem to have a higher chance of killing you than seasonal flu for each person infected: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cwPqmLoZA4s&t=1h9m50s
And he claims the WHO said 3.4% of people who get infected would die:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cwPqmLoZA4s&t=12m54s
But they actually said that was the case fatality rate at the time. Their actual quote was:
> Globally, about 3.4% of reported COVID-19 cases have died
I would respect him more if he just argued from am economic perspective that the economic damage is greater but his wild hypotheses about Covid being comparable to the common cold or flu have been completely refuted by all data.
Minor note, but it appears we are up to 14 now - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_on_D...
> Another Japanese man in his 70s died on 14 April, making him the fourteenth fatality.
the worst case scenarios are disproven it is true - but so is the idea that it's just a flu.
let us be grateful this trial run of a deadly global pandemic was only moderately bad.
Are you arguing that after all this time we still don't know what the actual CFR for flu is? And that the reported CFR is a gross overestimation? - I find that hard to believe.
To me, this feels that once this disease hits the reported flu numbers people start arguing that oh wait, the flu is actually even less dangerous ...
The CFR is, by definition, computed from known cases. It's thus trivial to determine exactly: just divide the confirmed deaths by confirmed cases. So we definitely know the CFR of flu. The problem is, of coures, that it's highly likely to be an over-estimate.
On the other hand, the IFR is hard to determine, since we don't know which cases we missed, nor whether the unresolved cases will end up living or dying. Which is why all we have is estimates.
>Globally, about 3.4% of reported COVID-19 cases have died
Ioannidis acknowledged that in his original STAT article:
>Reported case fatality rates, like the official 3.4% rate from the World Health Organization, cause horror — and are meaningless.
Maybe because he had an editor. But I saw him in a recent video claim the WHO said 3.4% of people who get infected would die. A blatant lie:
The major problem in the Stanford study was that they ran a test that has a 3% false positive rate, and found that 3% of the test-takers tested positive. (And that apparently the asymptomatic COVID-19 rate is 90+% - which does not square with the Diamond princess data).
They could have ran that same study back in 2018, and would have gotten the exact same garbage results.
Here, it's closer to a random sample, but more importantly it shows really high rates. Those rates overwhelm any error due to false positives.
Also, it shows numbers that are in line with our intuition. It shows higher infections in NYC, and higher infections among blacks. That reflects what the hospitals are seeing.
This study may well be really good news.