And as you pointed out, if the study came back with an infection rate of 50%, I am not sure I would consider that good news either. That means it would be nearly impossible to isolate vulnerable populations. So while a 50% infection rate would mean the IFR is lower, it also means opening things back up and only isolating the vulnerable would not work to protect them.
Unfortunately 21% is a long way from 70%, and it's taken a massive amount of death to get to that point.
The point I was trying to make, was that for the 'open back up' crowd, they are arguing that the IFR is similar to the flu, and only vulnerable populations are really impacted. So they say we should open up and just keep vulnerable population in lockdown. But they are ignoring the implications of the R0 value in their argument. i.e. if the IFR is really as low as they think (and consequently, the infected population is as high as they think), then nothing short of a total lockdown (or very aggressive testing and contract tracing) would stop vulnerable populations from getting infected.
The spread starts to slow before that point. If you're walking around infected and 20% of the people you come in contact with cannot catch it from you, 20% less people are going to catch it, no matter how much you cough on them.
It's good news because it strongly suggests that mortality is much less than previously suspected. There were numbers floating around from anywhere between 10% to 3% a few weeks back. A mortality rate < 1% is very good news because it means fewer people will die in the long run.
Mortality remains pretty much as suspected already two months ago:
“Based on these available analyses, current IFR estimates10,11,12 range from 0.3% to 1%. Without population-based serologic studies, it is not yet possible to know what proportion of the population has been infected with COVID-19.”
https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/situati...
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-0822-7
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.05.20031773v...
0.5% to 1% has been the most plausible for at least a month, and this NYC study seems to exactly line up with that.
“Globally, about 3.4% of reported COVID-19 cases have died. By comparison, seasonal flu generally kills far fewer than 1% of those infected.”
https://www.who.int/dg/speeches/detail/who-director-general-...
In reality, the WHO number was just confirmed deaths divided by confirmed cases, which was of course almost completely meaningless.
if they did the hospitalizations would rise as well
one reason the hospitalizations are falling has less to do with the numbers of cases and more with doctors ability to better tell who might need it.
Besides, generally if a virus is less fatal than previously expected, it means it's more contagious, meaning that much harder to get to herd immunity.
Good news would be things like: evidence the virus has mutated into something less severe; evidence of an anti-viral treatment that improves outcomes for everyone so it's not as big a deal to catch it; evidence that community spread has halted in an area and the boundaries are controlled so people in that area can feel secure they won't catch it; evidence of an impending vaccine.
Is this good news just because we're finally establishing that people have caught it once can't re-catch it for now? I guess I can see that as good news but that is so expected that it's more like it would be horrendously bad news if we found evidence that recovered people didn't have antibodies. But generally I don't really see what policy impact this has, other than identifying a pool of workers that can go work in meat-packing factories without fear of catching it again.