News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by umvi on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:48AM (#22935376)
> Apple doesn’t let employees contribute to unapproved OSS projects (even in their personal time).

Wow, that seems petty. And it enrages me enough that if I worked for Apple I'd immediately start looking elsewhere for a job. I can do whatever I darn well please in my personal time and any employer that says otherwise is being overbearing.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by taywrobel on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:55PM (#22940192)
That’s a major part of why I left Apple for GitHub. Their OSS culture is horrible there.

The only OSS projects that get approved to contribute to are ones where they’ve already hired most of the people that work on it. Cassandra, Mesos, and some other infra stuff come to mine. And occasionally they just buy a whole OSS company for their own use (FoundationDB).

Submitting a patch to a small library you use? A multi-month process to be told no in the end 90% of the time or more. Have your own OSS projects? Not any more you don’t.

In my exit interview I made my reasoning clear, and pointed out that as they move more into services and away from pure hardware as revenue, it’s going to be a bigger issue. Whether they agree or will work to fix it, only time will tell.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by cameronbrown on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:58PM (#22940214)
Genuine question, what's the value of providing feedback in an exit interview. At best you get nothing from it, and at worst you get put on some secret hiring blacklist. Either way nothing changes, you're just a datapoint in some HR piechart.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by taywrobel on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:02PM (#22940257)
Genuine answer - I have a metric shit ton of Apple stock after being there for several years. I want to see the company succeed, purely for financial reasons if none other. At least until I hold the stock for a year and only pay capital gains on it.

Secret hiring blacklists don’t exist. And if they did, I wouldn’t want to work at a company that uses them anyways.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by m463 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:42PM (#22940876)
Many companies DO have self-hiring blacklists. Basically a checkbox that says "would rehire". I don't know if there are legal criteria necessary to check that box.

I haven't heard of them sharing the lists with other companies.

Apple and other companies have also had do-not-hire agreements with business partners (basically no-poaching) but they were sued and I believe stopped doing that.

Now unofficially, your guess is as good as mine.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by taywrobel on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:05PM (#22941284)
Yeah, but Apple seems to hold grudges against everyone who leaves, so I’m not too worried about that.

I heard rumors of recruiting guidelines to not accept people back who left Apple to go to Netflix back when it was the new kid on the block. I also only knew 2 people who left and came back in several years there.

Given the rest of my experience there I am not chomping at the bit to return. It’s not a great place to work in server side infrastructure. At least not until some significant cultural shifts occur.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by positr0n on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:26PM (#22941792)
> I have a metric shit ton of Apple stock after being there for several years. At least until I hold the stock for a year and only pay capital gains on it.

Genuine question for anyone who gets RSUs at a public company like this. Why do you keep your $FANG stock when it is granted?

You've already paid income tax on the basis, which is the closing price the day you got it. The year long timer for long term capital gains tax starts the day you get it. So vesting $X of grants on your vesting day and holding is equivalent to just buying $X of stock on any old day. As a bonus, you're already heavily heavily exposed to that stock because A) they're your employer, and B) presumably unvested RSUs coming in the future.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by nine_k on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:21AM (#22942139)
It's not an equivalent of buying. It's an equivalent of receiving it and paying taxes on it immediately right with the stock, or with your cash if you so choose.

If your particular letter of FAANG currently outperforms the market ("S&P 500" index, etc), I see no incentive to immediately sell it and reinvest into something else. Of course you can sell and reinvest if you see an even better investment opportunity, but most of the employees don't, they are engineers, not experienced stock traders.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by positr0n on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:39AM (#22942251)
What's the difference that it is not equivalent to buying? Nothing is special tax-wise about those shares that they came from RSUs. If you got N shares at $X you've paid taxes on $X*N, she same if you bought those shares with cash in your bank account. If you wish to own extra stock in your employer you'd be better suited to dollar cost average and buy every paycheck.

> If [your company] currently outperforms the market

What does that mean? Outperforms over some past time period? That has no bearing on the future. If you have insider knowledge that you think your company will outperform the market in the future I agree it makes sense to keep, but see above about dollar cost averaging and also consult your lawyer about insider trading laws.

> most [don't], they are engineers, not experienced stock traders.

Exactly, and the standard advice for non-experts is to buy index funds. Not try and guess which specific companies will outperform the market.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by thawaway1837 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:35PM (#22940458)
There’s a lot of confidence there for lack of hiring blacklists when Google, Apple, etc are known to have shared hiring data with each other to underpay new hires.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by taywrobel on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:40PM (#22940487)
I've been involved with hiring in several companies accused of having "blacklists" or other shady hiring practices. The closest I have ever seen is recruiters or engineers recognizing problematic people from previous jobs and flagging that with the hiring manager. But there's no magic list they consult. Having such a thing even exist would be ripe for a heavy discrimination lawsuit if it ever saw the light of day.

Maybe I'm wrong and I'll be unemployed forever now that I had the apparent audacity to say this, but... yeah, I doubt it.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by kbenson on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:33PM (#22941130)
Maybe not quite what's being intended by this discussion, but definitely related to hiring blacklists in general (if for a different reason), were Google, Apple and Adobe agreeing not to hire some of each other's employees.[1]

1: https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-google-others-settle-anti-po...

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by jedberg on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:39PM (#22940483)
Telling them about systemic issues doesn't really get you a black mark, and maybe if they hear it from enough people they might fix it. So it's altruistic.

Obviously it's not a good idea to bad mouth individual people in your exit interview. The time for that was when you still worked there and could give it as candid feedback.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by jodrellblank on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:32PM (#22940432)
You're invited to a meeting, asked for your input on a work related matter, you're being paid to be there, it's part of your job because you haven't left yet. On what grounds would you reasonably refuse to answer? They already know you're unhappy enough to leave, if they're going to retaliate for that they already can.

> At best you get nothing from it

At best, other people can get something from it.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by pjmlp on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @04:08AM (#22943300)
Just as information, that seems to be a very US centric thing.

In Europe I have never done an exit interview, wasn't even aware that they are a thing if it wasn't for the occasional HN comments.

Naturally you might talk with someone informally, but isn't given.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by mratsim on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @09:05AM (#22945091)
I did have one, but I was working for an American company.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by ukd1 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:02PM (#22940254)
This. I presume it's hoping if enough do it, they'll be forced to change.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by cameronbrown on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:57PM (#22939775)
What's next? Banning unapproved use of maths? I mean, what if you invent the next million dollar equation without giving it to Apple... can't have that. Also, I guess if you're a hardware engineer... well, I guess you can't use your tools to fix your car anymore. Search engineer? No more regex's for you.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by m463 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:07PM (#22939864)
MIT math is ok, but GPLv3 math is a no-no.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by cameronbrown on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:28PM (#22940022)
Definitely wouldn't want to use viral licenses for maths, would we?
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by robenkleene on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:41AM (#22935935)
While I agree with you, I also find Joel Spolsky's blog post on the subject to be a thought provoking view of “side projects” from the employers' perspective https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2016/12/09/developers-side-pr...
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by SeanLuke on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:31PM (#22939536)
Right off the bat Joel makes what appears to be a very serious mistake regarding work for hire. His opening logic is as follows:

- When you hire a contract photographer to make some pictures, he owns the copyright on those pictures even though you hired him.

- The same goes for your programmer employees. They own the copyright on their work.

- Therefore you need to require your programmer employees to sign an agreement to sign their work over to you.

I am not a lawyer, but I'm pretty sure that's a gross misunderstanding of work for hire. If someone is your employee, they are doing work for hire and you own the copyright on their product. Photographers own their work because they were independent contractors and thus their work was not work for hire. I believe work for hire doesn't apply to patents, thus possibly justifying a patent agreement. But seriously, this (AFAIK) broken explanation is his opening justification?

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by Slartie on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:59PM (#22939792)
I don't know the exact legal situation in the US, but let me assure you, the described legal copyright situation is very much possible, because German copyright works exactly like that.

I am a software developer, so I write software. I am employed full-time by an employer for which I (usually) write code, documentation and such, and still I own the copyright to each and every line of code or documentation or whatever I write. Simply because copyright in German law is non-transferrable. Even if I want to, I cannot sign over the copyright to anybody else, hence my employer couldn't make me sign it over to him in my employment contract. Instead, there's a clause that I grant my employer an exclusive and irrevocable right to use the work I create during my paid work time in any way he wants. This effectively leaves me with the copyright, but I don't have any rights to profit off of that work anymore, so that copyright isn't of much use to me.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by LinaLauneBaer on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:49PM (#22940153)
You have every right to profit according to German law. You have to be compensated appropriately for your employer to be allowed to use what you hold the copyright for. Usually this is ensured by your monthly salary. However, if what you did and hold the copyright for becomes a surprise success you have to be compensated appropriately in addition to your salary. In practical terms, if your code makes a billion bucks and you only get a regular average salary you could sue the employer and would probably win.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by qayxc on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:12PM (#22940323)
> In practical terms, if your code makes a billion bucks and you only get a regular average salary you could sue the employer and would probably win.

I very much doubt that. Software isn't something that exists in a vacuum and even if you are the sole author of a program, it might contain or be based on trade secrets of the company.

Even if that's not the case, software doesn't generate profit on its own - you still need to sell licences or services based around it. Both of which are equally contributing to any profit a program generates.

Since it's still the employer who bears the entrepreneurial risk, there's a solid argument to be made against winning such a case.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by KillerDiller on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:52PM (#22940932)
So close and yet so far. You need to read section 69b of the German copyright code (§69b UrhG) asap.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by fragmede on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:56PM (#22940200)
> copyright in German law is non-transferrable. > I grant my employer an exclusive and irrevocable right to use the work

I am curious, what rights have you retained with your work then? What are the corner cases where you might you still want exercise your copyright?

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by Swizec on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:53PM (#22940577)
The way it works in slovenia and I imagine germany as well is that moral rights are nontransferrable. You always “own” your work. It’s the commercial copyright that you’re transferring.

In practical terms this means mostly boopkis.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_rights

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by bhaak on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:35PM (#22940455)
There is at least authorship.

If you wrote code, the company isn't allowed to claim someone else did.

But remember that gets very murky when you are working in a team.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by oh_sigh on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:30PM (#22940034)
Is there any observable difference between copyright being reassigned from employee to company vs copyright remaining with the individual but the company getting automatic exclusive and irrevocable use of the copyright?
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by droithomme on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:59PM (#22940223)
You have the right to be identified as the author of the work.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by ilamont on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:52PM (#22939716)
> When you hire a contract photographer to make some pictures, he owns the copyright on those pictures even though you hired him.

Depends on how the two parties set up the deal.

If you want the copyright or to change the license in some way that gives you (the publisher) more rights, the agreement will spell out those details and you could up spending more (maybe a lot more). I sometimes work with professional photographers and for pre-existing work I pay for a non-exclusive license that costs less than a commissioned piece. I also use stock photography extensively which works in a similar manner.

For commissioned photography or design work I'll insist on owning the copyright and the agreement will spell out that it's not work-for-hire:

To the extent that the Provider’s Work includes any work of authorship entitled to protection under the laws of copyright, the parties acknowledge and agree that (i) the Provider’s Work has been specially ordered and commissioned by Publisher as a contribution to a collective work, a supplementary work, a translation, or such other category of work as may be eligible for treatment as a “commissioned work” and a “work made for hire” under the United States Copyright Act; (ii) the Provider is an independent contractor and not an employee, partner, joint author or joint venturer of Publisher; (iii) the Provider’s ’s Work shall be deemed a “commissioned work” and a “work made for hire” to the greatest extent permitted by law; and (iv) Publisher shall be the sole author of the Provider’s Work and the Work, and the sole owner of original materials embodying Work and the Work, and/or any works derived therefrom.

Of course, the photographer or designer can opt to reject these terms, or make additional demands upon the publisher (more money, the right to use images in their own promotional materials, etc.)

Not sure how it works with independent contractors doing programming.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by greglindahl on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:24PM (#22941778)
... as mentioned above, in the US both programming employees and independent contractors doing programming usually sign a pre-employment agreement that makes all of this clear.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by paulclinger on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:36PM (#22939577)
I see Joel's point, but I'm not convinced it needs to be that broad. My (consulting) contract limits my IP rights assignment to "all IP right created in the course of providing services to or for the benefits of Company", which allows me to work on other projects, even though they may be related to Company's line of work (but not to my provided services).
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by strenholme on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:47PM (#22941542)
The supreme irony of Joel taking a hard line “we own everything you do 24/7/365 if you work for us, and forget about making open source software” stance is that he uses Nginx as his web server.

Nginx got in some legal issues because it started out as an employee’s side project: https://lwn.net/Articles/807324/

If Joel practiced what he preaches, and thinks no employees have a right to develop OSS software while on the company payroll, he needs to stop using nginx right now.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by city41 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:28PM (#22941806)
Did you read the whole article? I didn’t get the impression Joel took any stance. It felt more like “look this is how it is, and here’s why.”
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by strenholme on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:29AM (#22942185)
My impression is that he takes the stance that “I don’t just want to buy your 9:00-5:00 inventions. I want them all” (to quote the article verbatim).
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by aliceryhl on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @06:51AM (#22944214)
Joel put that phrase inside quotes and follows it up with

“This is where we are by default. This is the standard employment contract for developers, inventors, and researchers.”

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by mikestew on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:47PM (#22939674)
Thought-provoking, indeed:

"Before I start: be careful before taking legal advice from the Internet."

He got that much right, at least. I'm not going to argue every point, but as one with a broad range of experience on the topic I'd say there's enough wrong with that article to go find my advice somewhere else.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by senderista on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:52AM (#22935420)
It was the same at Amazon when I was there. You couldn't even work on your own game on your own time.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by Twirrim on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:07AM (#22935548)
It changed a bunch when I was there (2013-2016). You were allowed to when I joined, but you had to get permission and the process was a complete pain in the arse and took forever to navigate. By the time I left, you still had to get permission but the process was extremely quick and simple, as long as it wasn't on competing technology.

The one hard exception was game dev which remained a firm no-go, for reasons that never really made sense (Claim at the time was because Amazon had its own game studio?!)

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by mabbo on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:20PM (#22939446)
I'm still here. The process now is "don't ask, just read the policy and follow it in however you interpret it, but we'll sue you later if we disagree with your interpretation".
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by vkou on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:25PM (#22939491)
That's how Amazon handles non-competes as well. Are they going to enforce your non-compete? Who knows, just sign on the dotted line, and don't ask any questions.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by nefitty on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:53PM (#22939732)
I heard this from a Tim Ferriss guest, forgot who, but he said contractual agreements are really for when there are disagreements. I thought that was a novel way to think about them.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by Twirrim on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:53PM (#22940170)
Amazon seems to start taking legal action every year or so over non-competes, makes a splash in the tech press, and then comes to an agreement. I'm at least half convinced it's just to ensure the non-compete can't be argued to be null and void via failure to enforce.

IIRC the non-compete is pretty wide ranging from Amazon. Makes it almost impossible to get another tech job, depending on how you interpret certain phrases. Fun stuff.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by greglindahl on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:34PM (#22941833)
Have you considered moving to California? The economic benefit of states experimenting with laws is that you can choose what makes sense for you, instead of just accepting what's on offer in Seattle.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by mabbo on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @10:23AM (#22945866)
Not everyone at Amazon is in Seattle. Or even America. There's over 3000 of us in Canada right now, just on the tech side.

And honestly, given your political climate and attitudes towards immigrants, whew, no way, do not want to move to the USA.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by vkou on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:29PM (#22940028)
The problem is that you have no idea whether or not Amazon will find something in your behaviour to disagree with. And if they do, you have no idea whether it will be a reasonable disagreement.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by sbarre on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:36PM (#22940081)
Yeah that's true, but it's also important to have a solid mutual understanding of your arrangement up front, when all parties can be objective and (hopefully) fair-minded, as opposed to when there is an actual problem and everything is subjective and everyone is self-interested.

An old boss used to say "good friends make for good paperwork".

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by onion2k on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:20AM (#22935677)
(Claim at the time was because Amazon had its own game studio?!)

https://amazongames.com/ make games and a game engine called Lumberyard https://aws.amazon.com/lumberyard/ that's based on CryEngine.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by solarkraft on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:39PM (#22939604)
Sure. But why does that conflict with Amazon devs making their own games? If anything it seems like the engines could benefit from it.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by abj on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:58PM (#22939780)
Not defending Amazon, I'm an indie game dev who wants to own his off work hours side project. But Amazon Game Studios is releasing a game called "New World" this year. [1]

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_World_(video_game)

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by Rafuino on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:46PM (#22940897)
Amazon for sure has a game studio: https://amazongames.com/

They bought Twitch, they control a massive physical and digital distribution platform, and it's just a matter of time before they launch games that are exclusive to Prime/Twitch members. They literally control the whole pipeline. Yet another reason to break them up.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by falcolas on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:01AM (#22935498)
Being the status quo for technical companies doesn't make it legal, moral, or fair.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by aeonflux on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:09AM (#22935576)
But why is this not legal, moral or fair?
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by falcolas on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:16AM (#22935645)
Because it creates an unreasonable restriction on your life outside of work. Its somewhat unprecedented in the global market as well.

Proofreaders are not prohibited from reading books.

Concept Artists are not prohibited from creating art.

Writers are not prohibited from writing.

Teachers from teaching.

Workers from volunteering work.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by nemothekid on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:06PM (#22940280)
I feel like everyone is focusing on the wrong part of the Invention Assignment Agreement. The problem isn't that employers want to force you to not work on anything else (Apple might). The problem is, if you go home, and work on a work related problem, who owns that work.

The obtuse case is I work for your company as the lead engineer making TVs. All the TVs can't display blue. I then go home have an epiphany, and develop a method for making TVs blue. We fix the problem and call it day. Later still, I leave the company and sue you for infringement because I technically came up with the solution outside of work and therefore I own that code. This is the situation most companies are trying to avoid.

If you solve this problem without having the company own everything the programmer does in and out of work, then you can have stricter walls between work and home projects.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by jedberg on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:54PM (#22940579)
> Writers are not prohibited from writing.

Most are actually. If you're employed as a writer, you can't just go and write what you want without permission from your employer. They usually get the right of first refusal, meaning that you have to show it to them first and if they want to publish it then they get to do so.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by egypturnash on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:27PM (#22940010)
Most big animation studios have contracts that say “we own everything you draw while you work for us”. Or at least they did when I was in the industry around the turn of the century.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by bigiain on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:54PM (#22941577)
A friend of mine had to put his PhD on hold when his company was acquired by Oracle, who tried to force him into signing "their standard employment contract" which effectively granted them ownership to everything he thought while employed by them.

It took 3 or 4 months and 5 or 6 levels of management above his new boss before getting "an extraordinary one-off exemption" to allow him to finish thinking/writing his thesis and allow the university to publish it (as required by the terms of completing the PhD...)

Everyone was _pretty_ sure that would have been unenforceable here in Australia - but that there's a serious practical difference between what is and isn't enforceable in contracts, and going up against Oracle's legal team even when they're on the wrong side of the law. So he just "stopped thinking" for several months until he (temporarily) had written permission to think non-Oracle thoughts...

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by jariel on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:28PM (#22940021)
It's definitely not an unreasonable restriction for most, and those who don't like the policy don't have to work there.

Your examples aren't helpful because the don't address the issue, which is risk.

In the examples provided there's really nothing about the 'personal work' that puts the employers position at risk. Which is why, by the way, schools don't generally defy teachers from teaching on the side. Or proofreaders etc..

In fact such limitations are rare outside industries with IP issues.

Apple is a $1T company and all of that valuation is up for grabs by litigious people of various kinds who can use any kind of side-show tactic interpretation of the law to make money.

So imagine someone 'working from home' on the 'same computer' that they use for work. What counts as 'work time' vs. 'personal time' when flipping back and forth between activities?

How will a judge view this?

Then you have competitive problems: you work on 'iMovie' for 1 hour, then you work on 'MyMovie' (personal) the hour. This creates ugly conflicts of interest.

Then you have liability issues if Apple is seen to be contributing to an OSS without the right legal bits in place. It doesn't matter that it 'shouldn't' be a problem, what matters is that a bad actor + a lawyer can possibly make enough of a fuss to convince a judge that there's a problem 'Apple's contribution to this OSS code materially affected my business and it was no clear in the liscencing' etc..

As we've seen with Google/Uber, this stuff is very expensive, very strategic, can be very ambiguous, which is bad.

There's so much grey in the equation, and so much at risk, it's simply not worth it for Apple and Amazon.

So if you want to work there, that's it, you can't make games.

It'd be nice if there were some kind of regulatory issues around it, but it'd have to be clear.

I also think they should be nice enough to 'wave' people's rights to do certain things, like work on specific OSS projects.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by aeonflux on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:24AM (#22935722)
As I pointed in other comment - restrictions on life outside work are common and reasonable. Most people can't work competitors after work.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by patcon on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:44AM (#22935977)
It seems odd to consider "the commons" as a competitor... feels petty, like: "If we can't have it, then you can't even gift it to the human collective."
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by ac29 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @02:13PM (#22937669)
> Most people can't work competitors after work.

Non-compete clauses "are automatically void as a matter of law in California" [0], where Apple is based (though they have offices in other states and countries). I wonder if a ban on open source contributions would fall afoul of this law (I suspect yes, though Apple can afford pretty good lawyers).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-compete_clause#California

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by BossingAround on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @02:43PM (#22938022)
How is that fair? Apple pays me for 8h a day, why can't I work another 4h a day for Google if I choose to do so?

Now, disclosing secrets, that's a different matter. If I go to Google to inform them of amazing killer project Apple wants to do within 5 years, that's called corporate espionage.

No reason why I couldn't work for multiple companies though. In fact, I don't even see a reason why I should even tell these companies I work for multiple companies.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by nostrademons on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:41PM (#22940109)
> Apple pays me for 8h a day, why can't I work another 4h a day for Google if I choose to do so?

I've heard of someone that did this. Held two full-time jobs at different software companies. It wasn't Apple and Google, IIRC it was something like Oracle and Nvidia or Oracle and Salesforce.

He was fired from both when they found out and presumably blacklisted from being rehired, but other than that there weren't repercussions. It's not worth it to sue an individual engineer, and for many of the clauses in your employment agreement, their remedy is limited to firing you. He did it for a few years, too, and banked up a bunch of money doing so.

One thing that surprises a lot of people who were raised to follow the rules: you have a lot of freedom if you're willing to deal with the consequences. Some people are afraid to question their boss because they're worried about losing their job; others will steal all of their employers' self-driving car plans for $680M, risking $180M in fines and possible jail time in the process. You get to decide where on the risk/reward continuum you want to sit.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by umvi on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @02:55PM (#22938139)
> Apple pays me for 8h a day, why can't I work another 4h a day for Google if I choose to do so?

You can, if you are being paid by the hour. But you probably aren't being paid by the hour, you are probably collecting an annual salary which means you might be expected to work 8-10 hours per day, not work for other companies, and other restrictions.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by BossingAround on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @03:02PM (#22938205)
Even though my contract states yearly salary, that salary is calculated by $hourly_rate * 8 * $number_of_work_days_in_year. That's specifically stated.

My contract also specifically states that I agree to work 40 hours a week.

Maybe this is not the case in a typical US employment contract?

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by grumple on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:15PM (#22939402)
US contracts usually don't explicitly list policies like this. From my perspective, this means they can't hold you to anything, although the average person seems to think it means the company can do whatever they want. Either way, I'm pretty clear about my relationship with my employer - if you start asking me to do things, and I don't want to do them, I won't. They can decide if they want to live with that arrangement or not.

Some of us outside CA do sign non-compete agreements, though, which is another matter entirely.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by jfim on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:54PM (#22939740)
> No reason why I couldn't work for multiple companies though.

Many the employment contracts have a "no moonlighting" clause, which basically says that one won't be working for another employer during the employment period.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by zaphirplane on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:18PM (#22940363)
Chairman of google did that for a while
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by DonHopkins on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @05:03PM (#22939308)
Next thing ya know they'll prohibit their employees from playing Factorio, because it's too much like programming.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by wlll on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:01AM (#22935501)
Is that even legal? In my mind, if you want to dictate what I do in my non-work time, you pay me for the time.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by bcaa7f3a8bbc on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:26AM (#22935751)
By default it's not. However, if you join FAANG, chances are that you'll be required to sign a contract that basically says "I waive my rights of doing side-projects to to the greatest possible extents under the laws of California". When speaking of contributing to open source, Google generally has a more positive image, but there are still occasions that something could only be released after being reviewed by the legal department if it's work-related. On the other hand, Apple is known to have strict restrictions.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by aeonflux on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:08AM (#22935559)
Almost every company tries to force non-competition clauses in agreements. Even if they let one do side gigs, one can't work for competitor. This does sound reasonable and yet is a limitation on what you can do in your spare time.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by jodrellblank on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:46PM (#22940530)
Is it legal for something to be unfair against normal humans and in the favour of big companies? Tech companies spend 500,000 times your annual salary[1] lobbying the government each year, and you and I don't.

[1] $64Bn in 2018 - https://duckduckgo.com/?q=tech+company+lobbying

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by cosmotic on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:06PM (#22939856)
In some states, it is not legal for employers to take ownership of employees work off hours using their own equipment. Most employers still sneak these into their employment agreements even though they can't be enforced.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by non-entity on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:04AM (#22935524)
I cant say for sure, but I'd imagine so. As long as what you are doing isn't protected by some law, I imagine a company can discipline / fire you for whatever they please.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by saagarjha on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:29AM (#22935775)
Yes, due to certain provisions in California Labor Code which allow for curtailing what you can do in fields that compete with your employer (in a large company, this generally means anything could fall under this).
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by outside1234 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:57PM (#22940201)
Especially since, under California law, what you do with your personal time on personal hardware is yours, regardless of employment contract.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by larkost on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:14PM (#22940333)
Citation needed. That is not Apple's lawyers' opinion. It is also not the interpretation of this San Jose law firm:

https://www.sacattorneys.com/san-jose-intellectual-property-...

The relevant quote is: "It is legal to require an employee to assign intellectual property created in the employee’s own time if it required any of the employer’s tools, facilities, or intellectual property, or if that intellectual property relates to the employer’s business or research and development."

Since Apple operates in a wide swath of the IT world, it is very likely that most OSS developed by Apple employees could reasonably be considered "relate[d] to the employer's business". That is certainly the position that Apple takes in most case (source: I am a former Apple employee).

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by mgomez on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:17PM (#22940720)
I believe the person you're replying to was referring to section 2870 from the California Labor Code: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...

"(a) Any provision in an employment agreement which provides that an employee shall assign, or offer to assign, any of his or her rights in an invention to his or her employer shall not apply to an invention that the employee developed entirely on his or her own time without using the employer’s equipment, supplies, facilities, or trade secret information except for those inventions that either:

(1) Relate at the time of conception or reduction to practice of the invention to the employer’s business, or actual or demonstrably anticipated research or development of the employer; or

(2) Result from any work performed by the employee for the employer.

(b) To the extent a provision in an employment agreement purports to require an employee to assign an invention otherwise excluded from being required to be assigned under subdivision (a), the provision is against the public policy of this state and is unenforceable."

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by wahern on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:00PM (#22941270)
> Relate... to the employer’s business

This is the catch-all and I've always been curious what the seminal cases are which apply this language. For example, the charter for most corporations these days usually establishes the business for "any lawful activity", so if the scope of an employer's business is defined by the charter, then pretty much any commercially viable FOSS project could potentially be ensnared by an employer. Any IP lawyers here have some pointers to how "employer's business" is supposed to be interpreted and applied?

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by User23 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:08PM (#22941303)
Yeah, if Judge Alsup got the case it might get a very different ruling than another judge.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by esmi on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:42PM (#22940504)
Apple is in many states and countries. It’s way simpler to say no then try to manage it on a case by case basis for 1000s of engineers.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by greglindahl on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:31PM (#22941815)
Other big companies, like IBM, seem to do OK with OSS contributions by employees.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by esmi on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:09AM (#22946350)
Let me digress with a little story about one of my experiences with courts. In the 90s I was a technician at a small computer shop in CA. One day we had a sale for really cheap beige boxes so that we could offload some excesses inventory. A customer came in and want to buy all 10 of them. But I knew he owned a local warehouse and I suspected that he wanted these 10 computers to run proprietary inventory tracking software, and because some of our other clients ran that same software, I asked him if that’s what he wanted them for. He said yes. I told him these boxes won’t work with that software because their chipset is incompatible with it. He will have to buy these other, more expensive, ones. He insisted I was wrong. I showed him some documents we had, as I had ran into this before, he insisted anyway, very rudely. I told him if we sold them I wouldn’t allow a return. He said fine and bought all 10 and I wrote in hand “no refund” on the receipt. I was a teenager then so I thought this was “iron clad” and complimented myself for being so smart. A year later the guy came back and wanted to return all 10. We of course said no. He took us to small claims court and won. We were forced to give a full refund, at the one year old price, even though he admitted to the judge I warned him, showed him documents, and said no refund. His counter argument: he didn’t understand. The judge said this was the best way to make both parties whole again.

I lost but learned a valuable lesson, one just never knows with the law. These things are where one starts argument, it’s not where they stop.

Lawyers will have to decide how comfortable they are with the risk, and balance it against the reward. It’s totally natural that different entities will come to different conclusions in this environment.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by birdyrooster on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:25PM (#22941098)
What if they pay for your business class internet that you use to develop that software?
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by winter_blue on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:18AM (#22942470)
This policy is so ludicrous and morally offensive, that I would just willfully break it, and if they find out, throw a party to celebrate them firing me (for contributing to OSS projects).

Imagine you use KDE, and find a bug, and make a small PR with a patch for it. I can't even begin to fathom how a company can while being fair/just say that you're not allowed to do so (without "our approval" which could take months).

It's ridiculous beyond measure, and we should make it a goal to purposely get fired for doing OSS, and then also make sure to post about it online as much as possible so it draws a lot of attention, and hopefully results in a change in this.

After all, it's probably a piece of cake to land a new job (once the COVID crisis is over), if you have a Big N company on your resume, even if you were fired from it (not that you'd want to preemptively disclose that - unless you went public with it - which some folks might even see as a positive).

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by m463 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:06PM (#22939861)
Apple engineers are prohibited from eating lunch with friends at other companies in the valley (because of the things you have to sign to get a visitor badge for lunch)
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by chipotle_coyote on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @07:00PM (#22940240)
Uh, I've eaten lunch with Apple engineers at One Infinite Loop, and I worked at another company in the valley at the time. I have also eaten lunch with Apple engineers when they came to visit other companies in the Valley, and have even eaten lunch with Apple engineers at restaurants that weren't at other companies.

Off-topic: remember eating lunch at restaurants?

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by m463 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:29PM (#22940793)
> remember eating lunch at restaurants?

I understood this one way at first, then I got quiet. Our world is really different.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by ghostpepper on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:20PM (#22939953)
As someone who works at a company that provides no free lunch / on site cafeteria, this does not seem so draconian. You can just see your friends at a restaurant?
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by jjtheblunt on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:47PM (#22940134)
Since when, and says who?

My grad school friend(s) at Google visited Apple, and I visited elsewhere similarly, when working at Apple HQ. Not scandalous in the least.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by m463 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:19PM (#22940733)
I have a friend at apple, who cannot eat lunch at companies that require you to sign an NDA to get a visitor badge.

There are many companies that have this setup.

It could be his level of employment. Or it might be that it doesn't apply to all apple employees, or they don't know, or they don't bother.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by jjtheblunt on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @11:58AM (#22946952)
That could be.

Eating lunch at Caffe Mac was just print a visitor badge and walk across the quad with visitor.

Maybe some campuses require transiting team-specific lockdowns, but Infinite Loop for lunch did not.

Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by thrwn_frthr_awy on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:27PM (#22941419)
This is not true.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by pacamara619 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @05:07AM (#22943587)
Isn't it illegal for Apple to tell employees what to do in their personal time?
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by Rochus on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:05AM (#22935529)
Their secret police will still come after you, even if you change jobs.
Re:Apple engineer in need of OSS maintainers by Igelau on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:14PM (#22939915)
> if I worked for Apple I'd immediately start looking elsewhere for a job

Ooh that's a good one. I nearly snarfed my Pepsi.