The IFR represents how many of those who got it and ended up dead (regardless of whether their case was tested, diagnosed or confirmed). It doesn't represent the whole population.
The same study estimated 60-80% of people could eventually contract the disease. 70% * 0.66% = 0.46% mortality rate from the disease. This would equate to about 35 million people globally. (70% infection rate is not going to happen overnight and I would hope that one way or another fewer people get infected than this - on the Diamond Princess where they tested nearly everyone, only about 25% of passengers got infected - but we will see.)
It's important to understand the definitions of all the terms involved. A misunderstanding of the statistics has resulted in panic -- people see a 5% death rate from a specific group of confirmed cases and assume that translates to their demographic, or overall population etc. when it does not.
The mortality rate is the percentage of the total population that dies. The infection fatality rate is the percentage of all cases, diagnosed or undiagnosed. The case fatality rate is the percentage of diagnosed cases. [2]
Not saying it's not a serious disease, 35 million deaths is many many times more than the flu. But we aren't going to lose 1% of humanity to this disease. And personally I would advocate for a smart and measured response like we've seen in South Korea or Taiwan over a panicked and destructive response like we are seeing in the US and UK.
[1] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3...
No one wants to have to think about these numbers, but if you're responsible for making policy, it's very important to have good estimates of how many lives your policy will save and how many it will ruin. If you don't you're just reacting to the latest panic in the news cycle as sadly far too many politicians do.
Data matters, facts matter.
You're talking about a difference between a massive number of people dying, and a massive number divided by two dying, and then arguing that a massive number divided by two is not nearly as serious.
Nobody knows what the true numbers will be, but only the rough range they'll be in, so arguing over a factor of two is meaningless. These are terrifying numbers either way.
> If you don't you're just reacting to the latest panic in the news cycle as sadly far too many politicians do.
The "panic" is caused by people finally listening to what epidemiologists have been saying for months. False calm has been far more damaging on this pandemic than panic. If politicians had listened to the panic mongers earlier, the world wouldn't be in this situation.
Unfortunately, the short-sighted rush to reopen everything too quickly, or not to shut it down in the first place, is undermining these efforts. The shutdown worked in China, where it was strictly observed and enforced for several weeks. I hope the US can do the same.
IMF poverty line is < $1.90 a day so surely many of them will die from malnutrition or preventable disease as well.
Edit: it was Oxfam that published the report to inform the IMF and World Bank at their meeting next week
It's a relevant perspective, but I can't seem to find any source for IMF claiming that. Do you have one or are you referring to research publicized by Oxfam[1]?
The average COVID-19 death in Italy is 78 years old and sick.
The average hunger death is going to be young, otherwise healthy, and in the developing world (likely somewhere in sub-saharan Africa).
You can draw your own measures, but I would not personally weight these lives saved equally. I would personally throw several 78 year olds under the COVID-bus to save the life of one young child. I think most people would draw similar lines.
> The first thing that jumps out from the medical history section of Table 1 is that 93% of those critically ill with COVID-19 were “able to live without assistance in daily activities” prior to developing the disease. That typically suggests reasonable health. 3/8
> Secondly, just 7% of 2,124 intensive care admissions had “very severe comorbidities”. That’s significantly less than typical viral pneumonia patients (as illustrated in table 1)
> So 19 out of 20 were free of the most severe life-limiting conditions. 4/8
> Lastly, for now, the age distribution. Most critical cases are aged between 50 and 80.
> People of this age, without severe comorbidities, could reasonably have expected to have years of life ahead of them before they contracted this disease. 5/8
Not making any comments on the rest of your points, but I have to heavily disagree with this one. Sure, people who have cardiovascular and heart issues, diabetes, asthma, etc. are all "able to live without assistance in daily activities". That doesn't suggest reasonable health to me at all, it just tells me that they are able to live their lives without a caretaker by their side.
And data from Italy suggests that over 99% of the people who died from COVID had existing conditions like those[0].
0. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-18/99-of-tho...
They need to be intentional choices, with an understanding of the costs, where the costs are often paid by people we don't see or frequently think about.
The visualization at https://91-divoc.com/pages/covid-visualization/ is IMHO the clearest to explore this stuff. It's based on the Johns Hopkins data set, which is relatively well curated.
Separately Sweden is also a country with an extensive social safety net, where every citizen has the right to free healthcare and every employee will receive 80% of their salary for two weeks without a doctor's note at no cost for the employer[2].
Time will tell if the Swedish approach was the right one and even if so the Swedish case will end up being dependant on rather unique constraints that simply will not map to the US, at least not on a national level.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Amendment_to_the_United... [2] https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=1130&langId=en&in...
Most people are infected with some form of Herpes virus AIUI, from Chickenpox to Cold Sores, it's very common.
One ironic downside of “flattening the curve” is that it makes it longer. So, barring a vaccine or effective therapeutic treatment, we will all get the virus eventually (but in an orderly fashion, which is good for the health system), and that 75 million deaths will become a reality. Note that’s also assuming a 1% death rate which may be a vast overestimate depending on asymptomatic percentages.
That said, I tend to agree with you that we should keep social distancing in place until we are able to contain new cases, or until we have a much better understanding of the virus itself. At this point there is just too much uncertainty, so it’s better to wait it out until we can establish some clarity and have a better idea of how to approach therapeutics.
Source for this? That sounds like a shockingly high number if true.
https://www.sfgate.com/news/medical/article/Some-doctors-mov...
https://www.evms.edu/covid-19/medical_information_resources/...
https://thehill.com/changing-america/resilience/smart-cities...
https://news.slashdot.org/story/20/03/15/2024248/will-corona...
The fallout from letting the virus run its course is way beyond taking the current rates and extrapolating to the entire worldwide population.
That really shows you the scale.
Also some studies from Africa showed that economic downturns reliably predict wars.
I can't imagine that 500k people got cancer from 2008, and if they had cancer they may have already been approaching death.
Numbers like that seem extremely suspect because they can be spun however you like by assuming how things would have been.
Then, it's not about lives, it's about years of life lost. The average age of the deaths is >80 in Italy, close to that in WA (median is >80, not sure about the average). In years of life lost, one boy who was shot while the lockdown was being enforced in Kenya (iirc) is "worth" on the order of 10-20 average COVID dead (even if you don't weight earlier years of life heavier, which I would). A 30-year-old committing suicide in isolation in the US (acquaintance of a friend) is worth close to that.
Then, if you want a real example of loss of life from a major economic crisis, look at life expectancy in Russia between 1980-2000, or birth rates during the same and GD.
Finally, I would also argue having experienced the former that for (low) 100s of millions of people in ex-USSR, you have to count the 90ies as years at least partially lost, because they were spent in survival mode with giant loss of time and human potential. Personally I'd rather live a good life and die at 80 than throw away my e.g. 30ies working two jobs and trying to find where I can buy cheaper pasta, and live till 85.
Everyone dies. All of humanity does not exist for most of the age of the universe, to say nothing of individuals. That's a trite thing to say but it is no less true. Not everyone gets to live a good life, even fewer in situations like this.
Our DNA wants to stay alive, the existential dread is understandable, but culturally I think we'd be a lot healthier if we put more value in quality of lives than the preservation of them. Now balancing this is not easy and I'm not saying in our current situation we should just lift all measures, but if framed that way the conversation starts to take on a different tone than just looking at potential death rates as the overall guiding function.
And the population of the Earth could handle that without a blip, particularly as it is concentrated in the groups with the least economic contribution.
This is meme by this point but: it's possible that uncertainty has already been priced in by the markets. I don't think any trader actually thinks the infection rate is exactly what the official numbers are.
Why would anyone even consider the course of action you are proposing?
I've already had people close to me die. You should think some more and be able to provide a reasoned argument or be quiet until you can on this.
The whole "masks don't work" line being pushed by the US government and the media seems to be about keeping people from buying masks that are needed in the hospitals. In the process they are sort of lying to people about the effectiveness of mask wearing as a piece of overall strategy.
I actually don’t think this is correct, it’s a reasonable assumption but actually the “masks don’t work” has been accepted Western medical dogma for decades. They were giving the same advice years ago even in times of no mask shortage - to only wear a mask when you know you are sick or if you are a care provider. See, for instance, a roundup of research and previous advice here. https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/23/face-masks-much-more-t...
I think the main thing that made CDC turn around now was that the number of asymptomatic or very-mild symptomatic patients with COVID-19 who are spreading the disease during the initial infection when they don’t know they are symptomatic really makes the advice to not wear a mask unless you are sick not make sense since you don’t know when you are sick until it’s too late...
NIH has a study on their website that says basic surgical masks are roughly equivalent in protection or N95's in practical real word settings when respiratory illness is involved. [0]
There is also supposedly a huge supply of the Chinese N95 standard equivalent "KN95" masks available. They are said to be made in the same way but the factories that make them haven't gotten regulatory approval from the US Government.
Why not import KN95's and give them out to the public since healthcare can't / won't use them.
This sort of misdirected conversation will kill people. Please stop it. It is highly irresponsible.
If you disagree please cite a credible source.
Please do not include anything relating to any of Trump's briefing as those are all discredited and fake news.
[0] https://www.cdc.gov/quarantine/air/managing-sick-travelers/c...
Compare NYC and Taipai public transit during virus it's stark:
https://i.redd.it/ufezdm2hjul41.jpg
https://www.thenation.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/commute...
That has certainly not been true of China, S.Korea, NZ, Germany, Australia or other countries that have successfully followed a suppression strategy.
Taiwan has similar population as Australia, is higher density than Sydney AUS, and has a fraction of the cases and deaths. They didn't close everything down they did targeted tracking/testing and isolation of individuals, mandatory masks on transit, fever checks in public etc.
I don't know Taiwan's details but it sounds like they followed a test and trace strategy which is vastly different.
Thanks for clarifying.
In this context about anything in particular?
I'm not going to pretend to be innocent here. It doesn't take an expert in infectious diseases or economics to at least prepare themselves and their family. There are also decisions that we make collectively, though not institutionally, that are dubious. Some people are lucky in that their role in society is important enough that they are valuable in this crisis. Others will more-or-less have their value to society restored as soon as this is over. Then there are the people who's social value depends upon economic prosperity. Those people are going to be hit the hardest.
Then there are the institutional decisions. Some of those are the craziest. Organizations to handle domestic violence, homelessness, mental illness, etc. were scraping by in good times. Transient labor is not an issue in itself, reliance upon it is. While I'm guessing that your reference to transient labor refers to seasonal foreign workers from the context, something similar has been created in local job markets. Many people are working several jobs simply to make ends meet. They cannot provide their own safety net in the case of any crisis (personal, national, or global). In the worse of cases, they are providing a vector for the spread of disease (e.g. hospital and nursing home employees working at several facilities).
On top of all of that, we have the government. I'm not talking about politicians here. They are certainly part of the problem when the don't listen to their own experts, undermine them, or simply get rid of those they don't agree with. I am talking about the civil service. These are the people who provide continuity and should be doing comprehensive planning for different scenarios. (Not to mention ensuring that government services can handle emergencies.) What I have been seeing are a slew of half baked solutions that reflect politician's distorted world view that are, at best, addressed after reality is exposed to them.
My apologies for the rant. Part of the reason for it is that I think the wealthier nations will pull through this, but we could have done a lot better if we went into it prepared.
Is there any evidence that this could happen? I live in a small Northern European country and there have been absolutely no shortages of TP or food items here. Even at peak toilet paper demand, when I went to the supermarket one brand was sold out, but there were plenty of other brands available - the same happens if they have a promotion, so maybe it was just a coincidence.
It seems that most of these issues are caused by supply chain problems, not a lack of available food, and the bigger a country, the harder the impact is felt.
A lot of the common produce items are grown locally, it's mostly out-of-season (tomatoes) and more exotic fruits (mandarins, avocados) that are shipped from the other side of Europe or Africa. Almost all meat, dairy and grain items are produced locally. If we were only able to eat food grown within our country, I don't think we would be faced with mass starvation.
https://www.concernusa.org/story/worlds-ten-hungriest-countr...
Industrialized countries will have sufficient food for a while, but if major sectors of the economy are shut down for months then supply chains will break down and we'll start to see empty grocery shelves.
What we fundamentally got wrong is that ventilators don't work in 66% - 90% of cases, so "flattening the curve" was largely pointless and distracted leaders from low-tech solutions like quarantine centers and palliative care.
We should have learned that in 2002 from SARS-1, but nobody even seems to remember it.
Use of ventilators coincides with severe cases, and up until this point we haven't learned enough about curing those infected with this virus to recover all such cases.
Why are you assuming the ventilator recovery rate is static?
We should assume that by "flattening the curve", we've bought valuable time to learn more about this virus, getting closer to better methods of recovery.
Ventilators will always play a role in keeping patients alive who've deteriorated to the point of requiring them.
I don't think anyone had the impression that ventilators cured anything, which your phrasing of "ventilators don't work" seems to imply.
No they don't. After a few weeks your lungs turn to mush, among other problems.
And just letting hundreds of thousands of people die alone, on the streets or in the homes and with no proper burial or funeral is not something people will tolerate. It would be like dropping everyone in the middle of a war zone.
>What we fundamentally got wrong is that ventilators don't work in 66% - 90% of cases
[0]: https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/04/02/8261052...
I'm still waiting for an interview with a ventilator survivor. None so far.
https://www.sfgate.com/news/medical/article/Some-doctors-mov...
It's far from pointless.
Flattening the curve means a lot fewer people get sick all at once. That buys time for treatments and vaccines to be developed.
It's also not nearly as overwhelming to the health care system.
A lockdown until we develop a vaccine is economically impossible, as it's estimated to take at least a year. A vaccine will be useful for next year's coronavirus.
Thankfully the actual death rate is lower than what the models projected. Antibody testing will do a lot to dispel the fog of war surrounding this issue.
If we were to end the lockdown now there would be way more infections and deaths in the short-term then there would be otherwise.
Some deaths may happen anyway due to economic hardship, or social unrest, but the deaths from infections in the short-term are going to be greatly reduced, and even in the long term, the longer the lockdown can be sustained the fewer deaths from infection there are going to be.
In the meantime, the government really has to step up to the plate and come up with solutions to the economic problems, which (unlike the pandemic) are under human control.
I'm not suggesting we throw up our hands and attend tightly packed concerts.
I'm suggesting we stop pushing for an R value of 0, and instead deliberate what the least costly options are (both economicly and in human life) keeping the R value under 1.
We might not be conciously pushing for an R value of 0, but it appears that way.
We won't. US case load stopped growing about 5 days ago because of the mitigation effort. Prior to that, it was doubling every 3-4 days. So just in the immediately verifiable present, there are 2-3 thousand people alive today in the US who wouldn't have been had we not locked down.
That's just today. Let the virus run rampant and you get to the doomsday scenarios that everyone likes to scream about.
The point is that the mitigations are working, and because they are working we have a good measure of how much worse the pandemic could be. And it could be really, really bad.
If you have a better plan, it needs to be proposed and justified. But "let's not do this because of other causes of death" doesn't work, numerically.
Consensus from almost all countries is that you need to quarantine and shut down the economy in order to beat this. Those that believed that they could get around this with herd immunity are either paying a huge price (UK) or about to (Sweden).
And those politicians that took hard measures actually have been rewarded (Australia) and those that didn't punished (UK, US).
It’s too late now for countries that have allowed the coronavirus to run wild for months and spread throughout their society to emulate that.
Vietnam is another success story as well I think - 255 cases, 0 deaths.
This is definitely the ideal model to follow which is to prevent the disease from rooting itself within your borders, allowing the economy and society to continue as normal.
Once you have wide-spread community transmission as Western countries do, emulating this approach becomes difficult... I believe the lockdowns are an attempt to effectively reset the state back to a lower number of active cases so that a South Korea style containment of the disease could be attempted.
eg. Restarting factory production probably worth it soon, large sports events not.
A big problem with this is there are so many unknowns - will there be effective treatment, a vaccine and so on.
2. It's questionable whether we can become immune to it. We might keep getting re-infected.
3. It causes permanent lung damage in some patients. Makes re-infection even more lethal.
4. There's a chance that animals can catch it and become a reservoir for it. Imagine if every dog, cat, and pigeon in the world is infected with it, but doesn't die from it.
Yes, it's low probability. But it's not zero. And it's not negligible either.
A is an unknown variable that equals the what amount of a day people consider as "lost" as a result of mandated lockdown. IE, if everyone considers each day they spend not able to go about their business as a day of their life completely lost than A would equal 1. I suppose some people could consider the cost of a day lost to mandated quarantine as greater than 1.
Anyway, by my calculations based on a US life expectancy of 77.5yrs (28,287.5 days) and a US population of 330 million then that puts the lifetimes lost per day at 11,666. Note, that's lifetimes lost. IE, as if 11,666 babies were born each day, but instead of living the their full life expectancy they all immediately died.
edit: Markdown ate my asterisk symbol and \ doesn't work as an escape character apparently? Changed asterisks to x and the x variable to A.
At least then the problem would sort itself out.
I'm not even saying let up on all the social distancing measures. I think social distancing measures are good, but perhaps over the top. Nowhere have I seen a discussion of where to stop with the measures because of diminishing returns and increasingly negative economic (and indirect human life loss) impact.