Consensus from almost all countries is that you need to quarantine and shut down the economy in order to beat this. Those that believed that they could get around this with herd immunity are either paying a huge price (UK) or about to (Sweden).
And those politicians that took hard measures actually have been rewarded (Australia) and those that didn't punished (UK, US).
It’s too late now for countries that have allowed the coronavirus to run wild for months and spread throughout their society to emulate that.
Vietnam is another success story as well I think - 255 cases, 0 deaths.
This is definitely the ideal model to follow which is to prevent the disease from rooting itself within your borders, allowing the economy and society to continue as normal.
Once you have wide-spread community transmission as Western countries do, emulating this approach becomes difficult... I believe the lockdowns are an attempt to effectively reset the state back to a lower number of active cases so that a South Korea style containment of the disease could be attempted.