News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by somehnguy on Thursday March 26, 2020 @02:04PM (#22696189)
Wouldn't it ship faster if you just plopped in any regular ol HDD the company makes (the cheapest one, probably) instead of developing a custom one just for that product?
Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by rpcope1 on Thursday March 26, 2020 @02:55PM (#22696650)
If you're trying to bring a new drive to market (and even for many capacities, they get refreshed regularly if only to cut platters or find new ways to cut costs), and your firmware isn't ready for prime time as an internal drive, you can still ship it as an external drive earlier because you have a good idea of how the controller is going to treat the drive. Not only do the external drives tend to be the end of the waterfall in terms of quality, manufacturers also may ship with firmware problems that would be a stop ship if it was packaged for nearline or desktop.

Don't ask me how I know this.

Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by themaninthedark on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:39PM (#22697748)
And then consumers use external drives as a backup method...
Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by rpcope1 on Friday March 27, 2020 @01:24PM (#22704821)
Yes, if there's a take away for me, having seen how the sausage is made, it's far and above worth grabbing as NAS or nearline SATA drive and jamming it in a good SATA enclosure instead of buying a drive that's already in an enclosure if you want peace of mind.
Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by ipython on Thursday March 26, 2020 @06:39PM (#22698701)
Didn’t backblaze do exactly this (shuck drives from external enclosures) when they couldn’t buy enough drives on the open market after the tsunami?
Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by pilsetnieks on Thursday March 26, 2020 @09:12PM (#22699641)
And they themselves said that it's not a good idea, it simply was a time of desperation. They're not shucking externals now, now that proper drives are available.

Also they have a lot more tolerance for disk failure than almost anyone.

Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by chx on Thursday March 26, 2020 @09:10PM (#22699635)
They did but with 3.5" drives which were not USB specific. This is done to save space and noone cares for space with a 3.5" drive. If you ship with a converter board it is impossible to make it this small.
Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by muro on Thursday March 26, 2020 @03:15PM (#22696862)
I was always wondering how external drives can be cheaper than internal. This explains. Thank you.
Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by gambiting on Thursday March 26, 2020 @03:19PM (#22696907)
Yeah, and massively cheaper too. I bought a 5TB passport drive for £71 recently, an equivalent capacity desktop drive would be at least £200. The price disparity is insane.
Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by withinboredom on Thursday March 26, 2020 @02:38PM (#22696491)
In reality, it is probably exactly that. These are the drives that didn't make the cut to be sold independently.
Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by somehnguy on Thursday March 26, 2020 @02:44PM (#22696552)
Yeah pretty common thing across all industries. I would expect things like maybe the vibration is slightly out of normal spec, or an abnormal amount of bad sectors on a fresh unit.

But I don't understand how them maybe not being top quality would make part of the SCSI protocol disappear in the firmware. That indicates that these drives had a different firmware developed for them with missing features which makes no sense.

Re:WD Passport 4TB drives don't support WRITE SAME command by jamiek88 on Thursday March 26, 2020 @03:59PM (#22697314)
What you are missing is that WD Passports are 2.5 inch drives that are USB-only. The drive controller speaks USB directly, as opposed to SATA chained to a translator chip on a separate board.

They implement certain parts not pass through and do indeed have separate USB firmware.