News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by georgeecollins on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:46PM (#22541306)
Leaving aside (and I know this hard) the controversy of Tesla's valuation, Elon Musk and the environmental virtues of electric cars, think what a historic success Tesla is as a car company. There have been dozen(s) of car companies started in the US since WW2 and you could argue that not one of them has been a success. The biggest Kaiser Motors, has probably been surpassed.

For decades American and Japanese manufacturers have tried to compete with European luxury brands. American companies had almost no success and Japanese very little. Lexus does well, but it never displaced German car sales the way Tesla is now. I am not a Tesla fanboy, but I do like cars. You have to respect the product.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by dd36 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:18PM (#22541545)
And that’s to say nothing of what they’re doing to drive down battery costs through economies of scale and basically creating the energy storage mass market. $100kWh is revolutionary. Every home in sunbelt America can have decent backup or go off grid with solar for mere thousands of dollars. I still think few people grasp the paradigm shift that’s on the horizon.

The bottleneck is no longer fuel costs and delivery. It’s technology cost and it’s declining rapidly. Look at Enphase’s IQ8X grid forming micros. The future is coming fast.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by adventured on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:26AM (#22543543)
Just getting people to think differently about these things is extraordinary. Making the Powerwall an accessible consumer good, is an important step forward. Tesla single-handedly changed the public's perception of electric vehicles.

Some people obsessively, maniacally try to deny Tesla the credit they deserve for changing the auto market (for the exact same reason some people try to deny Apple the credit it deserves for entirely changing the phone market). Nobody else did it, which is also why they're so far ahead of their peers. The giants of the industry handed them a decade headstart.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by d1zzy on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:57PM (#22541405)
AFAIK when I was in Europe I would have loved to be able to buy Japanese cars but they were the top taxed cars, some crazy >20% amount or so. So there was no choice but to buy "local". With Tesla it seems a lot of countries are giving out serious tax breaks so I wonder how much of that will continue once those incentives stop.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by nordsieck on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:10PM (#22541496)
> With Tesla it seems a lot of countries are giving out serious tax breaks so I wonder how much of that will continue once those incentives stop.

My understanding is that gas is quite expensive in many European countries compared to the US, so even if there are purchase incentives that expire, I think there is probably still strong economic pressure to buy electric.

Until someone else comes out with a strong electric vehicle offering, that means Tesla.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by bjelkeman-again on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:23PM (#22541996)
An electric car is generally 1/5, or less, the cost per km to “fill up” in Europe
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by mrich on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:21AM (#22543519)
Unfortunately not the case in Germany, unless you have a house with solar. And its mostly due to taxes.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by jungturk on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @10:02AM (#22545902)
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by hibikir on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:27PM (#22542016)
Just like a big percentage of Japanese cars destined to the US market are assembled in the US or Mexico, Tesla will probably build their highest volume cars in the EU the moment it makes sense. They've broken ground for a large factory in Berlin already.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by prostoalex on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:51PM (#22542169)
The intense focus on robotic assembly seems to make sense in this context. Once streamlined, it makes it relatively cheap for Tesla to open up a new factory if supply chain allows for it.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by baud147258 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:34PM (#22542065)
From what I've heard, if you buy Toyota in France, your car is more likely to have been assembled locally vs any of the local brands (Peugeot, Renault, Citroën). So buying a Japanese car in Europe can mean buying a local car.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by mark-r on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:11PM (#22542272)
Much the same in the US. A Toyota bought here is likely to have more US value-add than a Ford or Chevy.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by jessriedel on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:49PM (#22541331)
In a recent podcast interview, Musk claims there have been thousands of new (EDIT: American) consumer car companies and that every single one has failed besides Tesla (if I recall correctly). Presumably this counts every incorporated team that made a rudimentary prototype.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by baybal2 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:12PM (#22541511)
BYD - been around for an eternity by silicon valley standards, few other genuinely new Chinese brands (ones which are not subsidiaries of BAIC or FAW,) Vinfast, Peroda
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by jessriedel on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:44PM (#22541737)
Sorry, I forgot to mention he specified American.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by aantix on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:53PM (#22541369)
Do you remember the podcast?
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by jessriedel on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:45PM (#22541752)
Third Row. Can't remember if it was part 1 or 2, but probably 2. It's very fanboyish, but there are some good stories on there about the early days of SpaceX and Tesla.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by cjhopman on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:07PM (#22542252)
Tesla has burned through more money than all of them combined.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by new_realist on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:08PM (#22541916)
Tesla has lost $6.5B over 17 years. It’s cheap money which has allowed it to persist despite these losses.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by bjelkeman-again on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:21PM (#22541983)
You say losses, i say investments. I expect they will be recouped now.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by selectodude on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:17PM (#22542310)
Toyota is the most profitable large car manufacturer on a per-vehicle basis and they make under $3,000 per car. Tesla needs to manufacture a few million more cars and not lose another penny before they recoup that investment.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by cma on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:23PM (#22542346)
Tesla charges $7,000 for full self-driving vaporware, and has already recognized a huge portion of it, even though they haven't delivered practically any of the value of it (they claimed your car would appreciate by over $100,000 when it entered the robotaxi fleet this year). More than Toyota's whole margin, they spent a lot on it but recently cut R&D significantly even though they aren't close. Maybe with the latest fundraising round they will increase R&D again and deliver before the cars that were bundled with it are falling apart.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by Dumblydorr on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @10:05AM (#22545926)
Cheap money is great for new companies. Whether it be Amazon, netflix, uber, lyft, Airbnb, lets face it: they all get a ton of cheap money to finance their technical coding and R&D. This is not a bad thing inherently, what we are describing is how you get hard technology to scale much faster.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by m463 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:36PM (#22542081)
I've sort of wondered about that. Governments should foster entreprenuers, the most important source of economic growth, and cheap money might be more successful and egalitarian than fingers-in-the-pie subsidies or other methods.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by foota on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:11PM (#22541935)
Seems pretty cheap?
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rconti on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @07:57PM (#22541399)
As a sidenote, it's easy to get lost among the "how many hundreds of thousands of model 3s can tesla produce in a year", but I just saw an overall production stat and noticed they're over 900,000 cars lifetime, and hadn't heard it mentioned elsewhere. 1 million vehicles sold will be a real milestone.

I stumbled upon a comment online, recently, from a guy who went on and on about peak oil for years. In 2008, he made a joke about "Tesla will have surpassed the US car industry". I don't remember the time horizon, but the first Roadster was delivered to Elon in February 2008. It just made me reflect on what we'd think of that prediction/joke and how it turned out, if we were to go back in time.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by latortuga on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:02PM (#22541442)
Musk tweeted about how they reached 1M just yesterday.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rtsil on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:02PM (#22541443)
> 1 million vehicles sold will be a real milestone.

They've just passed 1 million vehicles manufactured so that shouldn't take long.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by tardo99 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:17PM (#22541539)
Tesla's 10-K shows an accumulated shareholder deficit of $6B. That's over and above money spent to buy factories which are still operating. That's $6k a car at 1M cars sold. Add to that the $7500 rebate the US was providing until recently. That's $13.5k, on average, they lost per car they sold through the end of 2019.

Saying nothing about Tesla cars versus other companies, that's a huge financial advantage against other car companies. This is particularly true given that most of those car sales happened post-Q1-2018, when Tesla had already established a strong brand.

I'm not sure any established player could, at that point, compete with a company that gets to lose $13.5k per car they sell. That would be like if Nissan started building base-model Sentras and selling them for $4500. Yes, they would sell a lot of them.

As markets normalize and Tesla has to compete on a level playing field, my guess is their product is viewed more and more as what it is: a luxury car. Nothing wrong with that, but it's hard to see them owning more than a few percent of the market, especially considering established companies have gone all in on electric at this point.

And, nothing can justify a price-sales multiplier of 20 for the company. Nothing.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:12PM (#22541940)
> Tesla's 10-K shows an accumulated shareholder deficit of $6B. That's over and above money spent to buy factories which are still operating. That's $6k a car at 1M cars sold.

The money was spent on things like R&D and product development. That means you amortize it over the total number of cars they're ever going to make using that technology. They've made 1M already, but why would you expect them not to make any more?

Some of that money went into developing models that haven't been released yet. If you break it down per model using existing sales numbers then those models would have cost infinity dollars per car, but that's now how it works.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by sfblah on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:15PM (#22542292)
Let’s hope. The question is how relevant the 13.5k subsidy is to whether others can compete. The top comment about luxury cars being irrational purchases is probably the best commentary here.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by kmonsen on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:34PM (#22541658)
The 7.5k is available for anyone selling electric cars in the US, well except Tesla themselves at this point so right now they are actually fighting an uphill battle and still winning.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by DanCarvajal on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @10:28AM (#22546113)
Is it a battle when almost all the other competitors are just producing California compliance cars? They've barely survived financially without competition, I'd be deeply concerned with their ability to compete going forward.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rconti on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:01PM (#22548382)
Yeah, there was an article the other day interviewing James Dyson about his new flatiron. The first part of the article asked him about their EV, which was basically ready for production (they spent years on it), but he said there was no way to make it profitably.

That said, Tesla is still selling cars with no federal rebate. So, actually, while you're right about $13.5k (historically), that's no longer correct. (of course, they've lowered prices, so perhaps that $6k number goes up?)

I don't doubt a more efficient automaker could shave thousands off that $6k number. And people would still buy it for a couple thousand more; making up the pricing difference.

Of course, that still brings us "only" to $0 unit profit.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by TotempaaltJ on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:19PM (#22541550)
How does Tesla lose money on the rebate?
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by sfblah on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:26PM (#22541599)
They don’t. It’s that they get to charge less for their cars than would a competitor.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by mrep on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:35PM (#22541669)
Those competitors can sell cars with the same rebate as Tesla though.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by sfblah on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:15PM (#22542296)
Yes, assuming Tesla doesn’t successfully lobby to change the law, which I expect them to do.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:10AM (#22542911)
They get to charge more, you mean. They have had to steadily lower their prices as the rebate phased out.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:23PM (#22541575)
Fiat Chrysler and GM used to build compliance cars. Fiat's CEO was famous for saying not to buy theirs [1] because they lost money on it, but were required to build them to meet emissions mandates so they could sell their polluting combustion cars (fun fact: Fiat has to pay Tesla $2 billion now to continue selling non-EVs in Europe, they are effectively funding Gigafactory 4 in Berlin [2]). These companies have enormous existing manufacturing capacity, and capital market resources. If they didn't have spineless management, or short term shareholders, they could've been the ones to capture the gains from the transition to electrified transportation. Instead, Tesla came along, doing the hard work for a decade performing R&D, building their own manufacturing capacity (GF1, 2, 3, and now 4) and Supercharger network, and most importantly, a desirable and sexy brand. TLDR Tesla spends crazy money on capex but everyone funding Tesla is onboard with it, legacy automakers cannot do so.

Polluting and emissions have a very real cost (climate change, particulate pollution). I am astounded when someone complains that this cost must be paid for, and that it was in some way wrong or economic fraud for Tesla to take advantage of intelligent public policy (ZEV credits, tax credits, etc).

Disclaimer (bigger one in profile): I am a TSLA shareholder, and willing to wait until the heat death of the universe for any return on capital. My investment is in fixing climate change.

[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/chrsyelr-ceo-evs/fiat-chrysl... (“I hope you don’t buy it because every time I sell one it costs me $14,000,” he said to the audience at the Brookings Institution about the 500e. “I’m honest enough to tell you that.” -- Sergio Marchionne)

[2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-01-09/fiat-will... (Fiat Will Effectively Fund Tesla’s German Factory, Baird Says)

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by new_realist on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:10PM (#22541924)
It’s fine that Tesla is a compliance car manufacturer for hire. Just don’t claim buying a Tesla is good for the environment, because it is not. Every Tesla sold just allows for one more gas guzzling SUV to be made. Instead, focus your energy on lobbying the government for stricter emissions regulations.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:11PM (#22541934)
> Instead, focus your energy on lobbying the government for stricter emissions regulations.

I focus on solvable problems. Tesla solves problems today that the United States Congress might never solve (a carbon tax is extremely unlikely to pass with the current legislature configuration). Every Tesla sold gets us closer to a zero emissions future. You go to war with what you have, not what you want. Dysfunctional government? Those factories still churn out EVs that generate revenue to scale up battery manufacturing across the world.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by Dumblydorr on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @10:03AM (#22545909)
Are you kidding? People here can actually afford Teslas and your idea to support EVs is for HN tech workers to not buy EVs but rather try to convince climate denying Trump administration to tighten regulations they already slashed and wanted to slash even more? That's just silly, the best climate solution may not be EVs but let's not pretend the current admin will listen to climate lobbying.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by tardo99 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:32PM (#22541647)
Except that's not how public policy works. It's not like Tesla just happened to luck into these policies. They actively lobbied for them. There's a significant amount of "greenwashing" involved there. I think it's instructive to realize that both of Musk's companies have, as critical elements of their success, government policies which favored them at just the right time.

I have nothing against Tesla as a luxury car brand. I do get tired of fanboys suggesting they'll take over the entire industry. Normal people can't afford a $60k Model 3 (and that's what they actually cost). Other companies will do fine in the electric space. I'm quite happy with my used Nissan Leaf. Price? $8500. Let's see Tesla beat that.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:12AM (#22542921)
> Normal people can't afford a $60k Model 3

That's hyperbole. I paid a little less than $60K out the door for my Model 3, and it is the Performance model. You can order a $40K Model 3 right off the web site that is substantially identical aside from being slower and having a few miles less range (though in practical terms it's probably about the same because the P3D doesn't get anywhere near rated range). AFAIK you can still special order the $35K model.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:40PM (#22541714)
The ITC tax credit for solar and storage, the EV tax credit, and the electric vehicle charging station credit all existed before Tesla (and all other solar, storage, and vehicle manufacturers are eligible for these credits, not just Tesla, you just have to build the product). Tesla did lobby for vehicle manufacturers to be allowed to sell directly to consumers, which I cannot see any reason that shouldn't be allowed in a free market. Can you prove they lobbied for these policies?

A Nissan Leaf is a glorified golf cart with an air cooled battery that has no longevity and no fast charge network. There is a reason they are so cheap used. It is not a realistic competitor to an internal combustion vehicle, such that a Model 3, Y, S, or X is. That is why Tesla is successful and has sold their millionth car, and is running at a 400k unit/year run rate (based on Fremont and Gigafactory 3 production data). There is no need for Tesla to meet unrealistic expectations such as your example ("I'm quite happy with my used Nissan Leaf. Price? $8500. Let's see Tesla beat that.") when there is an entire worldwide auto market with consumers ready to pay top dollar for the cars Tesla builds (in the US, average sales prices of a new car in the US is $35K and 17 million cars a year are sold), and Tesla commands roughly 1/3rd of the Chinese EV market as of February 2020.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by marcinzm on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:17PM (#22541958)
>and that's what they actually cost

They cost $40k, you can try to do whatever random math magic you want to make your argument but that generally won't fly well on this forum.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by dathinab on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @11:07AM (#22546424)
But 40k is still unaffordable for a non small amount of people. And buying "old" ones cheap has problems "because batteries" (and Tesla might just recently have found a way to solve that).

To take over they would need to:

- Release a sub 10k car which is focused on in-City only use case but can also handle your grocery shopping and pre-planned inter City treveling to close by cities.

- Solve the logistic problem that everyone wants to charge theire car. (Note: I don't mean the whole bs. about power grid crashing, all this are technically problems with existing solutions).

- One way to solve that would be batteries with a capacity so large that you only charge once in four days _for the cheap sub 10k version_.

- Another would be batteries so small that they are easily exchanged instead of charging. (Tesla did implement that but the way it currently is, is just to unpractical. It would need a industry wide standard solution and a really easy to maintain exchange station.)

So could Tesla take over: yes.

Will Tesla take over: most likely not, they will just probably become well established for the mid/upper marked segment.

Will battery powered electric cars take over: likely but not necessarily. The often overlooked truth is the race is still on and the winner not yet clear as neither batteries not full cells have yet reached a level at which they can widespread replace fossil fueled cars.

Also let's not speak about current battery tech and fire...

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by marcinzm on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @11:40AM (#22546689)
>But 40k is still unaffordable for a non small amount of people.

The average price of a new car in the US is $37k which gives Tesla access to half the new car market. Used car buyers are meaningless in the metrics as they make car companies no money. Tesla is far far from saturating that part of the market so there's little incentive for them to move to cheaper cars (and dilute the brand in the process). In fact, it's probably better economically for Tesla to let other brands make cheaper electrics, annoy customers due to shortcomings and then swoop in with a superior product down the line (having learned from the mistakes of other companies).

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by sfblah on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:16PM (#22542306)
Sure, with no options. I’d like to hear your response to the $8500 used car comment.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by bananabreakfast on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:38PM (#22542429)
How on earth can you possibly compare a new Tesla to a used cheap electric go-kart?
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by marcinzm on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @08:52AM (#22545349)
A new Leaf is $30k base. A car which depreciates that much is going to look really bad to new buyers versus one that doesn't. And without new buyers there are no used cars to sell at $8500. Tesla is affordable to something like 50% of new car buyers and if it sells for $20k more used then paying $10k more is an easy decision if you can afford it.

edit: Or in other words, used cars are irrelevant in terms of market adoption since their supply is limited by the supply of new cars. So you need to look at the demand and sales of new cars.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rconti on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:09PM (#22548504)
The cheapest LEAF (don't ask me why they capitalize it) base MSRP is $31,600 vs a Tesla SR+ Model 3 at $39,900.

The LEAF S and SV with a 40kWh battery have 149mi range up to a $34,190 base price.

The cheapest 226mi range LEAF is $38,200.

Nissan offers a cheaper base price for a market segment Tesla is not playing in, which is great.

But if you want to compare apples to apples, the pricing is basically the same.

And then there's depreciation..........

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:14AM (#22542928)
There aren't really any options to select anyway, aside from a few extra bucks for non-white paint.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:17PM (#22542311)
New cars don't compete with used cars.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rconti on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:03PM (#22548417)
You lose credibility when you try to call Tesla supporters "fanboys", but then you artificially inflate the price of the car by 50%. This is not a mundane detail.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by imtringued on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:09PM (#22541919)
Why not get a Renault ZOE instead?
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:10PM (#22541923)
Not sold in the US.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by bananabreakfast on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:56PM (#22541832)
Nissan Leaf? Have fun in that pile of garbage on wheels. You get what you pay for.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by djehh3r7d on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:24PM (#22541584)
That didn't leave the controversy behind at all, most of the controversy is far past their valuation. Tesla is only interesting as a car company to people who are willing to lower their expectations below those placed on the actual car companies.

They market themselves as environmentally friendly while representing a comedically small percent of global emissions reduction. And within the auto industry itself the increasing efficiency of ICE vehicles has reduced emissions by far more than Tesla and their electric car hype.

At the same time, they advocate infrastructure expansions to accomodate their vehicle's needs while handwaving away the emissions and environmental consequences this process would create. And every time this is mentioned people just blubber some line about the long term while covering their ears to the tide of environmentalists saying that we need change /now/.

They might conquer Europe through legislation but the only reason that's practical is because European countries are tiny so the range issue is less relevant to them. Tesla hasn't actually cleared their hurdles, they've surrendered to them.

Meanwhile, they drum up this idea that Tesla's can be more than toys for rich people even though no one blue collar who isn't already a hard fan chooses a Tesla. In fact, speaking of legislation, they're so uncompetitive that Europe has to ban ICE engines for them to gain ground.

Even you framed this as Tesla competing against luxury brands, key word being luxury. This world where they've paved the way for cheap mainstream electric vehicles is a fantasy. They've paved the way for novelty in the luxury market and since doing so have shown little aptitude beyond their ability to wield that accomplishment as a shield to deflect criticisms.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by elihu on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:52PM (#22541803)
> They market themselves as environmentally friendly while representing a comedically small percent of global emissions reduction. And within the auto industry itself the increasing efficiency of ICE vehicles has reduced emissions by far more than Tesla and their electric car hype.

You have to start somewhere. Tesla is increasing their manufacturing capacity about as fast as you can reasonably expect any company to do it. Just because high-volume manufacturers like Ford or Honda or Volkswagen can have more impact on CO2 emissions by reducing fuel consumption slightly on many more vehicles is no reason to disdain what Tesla is doing on a smaller scale.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by vgchh on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:36PM (#22541679)
Tesla is no longer a novelty. They just manufactured the millionth car. I own a model 3 and people ask me how do I like it. My usual answer is that I have "no compelling reason" to buy an ICE car - ever. Despite all the free marketing that Tesla gets, I don't think people grok how good the car actually drives in real. You really need to experience living with it to appreciate why it's a game changer.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by tardo99 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:38PM (#22541697)
You think it's more of a game changer than the $8500 used Nissan Leaf I bought (which, before you start, is perfect for me because I use it around town, and yes it works fine for 95+% of my car trips, including 100% of my commuting miles)?

I'll tell you something. I'm sure enjoying having that extra $60k in my bank account that I saved by not buying a horribly overpriced depreciating asset.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by CydeWeys on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:45PM (#22541747)
You're just making a general argument about buying used vs new. That's not interesting, or revelatory. It's just overly judgmental.

And you're quite off on the price of a Model 3. I think you're confusing it for the Model S.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by cjhopman on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:12PM (#22542278)
$60k that he claims is much closer to the ASP than the $35k that Tesla claims.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by sfblah on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:18PM (#22542319)
It’s impossible to buy a used Tesla for anywhere close to $8500. I find the comparison compelling.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by CydeWeys on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:06PM (#22542575)
Because they're better cars than the Leaf and thus maintain resale value better. The Leaf isn't coming out on top in this comparison. There's a reason some things are worth more than others.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:16AM (#22542933)
Friend of mine is a Leaf enthusiast and even he concedes it's pretty awful. It could have been great, but the batteries degrade so fast you can practically watch the range decrease with every drive.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by mardifoufs on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:54PM (#22541816)
What's the range on the used leaf you bought? Maybe 100 miles without AC/heating? There's a reason why the Leaf didn't succeed in the way Tesla did, and it's not all because of Musk.

Also, a new model 3 is 40k, and Teslas depreciate a lot less than a Nissan. But I do agree that buying brand new is generally a bad idea imo

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by fragmede on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:23PM (#22542682)
Define "didn't". The 1st generation Nissan Leaf in 2011 was was pretty terrible, but they kept making them, and brand new ones (since 2017) are actually quite nice, with more power and 200 miles of range. Definitely not Model S nice, but luxury cars are a totally different segment. There's room in the car industry for Nissan making the economy electric car and Tesla in the luxury or up-market segment.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:17AM (#22542942)
AFAIK the current Leaf still has terrible battery management, so I wouldn't plan on it holding value any better than the ones made 10 years ago.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by mark-r on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:32PM (#22542401)
Buying a used Tesla might not be a great choice, because they've locked it down so you're forced to use their repair shops instead of 3rd party. That's going to increase your cash outlay in a way you weren't expecting.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by barkingtoad on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:59PM (#22542543)
Most common car repairs 2015:

Replacing an oxygen sensor – $249 - Teslas don't have these

Replacing a catalytic converter – $1,153 - Teslas don't have these

Replacing ignition coil(s) and spark plug(s) – $390 - Teslas don't have these

Tightening or replacing a fuel cap – $15 - Teslas have a charging port cover, and it breaks

Thermostat replacement – $210 - Teslas don't have these (in engines)

Replacing ignition coil(s) – $236 - Teslas don't have these

Mass air flow sensor replacement – $382 - Teslas don't have these

Replacing spark plug wire(s) and spark plug(s) – $331 - Teslas don't have these

Replacing evaporative emissions (EVAP) purge control valve – $168 - Teslas don't have these

Replacing evaporate emissions (EVAP) purging solenoid – $184 - Teslas don't have these

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by slaw on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:56PM (#22542832)
If you have common ICE car, it is very inexpensive to keep it running when you can wrench yourself. I spent less than $600 in 15 years and 160k miles for all parts to repair 2005 Malibu. I had to go to dealer once, because ABS control module is locked. You need dealer codes and 'programming'. $240 for 15 minutes work.

For 2005 Malibu:

Oxygen sensors: one is $19, still running on originals.

Catalytic Converters: one side Carb Compliant $319, still running on originals

Spark plugs: Iridium NGK 6*$5, took me 1 hour to replace

Thermostat: $4 + $3 shipping, 15 minutes to replace

Mass air flow sensor: still original $62

Prices from RockAuto.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by mark-r on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:12PM (#22542611)
And how much is a replacement battery pack? - ICE don't have those
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by whatarethembits on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @01:44AM (#22543322)
That's equivalent to replacing an ICE engine/transmission, how often does that happen, and how much does that cost? It's a moot point, ICE cars lose that one by default.

Secondly, it's not just the pure monetary value. We have four cars in a family of six, and despite my brother being good with the wrench, ICE manufacturers have made it incredibly time consuming and difficult to do even the most basic maintenance work outside of maybe oil changes and brake pads. HUGE dealership service costs are practically unavoidable with modern ICE cars despite improvements in reliability to previous eras. The peace of mind and reliability gained from having fewer mechanical problems is invaluable. I'm gladly willing to pay MORE for electric cars in their current state to not have to deal with dealerships and mechanics. They're only going to get better.

Thirdly, I've been in the market for a new car for the past year. Driving assistance on motorways and London like traffic where you spend hours daily are a huge help. Virtually every viable option right now is a baby compared to Tesla's autopilot. Although this could be improved upon, I have no trust in ICE manufacturers to make any meaningful strides to catch up anytime soon. They're still figuring out android auto (which is a must because their proprietary tech is equivalent to a kick in the balls). The new kid on the block is just doing it better.

Lastly, a decade-ish old company/tech here warrants serious discussion in its CURRENT state compared to giants that are decades old, and they have no answer so far. ICE Vs electric is a forgone conclusion at this point, but I wish other manufacturers catch up to the trend sooner rather than later because that's ultimately better for us consumers. I'm not a fan of Tesla's Apple like views on product ownership in regards to repairs etc. But sadly, their current offering is far better than competition so we have no choice.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by mark-r on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @11:50AM (#22546782)
You missed my point completely. The comment I responded to cherry-picked a large list of items that didn't apply to electric cars, so I cherry-picked an example that didn't apply to ICE cars. Neither example is really relevant to the point I started with, which is that Tesla in particular is locking you into their repair centers in a way that is new to the car industry.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by ericd on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:34PM (#22542730)
Mostly irrelevant, because it’ll last longer than the lifetime of almost any ICE car.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:19AM (#22542945)
I like my Model 3 pretty well, but maintenance cost is a losing argument at this point, still. So far, the real world numbers show that Teslas cost more to maintain than a similar ICE car. It may eventually be true that the simplicity of an EV means lower maintenance costs, but we are not their yet.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by bsder on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:51PM (#22541796)
You're not going to sway the people who were going to be buying a BMW or Mercedes with that argument.

Car buying is a LOT of signalling. There is a reason for the stereotypes surrounding people who buy those types of cars.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by xedeon on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:46AM (#22543067)
> You're not going to sway the people who were going to be buying a BMW or Mercedes with that argument.

Did you not read the article?

Also: https://twitter.com/thirdrowtesla/status/1236678690462765057

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by bsder on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:11AM (#22543479)
The comment I was replying to was extolling the virtues of buying a Nissan Leaf.

The people interested in buying a BMW are not going to be swayed by "cost effectiveness" arguments.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by random314 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:32PM (#22541646)
You should self reflect about how incredibly bitter you sound.

Tesla is a new successful electric car company that is helping with CO2 emission reduction. Nothing in your rant challenges this.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by mehrzad on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:42PM (#22541723)
And how are the emissions of electric car and car battery production looking?
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by CydeWeys on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:45PM (#22541751)
Over the lifetime of the vehicle, much better than an ICE vehicle.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by new_realist on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:13PM (#22541942)
Tesla has spent $20B so far. All of that money created a burst of carbon emissions which they haven’t yet offset though EV sales: especially since they sell pollution credits to other manufacturers. They’re still deeply in the hole.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by CydeWeys on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:27PM (#22542020)
I'm not following this logic. That $20B created a million vehicles (and counting) that release much less pollution over their lifetime than $20B spent making ICE vehicles.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:45AM (#22543916)
Presumably they mean Tesla have spent $20B on laying cement for new factories, filling them with robots, buying computers, building paint shops, flying managers to China, etc. All that activity has an environmental impact.

It's a reasonable point, our economy is energy based and so the more you spend the bigger the environmental impact. We are trying to decouple it but we have a long way to go yet.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by cjhopman on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:15PM (#22542298)
I don't think you understand. The $20B isn't the cost to make the cars, it's how much they've lost doing it. There's nobody in the world that is losing $20B making ICE vehicles, and even big daddy elon might have trouble convincing investors to blow that money on such a traditional product.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by CydeWeys on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:27PM (#22542369)
What? How have they "lost" $20B? They may currently be carrying that much debt, but plenty of other auto manufacturers are carrying significantly more debt than that (e.g. $155B for Ford). Debts that you invest into growing a business faster aren't lost money. Tesla makes money on every car sold. It made sense for them to take out debt to enable that scaling.

And what does this have to do with whether their products are good for the environment anyway? Whether it makes sense to take on debt to establish a new business seems completely orthogonal.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by bananabreakfast on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:40PM (#22542439)
Yeah and so is every other company on earth. At least they're doing something about it.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by mehrzad on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:52PM (#22541808)
Compared to used cars and public transit though, it doesn't nearly look as good. I like Tesla, but there is a lot more to be done before I consider their work truly environmentally friendly.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:21PM (#22541976)
Nobody manufactures used cars. They all start as new and they all have a finite lifetime as a result of wear and collisions.

A used electric car is better for the environment than a used ICE car, but the only way to get used electric cars is to make new electric cars.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by mehrzad on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:05PM (#22549220)
Isn't it better for society to focus on improving public transit than electric? You could say "we don't have to choose" but it seems SV already did.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by CydeWeys on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @09:06PM (#22541897)
Sure, agreed. Another problem is that cars are quite deadly, and EVs don't improve on that any. Then there's the whole issue of tire/brake dust (it's the majority of local pollution even for gasoline-powered cars).

E-bikes are a much better environmentally friendly solution for most trips. The problem is the road infrastructure isn't there for them to be safe enough yet; we only build roads for cars, and anyone else (pedestrian or cyclist) is at high risk.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by FpUser on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:47PM (#22541770)
Care to post any numbers showing how much the overall lifecycle of Tesla's car is reducing CO2 emission over making better ICE based cars?

And what about overall pollution. Lithium batteries hold a lots of poison.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by Klathmon on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:24PM (#22542683)
Here (PDF warning) is a link to a study done (in 2018) that shows that an electric car produces less co2 emissions than an ICE car over 150,000km.

It takes into account different types of ICE cars, it takes into account the environmental impact of building the batteries, it takes into account the emissions produced by the power plants for several European countries, and it even predicts how things can improve or change if current trends continue.

With the exception of Germany (where lifetime EV emissions are very similar to an "efficient" ICE due to their more "dirty" power generation), an EV produces less CO2 over it's lifetime.

In fact the higher upfront emissions in manufacturing an EV are "paid back" within 2 years on average.

And because the environmental impact of an EV is so dependent on how "green" the power generation is, investments in green power can lessen the impact of cars already sold!

https://theicct.org/sites/default/files/publications/EV-life...

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by frandroid on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:34PM (#22541659)
> They market themselves as environmentally friendly while representing a comedically small percent of global emissions reduction. And within the auto industry itself the increasing efficiency of ICE vehicles has reduced emissions by far more than Tesla and their electric car hype.

The emissions reductions attained by manufacturers have been done while fighting tooth and nail against them; also, it's good that they're reducing emissions, but you just eliminate them completely by driving a Tesla.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by tardo99 on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:40PM (#22541705)
What about the emissions involved in mining lithium, making the batteries, dealing with the batteries once they're exhausted, and in generating the electricity. Also, what about the emissions involved in building and maintaining the road infrastructure?
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @08:57PM (#22541839)
Necessary and solvable (if we've decided cars as a transportation method are here to stay, which appears to be the case in most countries). Lithium is evaporated in ponds, transport of which can move to electric. Lithium batteries can be recycled. All heavy vehicles (including for road infra work) can be electrified. Electricity is ubiquitous, and batteries will only decline in cost. This is not my opinion, these are facts.

As long as we keep ramping battery and renewables production, we'll get ahead of the emissions. To reduce emissions, you must displace combustion in all its forms, and destroy demand for fossil fuels. Renewables push out coal and natural gas on the grid, utility scale batteries push out natural gas due to price volatility (hat tip to Saudi Arabia on their current efforts to destroy the US fracking industry through pumping at full capacity, utilities desperately require stable prices for their fuels which is unlikely to happen if shale production declines due to low oil prices, which will prompt more rapid battery uptake), cheap/clean energy drives demand for EVs due to lower cost per mile than internal combustion (EVs are roughly half the cost per mile to operate as an internal combustion vehicle).

[dead]
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:09PM (#22542265)
> Seriously, you consider the Saudis preferable to the Americans?

It does not matter to me if you're the House of Saud or US frackers, if you're pumping oil I want you out of business. My agenda is the end of fossil fuels, and I don't much care how we get there. Saudi Arabia requires $80/barrel to fund their state (Russia is ~$40/barrel), a highly unlikely long term market price for oil even with Saudi Arabia increasing their market share. So, if they can drive US shale (which is heavily leveraged using debt [1]) out of business before they decline, kudos. The planet, nor carbon emissions, care not about geopolitics.

Not buying oil from an authoritarian regime who funds terrorism is also an option if you're not a fan of Saudi Arabia (see: tariffs and embargoes). Why getting off oil is never the first option is always strangely not prioritized. Can't complain they're terrible folks (which they are!) but do nothing to migrate away from depending on them. It's been almost 50 years since the 70s oil embargo, and the US is still pathetically behind (compared to resources available) electrifying transportation. We have only ourselves to blame.

[1] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/these-energy-companies-hav...

[dead]
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by toomuchtodo on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @11:08PM (#22542585)
Happy to have the chat!
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by Dumblydorr on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @10:08AM (#22545950)
With this logic, you would've expected Steve Jobs to introduce a non-luxury iPhone and expect it to compete mass market from day 1. Tesla's plan was always to start at the high end with early adopters, show an EV can be great, and slowly scale down prices, which they have done. I can't envision them doing it a different way successfully.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by alasdair_ on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:00PM (#22542215)
> no one blue collar who isn't already a hard fan chooses a Tesla

My friend is a Master electrician in the IBEW union. He is in no way a “hard fan” of Tesla. He put down a deposit on the new truck that they are making because he thought it was better than his other options.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by cjhopman on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @10:13PM (#22542285)
Haha. It's a $100 deposit for a car that'll never sell as they showed it. I wouldn't read too much into that.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by Barrin92 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:21AM (#22542962)
>Elon Musk and the environmental virtues of electric cars

this is arguably a pretty big red herring and despite good intentions the focus on electric cars will probably be a disaster by prolonging the broken American car-centric development.

Mind you an electric vehicle is only as clean as its primary source of energy (at the moment its lifetime emissions are about 70% of a traditional car), and the production of particular the batteries is ecologically problematic to say the least.

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by breakyerself on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:38AM (#22543039)
How are electric cars prolonging the car centric system? Were we on the verge of overhauling our transportation infrastructure and I just didnt hear about it?
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by Barrin92 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:50AM (#22543086)
I'm not going to pretend to be optimistic about the capacity for large scale social transformation in particular in the US I'll give you that, but there have been increasing voices for revitalizing rail.

I think electric cars will prolong the situation by giving influential people in the managerial and political class, in particular, the illusion that EVs are a big enough step towards changing our lifestyles and that it will induce a sort of "I've done my part" complacency.

Basically a Tesla is the car equivalent of a biodegradable Starbucks cup. I've even heard people like Zuckerberg say the 'future' is autonomous vehicles in hyperloops carrying people from or to ever larger suburbs. If that's the future I hope spacex works out so I can be shot to Mars at least

Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by hyperbovine on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @05:41AM (#22544387)
Not social — geographic and historical. With the exception of the Acela corridor, where rail actually thrives, it’s just not viable in America. The distances involved are too vast, and the development took place in a way that is incompatible with rail. Nowhere is this more evident than the farce that is the LA-SF HSR. The situation in Europe is quite different. Cities are much closer together, and they have been building railroads for close to two centuries. European style rail travel will never be viable in the US.
Re:Tesla’s success in Europe catches industry off guard by Dumblydorr on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @10:10AM (#22545964)
You're forgetting spewing emissions into cities which worsen childhood asthma and worsen development of dementia. Local emissions matter and EVs are much much better than ICE for urban air quality; this point matters if you care about kids with asthma and grandparents with dementia.

Further, you're totally ignoring how much greening of the grid will occur. Some places like Scotland, Iowa, Texas, california, Iceland, etc. Have very clean grids due to ample renewable power generation. Sure an EV in west virginia or Wyoming will be charging with dirtier electrons, but most EVs in the US are in California which has a ton of solar and more all the time.