News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by aabhay on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @03:44PM (#22487866)
There’s an interesting meta-phenomenon here. I call it automation handcuffs. A platform grows massively due to radically eliminating the policy and bureaucracy infrastructure that others have (YouTube vs typical content distro channels). That same platform is now so big that it has to add back in that bureaucracy and policy that it lacked. However, it’s now so big that it must use automation to solve these problems or else go bankrupt hiring people. In the end, society gets a half-measure. The platform is too big to legalize. The existing players are too small to compete. Users are forced to accept substandard experiences.
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by _bxg1 on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @03:51PM (#22487941)
> it’s now so big that it must use automation to solve these problems or else go bankrupt hiring people

This is what Google and Facebook would like us to believe, but I'm not convinced. What it really comes down to is that they'd very much like to stay in the realm of automation, especially Google who are notorious for keeping humans out of the loop at any cost. See the long history of problems with their automated "developer relations" on Android. And the problem is that the disincentives for continuing to fail at these halfway-automated tasks are simply not strong enough to force their hand.

So they can just keep "doing their best" with automation, even though automation itself is far from the best they could do.

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:12PM (#22488191)
Here, let me reword it:

> it’s now so big that it must use automation to solve these problems or else swim in slightly shallower pools full of money hiring people

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by minhazm on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:14PM (#22488207)
How else can they actually operate the platform without automation? Android app store submissions weren't even within several orders of magnitude to the scale of YouTube & Facebook videos.

I think something like 300 hours of video are uploaded every minute to YouTube. How do you propose people review that in real time? Just to keep up in real time you need (300*60) 18000 people watching the videos and not falling behind, which means you likely need at least 5x that number.

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by ksml on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:19PM (#22488260)
I don't think they need to screen all content in real time, but they certainly could use more people in reviewing flagged content and resolving disputes. This seems to be where all the major complaints -- it's just so hard to get a sane resolution when you are a corner case and the algorithm has decided against you.
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by _bxg1 on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:33PM (#22488390)
I didn't say without any automation. I'm saying that when these unreasonable cases come up, and people appeal, there often isn't even a human brought in at that stage (or at least, not one who's given enough bandwidth to legitimately investigate the situation). Example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19124324

Cases like this, and the OP, are common-sense to any human being. Google doesn't especially want them to be resolved in this nonsensical way, they just don't care enough to direct the necessary resources to make sure a human touch is applied to them.

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by Aunche on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @05:46PM (#22488990)
This doesn't apply to your example, but for copyright, what is there to prevent a content stealer from spamming the appeals? You can ban or demonetize their account, but that's basically the status quo.

Also, YouTube doesn't want to settle disputes because that makes them liable to be sued if they happen to be wrong.

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by nitrogen on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @05:34PM (#22488901)
At a globally generous $20/hr/person, 360,000k/hr, 24/7, that works out to about 3ish billion per year, maybe 5-6 with overhead. That's an upper bound for 100% review.

There are tons of levers to pull to reduce volume without reducing profit (e.g. replace "nyancat for 24h" with a loop option), and they don't have to review everything.

If we limit review to copyright claims only, the hourly cost may be higher per person, but the review volume would be much lower.

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by gambiting on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:50PM (#22488534)
If you don't have your account verified, your videos have to be verified by an actual human - leading to week long queues to upload anything, meaning that naturally the amount of submitted videos will reduce. If you do get your account verified, your videos go live instantly(as they do now) but if they get flagged, a human has to watch them manually.

So basically, how PornHub works. They cannot risk not reviewing videos because the risk is so great, so they do. And they somehow manage to thrive in their space.

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by sly010 on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:53PM (#22488564)
The ask is that they employ real humans to review disputed claims not watch every video uploaded.
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by deanCommie on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:18PM (#22488250)
Not if you want the products to stay free.

And people really really do.

And for every hackernews poster (including myself) who says things like "I'll gladly pay X$/month for Gmail/Google/Facebook/Youtube just so that my data/privacy remained my own", there is a THOUSAND or more voices that would not.

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by etrabroline on Thursday March 05, 2020 @12:29AM (#22491199)
With distributed hosting there is no need for youtube to monopolize video. They operate at a loss specifically in order to control discourse and collect data. If that were made illegal, alternatives would take over immediately.
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by nerdponx on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:09PM (#22488148)
go bankrupt

How many people would they really have to hire? YouTube alone made $5 billion in 3 months' ad revenue: https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/3/21121207/youtube-google-al...

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by bzbarsky on Thursday March 05, 2020 @12:31AM (#22491202)
To answer that first question: In August 2019, there were 500 hours of video uploaded to Youtube every minute according to <https://www.businessofapps.com/data/youtube-statistics/>. It's probably more now (e.g. it was 300 hours in 2017), but let's go with that number.

That's 720,000 hours per day. If you figure people work 8-hour days, that's 90,000 people. Assuming they never take vacations, don't get weekends off, and really do work 8-hour shifts with no breaks. None of which seems remotely plausible. If we assume 5-day workweeks, 6 hours of actual "productive" time per day, and 2 weeks annual vacation, closer to 175,000 people.

YouTube revenue in the corresponding timeframe is somewhere between $9.5 billion and $14 billion. How much of that is profit and how much is already being spent on infrastructure costs and whatnot is unclear. But 175k people at $50k/year, say, is $8.75 billion/year. Which is getting pretty darn close to those total revenue numbers.

Note that that's $50k expense to the employer (i.e. including benefits, employer-side taxes, office space, etc, etc, not just salaries), which is likely to be an underestimate if these people are in the US.

There's the question of whether every minute of video needs to be watched by humans, of course. But at that point we're back into automation-land to some extent.

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by cthor on Thursday March 05, 2020 @01:34AM (#22491433)
You don't need humans to moderate the "500 hours of video uploaded to Youtube every minute". Most of those videos get little to no views and are irrelevant, and then most cases of infringement are clear cut enough that automation can deal with them. Most people don't bother to appeal.

The number of cases that actually need manual moderation would be many orders of magnitude smaller.

Imagine a system that works something like the following:

- Users get access to manual dispute resolution by proving their real identity

- Persons with enough obvious violations (i.e. outright piracy with no possible argument of fair use) are barred from the dispute process

- All disputes get sent to human moderators and handled within 24 hours

- There are multiple levels of appeals, starting at appeals to unskilled laborers and ending at appeals to experienced copyright attorneys

- Going to higher levels of appeals requires paying in a nominal fee that is returned if the claim is overturned

- The final level of appeals can decide the case is too unclear and should be handled by the courts as per the DMCA

- Claimants are penalized some nominal fee for overturned claims

How many moderators would that need? It'd be 1,000 at most. Majority of them would be outsourced laborers costing around $20-30k, with a few experienced attorneys costing $200-300k for the final stage of appeals. Total cost $20-30M. That's a lot of money, but still only 0.5% of their actual revenue. Such a system would surely create far more value both to the company and to the world.

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by bzbarsky on Thursday March 05, 2020 @09:04AM (#22493543)
Thank you, that does sound like a reasonable setup!
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by nerdponx on Thursday March 05, 2020 @12:42AM (#22491239)
question of whether every minute of video needs to be watched by humans

Not even close. We're talking a small % of videos that receive copyright takedown requests, which is already a small % of all videos uploaded.

Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by themacguffinman on Thursday March 05, 2020 @12:03AM (#22491113)
Revenue isn't profit, they don't have $5B to spend on human reviewers.
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by jay_kyburz on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @03:50PM (#22487931)
If government wasn't broken, users would have have the power to say we don't want these substandard things in our society.
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by xyzzyz on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:05PM (#22488102)
Users are very happy with YouTube experience, and are unlikely to support new regulations which would degrade it: in fact, they'd rather support opposite. It's the small content creators that aren't happy with YouTube quasi-copyright private regulatory regime, but they don't have political power to do actually do anything about.
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by nerdponx on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @04:10PM (#22488161)
What regulation do you have in mind that would degrade the Youtube user experience?
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by xyzzyz on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @05:11PM (#22488709)
Anything that would require significantly increasing human review would result in significant reduction of the amount of content on the platform, for example.
Re:Explaining copyright broke the YouTube copyright system by nerdponx on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @06:26PM (#22489274)
Is that true?

Imagine if DMCA appeals required a human review on channels above a certain size, for example.