David Frum writing in 2017:
> The transition [in Hungary] has been nonviolent, often not even very dramatic. Opponents of the regime are not murdered or imprisoned, although many are harassed with building inspections and tax audits. […] The courts are packed, and forgiving of the regime’s allies. Friends of the government win state contracts at high prices and borrow on easy terms from the central bank. Those on the inside grow rich by favoritism; those on the outside suffer from the general deterioration of the economy. As one shrewd observer told me on a recent visit, “The benefit of controlling a modern state is less the power to persecute the innocent, more the power to protect the guilty.”
* https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/03/how-to-...
Do not let how autocracies worked in the 20th Century distract you from how they now work in the 21st. (Though no doubt there are still places where people are disappeared.)
I hadn't really thought of it this way, but that's a common thread through so many political problems of the last 20 years. If you can convince enough voters that immigrants are the problem and you are the solution then you can do anything you like.
The question is, what are we going to do about it? If we keep ignoring the condition of the working class for too long like in this country, you get Trump and the likes.
It's an enormous failure of our political class to have ignored real issues for so long, getting it to the point where pretty much the same thing is happening all around the world, and the plutocrats and billionaires are exploiting it because they can since they have all the power.
Not even a new thing, Rage Against The Machine wrote songs about all of this 20 years ago, it's just that most people weren't paying attention.
You can do better than such a low effort swipe.
Is there a fundamental difference between these if there are private groups guilty of persecuting the innocent, and the party in power chooses to not persecute (or prosecute) those groups?
Though there has been a student and minority led protests against these of late, they are just not effective in combating these, with so much odds stacked against them. Honesty many are loosing hope. What in HN's collective wisdom is the way out for us, the nations like India, Turkey and others like us?
For example: Apple paid Jobs in backdated stock options[1] while having Al Gore on the board. With a salary of $1/year, he was able to take all his income as long term capital gains and save on SS tax and income tax.
[1] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/steve-jobs-haunted-by-back...
In many European countries, the media gets directly paid by the government so they don't go tits-up. This ostensibly secures a free press. At the same time, wer zahlt, schafft an. In fact, if Turkey were doing this, they would probably be criticized for blatant corruption.
1. It's authoritarian because it hurts the free press.
2. It hurts the free press because it's Turkey doing it.
3. Turkey is doing it because they are authoritarian.
And looking from the outside, I can't see a difference. The Western media, who are funded by the Western governments, praise the Western governments for their support of freedom and democracy.
The third world media, who are funded by the third world governments, praise the third world governments for their support of tradition and family values, or whatever it is they do down there.
My point is that it's absurd to call media free when they are getting paid by those who they are supposed to investigate. A better model, I think, would be this:
1. Each year, the government gives the media money.
2. If they wish to partake in this scheme, they have to put the money they get in a fund, which must be kept separate from the rest of their assets.
3. By law, they are prohibited from withdrawing more than say 5% of the assets each year, just as they must maintain a minimum share capital.
4. At registration, the government should give the various media corporations 20x the annual contribution for their such funds.
5. Upon liquidation, they must return the excess assets in the fund to the government.
This would insulate them from short-term political decisions. Even after ten years of no funding, they would still have 60% of their assets plus whatever the return on the way they invested them in was.
But for me a critical aspect is their mission statement and whether they adhere to it. I expect the media in my country to be a check against politicians / the powerful. I understand having a system keeping this stable would be nice and being dependent on gov money has drawbacks, but just having such a culture is what I'd consider most important for the label free press.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_public_broadcasting_syst...
- official funding with oversight, including democratic participation of all parties, as well as transparent rules (eg equal screen time).
- private media without oversight, heavily favouring one party and in return getting kickbacks through eg state grants or contracts to related businesses.
- private media without oversight, no requirements on democratic participation of all parties nor equal screen time, in return getting kickbacks by relatively transparent processes
Sorry to be a little off topic, but I recommend the book Surveillance Capitalism to better understand how people are manipulated.
Bernie's platform, like Trump's in 2016, has faced an incredible lack of scrutiny.
I have yet to see him pressed on the very high possibility that most of his platform will never get through congress.
If you ask any presidential candidate about the chances of their platform passing as-is, they will all have the same three things to tell you: 1) Vote for members of congress who will support my agenda and this won't be a problem; 2) Give me a mandate to implement my agenda so I have more political capital for negotiations; 3) You need to plant a flag in the ground so that you have something to anchor negotiations later, which might involve compromises.
If your point is that voters, the media, and politicians spend way too much time on platforms when they are mostly just signalling devices, I agree.
Promising voters things and then not being able to come close to accomplishing them undermines people's faith in the system & process.
When Twitter suspends people it's always been "but they are private company!" We'll see how they pull that same line if this goes through.
I understand that people on the right feel the opposite, that's fine. But I don't feel like I should be obligated to complain when the media behaves in a fashion that I feel is appropriate, just to appease this both-sidesism.
You're saying that you want the media to be a political instrument, but you want to make sure it's a political instrument used only by the party you prefer?
Because the alternative wouldn't be "it should be used by both sides", the alternative would be "it shouldn't be a political instrument".
Can you give 3 examples?
I'll give you one for free, the rest you're going to have to bother googling by yourself:
I would like to raise to your awareness that when Bernie was accused of saying a woman couldn't be president, his talking point we're very close to what people on the right have been saying for years.
Whereas this is an outright political attack that has no concern for the technical work of Twitter.
The difference in motives is clear
First, a political motive could not have created Twitter. If twitter was created as a tool to influence politics, it would drastically changed who signed up for the platform, and it's influence and reach. There are plenty of platforms that have tried that route, and not a single one has been successful. Reddit is in a similar position as Twitter on this same issue, and take a look at Voat to see what that looks like. Therefore, Singer seeks to obtain influence he would not have had by co-opting a platform created for other purposes.
Second, Twitters political leanings are incidental. Twitter's employees are human beings, and when they make a decision, they are biased by their own thoughts and opinions, which happen to generally be on the left. While leftist, this still allows people like Trump and other conservatives to use the platform... and it limits what political actions they can take (they cant get too extreme or their diverse user base may revolt). In other words, this is a passive bias.
Whereas Singer (may--we don't really know his motives) seek to turn Twitter into a political weapon that he can use to battle liberalism. That's an active bias. And depending on how active he wants to get with politics using Twitter, it may destroy the platform.
A passive bias is very different than an active bias. And I don't know how you can claim they are indistinguishable.
That's assuming you have to start with what you want to eventually achieve. Startups don't work like that in business, why should they in politics? You invest money to buy growth and market share before you monetize.
I'm not suggesting that Twitter was created to be a political tool, but "political apps don't work, Twitter worked, therefore Twitter wasn't meant to be a political app" falls a bit short I think.
> While leftist, this still allows people like Trump and other conservatives to use the platform...
Isn't that mostly because they really don't want to open that can of worms by banning the US president? Do you believe that, if Trump had lost to Clinton in 2016 but just kept on playing the politics game instead of tweeting about how great his new show will be, they would've tolerated that? I seriously doubt that.
> Whereas Singer (may--we don't really know his motives) seek to turn Twitter into a political weapon that he can use to battle liberalism.
Burning it to the ground, wasting his money, because of his personal politics? Doesn't that sound a bit strange for a hedge fund?
Besides there are plenty of other conservatives on twitter. Then and now.
That's not the point. It wouldn't be Hillary making Twitter ban Trump, it would be Twitter not having to ban the president. Trump's tweets may not have changed (I'd say they did; his reach and the importance certainly has), but Twitters policies have evolved and what was okay 5 years ago isn't okay today.
This also scales nicely because you can start getting way overpriced ad buys when other companies also want to get favourable deals with the politicians, so you become a direct broker for access to the government.
Of course, the quality suffers and other media begins to emerge but you can keep buying the challengers or the govt can take care of them.
In Turkey, the pro-govt media is called "pool media" because a bunch of businessmen close to the ruling party created a pool to buy out newspapers and TV channels and an audio recording of them discussing the details was leaked(which is also very complicated, way out of the scope of this comment).