As an Indian, when I see resource consumption per capita for US, it boggles my mind. But I don't believe every single American can make a significant change without institutional and government support.
Environmental impact is a function of what your society has optimized for. You can't really depend on public transport if the entire society around you is optimized and designed for cars. You'd have a tough time being a vegetarian if meat is a primary component of every meal. You can't forego flights if the rail infrastructure doesn't work well.
A similar thing happens in India. India optimizes for cheap stuff so a lot of stuff available for purchase near me is practically use & throw. I've had keyboards, monitors, powerbanks, cables die on me in 6-12 months. I'm having a hard time buying good quality stuff as India grows. That also has a significant environmental impact.
At the risk of sounding like fatalist, I won't discourage individual action. Every single step is welcome but as humans we need to significantly step up our political initiatives if we are to make a significant dent in climate change.
No, you sound like a realist. My wife has been an ardent environmentalist her whole adult life, but she has echoed this sentiment to me, to the extent she would rather people not even recycle. It is, she says, the security theater of environmentalism. Political action is needed.
In fact, I believe the populist movements around the world will soon meet with climate change environmentalism, and we will see a great voluntary contraction, supported by governments, that will indeed make a big dent on the problem. Until then, not using plastic straws and veganism is just theater.
This doesn't really make sense to me. Trains don't deliver from foreign farms to my door. You have to drive the food from those farms to the train, and drive the food from the train to its final destination. I don't see how that can possibly be less resource-intensive than getting food from local farms. And that's not even mentioning the difference between monoculture industrial agriculture and small-scale organic farming.
In any case, if you're worried about your resource consumption, you can always make more of your diet plant-based, drive your car less, and avoid flying when possible. In every carbon impact calculator I've used [1], these things make a significant impact. And I agree with the above poster that these decisions can, far from being sacrifices, greatly improve your life.
You also are conflating organic and polyculture farming. Most organic farming is monoculture and much of it is industrial.
Yes I understand this. My point was that it's not as simple as comparing trains to old pickup trucks, which seemed like a strawman. But I've been doing some research and was surprised to learn that food-miles are a relatively small portion of the emissions associated with food, so point taken.
> You also are conflating organic and polyculture farming. Most organic farming is monoculture and much of it is industrial.
I didn't mean to conflate them, I meant that monoculture + industrial is more resource-intensive than organic + small-scale. But I guess I was using "organic" as a catch-all for sustainable farming practices, e.g. polyculture, rather than literally "USDA organic".
Debate about "local produce" aside (which I probably should have let go), my more important point is that it's definitely possible to reduce your carbon footprint meaningfully.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_d...
There's some lag built in, so even with a fertility rate below replacement, population can still grow for a while, but the root cause of population growth is already solved in much of the world.
The simplest and most effective way to limit population growth is 1) women's education, and 2) increase standard of living. With some or even one of those things, population rate naturally falls (even to below replacement rate, which is not good as Japan and increasingly Europe are learning).
Already, even China's birth rate has fallen to levels that will soon be of concern to the country (obviously, a small working population can't support a massive elderly population). And once India's birth rate makes the same transition, the global birth rate will start to level out. Already, projects are that it will level out around 2100.
Population growth is not the problem. Consumption levels and lack of environmentally-friendly sources of energy are the problem. We can solve one of those now, with nuclear power.
Well that's because it's not a realistic solution. Any solution that goes against the human nature is doomed to fail. Our species historically had issues with implementing solutions that require short-term detriment no matter how large the long term benefits were. Montreal protocol is often cited as one of these collective actions that succeeded, however what is NOT often cited is that the cost of implementing it was tiny compared to respective countries GDP. I.e. millions, not billions of USD.
The people who were predicting doom because of population were utterly and completely wrong and have been for 50+ years now. Just as terrible a prediction as those who predicted 'Peak Coal' in 1870. Guys like Borlaug are good at what they do but their understanding of the economy is incredibly limited.
The idea that population was the big issue is just fundamentally flawed assumption. The idea that population growth needs to end in order not to have a huge catastrophe is also incredibly flawed.
And add to all that, we can have both population and consumption growth at the same time, and we had that for a long time now and we can continue to do it for a long time. The energy inherent in the LITERAL DIRT on the ground alone could power advanced human civilization for 1000s of years and that is before we even start considering space based resources.
Simply put, with the 3x3x3 Cube of Dirt from where you are now, you have enough Thorium to literally power your whole life, including flying around with airplanes, driving and so on.
In fact we can do that AND at the same time reduce the amount of space people actually life on. Forest and other nature preserves are growing in the Western world. Increasingly people will live in population centers and more and more of the land around will have little actual use other then looking at it.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_di...
Yes and by far the biggest difference is with countries that use nuclear like France, Switzerland, Sweden.
Many of those gains, can absolutely not be achieved by US population 'purely improving their lives, before difficult decisions'. That is simply not the case.
It would require a total change in energy and transportation policy. Massively increasing the price of gas and flying. Changes in the way they live. And so on.
A comparative person living in New York City, Berlin, London is already not that different.
But we must also get over the idea that we need mass immigration into the West.
The most environmentally friendly thing to do is accept a slow decline in absolute population numbers.
This will mean roads are not as busy, hospitals not full to bursting and the chance to improve the kids to teacher ratio.
In fact, we are currently subsiding families. I tend to oppose that, but not because of fear of overpopulation.
Most roads are already not used often, its really just a few roads that are to full. And in those cases its really a density problem that we are not gone solve by having slightly less children.
For the rest I don't think population is the issue. The issue is with how those markets are organized. More people means you can have more teachers, not just more children. Currently the ratio is going down already, so I this is happening automatically anyway.
What would be the impact on overall income and employment rates?
> improving their lives
How could it be done with less income and less employment?
I'm asking honestly because I see this as a huge social-economic challenge.
Plus of course what good does income do if the world around you is shit?
Air quality, water quality, etc, should be baked into our economic models.
Income and employment age currently incomplete measures of health, happiness, and well-being — of which they are supposed to be indicators for.
Carbon capture, polluted water/air filtering, land recultivation, waste recycling, desalination, electricity powered transport, carbon neutral fuel production and even spaceflight - all these can fix our environmental problems if we have enough clean & cheap power.
Just reducing consumption means we reduce our options while still using our current old, expensive and dirty power sources.
And as for global footprint being bigger than the one of Earth at some time in the future - well, Earth and it's resources are just a very tiny part of our Solar System, not to mention it's wider neighborhood.
Only limiting ourselves to the resources our our single planet is a very bad thing to do as that will indeed lead to strife, but using the wider resources of the Solar System should enable us to avoid this pressure for quite a while to come.
The population extremists from the 60s, many in the 'green revolution' were part of that, were VERY actively promoting eugenics and wanted to deploy it on a massive global scale.
And this was not new, Eugenics was massive popular with the Progressives, in fact the Progressives were the primary political power behind Eugenics. And those are the exact groups moved over turned into the 'environmentalist' movement that was advocating those same Eugenics policy recommendation, but on a global scale. And because they were smart, they changed the language from 'We need to clean the human race' to 'If we don't clean the human race everybody is gone die'.
They wanted the US government to make aid conditional on Eugenics and population control tactics. Trying to prevent the population growth in India was one of their major goals and reading now what they advocated should be done about it, is truly disturbing.
Many of those, to be fair were not white supremacists, but if your main position is to advocate extreme policy to curb baby production in Asian and African countries, how much better are your really?
Whenever somebody quotes population control quotes from people associated with that movement these facts should be pointed out. Specially if it is in the 'referent' ton that indicates a willingness to support the same kinds of polices.
To be clear I'm not taking about everything that one means when saying the word 'Progressive' now. As that term is pretty watered down by now.
In general when talking about broad political and social moments its hard to come up with who 'exactly' they are.
Who prominently?
There definitely was a pro-eugenics movement in much of the West before WW2, but the anti-GMO fight is a very different one occuring 50 years later! I'd be surprised if there were very many people involved in both.
Think about the amount of concrete alone that would need to be used to get Africa up to 1st world standards. China used more in a few years than America did in a century. This will have to happen many times over just for the current population level, never mind a growing one!
It is like living in a house and everyone agreeing to cut their energy use by 20%.... while bringing in a new resident every few months.
Things like the tiny house movement and the sharing economy still have a long way to go.
Birth rates in the United States are already below replacement rate. Population growth is a result of immigration. Americans lowering their birth rates further won't do much.
Without reducing, new power sources will repeat what led Norman Borlaug said on receiving the Nobel Prize for his part in the Green Revolution:
"The green revolution has won a temporary success in man's war against hunger and deprivation; it has given man a breathing space. If fully implemented, the revolution can provide sufficient food for sustenance during the next three decades. But the frightening power of human reproduction must also be curbed; otherwise the success of the green revolution will be ephemeral only. Most people still fail to comprehend the magnitude and menace of the "Population Monster"...Since man is potentially a rational being, however, I am confident that within the next two decades he will recognize the self-destructive course he steers along the road of irresponsible population growth..."
We haven't made much progress stemming growth. Projections to 2100 still show our population growing, yet our global footprint is greater than one Earth.