News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Light Phone by Hamuko on Saturday January 04, 2020 @03:04AM (#21953596)
Do the makers think that there's a sizeable portion of people that hate their iPhones or Galaxies and want to spend $350 on a phone that doesn't do things? Doesn't do social media, doesn't do email, doesn't do news. Most consumers would at this point ask "What's the fucking point?"

Smartphones are popular because people want to do the things that they enable. You probably need to live in some sort of a niche social circle in order to justify $350 just to be able to tell people how your minimalist phone is not able to browse the Internet.

If you just wanted to have a basic phone that doesn't do a lot of things, you could buy a Nokia 3310 for $60. You just don't get to brag about your disconnected way of living since the Nokia 3310 can actually do those things.

Re:The Light Phone by ken on Saturday January 04, 2020 @10:04AM (#21955219)
I looked seriously at the first Light Phone. The main problem I found was that it's explicitly designed to be a second phone. You still needed to have a primary smartphone, and it would pair with that (and use the same number, somehow). It was just a phone for "I'm going out to dinner and I don't want to potentially be distracted by the internet, but I still want to be reachable". That seems to me like the intersection of two Venn circles that barely touch.

I might pay $350 for a phone that does only what I need, but I'm definitely not going to pay $350 extra for a second phone that only does what I need on top of a modern smartphone to leave at home that does lots of crap I don't.

The second Light Phone looks like it started moving towards being feasible as an only phone, but also piling on a strange set of features, for a phone designed to limit distractions. There's still SMS messaging but no encrypted messaging or email (and they brag it will never have these), but there is now music and ride hailing and so on.

So close, and yet so far! Any telco entrepreneurs out there: make me a little box that's only about communication with individuals I know (talk, text, popular encrypted chat, email), with modern interfaces (LTE, Wifi, USB-C), and I'll buy one. I bet my parents would, too.

$350 is not the problem -- service will still be the biggest cost in the long run. It's just not a useful device even for people looking to slim down and avoid distractions.

Re:The Light Phone by kurthr on Saturday January 04, 2020 @11:32AM (#21955769)
Wow... just use a glorified Bluetooth speaker and you’re there! Put all the configuration in an app on your “real” phone and it’s barely a hardware project and a contract programming job.

If you really want to minimize distraction that’s fine. The Bluetooth accessory can even limit logins (through TFA) by time and number (length would be complicated).

Re:The Light Phone by bebna on Sunday January 05, 2020 @01:04PM (#21962764)
Basically the Blackberry of old.

I miss those things. Shame they killed BIS in my country, so those are mostly unusable today.

I think the best way to achieve it all again is to create a set of interlocking apps who help you get things done instead of wooing you with animations for android and create your own distro with those apps pre-setup based on CyanogenMod/LineageOS/etc. This way you can use existing hardware, gain productivity and still be able to access tge appstore for everything someone needs for their personal work flow, like the tan generator of your bank.

Re:The Light Phone by arc4random on Saturday January 04, 2020 @04:14AM (#21953839)
You’re glossing away a lot of important details here with “phone that doesn’t do things”.

So, I’m very much in the market for what the Light Phone 2 is going for: not a phone that doesn’t do anything but make calls and text, but a phone with “the essentials”. The problem is that not everyone who wants such a phone has the same set of essentials.

The single biggest issue that I have with feature phones is that they lack a qwerty keyboard. I’ve tried a couple in the past few years, and I just can’t go back to texting on a numeric keypad. Texting today is very different from what it was in the 90s and early 2000s. So many conversations you would have today, you cannot meaningfully participate in with a numeric keypad. You find yourself immediately going back to the terseness that gave birth to the various forms of texting shorthand, because text input is so slow.

The second biggest issue is that I need a transit map. I live in NYC, and I’m not going to memorize all the different subway lines and stops and schedules. You can actually get Google Maps on a KaiOS phone, and it’s slow but it more or less works. Problem is, you’re still stuck with the numeric keypad. (You can use voice dictation via Google, but I don’t like using Google.)

Third, while I don’t need it often, I do sometimes need to use a ride-hailing app.

On top of all this, I don’t want a browser or social media apps or games or movies or music.

That’s just me, though. Someone else may want music, or a note taking app, or a calendar.

A lot of this stuff is on the roadmap for the Light Phone 2, but until it actually hits my set of essentials, it doesn’t work for me.

Re:The Light Phone by doovd on Saturday January 04, 2020 @04:21AM (#21953860)
You're missing the point - having these "essentials" shouldn't cost 350
Re:The Light Phone by i_am_proteus on Saturday January 04, 2020 @04:39AM (#21953913)
> I live in NYC, and I’m not going to memorize all the different subway lines and stops and schedules.

How long have you lived in the city? I lived there before smartphones and this is basically what people did.

Re:The Light Phone by BjoernKW on Saturday January 04, 2020 @06:07AM (#21954224)
I was going to say the same thing, not from personal long-term experience with the NYC subway system, but from regular experience with the London Underground, which is quite similar in terms of size and passenger numbers.

Then I had a look at the subway map and I can see why one might refrain from memorising the various lines and relevant stops: There are few significant features for distinguishing the lines, even the colours are very similar in some cases, and the stops often have cryptic or very similar names.

The London Underground map on the other hand is incredibly well-designed: The colours for the different lines are optimised for recognisability to the point they're almost iconic. On seeing a pink colour on the underground for example you can immediately tell "Hammersmith & City".

The lines and stops usually have easily memorable, often quirky names, too. This of course is in part due to London's long history, rather than a deliberate design decision.

However, usability still seems to have played a role when individual stops were named. For example, "Elephant & Castle" could've been easily named a far less memorable "London Rd." as well.

Re:The Light Phone by oneeyedpigeon on Saturday January 04, 2020 @07:39AM (#21954588)
> On seeing a pink colour on the underground for example you can immediately tell "Hammersmith & City".

I just wish they'd strictly adhere to matching the livery and the line colour, though. It's SUCH a good idea, but with trains sharing the same track on different lines, it causes no end of confusion!

Re:The Light Phone by Joeri on Saturday January 04, 2020 @08:13AM (#21954734)
You can get a cheap smartphone, put just the basics on it, and have someone else activate parental controls and keep the password from you so you are restricted to those basics.
Re:The Light Phone by bananamerica on Saturday January 04, 2020 @05:33AM (#21954118)
I can see how that seems useless to the average neurotypical, but devices with limited functionality are a huge plus for people that fights against strong compulsions.

I still think $350 is a lot, but when you have ADHD devices with a lot of features can be very detrimental to your productivity and your well-being.

Re:The Light Phone by fdsa_88989_ii on Saturday January 04, 2020 @05:48AM (#21954169)
I don't think you can separate features and price in this case. Looking vaguely iPhone 5-ish is not a feature that should add hundreds of dollars to the price.

My last dumb phone, which I bought to carry while cycling, cost me $30. Sure, it was ugly, but since the point is to not take it out of your pocket and play around with it, who cares?

This phone strikes me as the veganism of dumb phones. You want people to acknowledge the "sacrifice" you're making, so you're going to keep it visible, while you self-consciously don't interact with it.

Re:The Light Phone by nihakue on Saturday January 04, 2020 @07:26AM (#21954541)
I kind of understand why you went with the veganism example, but it seems slightly bizarre that it's your first choice. I think it's fair to say that most vegans' decision to become vegan has nothing to do with being sanctimonious. Not a vegan, though.
Re:The Light Phone by bananamerica on Sunday January 05, 2020 @01:40PM (#21962998)
I'm not sure if that is the case. They seem to be trying to provide some basic functions so the product remain useful even without regular smartphone features. Whether if they achieve this or not is a more subjective matter.
Re:The Light Phone by _jal on Saturday January 04, 2020 @07:42AM (#21954593)
You make such excited, highly normative claims about a phone, complete with involved speculation about the motives of anyone who might like it, and decide to insult people's eating choices along the way.

I could speculate about personal insecurity issues, but instead will simply note that not everyone comes from the same place you do or share your particular concerns or needs. It is a big world, exploring it some might be good for you.

Re:The Light Phone by bityard on Saturday January 04, 2020 @09:42AM (#21955094)
Mark my words, "I don't even have Facebook" is going to be the new "I don't even have a TV" in 2020.
Re:The Light Phone by hackworks on Saturday January 04, 2020 @10:15AM (#21955280)
That was my resolution a couple of months back. Signed off from Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and Reddit (never was on any other platform making crazy things with your snaps). Retaining accounts on HN and GitHub.

I miss nothing, actually feel good staying away from all the toxic comments on Twitter.

I did not need Light Phone or burn a hole in my pocket to achieve this. Plain simple determination.

Re:The Light Phone by mumblemumble on Saturday January 04, 2020 @10:20AM (#21955297)
Was not having a TV super trendy somewhere? I know plenty of people who don't have a Facebook account, but we're the only household I know of that's committed to watching their Netflix on a 13" laptop screen.
Re:The Light Phone by lproven on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:41PM (#21956935)
Was and is. It's even in a song lyric.

Been around the world and found / That only stupid people are breeding / The cretins cloning and feeding / And I don't even own a TV

https://genius.com/Harvey-danger-flagpole-sitta-lyrics

Re:The Light Phone by dgellow on Saturday January 04, 2020 @06:48AM (#21954385)
What's the issue with people bragging? That's what luxury items are for. It's just a modern status symbol.
Re:The Light Phone by lvturner on Saturday January 04, 2020 @05:10AM (#21954019)
I actually really want a stripped down phone - but without some of the popular messenging apps it's effectively a non-starter for daily use, both from a business and a personal perspective.
Re:The Light Phone by lproven on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:45PM (#21956963)
This is what compelled me to sell my Blackberry Passport, a lovely device with a good keyboard and a great OS (based on QNX).

I didn't care that it no longer had a FB or Twitter client, or that I couldn't access other soc.nets.

But for a comms-centric device with a wonderful unified inbox, the fact that it no longer worked with WhatsApp, FB Messenger and so on was a killer. A phone that can't talk to them is not really a phone any more in C21.

Re:The Light Phone by em-bee on Saturday January 04, 2020 @10:52AM (#21955509)
that's what i thought. i don't use phone and sms anymore. a phone without messaging would be useless.
Re:The Light Phone by ollifi on Saturday January 04, 2020 @09:17AM (#21954984)
I would guess the high price is partly because there is not so much demand and they don't have the volume. It's a niche product. I think it makes sense to set the price way up and only target the people who really want this. Why does everything have to appeal to some abstract group of 'most cosumers'?
Re:The Light Phone by qrbLPHiKpiux on Saturday January 04, 2020 @09:24AM (#21955018)
The first part of solving a problem is admitting one has a problem. Just like alcoholics and addicts admit problems, the solutions (rehab, withdrawal medications) are expensive, maybe this is the same thing?
Re:The Light Phone by giraffe333 on Saturday January 04, 2020 @11:29AM (#21955746)
I backed the Light Phone 2 with the thought that it's kind of like being an early Tesla buyer. People buy the Tesla to look cool, sure, but some also buy it because they want to see a world where cars become something they weren't before, and solve problems with existing cars (pollution, etc).

I'd love to see a world where people talk to each other again rather than sit at lunch, dinner, watching TV, whatever, with their phones out and ignoring each other. There aren't a lot of phones in this space so backing something like this may help create the market I want to see. I don't want to "live disconnected", but I do want to limit my behaviors like "hey let me interrupt this conversation so you can watch while I google that random thing we'll forget about in a minute".

Previously I had an LG slider phone with a physical qwerty keyboard for 5-6 years before buying the Light Phone 2.

I also hate the size of current smart phones, they're just so big. I'm weird I know, but I actually liked the size of my iphone 3G.

As a software engineer I'm hoping they get the custom "tools" available soon so I can tinker with that. I'd like to experiment with making a 2FA tool like Authy or some kind of push notification.

All in all, the Light Phone 2 is kind of slow to use, but it works, and it's not red like my LG was, so it starts less conversations when I use it.

Re:The Light Phone by samnwa on Saturday January 04, 2020 @03:55PM (#21957455)
Well, yes, of course that's what they think. And so far they have been right given that they are currently back ordered and saw 10,700+ backers on Indiegogo raising $3.5MM for the thing.
Re:The Light Phone by Nition on Saturday January 04, 2020 @03:42AM (#21953729)
For even simpler and smaller, get a Nokia 130[1].

[1] https://www.nokia.com/phones/en_int/nokia-130

Re:The Light Phone by ebg13 on Saturday January 04, 2020 @04:54AM (#21953957)
> ...nokia-130...

2G 900/1800MHz bands and therefore doesn't work in the US. Got a suggestion that actually works here?

Re:The Light Phone by simonh on Saturday January 04, 2020 @05:09AM (#21954015)
It does work here. Oh, in the US. Got you.
Re:The Light Phone by ebg13 on Saturday January 04, 2020 @04:46AM (#21953933)
> ...Nokia 3310...

2G 900/1800MHz bands and therefore doesn't work in the US. Got a suggestion that actually works here?

Re:The Light Phone by slim on Saturday January 04, 2020 @04:57AM (#21953970)
there is no shortage for simple symbian os, 3G capable, phones for less than $10
Re:The Light Phone by dqv on Saturday January 04, 2020 @09:53AM (#21955143)
>Got a suggestion that actually works here?

Literally the Nokia 3310

Source: me using the Nokia 3310 in the US on Ting