This is still less of an issue as the electric motor can spin faster due to the reduced resistance. Higher speeds will create higher resistances from within the motor itself (which will in turn be increase the heat generated in the motor).
That heat will also be harder to dissipate in lower pressures, but I suppose alternative cooling could be added as well.
The batteries may produce as much heat as the motor, and they have a more limited temperature range. Their service life decreases when run above 40 C. Tesla batteries are liquid-cooled.
Yes, but air-density-altitute problems are identical no matter what is spinning the prop, righ?
> This is still less of an issue as the electric motor can spin faster due to the reduced resistance. Higher speeds will create higher resistances from within the motor itself (which will in turn be increase the heat generated in the motor).
OK, so do the math for me here, I am a bit confused. I am not a motor whiz, but torque at the output converted to watts is going to be power at the input less i^2*r losses. The back-EMF will go up as the motor speeds up, so it may be at a somewhat less efficient point on the RPM-versus-torque curve, but the resistance of the actual wires doesn't change.
> That heat will also be harder to dissipate in lower pressures, but I suppose alternative cooling could be added as well.
I think that is all true. Seems to me you design cooling around the cooling capacity of the air flow at max operating altitude. Is that really a huge design constraint?
Does the RPM of the electric engine matter if the RPM of the propeller can't exceed a certain rate (because the tips of the prop will break the speed of sound, which you generally don't want for comfort reasons)? I mean this in terms of power generation and pushing air.
Beyond a certain RPM range electric motors lose torque. Eventually you'd reach the limits of the bearings or the maximum centrifugal force that the rotor can withstand, but that's usually at a higher RPM than gas engines are made to survive. I would expect an electric motor designed for an aircraft would be optimized for maximum power/efficiency at whatever RPM band is optimal for the propeller, and the battery would be optimized for whatever voltage is optimal for the motor at that RPM range.
Using large radiators on an electric engine kinda defeats the purpose especially when they can’t be effectively be built into the body of the engine.
source: https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2019/may/flight...
Plus you'll probably want to recover some of that waste heat to heat the cabin.
But discouragingly, just last August, in Norway, a Pipistrel Alpha Electro lost power shortly after takeoff and crashed. https://aviation-safety.net/wikibase/228207
Hopefully, these folks in Fresno, CA will get their electric aircraft flight school up and running sometime soon. But summertime in California's central valley is challenging: https://sustainableaviationproject.com/2018/10/28/we-hit-the...
Not to mention it makes a lot less weight to lift; the difference is huge.
Can we turn solar energy into hydrocarbons? (Water and CO2 are total feedstocks.)
Hydrogenate CO2 to methanol with electrolytic hydrogen produced from clean electricity [1]. Reform methanol to hydrocarbons [2] that can burn in existing engines. (Or burn methanol itself in slightly modified engines. This offers somewhat lower energy density per tankful of fuel, higher total efficiency from electricity-to-motion.)
Synthetic fuel makes sense for fueling aircraft, rockets, long distance shipping, collectible historic cars, and other niches. It doesn't make sense for fueling everyday ground transportation. Too much of the original energy is lost in the chain of chemical transformations and the chemical processing requires facilities on the scale of conventional oil refineries. The total cost is lower to electrify ground transportation and supply it with clean electricity than to transform clean electricity into liquid fuels for equivalent legacy vehicles.
[1] https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fchem.2018.0044...
What's driving the emphasis on lightweight batteries for aviation over better synthesisation?
- Extremely long flight endurance without refueling (in large solar/battery UAVs)
- Low noise
- Odorless
- Simpler and cheaper manufacturing
The advantages are much less obvious to me for aircraft that transport passengers or significant cargo loads. I suppose that the companies developing them are hoping to make the lifetime total cost of operation cheaper than existing aircraft serving the same niche. That seems much tougher to achieve.
EDIT: Bye Aerospace, the company described in the IEEE article, says they are targeting a particular niche:
https://byeaerospace.com/eflyer/
They intend to replace trainer aircraft that burn leaded aviation gasoline. This polluting niche fuel costs significantly more than kerosene. Maybe the economics can work out for this case.
Additionally 1st gen biofuels have poisoned the well to some extent due to competing with food crops.
For your comparison between ICE and electric vehicles, are you counting the fuel processing and delivery infrastructure? Electric delivery infrastructure has very low emissions once it's in place, and production continues to get better (especially with distributed models like rooftop solar). Also, do you have a citation for "...lower energy requirements for building ICE cars versus batteries"? Yes, battery production is fairly intensive (economically and resource use), but (like I said above) the drivetrain is vastly simpler.
I can't see how electric general aviation will become widespread without a monumental breakthrough. But it's hard to beat electric for ground-based transportation, IMHO.
https://www.carbonbrief.org/factcheck-how-electric-vehicles-...
Check out the "lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions" figures. It's really interesting in how it shows how different the total emissions are depending on which country you charge your electric car in. Also, depending on which electric car model you have, the lifecycle emission improvement over a conventional one might be relatively slim, depending on where and how much you drive it.
By and large, electrics are at a substantial disadvantage due to both battery production and fuel cycle emissions, which then gets compensated over time as you drive the car.
Edit: There's also this super interesting article on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_aspects_of_the_e... which is largely consistent with the Carbonbrief article.
Lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions for conventional and electric vehicles (by country) in grammes CO2-equivalent per kilometre, assuming 150,000 kilometres driven over the vehicle lifetime.
That's less than 100,000 miles - rarely do cars travel less than that during their lifetime.
Specifically in my country that would mean using the car for ~10 years, meanwhile the average passenger vehicle age is 14 years!
As for biofuels: land and water usage are major hindrances. For example you need ~1800 liters of water to grow 1kg of soybean. Sure, you can use waste products for fuels, but they need to be waste from something.
One nice thing about electricity is that it's much cheaper than biofuels. This is because motors are much more efficient than engines, and because large generating stations are more efficient than small aircraft engines. BC is 95% hydroelectric which makes electricity even cheaper.
I think the problems are more economics than physics. There was a huge investment in algal biofuels but it never proved economic. (eg https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/lessons-from-th...)
I was a fan of Algenol for a while who were supposed to have algae that gave off ethanol cheaper than normal fossil fuel but it never worked out. Maybe something like that in the future will work.
Biofuels make sense I think for aviation because you need that energy density to get a usable range, but the fuel is likely to be expensive for a long time. If you can figure out how to make liquid fuel for about fifty cents a gallon or so, it might be competitive with electricity for car use.
I don't know what the energy requirements are for modern batteries, but I expect it varies a lot depending on battery chemistry. Battery sizes vary a lot, too.
What's the GHG emissions for the different types of biofuels ? What's the land use needed ? How abundant ? Etc.
Short answer: Monied interests don't really care, or don't think it is possible or feasible.
How efficient is producing biofuels using renewable energy as a way of storing power long term?
By contrast, biofuels are available today and can be made from agricultural waste products (2nd gen), in bioreactors using salt water algae (3rd gen) or electrochemically (4th gen).
They're potentially a drop in replacement for regular fuel - for planes, but also for cars.
Due to the lower energy requirements for building ICE cars versus batteries, a biofuel powered car will be much better for CO2 emissions than an electric one, which you need to drive for many years before it beats a similar sized gasoline fueled car on sum CO2 emissions.
So why are we not heavily investing in biofuel infrastructure? Why are electric motors and batteries hyped up as being the tech of the future? That's an honest question, since I've yet to hear a well-founded physical or engineering argument against it.