What's driving the emphasis on lightweight batteries for aviation over better synthesisation?
- Extremely long flight endurance without refueling (in large solar/battery UAVs)
- Low noise
- Odorless
- Simpler and cheaper manufacturing
The advantages are much less obvious to me for aircraft that transport passengers or significant cargo loads. I suppose that the companies developing them are hoping to make the lifetime total cost of operation cheaper than existing aircraft serving the same niche. That seems much tougher to achieve.
EDIT: Bye Aerospace, the company described in the IEEE article, says they are targeting a particular niche:
https://byeaerospace.com/eflyer/
They intend to replace trainer aircraft that burn leaded aviation gasoline. This polluting niche fuel costs significantly more than kerosene. Maybe the economics can work out for this case.
Hydrogenate CO2 to methanol with electrolytic hydrogen produced from clean electricity [1]. Reform methanol to hydrocarbons [2] that can burn in existing engines. (Or burn methanol itself in slightly modified engines. This offers somewhat lower energy density per tankful of fuel, higher total efficiency from electricity-to-motion.)
Synthetic fuel makes sense for fueling aircraft, rockets, long distance shipping, collectible historic cars, and other niches. It doesn't make sense for fueling everyday ground transportation. Too much of the original energy is lost in the chain of chemical transformations and the chemical processing requires facilities on the scale of conventional oil refineries. The total cost is lower to electrify ground transportation and supply it with clean electricity than to transform clean electricity into liquid fuels for equivalent legacy vehicles.
[1] https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fchem.2018.0044...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_to_liquids