Not a math teacher, but I had a boss once when i was younger who constantly would tell me I only did a 99% job. I worked too fast and didn't finish the last little things. It pissed me off every time. He wasn't really that nice about it. He was a pretty blunt and straightforward kinda guy.
He was right though and it took a while but I eventually noticed that I did exactly what he said I was doing and it did impact things I did. Since I realized that, I hear is voice now telling me this before I think I've finished everything I'm doing and inevitably I find something I missed or didn't finish properly. In the end his blunt delivery of information and reasonable criticism did sink in and I feel like my attention to detail has improved because of it on anything I work on now.
For the unversed, my family's dinners can come off as abrasive. The reality is we just enjoy talking to each other in an uncivilized manner.
I think your argument conflates "there exist" and "forall" - certainly, there exist people that simultaneously demand niceness and are incapable of processing mean messages. But that's definitely not true for everyone.
So you can believe that people should try to grasp any valid meaning behind a mean message, and also believe that people should be kind.
The first thing GP suggests is that communicating a message more 'nicely' means more people will listen. So I'm not sure what your point is here independent of what GP has already written.
I suspect GP is emphasizing the importance of stomaching meanness because that's the harder (and more rewarding) thing to accomplish. It takes some effort to phrase and intone things more gently. But it takes a lot more effort to unlearn your own rapid emotional responses to someone else's tone... And successfully doing so is like having a superpower in social interactions. It starts to seem like everyone is driving drunk with respect to their own emotions: reacting instinctively when emotions are so strong that they drown out or dulled down all the other information.
> People often have good reasons for being mean, they could be tired, hungry, depressed or just spoke without thinking, those are really bad reasons for not listening if the actual message is sound.
How do you know if "the message is sound"? This actually has me thinking that it's an adaptive trait to pay more attention to people who have the energy to spare some kindness for others. Because clearly they're doing something well enough to either not feel tired/hungry/depressed or well enough to still have the energy to consider other people despite feeling any of those things.
> The meaner messages you can stomach the more information is accessible to you.
• From the receiver's view:
Meanness implies conflict. It evokes threat, defense, flight.
Those are instinctive responses to an intent of attack. Suppressing those requires non-zero effort.
• On the other hand, from the mean person's view:
They are experiencing impatience or frustration with something they want to change.
Suppressing that requires non-zero effort.
It all comes down to who can put more effort into suppressing their instinctual responses at a given moment.
Tl;dr human interactions are complex and require emotional and situational awareness to maximize effectiveness.
If I recently spoke to someone Harmfully Harsh, I will not be receptive to someone who is being Beneficially Harsh.
You cannot know the internal state of someone, so it does no harm to take that into consideration when interacting with them.
Put your complaints in the form of a question. People will use whatever internal dialog they are comfortable with to unpack it in their own heads.
Doesn't work on everyone. There's a couple engineers at every job who will happily answer questions about their Rube Goldberg machines as if they were innocent questions instead of an invitation to be introspective.
Questions like, "How can we have an audit trail for this solution, in case we have to diagnose problems?" demand an answer.
"This is a stupid idea and let me tell you why." invites a rebuttal, not a compromise or a re-think.
I can’t help it...
Also disrespect goes both ways. For many people, using "mean words" (e.g. "this is terribly wrong", "what a stupid mistake") is being disrespectful and offensive. For many experts, being incompetent or making repeated mistakes in your work is being disrespectful and offensive.
Meanwhile, if a tool we use or code I wrote is frustrating to use, I call a spade a spade. So then people open up about other stuff that bugs them. I hear everyone's fears and frustrations. I hear how bits of the code make people feel stupid. On other jobs I've gone out of my way to fix these problems. Often this doesn't impress your bosses (especially the bad ones) but it gets you plenty of respect from your peers and subordinates.
This particular system is such a Gordeon Knot that it's taken me years to see daylight. It's almost time for a new job and the code has just gotten to a place I wish it had been in on day 1.
That is called fragile. It isn't genetic, but it is socially reinforced. I suspect people who suffer from fragility are more prone to depression and anxiety.
> Everyone is conservative about what he knows best.
This is the base case. I understand that there are more extreme cases where you "win" in some specific ways if you keep stomaching mean speech.
Most of the evidence I see directly contradicts this. The most successful people I know are generally very nice, but can turn on the assholishness very tactically.
People don't remember Feynman's O-ring demonstration because it was nice, they remember it because it was a nasty takedown in spite of it not being strictly correct.
After 30+ years, my father could get most misbehaving high school students to stop with just a quip that embarrassed them in front of their peers. That may have pissed off the student, but it was less disruptive to both class and the student than having to stop class, send the student to the administration, and invoke overzealous cover-your-ass administration punishment.
In most successful projects I have been involved with, a single person dragged it's bleeding, broken corpse across the finish line. And, I assure you, they weren't always being very nice at the end--generally justifiably so to people in the way.
And, being nice in politics got us where we are today--a resurgent set of right-wing demagogues in multiple countries.
Sorry, just not seeing it. I"m not saying "You should always be a raging asshole," but I see precious little evidence that being the "nicer" person turns out better in the long run.
Game theory, in fact, prefers tit-for-tat, no? Be nice and forgive, but do punish those who deserve it.
I have a manager's manager that's great to talk to, and one of his stated talents is he can "take a passive-aggressive situation and remove the passive component quickly and effectively". He's great.
Shallow politeness may vary well lead to shallow politics, but empathy and actually being kind to other people is quite different in its outcomes.
Only if you are demanding that others are nice to you. You should demand that others are nice to others.
Also, I would bet that your perception of the meanness of messages changes over time as you restrict yourself to inoffensive ones, with your personal overton window for what offends you shrinking.
The nicer you state your messages the more people will listen to you.
The meaner messages you can stomach the more information is accessible to you.
So we'd expect those who demand others to be nice to be less well informed than those who can tolerate mean communication. For example, a person who thinks their math teacher is mean when the teacher corrects them will probably never become great at math. I believe that this is an aspect of communication we need to talk way more about, since large parts of the population are currently handicapped like this.
I'm not sure if it is genetic, but if it can be taught then we ought to tell our kids to listen to everyone and not just what feels comfortable. Fill your kids heads with statements like "It was a bit mean, but he is right, you should really try to do FOO". People often have good reasons for being mean, they could be tired, hungry, depressed or just spoke without thinking, those are really bad reasons for not listening if the actual message is sound.