News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by Despegar on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:19PM (#21457907)
The Eurozone is fatally flawed because they share a currency but have no transfer payments between rich and poor members. So you have countries like Germany that are effectively subsidized by poorer countries.

It's been a great setup for 20 years if you've been in the German capital class, not so great for anyone else.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by Reason077 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @07:35PM (#21458562)
> “The Eurozone is fatally flawed because they share a currency but have no transfer payments between rich and poor members.”

This is incorrect. The EU has substantial transfer payments. Wealthier EU countries (like Germany) subsidise poorer ones (like Poland) on the order of tens of billions of Euros annually.

Regional development (subsidies for poorer areas) is the second largest EU budget line item after agriculture.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-48256318

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by malloryerik on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:51PM (#21458974)
At the same time the euro gives Germany a benefit much greater than inter-EU German transfer payments. By greatly weakening the euro, the zone's fiscally-challenged countries pull open the gates for German exports which roar out of the Europe with significantly lowered sticker prices in other currencies. It appears to be a massive benefit since one can easily imagine a uniquely German currency being 30% higher. Now that's a bargain.

What's more, Germany may even have a built-in advantage datinng back to the inception of the euro, when the Deutsche Mark was brought into the union at what many believe was about a 6% undervalued rate. "Updated IMF data suggests that by 2017 the German pricing edge built into the euro had about doubled to over 12%."[1]

https://www.forbes.com/sites/miltonezrati/2018/01/23/the-ger...

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by peteretep on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @11:28PM (#21459708)
Germany paid net €12bn. California has net federal tax receipts of $450bn. Not identical types of figures, but comparing the tiny transfer payments in the EU to the gigantic ones in real financial unions is where the difference lies.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by Reason077 on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:21AM (#21463397)
> "Germany paid net €12bn. California has net federal tax receipts of $450bn"

It is meaningless to compare a net transfer to gross tax receipts. California's large, wealthy population generates high federal tax receipts, but it's net contribution is actually negative because the federal government currently spends more in California than it receives in taxes.

Source: https://www.governing.com/week-in-finance/gov-taxpayers-10-s...

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by WillySchu on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:26PM (#21466096)
It's pretty unlikely that this is still the case. The article you link to appears to be citing a 2017 report which itself uses data from FY2015[1]. This means that it doesn't take into account the 2017 federal tax overhaul which, among other things, capped deductions for state and local taxes paid. This means high tax high income states will almost certainly be paying more in federal taxes. Unfortunately, I don't think the data is available to confirm or refute this yet.

[1]: https://rockinst.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/2017-09-28_B...

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by OscarTheGrinch on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:17AM (#21460891)
Pretty sure that billions in Europe have three extra zeros.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by opless on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:01AM (#21461385)
Not when it comes to finance.

Everyone appears to use the short billion these days, and it caused me significant cognitive dissonance!

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by mcv on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:27AM (#21462878)
I think everybody here is talking about US-size billions, not European-size billions.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by Despegar on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @07:55PM (#21458677)
How much each member contributes to the EU budget is a drop in the bucket compared to the transfer payments I'm talking about (healthcare, social security, defense).

The Eurozone should either go all the way like the US, or they should scrap the currency union. This halfway step only serves the wealthy.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by _visgean on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:03PM (#21458723)
Not true at all. I am from Czech republic and we benefited massively from these contributions. If I compare for example general state of infrastructure it is much better than in UK where I currently reside. All the train stations were rebuilt using EU funds. Also not sure what you are talking about "This halfway step only serves the wealthy.", not not really. Look at quality of life and GDP rise in post soviet EU countries.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by Despegar on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:21PM (#21458831)
The Czech Republic isn't in the Eurozone and doesn't face the structural disadvantages that Greece or Portugal do.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by _delirium on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:32PM (#21458891)
The Czech Republic definitely shows one way to approach the EU: get the transfer payments from a political union and partial economic union (in trade policy, etc.), as well as remittances from emigrants employed elsewhere in the free-movement zone, but retain an independent floating currency and avoid monetary union. Greece would've been in a considerably different position if they had taken the Czech route and stayed out of the Euro. Arguably a better position, though that's not something all economists agree on. Certainly a different one, at any rate.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by eru on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:33AM (#21460470)
See https://marketmonetarist.com/2015/07/14/the-euro-a-monetary-... for the importance of a floating currency. (Or rather, the importance of not joining nor pegging to the Euro. Other currencies might not be as toxic?)
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by mcv on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:32AM (#21462922)
So the transfer payment are not part of the Eurozone, but part of the EU. That makes Eurozone membership a problem for weaker economies like Greece.

On the other hand, Slowakia and Ireland are part of the Eurozone and are doing very well despite starting out poor. (Maybe Ireland doesn't fit here, because they've been doing very well since long before the Euro.)

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by _visgean on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @09:11PM (#21459052)
Well you are talking about EU budget. If you look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_the_European_Union#E... its clear that both Greece and Portugal receive higher contributions then Czech republic. Also I am not sure what structural disadvantages you are looking at. Look at Slovakia that is in Eurozone and benefited massively.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by phicoh on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:43AM (#21461024)
At the introduction of the Euro, many were quite concerned about Greece joining.

The EU consists of independent, co-operating countries. This is quite different from the US. There is very little the EU can do without votes from the individual countries.

So the assumption is that a country that joins the Euro has carefully evaluated the pros and cons. At the same time, the amount of subsidies a country receives is not dependant on that country being part of the Euro-zone or not.

If you look at the Euro at the time of introduction, then there was every intent to make Euro as strong and stable as the Deutche Mark. Very much so against the wishes of France, who wanted a currency that was way more subject to political control.

Of course, one incentive for countries to adopt the Euro was exactly was the article is about: a small currency stands no chance against investors speculating against it. Better hide in a big currency.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by zajio1am on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:51AM (#21461616)
Slovakia was in similar position to Czechia, but joined Eurozone in 2009. From that time, it has similar or better GDP growth than Czechia.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by op00to on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:03PM (#21458724)
> halfway step only serves the wealthy

How?

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by bildung on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @03:37AM (#21460696)
(Warning: Armchair economist!)

Poorer countries in general have lower productivity (possible causes can be lacking infrastructure (roads, electricity, telecom, but also regulations etc.), lacking capital, lacking foresight/lacking capital to invest in future tech by the governement (e.g. broadband internet)).

This results - despite lower wages! - in higher unit labor costs.

If you form a monetary union with poorer and richer countries (like the EU), you have problem. The richer countries, despite higher absolute wages, will have lower unit labor costs. The richer countries can therefore expand exports at the cost of domestic production in the poorer countries (e.g. Germany vs. rest of EU).

If the poorer country wouldn't be part of the union, it could (among other things) lower the value of its own currency (or the forex markets would do that). Lower-valued domestic currency assists exports, which levels competition with the richer countries a bit.

This doesn't mean that there are no alternatives inside the current EU! They just haven't been implemented yet. Options would be

* way higher minimum wages in the rich countries (Germany was one of the last countries in Europe to implement them)

* implementing less union-hostile laws in the richer countries (resulting again in higher wages, but also for higher income groups not affected by minimum wage)

* More infrastructure investments in the poorer countries (there already are significant transfers, but more would help)

* A unified fiscal strategy. After implementation of the Euro zone, there were massive capital inflows into the poorer countries, resulting in overvaluation of the local economy. This was a big reason for the local problems of the last decade [1]

[1] https://streetlightblog.blogspot.com/2011/09/what-really-cau...

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by phicoh on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:59AM (#21461109)
Higher minimum wages to solve imbalances in the Euro-zone would probably result in a disaster.

In areas where countries like Germany directly compete with poorer countries, they do so by having more and better automation. Productivity is not that people work harder, is it that there are more machines to do the work.

The net effect of raising wages is that there will be more automation, largely negating the increase in wages. By it self this is not a problem.

Where is goes wrong is that within a country, there are many jobs that cannot be automated easily. In particular, with an aging population, you need lots of nurses and other care takers.

Increasing minimum wages with sole goal of reducing export imbalance can make those cost go through the roof, and generally lower the standard of living for a large part of the population.

Reducing the cost of 'care' and other jobs that dependent on personal service, is already very important to improve the standard of living.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by bildung on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @05:26AM (#21461224)
Not disagreeing that poorer economies need more automation.

But when looking at countries it is very important to not only look at wages as cost. Especially in Germany the low wages result in low domestic demand, which results in the country being a net exporter again and again.

Rising wages, especially minimum wages, are mostly spent domestically on services (think going to the hairdresser instead of cutting your own hair, or finally using healthcare as needed).

Germany was a wonderful field experiment for exactly this in the last years, as it was one of the two countries out of 27 European countries not having minimum wage laws. After implementing minimum wage (starting at 7€ something, now at 9.20€/h) pretty much zero job loss could be observed, depending on market segment quite the opposite. Because wages are not only costs, but also create demand.

In Germany, the lower 60%(!) of the population only hold 3% of the wealth. In other words: Almost every € earned gets spent on consumption. If those people earn more money, they spend more money, thus creating demand.

Automation is a real thing, but then again what gets automated aren't those low wage jobs in the service economy - it's mostly work in higher income brackets. And the automation can result in severe disruption in local market segments, but overall it doesn't result in less employment - see yearly productivity growth and employment rates of most industrialized economies. Just look at the United States, which currently has nearly full employment despite currently being the world center of (software) automation.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by MagnumOpus on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:46AM (#21464268)
> one of the two countries out of 27 European countries not having minimum wage laws [...] zero job loss could be observed

Even before minimum wages, Germany has very high sector-level minimum wage due to union tarrifs that are binding for non-union employees. Job losses were negligible because the number of people that have been affected by the minimum wage was rather small.

> the lower 60% of the population only hold 3% of the wealth.

Germany has state pensions that you can live on comfortably, and renter-friendly housing laws. So people don't need to own a house as a retirement plan (unlike much of the rest of the world).

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by bildung on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @01:51PM (#21465686)
> Even before minimum wages, Germany has very high sector-level minimum wage due to union tarrifs that are binding for non-union employees.

True! Those were for the "high-paying" low wage jobs, though - mostly in construction. Gastronomy, hotel industry, haircutters etc. didn't have those. Wage laws in construction mosty were already at more than 9€/h before country-wide minimum wages were implemented.

I can't really agree on that being the reason for no observed loss of jobs though - there are too many other examples of successful minimum wage laws in other regions where the feared job losses failed to materialize, too [1].

>> the lower 60% of the population only hold 3% of the wealth.

> Germany has state pensions that you can live on comfortably, and renter-friendly housing laws. So people don't need to own a house as a retirement plan (unlike much of the rest of the world).

Yes, my angle was a bit different, though: As middle class and upper class earn more, they can afford to save more. Saving, though, does mean that the money saved doesn't take part in the economy anymore (or at least to a lesser degree).

If a low-wage person gets lets say 100€ more per month, that money will get spent almost completely at places like groceries, haircutters etc. - places that also have relatively low wages, which means those people will also spend the money completely and so on. A rise in minimum wages gets you the most bang for the buck, if your goal is stimulation of domestic demand.

[1] As one example New Jersey in the US: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/17/opinion/paul-krugman-libe...

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by zajio1am on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:47AM (#21461597)
> This is incorrect. The EU has substantial transfer payments.

Size of EU budget is about 1 % of EU GDP, so these transfer payments are likely inconsequential as a fiscal mechanism.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by skokage on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:55PM (#21458261)
>So you have countries like Germany that are effectively subsidized by poorer countries.

Could you explain this comment further, or have links to stories that go in depth on how that works? Not saying you are wrong, but I don't understand how germany, which is an economic powerhouse and exports a lot of goods, are being subsidized by poorer countries.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by wheels on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @07:03PM (#21458326)
The gist of it is that if Germany were still on the Mark, then the Mark would be significantly stronger than the Euro is today. Having weaker economies on the same currency causes Germany's currency to be artificially weak, which makes its exports artificially cheap on the world market. In contrast, the poorer Eurozone countries have an artificially strong currency, which makes their exports more expensive than they would be if they had their own free floating currency.

There are some transfer mechanisms from rich to poor Eurozone countries, but they're nothing anywhere close to the scale of e.g. the US federal government.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by p1necone on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:01PM (#21458709)
Even though it's the same currency, wouldn't the buying power and cost of living be higher and lower respectively in the poorer countries and somewhat balance it out? Separate currencies are just an abstraction - what really matters in the local economy would be things like the cost of wages or the cost of living expenses.

Edit: _delerium answered my question pretty well in a reply to another commenter.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by lol_wut on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:13PM (#21458787)
how is having an artificially weak currency a subsidy to Germany? isn't that like underpricing their goods? and wouldn't that imply that countries who import German goods are being subsidized, because they are able to get German goods at artificially low prices?

also can you suggest a place where I could read more about this? its awfully confusing, and somewhat counter-intuitive and it would be helpful to read where someone has presented this idea in a paper or article or something.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by Analemma_ on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:39PM (#21458922)
I don't like how you're being downvoted for asking a legitimate question in apparent good-faith. This idea can be genuinely counterintuitive the first time you encounter it.

The issue is that, normally when a country with its own currency is economically uncompetitive, its currency weakens, which helps give a boost to domestic industry by making their exports cheaper than those of richer nations. So there's a natural corrective function to economic fragility that helps these countries get back on their feet. The Eurozone breaks that corrective mechanism: without the Euro, right now e.g. Greece would have a weak currency and Germany a much stronger one, which would help Greek industry because their products would be cheaper than Germany's. But since they're all using the Euro, Greece can't get any kind of comparative economic advantage.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by _delirium on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:44PM (#21458940)
To add to this, one of the parts that's counterintuitive is that in principle currencies are just accounting mechanisms, so you can achieve the same effects in a currency union. The problem is that it requires a lot more coordination. When you devalue a currency, a bunch of things in the country move together: wages go down in external terms (e.g. $ or € denominated terms), but housing costs, domestic service prices, etc., all move together, because they're denominated in the same local currency. So the currency has become worth fewer dollars or euros, but the ratio between wages and rents in local currency is unchanged, so people can still in the immediate future pay their rent out of their wages, the same as before.

To accomplish the same without an independent currency requires managing this movement in nominal terms. If the problem is that the country is basically broke or uncompetitive, and needs to solve this by "getting cheaper" compared to other countries, everything in the country has to get cheaper simultaneously. Wages have to go down in €, housing has to go down in €, etc., and this all has to happen in a coordinated way so everyone can still pay their now-lower rent with their now-lower wages, and so on. Economists call this "internal devaluation", i.e. achieving the same effects as a currency devaluation while not having a separate currency, by just lowering actual prices for everything.

The consensus seems to be that it's difficult to pull this off successfully, and really good positive examples are rare. It's complicated by just the general difficulty of coordination, as well as longer-term contracts (e.g. most people's rent and wages don't get renegotiated monthly). Greece has been sort of doing this through consistent single-digit deflation, but it draws it out over a long period. Many (though not all) economists think the result is worse than an all-at-once currency devaluation would've been.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by knzhou on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:25AM (#21460435)
This is the clearest explanation of this topic I've ever seen -- my sticking point has always been exactly what you just explained. Is there a good place to get more macroeconomic explanations like this?
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by StanislavPetrov on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:32AM (#21460459)
Not only that but when when a country issues their own currency and controls their own finances they control the level of debt they want to take on in a crisis, and aren't bound by the Eurozone.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by wheels on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @09:05PM (#21459024)
I read this long essay, "Germany Must Lead or Leave", by Soros himself, seven years ago when it first came out:

https://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/george-soros-on-...

My memory of such isn't perfect, and I won't reread all dozen-ish pages for the sake of an HN comment, but I remember it covering some of the issues of Eurozone integration, and seems very topical given this thread is about Soros.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by mcv on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @09:48AM (#21463074)
> "wouldn't that imply that countries who import German goods are being subsidized, because they are able to get German goods at artificially low prices?"

Yes, and that makes German products more attractive, boosting German exports. Germany gets a boost to their export, at the cost of importing at higher prices. Because Greece's currency is artificially boosted, they can import relatively cheaply, but they have trouble exporting because their exports are too expensive, so money is leaving the country.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by kaonashi on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:29PM (#21467576)
https://www.lrb.co.uk/v14/n19/wynne-godley/maastricht-and-al...

>If a country or region has no power to devalue, and if it is not the beneficiary of a system of fiscal equalisation, then there is nothing to stop it suffering a process of cumulative and terminal decline leading, in the end, to emigration as the only alternative to poverty or starvation.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by raxxorrax on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:50AM (#21460528)
For the average German it is plain and simple not an advantage. Maybe if the export bonuses keep the company you are working for alive, but that is a unrealistic edge case.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by wheels on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @03:26AM (#21460656)
That's false. I'll give you a very easy example of how it's benefited me (and many, many Germans):

I sell SaaS software on a subscription basis to customers all over the world. They pay for our service in USD, which is then converted to EUR when I get paid from the company.

If the Euro was stronger, which it would be if it were only the currency for Germany, I'd get less Euro when that conversion happened, and I'd have less local currency for things like rent, groceries, etc. The Euro being artificially depressed against USD absolutely benefits anyone who either personally or via their company exports products, including stuff like SaaS. Since exports are the backbone of the German economy, it has a very concrete benefit to most Germans. Greece's economic problems literally mean I get more cash.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by martinlaz on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:22AM (#21460915)
> If the Euro was stronger, which it would be if it were only the currency for Germany, I'd get less Euro when that conversion happened, and I'd have less local currency for things like rent, groceries, etc.

But wouldn't you be able to still buy exactly the same stuff with less (but stronger) Euros?

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by wheels on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:44AM (#21461029)
No. My rent won't go down in Euro just because the Euro is strong. The strength or weakness of a currency mostly dictates how it interacts with goods and services from outside of its currency zone. So I might be able to buy more consumer electronics (which mostly aren't produced in Germany) with a strong Euro, but rent, milk, bread, which are internal to Germany, will stay approximately the same in their Euro denomination.

This is true in most places without particularly volatile currencies, though in countries that do have very volatile currencies, things like rent have historically been specified in stable currencies like US Dollars, Deutsche Mark or Euro.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by martinlaz on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @07:16AM (#21461735)
The point is that these extra Euros, if they were any significant amount, in the local market would drive the demand for goods up, along with their prices. And then we'd be buying the same amount of stuff, just more expensive.

Surely things like rent take longer to reflect an increased demand but they do eventually catch up.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by raxxorrax on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:44AM (#21461032)
That is by far not the average situation. That would also mean that wages would increase when the Euro was introduced.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by rienbdj on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:07AM (#21460365)
Is this also true within a country? Does Wales (for example) pull down GBP for the benefit of the rest of the UK?
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by stephen_g on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:29AM (#21460447)
Usually not if you have a central/federal taxing and spending Government. That generally balances things out.

That's why this isn't as much a problem for the US as the EU.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by goodcanadian on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @07:10PM (#21458388)
I don't necessarily agree with the grandparent comment, but I think the mechanism at work is exchange rates. Because of the strong German economy (for example), if Germany still had a separate currency, that currency would be much more expensive than the Euro currently is thus making German exports more expensive. Conversely, the Italian Lira would be much cheaper making their exports relatively cheap. An argument can be made that the Euro therefore benefits the richer countries at the expense of the poorer ones.

There are other factors at play, of course, and I think that a complete analysis would defy any simplistic explanation. Compare to the US dollar: does New York benefit from a common currency at the expense of Louisiana?

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by mattmanser on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @07:44PM (#21458614)
Not entirely, as federal dollars pay for army bases, manufacturing projects, etc. across the country, resulting in significant redistribution of wealth.

The EU has far, far less tax income, and for the last 10 years been spending all that money on the new entrants instead of Greece, Spain or Italy as it did pre-EU27. (And I would argue of course they should spend the money there for the greatest good).

So there's no redistribution through tax, and Germany benefits from a much weaker currency, while struggling countries can't use currency controls to kick start their trade.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by lanevorockz on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @07:15PM (#21458427)
Very simple, open markets means that products from Germany can flood other markets. This kills any national business and creating a dependency to Germany. Money flows in one direction.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by eru on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @02:31AM (#21460452)
I agree that the Euro is flawed, but I don't think your reasons are right.

Other commenters point out that there's some transfer payments in the EU, a superset of the Euro zone.

Also around the world you have other currency unions that don't involve transfers and that are doing just fine. Eg Hong Kong effectively uses the USD. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_substitution for some more background.

And, of course, Scotland, Canada and Australia were doing just fine on the gold standard in the 18th and 19th centuries; without any fiscal transfers between countries in the gold block. (I explicitly mention those countries, and not eg the US or England for specific reasons. I also explicitly not mention the interwar gold standard.)

See https://marketmonetarist.com/2015/07/14/the-euro-a-monetary-... for an empiric demonstration of the Euro's flaws. And https://marketmonetarist.com/2015/07/19/the-euro-a-fiscal-st... for a follow up.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by riffraff on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @03:59AM (#21460796)
The currency union in this case is paired with lack of tariffs and free movement of capital and goods, which is not the case for Hong Kong and the US, nor was the case in the 19th century Australia and Canada.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by eru on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @04:11AM (#21460864)
Good points. Though to be honest, the EU has plenty of de-facto restrictions on free trade in services.

(Unilateral) free trade was a pretty popular policy back then.

In practice, the decrease in transportation costs we have today dwarfs the difference in tariffs.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by PeterisP on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:36PM (#21458084)
The majority of EU budget consists of programs such as the common agricultural policy, ERDF and other infrastructure funding which are de facto transfer payments to improve and sustain poorer areas.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by Despegar on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:44PM (#21458150)
Until German taxpayers are financing universal healthcare and pensions for Greeks and Italians, those things are marginal at best.
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by richardknop on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:54PM (#21458252)
Correct me if I’m wrong but isn’t majority of agricultural funding going to France, Germany etc, the wealthy members?
Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by PeterisP on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @07:08PM (#21458371)
Well, they're both the largest recipients and the largest contributors because they're the largest and most populous countries.

However, France and Germany contribute significantly more than they receive, and poorer regions receive significantly more than they contribute, so that's effectively a transfer mechanism.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by barrkel on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:06PM (#21458747)
There is no fiscal union, but there certainly are transfer payments done on a regional (not national) level; i.e. a region of a country (or the whole country, if it is particularly poor) can access EU funds for infrastructure and the like.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Regional_Developmen...

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by Zenst on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @07:26PM (#21458506)
>but have no transfer payments between rich and poor members

You do if you count open free trade, least that is the ideology. Though the reality is very disproportional and for countries able and in a position to leverage that, did very well.

So you get some countries doing better than others, how do you balance that out. Well, with a membership fee based upon how well the individual member is doing in relation to other members and using most of that fee to invest in those countries doing less well.

Which seems a simple and fair way. At least on paper when they signed it all off it did.

I will say though, I've always worried about the aggressive QE usage by the ECB. Whilst great for exports, it has equally impacted imports. This with most consumer tech being imported, then it would be more advantages to companies that export outside the EU to have QE keeping the Euro from racing ahead than for importers.

Hence countries with a dominant export outside the EU, have done rather well out of QE and those importing, equally less so.

But then, how QE is not counted as currency manipulation is beyond me.

Re:When George Soros Broke the British Pound (2014) by arbitrary_name on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @11:37PM (#21459742)
What? There are billions in direct transfers to poorer EU countries.

It has been great for millions of non-Western EU citizens.