News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by kilo_bravo_3 on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:00PM (#21400589)
The only reason Sparta lasted as long as it did was because it was a valueless minor city-state not worth the effort of conquering until the point that conquering and absorbing it was so effortless that it was done almost as an afterthought.

It was a sick and broken society populated by fanatics, that was quickly (on a historical timescale) out-advanced by its neighbors.

Imagine if a casino-less (Mormon Fort-era) Las Vegas, NV was full of militiamen and religious zealots and got involved in a war with the surrounding area and it managed conquer all of Clark County, the county that surrounds it, and control it for about 30 years by implementing a cruel system that enslaved most of its population.

And then that short-lived city-state collapsed after the rest of the Nevada developed over the decades to the point that a coalition of other small counties quickly steamrolled the now-decrepit and hollow Clark County city-state.

Like, super steamrolled. Like the rest of Nevada had developed tanks and artillery and the "Vegans" still fought with Mormon Fort-era weaponry.

That's Sparta.

I don't get why Sparta seems to be so fetishized, particularly by people who are not pleasant to be around.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by dang on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:27PM (#21402250)
Please don't post in the flamewar style to HN, and particularly please edit out flamebait, such as your last sentence.

If we can't discuss classical history without flamewar, we can't discuss anything without flamewar. Let's discuss things without flamewar.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by HeroOfAges on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @05:55PM (#21403253)
I don't see what was "flamewar style" about the grandparent post. Are you referring to the mention of "Vegans"? I took that to mean Vegans as in citizens of Las Vegas. People say Angelenos to refer to inhabitants of Los Angeles. I believe that was the spirit in which the reference to "Vegans" was intended.

edited to correct the spelling of Las Vegas

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by dang on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @07:06PM (#21403957)
Looking at it again I think I was reacting primarily to the last sentence.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by coldtea on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:10PM (#21400696)
>The only reason Sparta lasted as long as it did was because it was a valueless minor city-state not worth the effort of conquering until the point that conquering and absorbing it was so effortless that it was done almost as an afterthought.

Yeah, that's not even wrong.

Sparta was an important city-state, and survived centuries without being pushed around like others, even larger had. They also bossed lesser city-states around, and of course defeated Athens itself, while also being important for the defense against Persian invasions.

No city-state at the time (of which were dozens) would consider Sparta a "valueless minor city-state". The very opposite is true.

The rest of the comment (or rather, all of it) is irrelevant drivel, more a rant about modern day gun-freaks and rednecks and US issues, than about historical Sparta.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by kilo_bravo_3 on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:27PM (#21400886)
By what metric were they important?

Economic output?

Influence abroad?

Cultural contributions?

Trade hub?

A cultural impact that lasts to today that makes them important in retrospect?

A city-state conquering 21,000 square kilometers (roughly the same area of Clark County, NV, chosen purposefully for my example) of olive groves and poor towns on a peninsula that is almost completely surrounded by sea with no other major players doesn't make one important, in the big picture.

I mean, I know philosophers liked to wax... philosophically... about them, like they were the lost city of Atlantis or something, centuries after the slow and creaky absorption of the hellish nightmare that was a declining Sparta into their neighbors, but so what?

I don't know what your gun stuff was about.

edit: I can imagine all of the rulers of the ACTUALLY relevant kingdoms and empires that surrounded Sparta looking at a map that was all colored in except for Sparta and saying to their generals:

"You know what? We'll give it a try but even if we do conquer Sparta all we'll get is a bunch of olives, goats, and a whole bunch of whacked-out weirdos with no gold, no navy, and a lot of baggage. So commit but don't 'Commit' and if we lose we'll just wait them out and color in the entire map later when they inevitably collapse."

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by ARandomerDude on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:49PM (#21401114)
Your list of important-making features is dominated by a modern mindset. In the ancient world, ability to wage war was an important -- if not the important -- feature of many civilizations. Rome, Greece, Persia, Carthage, everybody was obsessed with it.

Looking at purely economics or modern cultural relevance is anachronistic.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by ethbro on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @03:33PM (#21401595)
In those times, the ability to project power (in a modern military sense) was virtually non-existent.

Aircraft hadn't been invented yet.

Naval transport was subject to the vagaries of the wind and slow.

Land transport was a matter of multi-year campaigns, supplied at great cost.

So effectively, most conflicts were the business of the belligerent and defender, and no one else.

In that world, absent coordinated international response, it's unsurprising military might took on a much more existential value!

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by marcusverus on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:07PM (#21401978)
"In those times, the ability to project power (in a modern military sense) was virtually non-existent."

This isn't really true. The contemporary Carthaginian and Roman empires spanned hundreds of miles of Mediterranean coastline.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by ethbro on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @05:40PM (#21403090)
The Carthaginian Empire expanded over ~400 years, and never penetrated far from coasts (per design, but also illustrating the limitations of transportation at that time).

The Roman Republic / Empire expanded over ~600 years.

We may have different definitions of "power projection."

Mine does not include "we'll eventually be there, after everyone who is alive today has lived a full life and died of natural causes."

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by marcusverus on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @07:06PM (#21403955)
You are confusing projecting power over a sphere of influence with expanding the sphere of influence within which one can project power. These empires ruled over vast areas of land by threat of force. That is projection of power. The fact that they later projected power over a larger area has no bearing on this.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by ethbro on Thursday October 31, 2019 @05:56PM (#21414144)
You're missing my point.

How much would the Japanese have cared about what Rome thought?

Vs now.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by notfromhere on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @05:14PM (#21402821)
Rome stretched from Scotland to Iraq and ruled the entire Mediterranean. So power projection still existed
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by nicwolff on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @05:10PM (#21402779)
Uh, international coordination was definitely a thing! There was a whole Delian League formed specifically to coordinate the city-states' response to the Persian invasion – Sparta's exit from the League precipitated the war with Athens.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by ethbro on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @05:25PM (#21402937)
Syria to Tunisia is ~2,300 km.

For reference, that's about the same distance from NY, NY to Houston, TX.

And that's the long axis of the Mediterranean Sea.

IMHO, that's very different than how we talk about international cooperation (and specifically: intervention) in modern times.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by rumanator on Thursday October 31, 2019 @03:14AM (#21406372)
> For reference, that's about the same distance from NY, NY to Houston, TX.

That's roughly the distance between Paris and Moscow, crossing through Belgium, Germany and Poland.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by astine on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:32PM (#21402315)
"Economic output?

Influence abroad?

Cultural contributions?

Trade hub?"

Yes, Yes, Obviously, and not as much.

At its height, Sparta was one of the more important military powers among the Greek city states. After the Peloponnesian war, which it won, it was for a time the dominant and most influential of all Greek city states. This dominance and influence is the reason that ancient Greek writers found them important to talk about and consequently is the reason we still talk about about them. The fact that we still debate the legacy of the Spartans speaks to the wide range of their influence.

""You know what? We'll give it a try but even if we do conquer Sparta all we'll get is a bunch of olives, goats, and a whole bunch of whacked-out weirdos with no gold, no navy, and a lot of baggage. So commit but don't 'Commit' and if we lose we'll just wait them out and color in the entire map later when they inevitably collapse." "

Actually, Sparta was quite wealthy if you measure it's wealth in productive farmland land rather than precious metals. We privileged modern westerners don't really recognize the importance of that, but it was quite important for the time.

Also, while the Spartans did not initially have a navy, they had no trouble buying one from the Persians and beat the previously unbeatable Athenian navy with it.

Olives were actually incredible valuable to the ancient Greeks (still are valuable, actually) one of the most important crops and essential to all of their industry. According to myth Athens was given the choice of naming their city after Athena or Poseidon. Athena offered olive trees while Poseidon offered naval power. The Athenians judged that olive trees would be more valuable.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by peterwwillis on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:30PM (#21400920)
Mainly they were economically and politically important. They were incredibly rich and had alliances with all neighboring city-states, using each alliance as leverage for more alliances. They didn't even need to send many of their own soldiers or slaves for any given war, their allies would send the bulk of the forces.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by paleotrope on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:05PM (#21400642)
Sparta is fetishized because they beat Athens in the Peloponnesian war and Plato idealized the spartans.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by coldtea on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:14PM (#21400733)
Sparta was considered important way before they "beat Athens". And it has nothing to do with Plato either.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by paleotrope on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @03:03PM (#21401280)
I don't believe I said that Sparta wasn't important in pre-Macedonian conquest greek politics or even that Sparta wasn't important as an idea in later philosophy and in the idea of governing.

Idealized and fetishized, yes, by those that see in Sparta something that they want in their own society. Even if most of it is dismally misguided. Plato, of course, loved spartan society and based his own utopian ideal state on it and Plato has an outsized reputation in history by his writings and his characterization of his teacher, Socrates (who wrote nothing).

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by astine on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:44PM (#21402468)
Nah, Corinth was considered important too, but Sparta is much better known in the modern world.

And Plato is pretty important here. Sparta gets relatively high praise in the Republic which is probably one of the more influential books from its era. Platonism's enormous influence on Christianity ensured that this praise would remain relevant even into the modern era.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by lolinder on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:46PM (#21401082)
Can you provide a source or an alternative point of origin for Sparta's importance? You've stated categorically that the parent is misinformed, but provided no information to back it up.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by coldtea on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @03:11PM (#21401378)
Why, are the claims controversial? They're backed by 2+ millenia of historiography.

Just off of the easiest sources available on the web:

Given its military pre-eminence, Sparta was recognized as the leading force of the unified Greek military during the Greco-Persian Wars, in rivalry with the rising naval power of Athens. Sparta was the principal enemy of Athens during the Peloponnesian War (between 431 and 404 BC), from which it emerged victorious. (...) Sparta was the subject of fascination in its own day, as well as in Western culture following the revival of classical learning. (...) In ancient times "Many of the noblest and best of the Athenians always considered the Spartan state nearly as an ideal theory realised in practice." Many Greek philosophers, especially Platonists, would often describe Sparta as an ideal state, strong, brave, and free from the corruptions of commerce and money. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sparta

Sparta was one of the most important Greek city-states throughout the Archaic and Classical periods and was famous for its military prowess. The professional and well-trained Spartan hoplites with their distinctive red cloaks, long hair, and lambda-emblazoned shields were probably the best and most feared fighters in Greece, fighting with distinction at such key battles as Thermopylae and Plataea in the early 5th century BCE. https://www.ancient.eu/sparta/

During the 5th century BC Sparta was very powerful. This was due to her army, which was feared by other Greeks. Sparta focused on producing good soldiers and all Spartan male citizens were part of the army. The Spartan army played an important role in the Greek victory over the Persians, in 480-479 BC. http://www.ancientgreece.co.uk/sparta/home_set.html

The Athenian view of Sparta oscillated between admiration and fear, according to whether their warlike neighbors were allies or enemies. Without Spartan participation in the war against Persia at the beginning of the fifth century B.C.— especially their heroic stand at the critical Battle of Thermopylae in 480—the Persians may well have conquered Greece. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/magazine/2016/11-...

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by kieranmaine on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:57PM (#21401223)
I always thought the Spartans came to prominence in this war - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greco-Persian_Wars
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by hodgesrm on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:09PM (#21400688)
There was also that little skirmish at Thermopylae that helped grow the legend.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by lolinder on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:55PM (#21401192)
I'd argue that the mythology surrounding Thermopylae is the result of the mythology surrounding Sparta, rather than the other way around. Objectively, Thermopylae was an abject defeat (even by Herodotus's account) that didn't do anything to save Greece from Persia conquering basically everything. The only reason it's more than a historical footnote is because of the Spartan legend.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by cafard on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @03:03PM (#21401279)
It was a holding action that gave the Greeks time to consolidate further back, no? And really, quite number of holding actions and retreats have achieved considerable fame. Among the retreats I'd mention the Anabasis, Sir John Moore's retreat on Corunna, the Long March, Dunkirk, and Stillwell's retreat to Burma.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by nidificate on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:09PM (#21402006)
> Spartan planning is both direct and unrealistic: find a choke-point, fortify it and hold it indefinately with a hoplite army. Attempted at Thermopylae this plan fails; the Battle of Thermopylae is often represented in popular culture as an intentional delaying action, but it was nothing of the sort – Herodotus is clear that this was supposed to be the decisive land engagement (Hdt. 7.175; Cf. Diodorus 11.4.1-5).
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by dr_dshiv on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:53PM (#21402566)
He is wrong about that. Herodotus says that they were an advance front to buy time for the rest, who were at a religious festival and at the Olympics:

“The force with Leonidas was sent forward by the Spartans in advance of their main body, that the sight of them might encourage the allies to fight, and hinder them from going over to the Medes, as it was likely they might have done had they seen that Sparta was backward. They intended presently, when they had celebrated the Carneian festival, which was what now kept them at home, to leave a garrison in Sparta, and hasten in full force to join the army. The rest of the allies also intended to act similarly; for it happened that the Olympic festival fell exactly at this same period. None of them looked to see the contest at Thermopylae decided so speedily; wherefore they were content to send forward a mere advanced guard.”

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by muro on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @03:33PM (#21401601)
Only if made by victors, no?
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by notfromhere on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @05:18PM (#21402853)
Pretty sure Persia lost that war pretty significantly.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by mandevil on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @03:19PM (#21401468)
They beat Athens only with the help of tremendous quantities of Persian gold. That was what enabled Sparta to win the war, not Sparta's military capabilities.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by catalogia on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @05:46PM (#21403152)
I think it has a lot to do with Plutarch telling wacky fun stories about Lycurgus and Sparta. The sort of stories that are fun to share with others.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by cafard on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @03:03PM (#21401285)
They also contributed greatly to beating the Persians at Plataea.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by friendlybus on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:59PM (#21402646)
The same reason people fetishize pirates, astronauts and jedi. They represent a niche symbol that doesn't have a compare. The historical truth of Sparta is important to know, but the symbol is a separate thing. The spirit of the hold-out warrior who's heroic society succeeds and fails, is interesting in many different ways.

I think it's good people know about and integrate the spartan story into their own world view, there's a lot of cautionary tales in there for those that believe you could ever succeed at having such a radical worldview as the Spartans maintained. The unpleasantness of the fan is directly proportional to how much they need to learn the lessons of the past and the folly of that mindset. There are also lessons about aspects of masculinity, femininity and most of life that stories like Sparta can be a useful reflection tool.

Sparta is a small moment in a large pantheon of stories that make people better people. Even to the most cynical view, it's better these unpleasant people explore this mindset in art than to carry out the actions in their full in real life.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by leftyted on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @07:15PM (#21404038)
> I don't get why Sparta seems to be so fetishized, particularly by people who are not pleasant to be around.

The "fetishization" of Sparta goes back to Thucydides and Xenophon, Athenians who admired the Spartans, and Plutarch, a Roman who admired Sparta.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by astine on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @10:21PM (#21405106)
Plutarch was a Greek.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by 0xbadcafebee on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:27PM (#21400889)
Sparta is fetishized because human societies worship glory, courage and sacrifice, and that's what their myth is all about. As it's mythological, we tend to obscure the details we don't like and embellish the ones we do.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by bilbo0s on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:22PM (#21400838)
>I don't get why Sparta seems to be so fetishized

I'll just say that it's human nature to romanticize the past. Particularly when we feel we have an affinity for that past.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by gaogao on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @02:49PM (#21401121)
Sounds like Fallout New Vegas
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by Gabriel_Martin on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:12PM (#21402043)
Fallout: New Vegans (if you follow OP's naming convention)
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by grouseway on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:32PM (#21402325)
>I don't get why Sparta seems to be so fetishized, particularly by people who are not pleasant to be around.

War College had a good interview with a historian on this subject.

https://player.fm/series/war-college-1324080/this-is-not-spa...

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by smacktoward on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @03:31PM (#21401586)
> I don't get why Sparta seems to be so fetishized, particularly by people who are not pleasant to be around.

It's because they saw a movie that depicted the Spartans as super ripped badasses who kicked ass all the time.

Seriously, there's not much more to it than that.

Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by edgarvaldes on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:36PM (#21402372)
>Seriously, there's not much more to it than that.

Do you really think that everything comes from that 2006 film? I learned about that civilization more than 30 years ago, when my primary school teachers taught me about classical Greece and its legacy. There is a long Hellenistic tradition that takes Sparta and Athens as the embodiment of two models worthy of historical study.

[dead]
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by nidificate on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @04:08PM (#21401983)
Xenophan and Plutarch probably hit a bit to do with it.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by catalogia on Wednesday October 30, 2019 @07:20PM (#21404082)
Absolutely. Anybody who's read Plutarch's Parallel Lives would be hard pressed to not have some degree of fascination with Sparta.
Re: A military historian’s analysis of Spartan myth by teambayleaf on Friday November 01, 2019 @11:47AM (#21420043)
Then why did Xerxes try to invade Laconia? To tramp on valueless minor city-states just for fun?