News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by whyenot on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:40PM (#21300317)
Amazon, Apple, Disney, HBO Max, Hulu, Peacock, ..., oh, and Netflix. How many monthly memberships are people going to want to pay for, especially when there is already a huge library of free content on YouTube? Interesting times...
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by echelon on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:56PM (#21300424)
This is strictly worse than cable.

Streaming in the 2010s was a breath of fresh air. You could find everything on one platform, watch it at your leisure, and pay way less than cable.

Now we're going to have to pay more AND switch between nine different apps with broken UIs.

This is god awful. All of this because of greed and a lack of regulation.

We need to campaign for limited copyright (20 years), and build services like Spotify that have everything and merely pay the rights holders.

Disney needs to be broken up. They own 90% of American pop culture. They're going to begin protection racketing theaters and dumbing down everything to appease the masses (and foreign governments).

God, I hate what the Internet is becoming.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by nostromo on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:09PM (#21300496)
No, it’s much better than cable.

Most people don’t watch that much TV and won’t need more than one or two services. Those people are saving a ton of money.

And a few people that are glued to their TVs will pay more. As they should.

I’m particularly happy that I no longer have to subsidize sports, which I never watched, to the tune of $20 a month or so.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by didibus on Saturday October 19, 2019 @06:45PM (#21301196)
Agreed, and people forget that you are not locked into contracts for any of them. That's the killer. Alternate them as you see fit, don't need to have them all at once. And since they all allow you to watch what you want when you want it, it's more like choosing a show to watch every month and paying only for that by subscribing for that service only for that month.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by mrfusion on Saturday October 19, 2019 @08:59PM (#21301686)
Problem is if you want one show from each service.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by CharlesW on Saturday October 19, 2019 @09:44PM (#21301843)
What do you think of this solution? (1) Sign up for a month, (2) binge, (3) cancel.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by mrfusion on Saturday October 19, 2019 @09:57PM (#21301892)
Good idea except I don’t like phoning up companies to cancel.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by TrunkleBob on Saturday October 19, 2019 @10:30PM (#21301997)
I've canceled (and later resubscribed) to Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon without ever picking up the phone.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by echelon on Saturday October 19, 2019 @11:25PM (#21302158)
This is easy now. Just wait until retention starts hurting their bottom line.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by jfim on Sunday October 20, 2019 @04:27AM (#21302878)
That's not legal in California since 2018. From SB 313, which requires that a subscription that was initially started online shall be cancelable online as well:

a consumer who accepts an automatic renewal or continuous service offer online shall be allowed to terminate the automatic renewal or continuous service exclusively online

https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by echelon on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:53PM (#21306218)
What about all the other states? I don't live in California. Companies can and do script different behaviors depending on which state you live in.

And that doesn't stop them from using dark patterns or cancellation fees.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by dillonmckay on Sunday October 20, 2019 @01:13AM (#21302408)
YAGNI
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by adamweld on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:06AM (#21302528)
You could use privacy.com to limit each service as you sign up and then forget about it.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by barkerja on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:59PM (#21300445)
I don't know if I'd go as far to say it's worse. Cable forced one's hand into paying for things they didn't necessarily want. At least with this model, we the consumer have the ability to pick and choose exactly what we want to pay for.

If a network has shows that look appealing to you, subscribe for a couple months. If there's only one show that looks appealing, buy it on iTunes.

We're never going to have an affordable, legal, pay-once-for-everything model.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by dehrmann on Saturday October 19, 2019 @09:56PM (#21301884)
> We're never going to have an affordable, legal, pay-once-for-everything model.

Why does it work for music, though?

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by dillonmckay on Sunday October 20, 2019 @01:28AM (#21302441)
I think it comes down to simple economics of delivery and media costs (both time and money).

We would be having a different conversation if I could have a thumbdrive w enough storage capacity to hold the entire Disney catalog for $35.

This makes even more sense if my ISP charges per GB. Why should I pay for duplicate transfer of data?

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by redis_mlc on Sunday October 20, 2019 @01:40AM (#21302471)
The US music industry doesn't have the MPAA.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by dragonwriter on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:17AM (#21302549)
No, they have the RIAA, which is pretty much the exact same thing, but for the music industry.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by TeMPOraL on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:09PM (#21300492)
> We're never going to have an affordable, legal, pay-once-for-everything model.

That possibility is a huge market failure. The demand is there.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by jeromegv on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:22PM (#21300557)
How can you have access to all content while keeping it affordable? Cable was “everything” but it wasn’t affordable. Movie and TV Content is expensive to produce, can’t have it all for $10/month.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday October 19, 2019 @11:29PM (#21302169)
> How can you have access to all content while keeping it affordable?

For the same total amount of content produced, they could give everyone access to all of it for the same total revenue they receive now and the only thing that would change is that everyone would have access to all of it.

You don't make more money by having only 20% of the customers even if it means you don't have to share the revenue with four other studios. You make less, because having access to some of the content isn't worth as much as having access to all of the content, so the industry as a whole is providing less value and consequently doing less business.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Saturday October 19, 2019 @06:26PM (#21301124)
The marginal cost of watching something is neglible. The only reasonable outcome is everyone being able to access everything, anything else is a huge market failure.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by unlinked_dll on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:33PM (#21300609)
>How can you have access to all content while keeping it affordable

Media companies could stop over pricing their content

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by basch on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:41PM (#21300640)
>Now we're going to have to pay more AND switch between nine different apps with broken UIs.

Roku, Fire, Apple all make it easy to search and browse for a show and then deep link into the correct app. It's not perfect, and I hope it will get better, but you are not currently forced to open the apps. Fire goes a step further and lets you play videos you are licensed to right out of the fire interface, without the app firing up. It's easy to subscribe to hbo, cbs ets and have the content you are licensed to see show up right with your other stuff. (The Fire interface being not so pleasant to use is another story entirely.)

>Disney needs to be broken up. They own 90% of American pop culture.

Has a company ever been broken up for its library of content?

>build services like Spotify that have everything and merely pay the rights holders.

These platforms above are the single aggregator you are looking for. Comcast and DirecTV were these, but without the option for a la cart.

>pay way less than cable.

You have the option to make it cheaper if you want to rotate your subscriptions and not hold them all at the same time. I see that as a net gain vs the previous status quo of the TV Provider bundle era.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Saturday October 19, 2019 @06:26PM (#21301127)
> Has a company ever been broken up for its library of content?

There's a first time for everything.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:15PM (#21300530)
Yet another post on HN about a company that needs to be broken up because they are big in some made up market. Now are we going to define a monopoly as the “Pop Culture” market.

Would you also like the government to “build a market” so that everyone can have all the software they want and have the government decide what a fair amount for software is?

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by Teever on Saturday October 19, 2019 @11:34PM (#21302180)
The government built this market! It wouldn't exist without copyright law or the perpetual extension of it!
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by echelon on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:29PM (#21300594)
Disney films are generic, cookie cutter formulas designed for mass appeal and ROI. They buy everything they can and then force theaters to show their films in the most desirable weekend spots. They're soaking up all the money and pushing the smaller players out.

They're now trying to eat Netflix.

Not to mention that they follow Beijing's content directives.

We should take a serious look at balancing the scales.

If we expired Star Wars' copyright after 20 years, others could use the license and develop their own take. Disney would be forced to innovate and pursue new IP creation. It would be good for competition.

This is just my own thought on the matter. Maybe it's wrong. I happen to think it would improve the status quo and actually result in market growth as you'd need new to hire more creatives. Novel content in turn results in more interest.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:39PM (#21300632)
Every commercial product is designed for maximum ROI.

They buy everything they can and then force theaters to show their films in the most desirable weekend spots.

You really think movie theaters would rather show movies that don’t fill it?

They're soaking up all the money and pushing the smaller players out.

Ever heard of Blumhouse? Their entire business model is to make low budget movies that cost under $10 million and they usually have a higher ROI than Disney movies.

If we expired Star Wars' copyright after 20 years, others could use the license and develop their own take. Disney would be forced to innovate and pursue new IP creation. It would be good for competition.

Why not force other people to innovate instead of building on top of Star Wars?

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by echelon on Saturday October 19, 2019 @10:47PM (#21302051)
> Every commercial product is designed for maximum ROI.

Not true with art.

> You really think movie theaters would rather show movies that don’t fill it?

Disney takes a larger cut per screen, so the theater actually makes less money on Disney films. If they don't show Disney films on their best screens, they'll lose the right to show any Disney films. It's extortion. [1] [2]

> Ever heard of Blumhouse? Their entire business model is to make low budget movies that cost under $10 million and they usually have a higher ROI than Disney movies.

These are horror films. That genre has always been cheap to film. Blumhouse is a great businessman. I don't think this model fits for every genre, eg. period pieces and art house cinema.

> Why not force other people to innovate instead of building on top of Star Wars?

I'm not saying that they shouldn't. Disney should start innovating instead of stretching its licenses over and over. Pixar has become garbage since Disney took over. They're not going to make risky films like Logan with their IP, either.

I'm doing everything I can to get into this market, and I'm terrified of having to compete with this juggernaut. If they're going to play hard ball with their IP, I'm going to lobby for looser IP protections. It's good for consumers and creatives anyway.

[1] https://mashable.com/2017/11/01/star-wars-last-jedi-theaters...

[2] https://qz.com/1479408/small-theater-chains-worry-a-mid-cent...

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:04AM (#21304213)
Disney takes a larger cut per screen, so the theater actually makes less money on Disney films. If they don't show Disney films on their best screens, they'll lose the right to show any Disney films. It's extortion. [1] [2]

Movie theaters have never made most of their money from ticket sales. They make money from concessions.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by echelon on Sunday October 20, 2019 @03:31PM (#21306471)
> Movie theaters have never made most of their money from ticket sales. They make money from concessions.

We're getting nitpicky here.

Theaters still make money through ticket sales, though the studios take most of the revenue [1]. Sometimes theaters earn over 50% of revenue. It depends on the film. Disney takes more than anyone, leaving barely anything for theaters. Better not sneak in any snacks to their films or you'll be stiffing the theater!

But the bottom line is that Disney dictates what gets shown and when. If theaters don't give up as many screens as Disney wants, they'll lose their rights to Disney films outright. And that isn't fair.

[1] https://theweek.com/articles/647394/when-buy-movie-ticket-wh...

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Saturday October 19, 2019 @06:30PM (#21301143)
> Would you also like the government to “build a market” so that everyone can have all the software they want

Yes, of course I would like the democratically elected government to run the economy in a sane way.

> and have the government decide what a fair amount for software is?

No, that would be absurd. The fair amount for software is equal to its marginal cost which is zero.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Saturday October 19, 2019 @07:16PM (#21301307)
So how should we pay for software developers? Should software as service products that have hosting cost also be free?
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Sunday October 20, 2019 @05:34AM (#21303116)
> So how should we pay for software developers?

Taxes, of course. That's how we fund things where individually charging people does not make sense.

> Should software as service products that have hosting cost also be free?

Generally not, why?

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:38AM (#21303528)
So now we are going to charge higher taxes to subsidize software developers.

Are we also going to have a centralized “5 Year Plan” for the economy? How has this worked for China and Russia. They realized decades ago that this didn’t work.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:09AM (#21304239)
> So now we are going to charge higher taxes to subsidize software developers.

What's wrong with "subsidizing", aka paying, software developers?

> Are we also going to have a centralized “5 Year Plan” for the economy? How has this worked for China and Russia. They realized decades ago that this didn’t work.

The lack of creativity on a website supposedly populated by engineers keeps astounding me. Hell, you don't even need creativity to be aware that public broadcasters exist.

Or to recognize that computing and communication technology has somewhat improved in the past 30 years. Considering that the planners of the eastern block had to greatly simplify their plans and still weren't able to finish their calculations within 5 years, the state capitalist economy worked remarkably well.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:36AM (#21304404)
Public broadcasting isn’t exactly producing great content. Do you really want broadcasting to be controlled by the government? What happens when the “other party” is in power?

China didn’t “work” until they started allowing private ownership and profit.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Sunday October 20, 2019 @01:08PM (#21305433)
> Public broadcasting isn’t exactly producing great content.

I frankly don't know if our experiences differ that much or if your mind is clouded by ideology.

> Do you really want broadcasting to be controlled by the government?

Of course not, that would be even worse than private broadcasting is.

> What happens when the “other party” is in power?

I don't understand the question. Which "other party" do you mean? There are many.

> China didn’t “work” until they started allowing private ownership and profit.

China didn't have an economy at all? That's news to me. Maoism must be even more stupid than I thought.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:29PM (#21306047)
If the “public” is funding broadcasting and the elected officials are holding the purse strings, do you really think they are going to be overly critical of the government?

China had an economy but resources weren’t properly allocated and people were starving in one region while the other region was producing things that no one needed.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Sunday October 20, 2019 @04:51PM (#21307038)
> If the “public” is funding broadcasting [...] do you really think they are going to be overly critical of the government?

This is not a hypothetical question, public broadcasters do exist and do criticize their governments. Will your next question be if public healthcare can work better than what the USA is doing?

> If the “public” is funding broadcasting and the elected officials are holding the purse strings

Then whoever drafted that law didn't do their job which would have included researching how public broadcasters around the world are organized. Or they're British and think limiting the power of Parliament is for Europeans, Colonials and other wimps anyway.

> China had an economy but resources weren’t properly allocated and people were starving in one region while the other region was producing things that no one needed.

Thanks for telling me things that I already know. I didn't write "Considering that the planners of the eastern block had to greatly simplify their plans and still weren't able to finish their calculations within 5 years," for decoration.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:06PM (#21307527)
And a quick Google search....

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-33654279

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:41PM (#21308121)
Carry on?
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by slovette on Saturday October 19, 2019 @10:30PM (#21301998)
Not trying to be rude: I’m not sure you really know what “marginal cost” means and it’s relation to a product’s economic impact. Twice, so far, you’ve used it here in the wrong context.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Sunday October 20, 2019 @05:40AM (#21303136)
Please explain then.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by slovette on Saturday October 26, 2019 @01:18PM (#21364927)
I didn’t see this response, apologies.

It seems you keep referencing: marginal cost == value. That’s very untrue. Indeed marginal cost is a factor in value, but is most certainly not directly relational.

Simply put, value is ascertained by a product’s measure of overall impact. An example would be a simple script that tally’s an employee’s hours from clock in and clock out times. Say a task that once took a bookkeeper an hour to do, with the script takes .1 seconds.

Let’s say the script cost $5 to create but zero dollars to duplicate. It doesn’t mean it’s value is zero. It’s value is equivalently equal to the hour of bookkeeping time that person saved multiplied by however many times the task is used in any given time frame.

Marginal Cost is 0. But the value is far from it. A similar exercise is done to evaluate the value of entertainment. Different factors, but same idea.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by solipsism on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:59PM (#21300439)
You don't have to do anything. You just feel the need to watch everything that can be watched. If you don't want to pay for every service, you should just reset your expectations.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by TeMPOraL on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:07PM (#21300487)
That's not how it works.

For one, it's the age-old anticonsumer situation, but a fully distributed edition. People value movies and shows by title, not by distributor. Platforms aggregate orthogonally to that. The end result is, even if you ranked all the movies/shows by how much you wanted to that and restricted yourself to top 10, you'll likely end up having to subscribe to all the mainstream platforms to get them.

Secondly, wrt. not having to watch anything, you sort-of do. Popular entertainment becomes popular culture, and if you want to participate in the society and build relationships with other people, you kind of have to be at least aware of some of the current offerings of that popular culture.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by solipsism on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:42PM (#21300642)
Popular entertainment becomes popular culture, and if you want to participate in the society and build relationships with other people, you kind of have to be at least aware of some of the current offerings of that popular culture.

Oh come on. Are you really claiming that if you can talk with your friends about Stranger Things, but not Game of Thrones because you don't have HBO, then you face some kind of serious impediment to participating in society? That strikes me as completely ridiculous.

Customers don't like a big monolithic bundle because the single bill is too expensive.

Customers also don't like a la carte content (which is available on any number of platforms, including Google and Amazon and Apple) because each individual bill is too expensive.

Customers also don't like medium sized bundlings, because when things get split up across different bundles then people feel left out, and everyone feels the need to watch everything.

So what's your proposal? It's not like the market isn't trying to cater to customers here. Do you propose we pass laws that restrict companies from creating exclusive content? Or should we pass laws that restrict content from costing more than a specific amount? Will we also have to pass laws to keep the quality up in that case? Why? Just because customers insatiably want and want and want?

There are lots of real problems in the world for us to solve. This is not one of them.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by TeMPOraL on Sunday October 20, 2019 @05:02AM (#21303005)
> Oh come on. Are you really claiming that if you can talk with your friends about Stranger Things, but not Game of Thrones because you don't have HBO, then you face some kind of serious impediment to participating in society? That strikes me as completely ridiculous.

Perhaps not serious, but an impediment, yes. Stranger Things is not for everyone, but Game of Thrones actually was the #1 topic in the office at previous workplace for almost the entire time I've been there. But I have an even better example: Chernobyl. My wife and I were to Chernobyl, so we didn't feel in a particular hurry to watch the TV portrayal. But once everyone on our Facebook feeds - and I mean everyone, including people who can't spell "nuclear" half the time - started talking about the show, and started bringing it up in meatspace meetings, we kind of felt left out, so we sat down and just watched it.

That's how the popular culture rolls. You can't be in sync with it all the time, but you have to stay in sync with hit some of the time, if you want to participate in group conversations.

> Customers don't like a big monolithic bundle because the single bill is too expensive.

> Customers also don't like a la carte content (...) because each individual bill is too expensive.

You've just identified the problem with these two options :). Remember that video is one of few cases when people are just being nice by offering to subscribe to these streaming services. They always have the option of getting that content for free, or at a fraction of the price.

> So what's your proposal? It's not like the market isn't trying to cater to customers here.

I believe it isn't. The market is trying to gouge customers, and currently is in the state of balkanizing.

> Do you propose we pass laws that restrict companies from creating exclusive content?

That would be a start. But the emphasis is on "exclusive", not "creating" - an equivalent way of putting is would be a law restricting companies from exclusively licensing the content. So for starters, streaming services should get unbundled from the shows they carry and compete on the actual value they provide - UI and curation (i.e. categorization, sorting order; though honestly, that should be a separate, orthogonal service).

(You'll note I'm only talking about exclusivity here, not IP ownership. The money for streaming, say, GoT would still go to HBO regardless of where they were streamed, but HBO shouldn't be able to refuse to license other platforms to steal it.)

> Or should we pass laws that restrict content from costing more than a specific amount?

Nah, competition - actual competition - between streaming platforms would do the rest. Movies and TV shows are non-substitutable goods, so exclusive deals prevent competition from happening.

> Why? Just because customers insatiably want and want and want?

So the industry spends billions on brainwashing[0] people into wanting more and more, plays off the FOMO, and you're surprised "customers insatiably want and want and want"? Maybe they should stop hooking them on hard drugs. With companies telling people to consume more and more, giving them more and more stuff to consume, and with politicians and economists saying this is good, because our economy needs to grow exponentially - I find it funny... no, disingenuous, to see customers being blamed.

--

[0] - I'm past calling marketing and advertising anything less than that.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @04:00PM (#21306665)
You'll note I'm only talking about exclusivity here, not IP ownership. The money for streaming, say, GoT would still go to HBO regardless of where they were streamed, but HBO shouldn't be able to refuse to license other platforms to steal it.

Let’s talk software, should developers who write GPL software be forced to allow on the iOS App Store? Should GPL 3 software not be allowed to ban TiVo from using it? What If I have a SASS offering and I don’t want it to be used in a Confederate Memorabilia store. Should that right be taken away from me? What if I have a Christian movie, Pornhub opened a digital video store and I decided not to license it to them, is that not my right?

Right now, Mongo’s license doesn’t allow AWS to host a managed offering even though you can download the same software and host it on an EC2 instance for free. Should that not be allowed either?

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Saturday October 19, 2019 @06:37PM (#21301169)
1. If cultural works are important, it's important that people can access them.

2. If they aren't, let's get rid of them and reallocate resources to more important things.

3. If allocating resources is the job of the market, then the market has decided that these cultural works are important. GOTO 1.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by solipsism on Saturday October 19, 2019 @06:57PM (#21301233)
Who's talking about cultural works that people can't access?

What we're talking about is how much money they can access them for, and how many services they have to sign up to access them, and whether every single person needs access to every single work.

Your analysis is way too simplistic for this conversation.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by anoncake on Sunday October 20, 2019 @05:36AM (#21303122)
For everyone who doesn't have infinite money, cultural works costing money means they can't access (some of) them.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by zzzcpan on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:27PM (#21300580)
Entertainment is not really pop culture and is diverse enough these days, thanks to the internet, that you can easily not find a single tv show or a movie to talk about with someone.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by TeMPOraL on Sunday October 20, 2019 @05:04AM (#21303016)
With a someone, yes. But the role of pop culture has always been to facilitate conversations in group settings, especially groups when not all participants know each other well.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by beyourself911 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:49AM (#21303557)
If you sold your TV I bet you’d have something to talk about.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by wolco on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:07PM (#21300486)
90%? Disney doesn't really own a lot. They have huge brands in some niches but overall not much % wise. They refuse to touch anything adult in nature and that is the vast majority of content.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by redis_mlc on Sunday October 20, 2019 @01:44AM (#21302479)
> Disney doesn't really own a lot.

The scene has changed in the past decade.

They're one of the largest US media conglomerates now.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by dehrmann on Saturday October 19, 2019 @09:58PM (#21301894)
Disney used to own Miramax so it could release R films without tarnishing the main brand.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by amayne on Saturday October 19, 2019 @10:20PM (#21301970)
Disney created Touchstone for this purpose in the 1980s. Disney bought Miramax in the 1990s and as far as I know, they never used Miramax to release a Disney Studios-originated property. I could be wrong.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by Shorel on Sunday October 20, 2019 @01:18PM (#21305503)
You can't do binge-watching with cable. This is the fundamental difference here.

You can subscribe to one service, binge all you want, change to another, and so on.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by echelon on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:56PM (#21306241)
> You can subscribe to one service, binge all you want, change to another, and so on.

That is such a headache. Are you calling this a feature?

What about those with ADHD that struggle to pay bills on time and never cancel gym memberships? How's that going to work out for them?

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by friedman23 on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:53PM (#21300406)
Disney owns ESPN, a controlling stake in Hulu, Marvel, Lucas Films, Pixar, Disney Animation, and 20th century fox (FX, fox searchlight, many classic movie franchises, X-Men, Fantastic 4, etc). I'm probably missing something. I imagine that Disney will eventually sell a mega subscription service that bundles all of their media.

HBO Max will have all HBO content (obviously), all Warner Bros content, the CW (you know all of those teen dramas people love to watch on netflix like Riverdale, Supernatural, the Flash), Cartoon Network and a bunch of other subsidiaries that I can't name off the top of my head.

Amazon people will have prime subscriptions which gives them access for free.

I don't know why anyone would keep a lifetime subscription for any of the rest. Maybe only subscribe when your favorite shows are on?

Anyway, I think the future of streaming will be interesting to watch. I've made a fairly large bet on Disney stock and I would have bought Warner bros stock if it wasn't owned by ATT (I like Warner bros, I don't like the rest of their business).

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by skinnymuch on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:16PM (#21300538)
Disney controls 100% of Hulu now and can own the entire stake by 2024 when their deal with Comcast comes up for decision.

Disney is already doing a bundle for ESPN+, Hulu, Disney+. The Hulu is the lower priced ad one, but still, they’re already mostly there with an ultimate streaming bundle.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by dawnerd on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:55PM (#21300423)
Disney+ already will have espn and Hulu bundled (for a great price to boot).
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by SN76477 on Saturday October 19, 2019 @10:51PM (#21302070)
I will pay for several, lets just keep it under $40 a month. right now we have netflix, hulu, amazon prime and will get disney+ in our home. This along with youtube keeps us satisfied with almost anything we want to watch.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by basch on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:51PM (#21300693)
CBS/Viacom/Paramount/Nickelodeon/Showtime. Sony.

Disney/Hulu/ESPN count as one, though you can buy smaller packages.

ViacomCBS, NBCUniversal, WarnerMedia, and Disney will still be the big 4 of all the ones you listed. Amazon, Apple, and Netflix have minuscule content libraries by comparison. After people binge through new shows, the big 4 will be the ones holding all the old content. Netflix cant afford to produce content fast enough to backfill all their soon to expire licenses. Warner/Turner, Disney/ESPN, NBCSports also own a lot of sports coverage (CBS has a play as well) while Amazon, Apple, and Netflix barely have any coverage.

People are underestimating the play ViacomCBS will be able to make against NBCUniversal, WarnerMedia, and Disney now that they are united. CBS All Access and Pluto will be a killer combo, if they so choose to venture that route AND they own Philo to compete with Sling, Vue, ATT, Hulu, Youtube. CBSAA/Pluto/Philo is absolutely a threat to Disney/ESPN/Hulu's attempt at dominance; NBCUniversal(XfinityComcast), WarnerMedia(DirecTV/ATT/HBO whatever its named this week) wont go down with a fight either.

Discovery, Sinclair, AMC Networks all still exist as well. Verizon is making a bad play not gobbling up whats left.

At some point there will be a race to the bottom on price, and ad supported Pluto(CBS)/Hulu(Disney) like products will be dirt cheat to get people in the door. The extra money will come from people not wanting to watch ads.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by Vomzor on Saturday October 19, 2019 @10:33PM (#21302012)
The only streaming services that really matter are the ones that are global. Prime, Netflix, Disney. Netflix has a huge headstart. I believe almost 60 % of their subscribers are outside usa. They make local originals in every region they are. Just look at the amount of Spanish language originals that came out this year. Spanish, Dutch, Turkish, Korean, Italian, ... originals. It’s their ‘secret’ weapon.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by killerdhmo on Saturday October 19, 2019 @10:50PM (#21302063)
I don’t disagree I just think it’s naive. The biggest grossing programs are still American, so the question is if the future is in blockbusters like Marvel / Game of Thrones or if the better play is smaller niche plays.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by dillonmckay on Sunday October 20, 2019 @01:41AM (#21302473)
I don’t know, you said American, and even with the monthly premium, there are less than 400 million potential customers, right?
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by PopeDotNinja on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:23AM (#21302558)
American shows have global audiences, as the rights are sold worldwide. For example, I stayed in Austria last night and watched Game of Thrones in German on something other than HBO.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by kd5bjo on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:25AM (#21302566)
> The extra money will come from people not wanting to watch ads.

Having both an ad-supported and paid ad-free versions of the same product is likely an unstable equilibrium— Customers with disposable income will gravitate towards the ad-free product, and those are the people that advertisers are really paying for access to.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by bryanrasmussen on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:43AM (#21302610)
I think that's opposite, whenever I see studies of ad-free and ad-supported it seems like most customers went for ad-supported solutions. Maybe though other forms of online content are different than video.

Also I'm not sure if disposable income is the only factor that advertisers aim for, I mean a lot of advertisers aim for the youth market which sure have some disposable income but more importantly have disposable time.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by basch on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:30AM (#21304362)
Why would a streaming provider not offer the customer an equal cost to not be advertised to, that the advertisers are paying to advertise to?

Plus, I would still expect ad free to allow an ad before the show starts, although its often an ad for other content, a la Disney Channel only playing ads for other Disney channel shows.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by kd5bjo on Sunday October 20, 2019 @11:38AM (#21304777)
It’s tricky to nail down how much revenue loss each switch to ad-free will cost because you’re splitting your demographics. If you’re playing ads in the paid version, it’s by definition not ad-free; it’s some kind of hybrid that I haven’t thought enough about to address.

If enough viewers that actually buy things move over to your ad-free product, you tank the value per impression that advertisers are willing to pay. Thus you lose not only the impressions of people who pay, but also the lower the value of each ad you’re still showing.

I suspect that this will cause most providers to be either primarily subscription or primarily advertising, to the extent that the less-popular choice doesn’t have enough customers to be worth keeping around.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by AJ007 on Saturday October 19, 2019 @06:47PM (#21301200)
How will there be a race to the bottom on price, when companies like Netflix are barely cashflow positive right now?

Will subscribers really decide to pay $5 a month for a subscription with a bunch of shows they don’t want to watch instead of $10 a month for a subscription with a few shows they really want to see?

How are these companies going to deliver more video ad value per viewer than someone like Google does with YouTube? They may have all of the big brand advertisers lined up, but will they ever even reach parity the revenue per user of Google and Facebook?

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by zanny on Saturday October 19, 2019 @07:49PM (#21301422)
These companies will treat streaming like they treat all other markets dominated by networking effects and mindshare - dig into their vast scrooge mcduck money pits they have been accumulating (mostly internationally) for the last 10 years to sell the services below cost to try to attrition out the competition so they can reign alone as the last corporation standing.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @04:02PM (#21306683)
And how is that different than VC backed startups?
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by basch on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:33AM (#21304386)
>How will there be a race to the bottom on price, when companies like Netflix are barely cashflow positive right now?

I think netflix is in a bind cash wise, it costs cash to make content and they down own decades of library paid for in the past. The big 4 I mentioned are the ones that can race to the bottom. Disney might want to raise prices in 3 years but itll be right as ViacomCBS and NBCUniversal go into full swing.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by h2odragon on Saturday October 19, 2019 @09:49PM (#21301861)
> Verizon is making a bad play not gobbling up whats left.

they're the phone company, they don't have to care. The content companies will gobble their knobs now to be allowed access to the pipes they must have. They'll take what they're given and say "thank you."

I hope thats just cynicism and it isn't that way really. Look at how they behave.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by ethbro on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:59AM (#21302633)
Ironically, being the last pure last-mile operator makes you more neutral than your content-integrated competitors.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by bastardoperator on Sunday October 20, 2019 @12:48AM (#21302339)
Verizon digital media is a backend CDN for over half the companies you listed. They’re betting the future of the entire company on cord cutters.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by dillonmckay on Sunday October 20, 2019 @01:37AM (#21302460)
It also seems we are headed towards coupled offerings of content AND connection.

Certain content available via certain ISPs only.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by megaremote on Saturday October 19, 2019 @06:09PM (#21301065)
> After people binge through new shows, the big 4 will be the ones holding all the old content.

Do most people really want that old content? Apart from a few shows, I say no.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by prepend on Saturday October 19, 2019 @06:41PM (#21301182)
I stopped watching real time stuff (news, local, etc) and like watching old series an episode or two a day. TNG was great and it took a few months.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by raverbashing on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:07AM (#21302531)
Actually, I do think there is a market for that.

Like the "catalog" section of the old rental places, it surely would be interesting to watch an "old" movie sometimes (which by today's measure could be something like >3yrs)

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by basch on Sunday October 20, 2019 @12:11PM (#21305006)
arent Friends and The Office some of the most streamed shows?

I have to think Disneys back catalog of shows and movies will be a bigger draw short term than their new content. Are people buying it to watch The Mandalorian and the new Lady and the Tramp, or are they buying it so their kids can watch every disney movie ever made? Dont get me wrong, having a bunch of Marvel mini-series as their launch content is a brilliant move to make it not "just the old stuff."

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by toast0 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @03:07AM (#21302645)
There's a ton of old stuff I'd like to show my kid, but so much from my youth isn't available.

I'd also like to watch more garbage tv from the 80s.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by brogrammernot on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:47PM (#21300360)
Amazon doesn’t really count as it’s an added benefit of Prime.

However, all of those you listed are cheaper than adding cable to my bill.

I pay for Netflix, Hulu and YoutubeTV. It’s cheaper than adding cable to my bill & that’s just absurd to me.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by wincy on Saturday October 19, 2019 @09:32PM (#21301795)
I just cancelled my Prime subscription since it’s $120 and it seems to just be increasing so they can make more tv shows. Super annoying.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by aarpmcgee on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:51PM (#21300389)
Are you suggesting that it doesn’t count because you assume everyone has a Prime subscription?
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:12PM (#21300515)
It’s estimated that 62% of households in the US have Prime subscriptions.

https://www.geekwire.com/2019/new-survey-estimates-amazon-pr...

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by Supermancho on Saturday October 19, 2019 @11:19PM (#21302138)
Amazon Prime Video is not the same as Amazon Prime and Amazon Prime has nowhere near 62% (since 101m is less than 1/3 of the US population). If we're talking "households", that doesn't pan out either since the average US household has 2.6 people, right now. I would be willing to say these numbers aren't concrete, but they are closer to the ballpark of reality than a 62% market penetration when I can ask all my coworkers at a well-known company and 25% have Amazon Prime...and these are people with disposable income that allows for it as opposed to people working out of an airport in Minnesota.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @07:52AM (#21303568)
Everyone who had Amazon Prime has Amazon Prime video. Should we base how many people who have Amazon Prime on your anecdotal experience at “the company you work for”? Do you have a better citation?

We also don’t have to guess the number of households in the US. We have the Census.

https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/HSD410217

Around 119 million.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by Skunkleton on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:58PM (#21300432)
This isn't the point OP was making, but I don't think Amazon counts. Not because "everyone has prime", but because you can pay them extra money to add content to their platform. For example, you can pay to add British content, CBS, or HBO. Amazon is doing streaming right.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by skinnymuch on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:09PM (#21300494)
I don’t think that’s a good reason. HBO will likely not be an add-on in near future. Hulu allows you to add Showtime too.

CBS or Showtime have a good chance of not remaining with both products. Once CBS merges with Viacom [again]. Showtime and CBS’s new parent company will have to decide what to do about their streaming future.

Edit: Hulu has add-one for HBO, Showtime, Cinemax, and Starz. Hulu obviously counts so then Amazon should count too.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by wolco on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:01PM (#21300456)
You are paying for it with Amazon just bundled into the overall price. Probably 10% more.

That's why cable costs so much the bundling of various properties adds up. For now streaming inventors are eating the cost but they expect that to change by 2024.

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by scarface74 on Saturday October 19, 2019 @04:11PM (#21300510)
It’s easy to put a nominal value on Amazon Prime Video. Amazon sells it separately for $6.99 a month. Whether it’s worth that is an exercise for the reader.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by TeMPOraL on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:59PM (#21300440)
Any of them individually, or all of them together? If the latter, then wherever it is you live, you have some ridiculous places for cable TV there.
Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by brogrammernot on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:47PM (#21306178)
Together, the cheapest plan I could add that would actually give me the shows I watch is around ~$50 additional, so it’s about even.

Not taking Prime into account cause I use other prime features more-so

Re:Disney: Bob Iger bets the company (and Hollywood's future... by cobbzilla on Saturday October 19, 2019 @03:45PM (#21300348)
Their customers are also paying for curation and safety.