News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by btmorex on Saturday January 22, 2011 @04:24AM (#2130218)
These would have been far more interesting if they focused on newer, less established companies and products. Everyone already knows exactly what Twitter, Facebook, and the iPad are and no one cares if they win awards.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by electromagnetic on Saturday January 22, 2011 @08:19AM (#2130368)
What I was thinking when I read the title "Uhh, twitter didn't start in 2010".

A well established company (IE surviving the first 3 years where most companies fail miserably) is not a startup. It may behave as one, it may act as one, but if it doesn't have the massive impending doom of simply being a brand spanking new company, then it's not a start up.

By the logic demonstrated here, I vote for best startup for 2011 to be Apple.

Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by knowtheory on Saturday January 22, 2011 @10:35AM (#2130504)
One wonders if General Motors qualifies as a startup or product by their definition. They've put out a cool piece of technology (the Volt) even.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by ebaysucks on Saturday January 22, 2011 @09:25AM (#2130428)
Maybe they use AOL's perspective of what a "startup" is.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by nerfhammer on Saturday January 22, 2011 @12:02PM (#2130620)
There were separate categories for "best new startup or product" (winner: Quora) and "best overall product or startup". I personally agree that the best new startup is more interesting and would make a better headline for the announcement.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by phlux on Saturday January 22, 2011 @12:04PM (#2130629)
Techcrunch is about fostering and nurturing the growth of Arringtons ego. If he can focus on all the people who really do technology and are already successful, then he can feel like he is important and part of the scene.

Just like how he invited himself to the angelgate meetings and was greeting with a nice helping of "please god, not this fucking guy" yet referred to all of them as his "close friends"

Sure Disrupt is a good platform for startups and tech to launch, but seriously looking at the quality of their hosts, and all the article after article postings on TC that are riddled with mistakes, spelling errors, grammar errors etc, one cant take them too seriously.

It is ego factory, nothing more.

Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by richcollins on Saturday January 22, 2011 @01:17AM (#2130074)
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by btipling on Saturday January 22, 2011 @04:46AM (#2130235)
I've been feeling down in the dumps all day, depressed about life in general, and I've just discovered thanks to you that watching videos of Richard Feynmann cheer me up. Thank you.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by richcollins on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:32PM (#2131464)
I have trouble watching them because they always make me feel like I'm wasting my life :-(
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by kordless on Saturday January 22, 2011 @11:00AM (#2130542)
"And then all of a sudden some strange phenomenon occurs in a corner."

That give me hope. :)

Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by ericflo on Saturday January 22, 2011 @03:47AM (#2130188)
Wow. That video was wonderful.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by chrischen on Saturday January 22, 2011 @01:58AM (#2130108)
Awards in general are silly.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by chegra on Saturday January 22, 2011 @03:11AM (#2130171)
I don't think awards should be the end goal, but they do serve a purpose. For instance, most people on here probably wouldn't have heard about Liu Xiaobo, well atleast before he won the Nobel Peace Prize. Having the backing of prestigious award such as Nobel Prize will only bolster his cause; he's in prison. Increase financial and political support is not silly at all.

For scientist, this might mean that they wouldn't have to fight as hard to get funding from people who don't understand their research. The people who don't understand research understand awards, so it can be used as a proxy to make judgement.

Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by chrischen on Saturday January 22, 2011 @04:50AM (#2130239)
You don't need an award for any of those things. The award recognizes the accomplishment only to those who cannot understand it. That's why it's silly. But there are other ways to recognize their achievements... like understanding what they did and why it's important. Yes in an ideal world it should be unnecessary...
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by Aaronontheweb on Saturday January 22, 2011 @03:51AM (#2130189)
Doesn't it seem somewhat passe to give the award to someone as well-established as Twitter?
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by dkasper on Saturday January 22, 2011 @04:20AM (#2130211)
Well Facebook had won it for the past 3 years (which happens to be every other year the Crunchies have existed), so I wouldn't say it's that unexpected.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by jamesteow on Saturday January 22, 2011 @11:25AM (#2130561)
Just as much I guess as giving a Person of the Year award to a guy who's startup hit the mainstream years ago.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by lenley on Saturday January 22, 2011 @08:15AM (#2130366)
of course ... it's called generating traffic.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by leftnode on Saturday January 22, 2011 @06:28AM (#2130296)
I think it's ironic 37Signals is listed under the Best Enterprise category.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by uptown on Saturday January 22, 2011 @10:24AM (#2130487)
Agreed. Context for anyone that may have missed it:

http://twitter.com/#!/dhh/status/27434483292573696

Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by locusm on Saturday January 22, 2011 @03:53AM (#2130190)
and second place went to Microsoft
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by whatusername on Saturday January 22, 2011 @08:30AM (#2130372)
I hear IBM came third. (At 99 years old they squeaked in). They almost had as much revenue as Apple in 2010. Nintendo (at 123 years old) is no longer a startup and is no longer eligible.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by ugh on Saturday January 22, 2011 @02:07PM (#2130822)
Damn you, sir! You sent me on an awesome trip looking around for the oldest companies.

Few are older than a few centuries, most are Japanese (others are European), small and restaurants, hotels or breweries. All are fascinating.

Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by whatusername on Sunday January 23, 2011 @07:29PM (#2133774)
I too have undertaken this trip in the past. A fascinating journey, albeit one to avoid while you face pressing deadlines. :)
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by haecib on Saturday January 22, 2011 @09:55AM (#2130457)
I really think they need to define 'startup'. I don't think that word means what they think it means...
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by EJE on Saturday January 22, 2011 @06:56AM (#2130320)
original title was for PG/Y Combinator as "Angel Investor of the Year", but the title was changed...
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by EJE on Sunday January 23, 2011 @09:28AM (#2132434)
it changed automatically
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by iam on Saturday January 22, 2011 @01:32PM (#2130759)
Kinect didn't win best device? How disappointing, since it was the only actually novel thing on there.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by nhangen on Saturday January 22, 2011 @01:58AM (#2130109)
Well deserved. If it weren't for PG and YC, I wouldn't know half of what I've learned as a result of stumbling onto Hacker News.
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by nhangen on Saturday January 22, 2011 @10:00AM (#2130463)
Why did the title of this thread change since I've left my original comment, which was in regards to PG and YC winning Angels of the Year?
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by kordless on Saturday January 22, 2011 @05:30PM (#2131232)
Wife said to me this morning, "Wait, didn't you sign up for Twitter in like 2007? They're not a startup!"
Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by ddemchuk on Saturday January 22, 2011 @11:54AM (#2130605)
I'm sorry, but WHAT?!?!

1) They are not a startup. They're over 4 years old. They have officially passed the starting phase

2) They have not monetized since graduating into the big boy businesses phase. Riding the coattails of VC's for years with no clear plan to reach profitability is not business

3) They are instable as hell. They crash nearly everyday, with millions of dollars in the bank, hundreds of engineers working for them, and 4 years of development under their belt, and they have a frickin meme because of how instable they are

4) They've stopped innovating. Nothing new has come from twitter in the last 2+ years other than their API. 140 character messages, we get it.

Blatant buzz word fanboyism is still running amok apparently.

Re:Crunchies Winners: Twitter Takes Best Startup Of 2010 by fredoliveira on Saturday January 22, 2011 @12:19PM (#2130645)
I'm going to do something I dislike and play devil's advocate. You're not the only one here saying that Twitter is no startup, and while I agree with that assessment to a certain extent, you've pretty much described a startup with your points. A startup is no longer considered being a startup if they become profitable (twitter isn't), is acquired or merges into another entity (twitter hasn't) or becomes public (which twitter hasn't either).

Is twitter a startup? Yes. Would giving the prize to some other company be more interesting? Definitely. These competitions are often not fair, but honestly, who are we to judge?