News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by dangus on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:26PM (#21177082)
I'm totally out of the loop about what this drama is about, and I'll stay that way.

These are unpaid community moderators. They are essentially volunteers doing this work because they want to. So let's ponder to ourselves and relate this to our own lives, what kind of relationship do we have with the organizations and people we do volunteer work with?

If you're at a point where you're so dissatisfied that you're writing a sprawling open letter, a manifesto of your dissatisfaction, going as far as buying a domain and setting up a website to publicize how upset you are, just to complain to a place that you volunteer at, you know, maybe it's time to just let it go. Maybe don't volunteer there. StackExchange isn't even a charity, it's a private for-profit company.

At the end of the day, people visiting the site just did a quick Google search and wanted their questions answered for free. They are generally unwilling to pay for this service. If StackExchange didn't exist something very similar would take its place. None of the general public needs to hear about whatever moderator drama took place, even if something criminal happened. It's not our problem.

The users don't actually implicitly value what the moderators do. So if the moderators aren't happy, they should do something else with their valuable time.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by brian-armstrong on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:41PM (#21177174)
This is a shockingly unempathetic way to view the situation. These people have poured lots of their time into making SO work, and they deserve to be heard. There's no way anybody could build this service without volunteers. These things don't just spring up from the ground on their own, and as someone who uses the SE properties for personal and professional reasons, I hope these moderators can find some sort of satisfactory resolution.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by x0x0 on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:18AM (#21177423)
Per Monica, a senior SO employee --Sara Chipps -- is publicly lying about Monica. Monica's claim is multiple messages went unanswered, and then...

> Sara Chipps, Director of Public Q&A, left responses on various moderators' resignation posts maligning my character. You can see an example on my Mi Yodeya post. The cut-and-pasted message included, specifically referring to me: "When a moderator violates [inclusion and respect], we will always do our best to resolve it with them privately." Both halves of that statement are false. [1]

Let's call publicly talking about an observant Jewish ex-mod on Rosh Hashana a lagniappe.

This pretty strongly seems StackOverflow saying use personal pronouns and don't question our policy, or GTFO.

Which is of course fine -- their house, their rules -- and frankly something I generally support. But given both the willingness to de-mod Monica, ghost her, and then (again, per Monica) lie about it in public, and (2) be far more responsive to a random twitter message than multiple longstanding mod requests, SO's position is quite clear.

So yes, mods saving SO millions of dollars of paid employee time per year should certainly re-evaluate their relationship with their corporate beneficiary.

[1] https://cellio.dreamwidth.org/2064709.html

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by olingern on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:51PM (#21177231)
I agree. Without these people the site could fall into a mess of bad answers or a self promotion answer driven platform like Quora.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by edoceo on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:08AM (#21177339)
Sounds like they are so important they should have been compensated. I mean, if they were so critical to the success.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by brian-armstrong on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:24AM (#21177462)
There are more forms of wealth than just cash. Some people find it rewarding to help others, and SE is set up to make it so that people could create the canonical answer to a particular question. This is a force multiplier so that helpful answers can reach a maximum audience.

This probably won't continue to feel satisfying if SE doesn't show respect for its volunteers. The force multiplier only exists because the moderators keep the site clean and well-organized. It sounds like SE both explicitly and implicitly showed gratitude for this effort, but now they are failing to do so.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by smhost on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:49AM (#21177604)
what're you trying say, exactly? that people who get more satifaction from doing a job should be paid less?

if you want to start assigning a dollar value to subjective experiences like that, the argument goes both ways. you should pay more to people who experience more emotional distress from their jobs. but in that case a majority of companies would probably go bankrupt, since most people despise their jobs.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by whatshisface on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:22AM (#21177449)
Some of them rise up to community managers and are then compensated. The person who recently got steamrolled was getting very close to that position.

I think some sympathy is due for the working-for-free workers on stack exchange, at least from us, Hacker News' unpaid content authors.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by godzillabrennus on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:22AM (#21177450)
They contribute to the community that is owned by the company that then profits from the community.

In return they get points.

Points allow for showing how important they are to the community.

Points that have zero cash value.

Disgruntled volunteers are not going to be easy to replace.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by mister_hn on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:12AM (#21177370)
They've got compensated in visibility. I don't know any moderator with less than 20k points to date.

And the more points you have, the upper you stay in the ranks and you can always embed their badge in your website.

So, yes, they don't earn money, but they receive visibility

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by edoceo on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:18AM (#21177416)
Sounds like they gave value but got none to me..."visibility" ain't worth shit. How much SO got in the bank? What's the ratio of visibility to dollars here? I've never seen an SO badge anywhere and never mentioned in any resume.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by p1esk on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:15AM (#21177389)
What does this visibility mean? Can it be converted to cash somehow?
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by bryanrasmussen on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:54AM (#21177631)
I suppose if your profile on StackOverflow is high enough you could put it on your cv.

SO also has a jobs site, which I suppose can be linked to your profile if you want it to.

A company I consulted at one time was trying to improve it's profile for job applicants so they wanted people to put up their github profiles and SO profiles in some advertisements or whatever they were doing - I think it was on linkedIn they were doing this. Anyway I think they stopped because nobody had a particularly high impressive number so why would you even want to do that (but they did it)

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by p1esk on Monday October 07, 2019 @01:32AM (#21177827)
Lots of SO points means I spend a lot of time there answering questions (usually during work hours). Not sure I’d want to advertise that.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by bryanrasmussen on Monday October 07, 2019 @09:54AM (#21180783)
I would totally agree with that, however I have over the years developed the suspicion that people who make hiring decisions might not be operating at the same logical level that I am.

Given both that suspicion, and how they seem to behave about prominent github profiles and such, I think that being in the top 20th percentile or so on SO and a strong focus on the tags that correlate to the terms in a job announcement might be a big draw to some HR people/managers who just really don't want to mess up one more time! After the fifth complaint or so of programmers we hire don't know how to code or whatever - it might be soothing.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by mister_hn on Monday October 07, 2019 @03:04AM (#21178199)
yes, if you do freelancing
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by godzillabrennus on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:22AM (#21177451)
Maybe create an ICO for these points?
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by Alex3917 on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:36AM (#21177535)
The self-promotion is the main thing that makes Quora useful though. If you want to know what are all the startups that have attempted solving problem X, it's usually impossible to get a complete answer without using Quora. Just searching Google / Crunchbase / HN / ProductHunt etc. will miss the last third of startups, that you can only find mentioned in the relevant Quora thread.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by na85 on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:33AM (#21177513)
>There's no way anybody could build this service without volunteers.

Agree. Maybe it should cease exploiting the good will of its users and either pay them, or wither away.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by xvector on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:43PM (#21177189)
> going as far as buying a domain and setting up a website to publicize how upset you are, just to complain to a place that you volunteer at, you know, maybe it's time to just let it go.

This is a terribly shortsighted interpretation. Stack Exchange is a community like any other. Volunteers tend to care about the communities they take part in.

It is entirely reasonable to complain if you volunteer in a community and see the organizers of the community take action that cause it to deteriorate.

Telling people that participate in a community to shut up and go elsewhere solves no problems. It doesn’t improve the community. It doesn’t even necessarily help other communities.

Honestly? Your comment is so devoid of empathy that I am not sure if you are intentionally trolling or not.

> The users don't actually implicitly value what the moderators do.

You have no proof for this statement, just like most of your other statements.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by stOneskull on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:11AM (#21177369)
i don't think it's trolling. it's just a different opinion. may not agree but i do appreciate individual expression.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by labster on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:48PM (#21177215)
That's what a lot of them are doing, something else with their valuable time. They're just letting Stack Overflow know why on their way out.

The problem is perhaps the extent to which people invest time and effort into other people's private corporations. The Wikimedia Foundation, for all of its flaws, actually does try to listen to its users and build a public good. But when you play around in a corporate sandbox where you are just a commodity to be sold to advertisers, you don't have any rights.

I think it's a flaw in human nature really -- we expect to be recognized and given status for building community and providing value. But when you do that for a for-profit company like Stack Overflow or my own experience with TV Tropes wiki, you may find out one day that your value is only in your imagination, and you can be shut out of your community. This is not how it happened in tribal societies, or in small cities, but the information age has enabled even more detachment from empathy than the industrial age did. Now you can take away someone's community from them on their holy day from a chair a thousand miles away.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by zonidjan on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:45PM (#21177203)
> Maybe don't volunteer there. StackExchange isn't even a charity, it's a private for-profit company.

This. Stop giving your time for the profit of people who don't care about you. You want to help the community? You want to be respected? Great! Find some like-minded people, start a new site, maybe even make it a non-profit or at least democratic. But above all, stop making rich people richer off your labor

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by wpietri on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:12AM (#21177375)
Yeah, it kills me when they say they are "people who have invested a lot in the network". Sorry, kids, but investors get stock. Employees get paid. And only non-profits have volunteers.

Stack Exchange describes themselves as a "a hyper-growth enterprise software company" [1]. I have no idea why anybody's giving them free labor. I'll happily volunteer for Wikipedia. But until somebody sets up a non-profit Q&A site, there's no way I'm contributing content.

[1] https://stackoverflow.blog/2019/09/24/announcing-stack-overf...

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by sfink on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:52AM (#21177611)
> Sorry, kids, but investors get stock.

Ironic phrasing, considering that we parents invest insane amounts of time and money into kids. And no, we don't get stock. Not even a percentage of future earnings.

Yet we keep investing more and more anyway. Not all returns are financial.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by wpietri on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @11:39AM (#21193452)
If you really can't tell the difference between the child you chose to have and a for-profit, investor-backed corporation seeking hyper-growth, I'm not sure if I can help you.

Yes, not all returns are financial. But companies exploiting others' generosity to get rich is a cuckoo's-egg strategy.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by gizmo686 on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:16AM (#21177394)
They invested time and effort with the goal (presumably) of building/maintaining the community. You may think that is a poor decision on their part; but it is still an investment, and they are still volunteers.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by wpietri on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @11:40AM (#21193465)
It's not investment when other people get the returns. At best, it's a gift. At worst, it's a con. I also question that there is a "the community" in a meaningful sense of that term.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by curiousdannii on Monday October 07, 2019 @01:29AM (#21177813)
Aside from a few of the biggest Stack Exchange sites (including Stack Overflow) most of the 170 sites don't have ads and don't make profit. The only profit is very indirect, demonstrating that Stack Overflow the company can run sites like these, something which is now in doubt. (Disclosure: I'm a mod on one of the small SE sites and helped author the letter.)
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by yezr on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:43PM (#21177188)
I think you should invest the time to read what happened, the moderator the letter was written to support has her detailed write-up here [0].

[0] https://cellio.dreamwidth.org/2019/10/05/stack-overflow-fias...

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by fenomas on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:17AM (#21177407)
"I don't know what's going on here and I don't intend to learn, but everybody upset about it should just go do something else" is never a useful take.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by bluetwo on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:40PM (#21177172)
I have to agree: Voice your concerns and then vote with your feet.

That said, I am confused as to why a letter representing a group of people adept at concise and clear communication would have no real goals or structure.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by bryanrasmussen on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:47AM (#21177593)
the thing is that stack exchange has managed to disrupt the old newsgroup/forum based way of helping newbies get into new languages/handle problematic issues in languages they are used to.

In some ways they have improved this old system because of their ability to bring relevant questions together in such a way that you can build up a pretty big view of your problem space.

In many ways they have worsened the old system, for example by deleting questions that did not have example code. As I have said here before when you are really stumped you might not be able to make any example code that does what you want.

However there is a similarity between the old and new system, people working for free because they love their languages (also maybe because it improves their profile in the language and allows them better consulting jobs, positions in the future)

In the old system if there were problems with how a mail-list or whatever solution was being run you would probably get something like this so it seems reasonable to me that people would do the same thing in the new system.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by MrStonedOne on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:54PM (#21177241)
Just because quit is an option doesn't mean some can't or shouldn't choose to try and make a final ditch effort to save something they care about.

Sure, to somebody who doesn't care, its easy judge the fact that they care, telling them to just stop caring. Unfortunately people don't work that way and if you ask somebody who has volunteered at a food shelter or drop in center for 5 years if they would walk away the moment they stopped liking the direction it was going, its not hard to see why some would have a hard time saying yes

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by ALittleLight on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:00AM (#21177286)
They aren't working at a food bank though. They are helping a company make money. If you heard your waiter complain that the for profit restaurant he volunteered for treated him badly, repeatedly, and had no signs of changing, you might ask him why he doesn't consider not working there anymore.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by morpheuskafka on Sunday October 06, 2019 @11:45PM (#21177205)
Maybe they should and maybe they will move on--but that will be to the serious loss of both StackExchange and StackExchange Inc.
Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by hitekker on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:28AM (#21177484)
> I'm totally out of the loop about what this drama is about, and I'll stay that way.

Yes, you who claims not to want to know, and then spends time and effort writing vitriol about the subject you don't want to know about.

Re:Dear Stack Exchange, Inc. by sitkack on Monday October 07, 2019 @12:14AM (#21177382)
So basically volunteer, but if you want to change things you should just leave? SO gets the spoils of labor and you get a high quality knowledge base.