Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by jacobkg on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:02AM
(#21137198)
I used 3D Touch all the time for one specific feature: if you did a 3D Touch on the keyboard it would turn into a touch pad for moving the cursor around a block of text.
For anyone else who was devastated to lose this feature, I was happy to learn it’s still there! Now you do a long tap on the space bar to activate it.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by Shank on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:05AM
(#21137224)
> I was happy to learn it’s still there! Now you do a long tap on the space bar to activate it.
It's not though. The feature implemented with haptic touch only lets you long press on space bar and move the cursor. You have to use a second finger to start selection and control the bounds, and it's far less accurate.
With 3D touch, you could press down once to start cursor mode, again to start selection, and again to stop. You could also reset the selection while staying in cursor mode. I was able to, quite frequently, change entire sentences and edit text really efficiently with a single hand holding the phone. That's impossible now.
I'd be really happy if Apple went back and improved the spacebar cursor system, but right now it's objectively worse as it requires two fingers rather than one to select text.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by mstade on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:56AM
(#21137844)
Add one datapoint to the discoverability argument made in the article: I have had 3D Touch enabled iphones for a long time now and had absolutely no idea that the feature you're describing existed. I just tried the new long tap version of this feature on my iPhone 11 pro and it's just as you say kind of awkward because of the multi touch requirement to select, I can definitely see how 3D Touch would've made this better.
Now I wonder what other actually useful 3D Touch features I missed because I never discovered them. The only ones I did find where pretty useless and more often than not just got in the way, e.g. rearranging home screen icons.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by pault on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:58AM
(#21137860)
That is awesome, and despite using cursor mode for years I never knew that you could make selections too, which I guess illustrates the dichotomy of 3D touch UX. :)
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by nothrabannosir on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:21AM
(#21137407)
Another useful feature: force touch swipe the entire screen with your finger from left to right is a poor man’s Alt+Tab (switch to last process). Very useful when switching back and forth to check / copy something. Less faff than home button double click and tap.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by baddox on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:31AM
(#21137536)
FWIW, all the new iPhones from last year’s and this year’s generation have no home button and allow you to swipe between apps at the bottom of the screen (without 3D Touch). It’s a very nice UI paradigm.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by RodgerTheGreat on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:18AM
(#21136707)
Force touch is even less discoverable than gestures. If it is used to distinguish between "simple" and "complex" actions in the way right/left click do with a mouse- as Apple attempted in several places in iOS- it's far easier to activate accidentally than intentionally. Overall the feature was a horrendous usability misstep, and it's not surprising it was quickly nixed.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by coldtea on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:30AM
(#21137521)
Initial discoverability is overrated.
Some actions are not discoverable, but are very handy and much faster than anything discoverable could be when we are once shown or taught them.
An issue deeper than initial discoverability is "where can I do this", but this could be solved with e.g. a small mark/hue change/etc consistently shown on items that allow for force touch.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by RodgerTheGreat on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:59AM
(#21137885)
If it's a supplementary way to access functionality- a shortcut- poor discoverability is acceptable. If it's the only way to access functionality, poor discoverability is bad design, full stop.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by coldtea on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @12:39PM
(#21138367)
Those are not the only 2 cases.
1) supplementary way to access functionality
and
2) only way to access functionality
there's a 3rd option, which is the case here, for which is acceptable:
3) supplementary way to access _secondary_ functionality
Major functionality is still accessed by touch, menus, etc.
But even for primary functionality, I'd take fast, convenient, powerful over discoverability, any day of the week. The idea that users should not do any learning, and we should constrain our UI to stuff that's readily and immediately discoverable is incredibly limiting...
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by RodgerTheGreat on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @12:50PM
(#21138467)
There is no such thing as a user interface which is naturally "intuitive". Discoverable user interfaces provide consistency and affordance. If a new operating system or device uses similar affordances to things a user has seen before, they can rapidly transfer their experience. This is usually what people mean when they call a UI "intuitive": conventional.
Users always have to learn, and as user interface designers we must give them a path for learning. If there's no path to learning about a feature, it might as well not exist, irrespective of whether you consider it "secondary".
Gestures, by design, have no afforances. Pinch-zoom is nearly the only multitouch gesture that has been so universally accepted and applied that it can be taken as given.
Pressure-based shortcuts, in the absence of corresponding visual cues (as implemented by Apple), likewise have no affordances. The 3d-touch hardware was great, and worked as intended. iOS used it in an opaque, undiscoverable manner, and the result was a total dud.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by wlesieutre on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @02:42PM
(#21139497)
HN is 50% “vim is amazing I can be so productive now that I learned to use this” and 50% “Steve Jobs never would have allowed a long press action how will anyone ever learn to use it?”
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by dandare on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:55AM
(#21137122)
One navigation paradigm I miss on iOS that is very consistent on Android (and all desktop browsers including some desktop apps like Spotify) is the back button. The strong touch - a completely new and unoccupied mode of interaction could have been consistently used to "go back", regardless of context.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by yoz-y on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:28AM
(#21137494)
I feel that the back button is only consistent in its position but its functionality remains a mystery to me. Sometimes it goes to a previous page, sometimes to another app, sometimes to the home screen... I like that on iOS this is separated between the "go back to previous app/swiping on home indicator" and app specific buttons.
Fortunately Android 10 has introduced gestures so trying to reach the back button is no longer painful.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by basch on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @02:09PM
(#21139200)
theres one pattern, opening google photos, pressing share, choosing facebook messenger, sending a photo to a group that ALWAYS causes messenger to get stuck at the share screen. pressing back minimizes fbm but doesnt back out of share, so when you reopen the app, you are buried back at that deep share page. (one may ask why you would ever do it this way, with android 10 many apps couldnt access the device photos directly. even though its fixed, this still serves as an repeatable example of 'back' being confusing and broken.)
the inconsistency of the back button ranks very high on my "ios to android" learning curve list.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by jorvi on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:30AM
(#21137510)
> that is very consistent on Android
I'm pretty confused by this statement since a near universal complaint about the Android back button is that it's more like a 'shuffle' button that chooses between going a screen back, going back to the previous app, undoing an action or exiting an app. And there is zero clarity on which of those it will do.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by wombat-man on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:24AM
(#21136763)
Yeah, I liked it and used it when possible. Especially on the app screen where I could dive right into a specific in-app action. It's what nudged me into getting a 6s instead of another Android phone.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by dawg- on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:11AM
(#21136626)
Exactly, it's a failure for now, but apple now owns the intellectual property to that forever. If anybody ever finds a better way to use it, they own it and can jump on the opportunity. That's why when you are a company like apple with mountains of cash, you can feel good about investing money developing fancy aspirational things, even if they don't pan out immediately.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by InTheArena on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:09AM
(#21136607)
I'm not sure I would classify this a epic failure. This feature was enabled, and used fairly widely. It didn't live up to it's potential, and the biggest issue may be the weight / thickness requirements that it put onto Apple products. Apple traded that weight / thickness for more batter on the current phone, which is well worth it.
I miss 3D touch with the newest IOS builds. All that said, the discoverability aspect is huge here. It either needed to be built into everything, or nothing. Lukewarm adoption here was a major issue, because it meant that users had to experiment to discover what was actually possible.
Apple's version is novel and more robust. What doomed both is the uneven implementation across apps, lack of affordance, and differing skill of applying variable force among the population (aka 'hitting the sweet spot') Press and hold fulfills pretty much the same function, though not as elegantly.
As a UX designer, I wouldn't advocate deprecating force touch features but rather, leave them in for advanced users, work on onboarding and affordances, and let the masses 'tap tap tap..' for the same functionality. Imo, there is too much Lowest Common Denominator design out there, and advanced UX shouldn't be eliminated because some people don't get it.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by program_whiz on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:01AM
(#21136505)
Seems like a costly mistake, surprised they didn't figure out whether this was solving a legitimate problem, and/or filling a legitimate market need _before_ the costly development cycle. I literally cannot even imagine a UI that would be made better by this feature -- so surely before all that investment, apple had _some idea_ of how it would be used that would radically transform UI forever.
Maybe this comes down to a human brain / body form thing, where the best thing is just to have a simple point-and-click interface because it aligns well with human intuition and natural behavior.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by emsy on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:16AM
(#21136677)
I’m a firm believer that this is a failure of educating the user rather than the feature itself. With my next iPhone I will be forced to touch and hold, causing me delays which I hate. In hindsight, it might’ve worked to have the 3D Touch features available by 3D Touch and long press, causing users to stumble upon it by accident. I just wrote this reply on my phone and had to shake to undo, prompting a hint that I could achieve the same thing by double tapping with three fingers. Something like this would’ve worked for 3D Touch I’m sure. Imagine how loaded desktop UIs would be without right click context menus. This is what 3D Touch could’ve solved for touch UIs. Now where back to UIs that are either dumbed down or crowded. Or we have long press delays, punishing power users.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by machello13 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:47AM
(#21137027)
> Imagine how loaded desktop UIs would be without right click context menus. This is what 3D Touch could’ve solved for touch UIs.
This is still solved, and in a much better way, with the new iOS 13 context menus, which are standardized across every application and are on every iOS/iPadOS device, and have easy APIs for developers to create complex nested menus. I'm not happy about the delay introduced on the new phones, but I think it's an overreaction to suggest that the delay negates the entire concept.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by emsy on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:48AM
(#21137742)
I never argued that it negates the concept. I argued against the parent that 3D Touch is useless when it isn’t. Lag/delay is one of the worst things in UX. This fact is probably mentioned in the very first lesson on most UI/UX courses.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by zozbot234 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:48AM
(#21137041)
> Imagine how loaded desktop UIs would be without right click context menus.
I mean, they might have to use hamburger-menus or menubars (which are functionally equivalent), just like desktop UIs did back when Apple mice only came with a single button! (and this is coming back in style, now that touchpads come with only a single physical "click" action, and no separate buttons) Why can't touch UIs do the same? It works just fine on a detachable tablet PC when running GTK+3 apps, I could easily imagine doing quite involved work there.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by gumby on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:19AM
(#21137390)
Apple touchpad have more than a single click action: they have had multitouch for many years. I use several multi-finger actions every day. The simplest is clicking with two fingers, which calls up the context menu (same as "right click" since the 1970s), but I also use three and four finger gestures, pinch-and-zoom etc.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by Tade0 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:46AM
(#21137723)
I think it was just an example of a feature without a use case.
The home "button"(actually just part of the screen) in my Galaxy S8 is pressure-sensitive.
I have immersive mode on, so the back, home etc. buttons are normally not visible, which becomes a problem when an app hangs, because you cannot swipe to invoke them.
Enter the pressure sensitive area - one angry push and I'm back to the home screen.
Re:The Failure of 3D Touch (2018)
by mensetmanusman on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:47AM
(#21137030)
This was a major decision to backtrack on this implementation. It will take a generational change before people are willing to try again. We may not see it implemented on an iOS device for 20 years now.
For anyone else who was devastated to lose this feature, I was happy to learn it’s still there! Now you do a long tap on the space bar to activate it.
It's not though. The feature implemented with haptic touch only lets you long press on space bar and move the cursor. You have to use a second finger to start selection and control the bounds, and it's far less accurate.
With 3D touch, you could press down once to start cursor mode, again to start selection, and again to stop. You could also reset the selection while staying in cursor mode. I was able to, quite frequently, change entire sentences and edit text really efficiently with a single hand holding the phone. That's impossible now.
I'd be really happy if Apple went back and improved the spacebar cursor system, but right now it's objectively worse as it requires two fingers rather than one to select text.
Now I wonder what other actually useful 3D Touch features I missed because I never discovered them. The only ones I did find where pretty useless and more often than not just got in the way, e.g. rearranging home screen icons.
You can also long hold on the backspace key, then swipe left to delete whole words. Similar to ctrl+backspace on windows.
May need to go to settings to enable these features IIRC.
Some actions are not discoverable, but are very handy and much faster than anything discoverable could be when we are once shown or taught them.
An issue deeper than initial discoverability is "where can I do this", but this could be solved with e.g. a small mark/hue change/etc consistently shown on items that allow for force touch.
1) supplementary way to access functionality
and
2) only way to access functionality
there's a 3rd option, which is the case here, for which is acceptable:
3) supplementary way to access _secondary_ functionality
Major functionality is still accessed by touch, menus, etc.
But even for primary functionality, I'd take fast, convenient, powerful over discoverability, any day of the week. The idea that users should not do any learning, and we should constrain our UI to stuff that's readily and immediately discoverable is incredibly limiting...
Users always have to learn, and as user interface designers we must give them a path for learning. If there's no path to learning about a feature, it might as well not exist, irrespective of whether you consider it "secondary".
Gestures, by design, have no afforances. Pinch-zoom is nearly the only multitouch gesture that has been so universally accepted and applied that it can be taken as given.
Pressure-based shortcuts, in the absence of corresponding visual cues (as implemented by Apple), likewise have no affordances. The 3d-touch hardware was great, and worked as intended. iOS used it in an opaque, undiscoverable manner, and the result was a total dud.
Fortunately Android 10 has introduced gestures so trying to reach the back button is no longer painful.
the inconsistency of the back button ranks very high on my "ios to android" learning curve list.
I'm pretty confused by this statement since a near universal complaint about the Android back button is that it's more like a 'shuffle' button that chooses between going a screen back, going back to the previous app, undoing an action or exiting an app. And there is zero clarity on which of those it will do.
It's a pity that it wasn't marketed/documented appropriately.
The main patent on the 3D touch technology expires on March 3rd 2033. https://patents.google.com/patent/US9772721B2/en
I miss 3D touch with the newest IOS builds. All that said, the discoverability aspect is huge here. It either needed to be built into everything, or nothing. Lukewarm adoption here was a major issue, because it meant that users had to experiment to discover what was actually possible.
https://pocketnow.com/force-touch-android-has-had-that-for-y...
Apple's version is novel and more robust. What doomed both is the uneven implementation across apps, lack of affordance, and differing skill of applying variable force among the population (aka 'hitting the sweet spot') Press and hold fulfills pretty much the same function, though not as elegantly.
As a UX designer, I wouldn't advocate deprecating force touch features but rather, leave them in for advanced users, work on onboarding and affordances, and let the masses 'tap tap tap..' for the same functionality. Imo, there is too much Lowest Common Denominator design out there, and advanced UX shouldn't be eliminated because some people don't get it.
Maybe this comes down to a human brain / body form thing, where the best thing is just to have a simple point-and-click interface because it aligns well with human intuition and natural behavior.
This is still solved, and in a much better way, with the new iOS 13 context menus, which are standardized across every application and are on every iOS/iPadOS device, and have easy APIs for developers to create complex nested menus. I'm not happy about the delay introduced on the new phones, but I think it's an overreaction to suggest that the delay negates the entire concept.
I mean, they might have to use hamburger-menus or menubars (which are functionally equivalent), just like desktop UIs did back when Apple mice only came with a single button! (and this is coming back in style, now that touchpads come with only a single physical "click" action, and no separate buttons) Why can't touch UIs do the same? It works just fine on a detachable tablet PC when running GTK+3 apps, I could easily imagine doing quite involved work there.
The home "button"(actually just part of the screen) in my Galaxy S8 is pressure-sensitive.
I have immersive mode on, so the back, home etc. buttons are normally not visible, which becomes a problem when an app hangs, because you cannot swipe to invoke them.
Enter the pressure sensitive area - one angry push and I'm back to the home screen.