News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @04:37AM (#21079250)
Some potentially interesting uses for it:

- definitive sink to send all of our nuclear waste (it would be the /dev/null of the Solar System)

- gravitational energy generator (limitless, until we have no more mass to throw in)

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by dvdkhlng on Thursday September 26, 2019 @06:04AM (#21079609)
Another idea would be to use the black hole as a gravitational lens to construct a large telecscope. I wonder what the focal length and the effective lense diameter would be. Also the orbital velocity of the image sensor (in orbit around the black hole) might be too high to make this useful.

See also [1].

[1] https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/25498/the-sun-as...

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by Enginerrrd on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:16PM (#21082458)
I can help on this one! In short, it won't work very well. The sun is a much better object to use.

Basically, gravitational lenses don't have a "focal length" per se. It's not an exact analogy to a classic glass lens. There is a minimum distance you need to be away from an object to use it as a g-lens. But as you get further away than that, it'll work better.

Now, the minimum distance you need to be away from the massive object decreases as the mass of the object increases. So for the sun, you'd have to place a camera about 500AU away to use it. That's too far to be practical at our current technology level. For a smaller object like a planet sized blackhole, you'd have to be orders of magnitude further away. Not very helpful!

Now, it's possible I'm mistaken as I'm thinking about some calculations I did on schwarzchild geometry and I didn't consider what would happen very close to the blackhole where curvature is very high, but my intuition says that it won't be very helpful at all.

That doesn't mean the blackhole won't be helpful though!!! I think there's an ENORMOUS number of useful experiments we could do. And, I think blackholes can be used as very powerful computers, possibly quantum ones, but I don't know the details.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by jagger27 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:02PM (#21082287)
Wouldn't you place it at the Sun-IX L1?

Edit: never mind, I just remembered there's a specific distance from a massive object you have to be to hit the focal length sweet spot. I wonder if having a smaller radius makes the focal length shorter?

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by ryan_j_naughton on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:12PM (#21084392)
The concept of waste is a very narrow view of the world and one trapped in our 20th century concepts.

Waste implies we have no use for it any further. This concept views the world on very limited time scales (wherein we can continue to take from the world and turn things into waste that we have no use for any longer).

Instead we should always be thinking about reuse of materials. Waste should never be a terminal state so much as the waste products of one process should be converted into a useful input to something else.

Ultimately with limited materials on planet earth, virtually everything needs to exist in a cycle (water cycle, carbon cycle, etc).

The problem with the blackhole idea is that all atoms / baryonic matter could be used for something. When you send them to a blackhole, they literally cease to exist as baryonic matter (or at a minimum are never usable again). Thus, you are literally taking that material out of use (technically they will eventually be converted into energy as hawking radiation).

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by m4rtink on Friday September 27, 2019 @09:46AM (#21091896)
Exactly - in our universe on a fundamental level all waste is just atoms and elementary particles in the end.

With enough clean & cheap energy nothing really prevents you from reassembling those particles into something useful.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by EricE on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:01PM (#21082933)
Why would you want to throw away "nuclear waste" - we should be burning it! It's only viewed as waste because of politics and ignorance. Instead of stupidly burying it we should be building the various reactors that will easily burn our existing waste - dramatically reducing the overall radioactivity and producing energy at the same time!

All the fear mongering around nuclear power is beyond hysterical at this point :(

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by jorge-d on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:17PM (#21083764)
"Nuclear waste" is a term that is used to describe the byproduct, but also all the equipments that came in contact with radioactive material (cf [0]). So while we can indeed reuse some of the waste on other future nuclear facilities, there will still always be some kind of waste.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste#Low-level_wa...

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by emilfihlman on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:16PM (#21083757)
100% this. Sending nuclear waste to a black hole? Now that's the epitome of stupid.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by hackerpacker on Thursday September 26, 2019 @06:34PM (#21086316)
you must have missed the second bullet point.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by labawi on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:42PM (#21083343)
Personally, I'm also concerned with magnitudes of "low-level" waste, which I believe is not really burnable. Not that it would be reasonable to launch entire reactors and ancillaries.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by sandworm101 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:06PM (#21083603)
If it is still radioactive, it can almost certainly be reprocessed and shoved back into a reactor.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by beefman on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:45PM (#21084117)
Parent is talking about stuff like tyvek suits. Also, steel components like reactor vessels and steam generators. Also, fission products are extremely radioactive and non-burnable. None of it is the least cause for "concern", of course.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by dvdkhlng on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:50AM (#21079552)
I think the most obvious way to utilize a close-to-earth black hole is for space-flight. By utilizing the Oberth effect [1] it is possible to gain extra kinetic energy when firing engines very deep inside the black hole's gravity-well (while performing a sling-shot). The Penrose Process [2] may also allow for some kinetic energy boost.

Unfortunately both effects do not seem to offer the kind of multiple-orders-of-magnitude gain required to make interstellar travel practical.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oberth_effect

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penrose_process

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by beobab on Thursday September 26, 2019 @07:04AM (#21079824)
I'm pretty sure I read a short story about this in an anthology called "Black Holes" by Jerry Pournell back when I was a youngster. In short, the black hole was a "gift" from some advanced race who dropped it into orbit of our star by braking it with Pluto (hence its erratic orbit) for the purpose of interstellar travel.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by m4rtink on Thursday September 26, 2019 @11:15AM (#21081649)
You can use a small black hole for mass transmutation of lighter elements (like all that surplus hydrogen just sitting idly in your local gas giants or star) into much more useful heavier elements (metals, carbon, oxygen, etc.):

https://www.orionsarm.com/eg-article/464790d2497de

The extreme temperatures and pressures in the accretion disk are basically used to fuse the lighter elements together into heavier ones, which are then pulled out by machinery in close orbit.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by networkimprov on Thursday September 26, 2019 @11:43AM (#21082012)
Machinery made of... plasma \o/

Because anything in close orbit is by definition plasma.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by fragsworth on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:29PM (#21082623)
It doesn't have to be that close.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @06:29AM (#21079700)
However if it is a primordial blackhole it is probably not much rotating... thus no much energy to get by the Penrose process.

I thought that just by letting masses getting sucked in while pulling ropes tied to alternators we could generate electricity... is it too naive? The amount of energy given by the fall into the blackhole would be superior than that used to bring the masses there in the first place.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by dvdkhlng on Thursday September 26, 2019 @06:49AM (#21079778)
I don't think that this would work: whoever is holding the alternator would also be pulled into the black hole while generating the electricity.

Maybe the "right" way to convert potential energy is via conversion to heat and black-body radiation in the accretion disk? Might be difficult to capture significant percentage of that energy, though. See also [1]

[1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/astro-ph/0307333v1.pdf

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @07:25AM (#21079921)
I would have started by an orbiting station (or even an orbiting ring-shaped station), staying at a safe distance from the horizon, from which the masses would be droped.

Is it still too unrealistic?

For the radiation energy, it sure makes sense! Moreover isn't it any hard radiations emitted when the hadrons' quarks are torn from each other on reaching the events horizon?

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by petschge on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:12PM (#21082409)
If your station is in orbit, then so is the mass you want to drop into the black hole. Orbital mechanics works quite differently to what you are used to from the surface of a planet.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by raducu on Sunday September 29, 2019 @05:10PM (#21109641)
But the black hole is very small as far as I know, maybe we could build an orbital ring around it, attach alternators to the orbital ring and then feed "ropes" to the alternator one one end and on the other end let them fall into the black hole.

By "ropes" I mean charged particles and by alternators I mean just very powerful electromagnets that can extract the energy of the charged particles falling into the black hole.

My point was that things attached to the outer core of an orbital ring are not in 0 G, but they feel the actual gravity at the particular height the orbital ring is orbiting -- on Earth if you would be sitting on an orbital ring situated at a height of say 300km, you would feel as though you were sitting on a 300km mountain; maybe on a primordial black hole you could build an orbital ring just a few km from the black hole and have spokes going down very close to the black hole (maybe active structures to overcome our current material strength limitations) and let charged particles fall into the black hole and extract their energy as they fall into the black hole.

Or maybe the black hole is small enough that a very crude electromagnets field could just encompass all of the black hole and it could very easily extract all that sweet energy of a charged particle falling into the black hole with an electromagnet an amateur could build in his garage.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @06:13AM (#21079642)
Isn't there some way to stockpile the kinetic energy in several passes, instead of only one slingshot, then finally use all of that for a final throw?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by lukeschlather on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:13PM (#21082432)
Not really. The thing is, you're not so much stockpiling kinetic energy as you are using the mass of the body to amplify the force you apply. There is an optimal time to apply that force, which is when you are closest to the body you are orbiting.

So what may happen is if you have a low-thrust engine, you will do a burn at the optimal time, then stop and wait an orbit until you reach the optimal time again. But you're not "stockpiling" anything so much as you are just thrusting at the optimal time. And once you reach escape velocity you have to keep thrusting, there is no more opportunity to do another pass.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by hinkley on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:13PM (#21084406)
I can't recall which probe, but NASA has used the same body for multiply slingshots. But that's stealing orbital energy from the body you pass in the same direction it's orbiting.

I think the mass of the body only matters in how much momentum it has. If you fly by an asteroid you will deflect its course. You could convert the entire mass of earth into spaceships and slingshot them past Jupiter and it would barely register.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by fsagx on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:27PM (#21082596)
You could make multiple passes, if needed, gaining a + delta V each time by designing the orbit such that the spacecraft is on a transfer orbit back to PBH to make another pass. (If, as guelo mentioned, you did not at some point reach escape velocity of the solar system at that orbit.) It would be a very long wait between passes though...

Seems like a Jupiter gravity assist would always be much more practical.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by guelo on Thursday September 26, 2019 @11:59AM (#21082254)
The limit is the escape velocity of the orbit.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by hinkley on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:18PM (#21084457)
Not if you have time. And three bodies. If you've achieved escape velocity from the 2nd body (eg, Earth) but not the first body (eg, the Sun) you can keep swinging around the 1st body stealing speed off of the 2nd one each time.

Takes some careful orbits and a long time, but NASA does it all the time.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by dvdkhlng on Thursday September 26, 2019 @04:48PM (#21085378)
It would be very cool to have a binary black hole system somewhere in the solar-system. I.e. two black holes in a tight orbit around each other at very high orbital velocities. This could allow for very powerful slingshots to bring probes to interstellar speeds.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by hinkley on Thursday September 26, 2019 @11:00PM (#21088025)
If you have the energy to get to black holes rotating around each other, you probably can build ships that don't need to slingshot. 'Cept perhaps for braking maneuvers.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by eloff on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:16PM (#21082453)
There are much easier ways to deal with nuclear waste. If you could afford to launch it into space, that's really good enough. You can put it on a collision course with the sun, or just into an out of the way orbit around the sun (or even the Earth as long as it doesn't degrade and fall back while still active.)

But really it's easier still to manage it on earth itself. Which is why, even at SpaceX prices nobody does that (that and rockets have a nasty habit of suffering rapid unscheduled dissembly.)

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by skykooler on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:20PM (#21082508)
> You can put it on a collision course with the sun

Counterintuitively, this is far more expensive than launching it into said black hole, or just out of the Solar System all together.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by Symmetry on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:51PM (#21084172)
If you're using a Hohmann transfer, sure. But IIRC a Bi-elliptic transfer will get you on a collision with the Sun for less delta-v than escaping the solar system. That's where you speed up to get high and slow then burn to cut your velocity when there. For ratios of oribital radii over 15 it's more always more efficient than the standard Hohmann transfer and since the ratio is very large in this case it works much better. But in this case you're just trying to get within the radius of the Sun and don't even need the third burn to slow down.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bi-elliptic_transfer

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by fragsworth on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:24PM (#21082564)
I assume you have to "slow down" ~107,000 kmph to fall into the sun, how much do you have to "speed up" to escape?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by tfha on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:23PM (#21083166)
~11 km/s to escape the sun, ~30 km/s to fall into it. Escaping is easier.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by sandworm101 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:09PM (#21083651)
Just getting into the sun isnt enough. The sun's outer layers are not very dense. A blob of uranium might survive long enough to come out the other side, at least on the initial few orbits.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by theelous3 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:50PM (#21084789)
I don't think we have to be very precise. It doesn't really matter if a blob of uranium orbits the sun for a few thousand years.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by skykooler on Friday September 27, 2019 @09:34AM (#21091758)
In that case, why get it into the sun at all? Just put it into an orbit that doesn't intersect Earth.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by ruffrey on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:23PM (#21082554)
Interesting- why is that?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by thebluehawk on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:41PM (#21082719)
Orbital mechanics.

The earth is orbiting the sun at 30 kilometers per second. So if we launched something into space, since it started on earth, it would have that speed (similar-ish to throwing a ball from a moving car). So that object would now also be orbiting the sun at 30 km/s. We would need to slow it down that much in order to "fall" into the sun.

Once something was in earth orbit, it would only take about 12 km/s of delta v (change in velocity) to escape the solar system.

More info and math here: https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/3612/calculating-s...

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by ChuckMcM on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:54PM (#21083469)
Although you could do it with about 17km/s if you put it into a Holman transfer orbit to Venus and used a low flyby and aerobrake maneuver of Venus and that puts you into a flyby of Mercury which changes the orbital plane such that the ellipse intersects the corona.

Sad note that also limits your launch window to once every 113 years as I recall from the last time I did the math :-(.

From a technical perspective you push into an elliptical orbit that intersects Venus, you do a slight aerobreak (skim the surface of the atmosphere) to dogleg toward a Mercury intercept, and then as you pass Mercury it tightens your ellipse still further and you head out, and come back and fly through the outer corona of the Sun (which is its hottest point). At which point you're in a degenerate orbit that will go out and come back through the Sun's corona until you've been completely consumed/burned up.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by mihaifm on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:11PM (#21083041)
Why do you have to slow it to 0 to hit the sun? Can't you just cruise at whatever speed you're cruising and redirect it with thrusters towards the sun?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by dTal on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:16PM (#21083752)
In space (and any frictionless medium), you can't "redirect" an existing velocity vector with thrusters. You can only add a velocity vector. This means that if your desired direction is perpendicular to your current direction, your current speed is no good to you at all. If you're heading due "north" at 10mph, and you want to be heading due "east" at 10mph instead, you have to 1) fully negate your "north" velocity, and 2) come up with 10mph of "east" velocity from scratch.

Now, the trajectory of an object in solar orbit is exactly at right angles to the direction it needs to go in to hit the sun. No part of this velocity is helpful for getting to the sun - in fact it actively prevents it! The only vector that takes you directly into the sun is one with no sideways component - if you imagine yourself falling right in, any sideways nudge will cause you to miss it by a hair and go flinging off into a highly elliptical orbit. If you just ignore this and just thrust directly at the sun, hoping to overpower everything by brute force, then like a ballerina pulling her arms in, the more you try to get close to the sun with your thrusters, the faster your orbit will go; the closer you manage to get, the further out you'll be flung when you inevitably miss.

All this ignores that the sun is not a point, but quite a large ball - you can get away with some small horizontal velocity. A highly elliptical orbit will still do what you want if its lowest point is below the surface.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by rileyteige on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:22PM (#21083156)
Once you're in orbit (say around the sun), you have to cancel the orbital velocity to fall into the object you're orbiting around. If you point at the sun and accelerate 1 km/s directly at it, you're still moving 30 km/s "sideways". All you'd end up doing is making the orbit more elliptical-shaped.

At least that's how I see it, but I am far from being an authority on this topic.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by JshWright on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:56PM (#21084230)
(I mean this in all seriousness)

You should play Kerbal Space Program. It will very quickly give you an excellent intuition for basic orbital mechanics.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by mihaifm on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:29PM (#21085747)
Thanks, I actually have it installed, but never made it through all the tutorials. I'll probably give it another shot, would make it much easier to get an understanding of simple questions like this one.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by kibwen on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:26PM (#21083195)
I'm no rocket scientist but perhaps that would cause the object to shift from the Earth's kinda-circular orbit into a highly-elliptical orbit, its existing sideways velocity (relative to the sun) causing it to be flung past the sun at more of a straight line and hence way out into the solar system instead.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:26PM (#21084537)
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by tux1968 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:26PM (#21083194)
You can but then you're using a lot of propellant rather than gravity to reach your target.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by deepsun on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:17PM (#21083105)
No, once something was in Earth orbit, it would only take 1.7 km/s to escape solar system, per your link.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by 317070 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:35PM (#21082675)
The escape velocity from the sun is 42.1 km/s, while the earth is orbiting at 29.78 km/s. The 29.78 km/s is 3 times closer to the escape velocity than to 0 km/s.

This is the first order approximation reason.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by dmd on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:46PM (#21082784)
Here's a delta-V map of the solar system: http://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by labawi on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:33PM (#21083262)
That seems like a orbit/landing chart. Doesn't seem accurate for head-on collisions. Or am I reading it wrong?

As a counter example, someone mentioned nearly leaving and then cheaply coming back directly into the sun.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by jhrmnn on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:04PM (#21082962)
Interesting! I would have never guessed that starting from Earth, getting to Mars is harder (by about 5%) than escaping the Solar system.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by Agathos on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:57PM (#21083511)
Well, there's "I want to match Mars' orbit around the Sun, so I can orbit the planet," and then there's "I want to intersect Mars' orbit just as the planet is passing through so I smack into its surface and leave a big crater."

The latter takes a lot less delta v, but it has its drawbacks. Leaving the solar system, you don't have to budget for that rendezvous.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by thegagne on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:23PM (#21083162)
Ever been on a merri-go-round?

While spinning it’s hard to get to the center. Once it stops, it’s easy.

The earth is spinning around the sun. To get to the sun, you need to slow down.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by ekimekim on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:37PM (#21082696)
The Earth is moving around the sun at ~30km/s. The escape velocity of the sun is ~42km/s. So if you start from Earth, it only takes 12km/s of change in velocity (called "delta-V" by rocket scientists / KSP players) to leave the solar system, but more than twice that (30km/s) to slow down enough to hit the sun.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by labawi on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:42PM (#21082732)
Can't you use some kind of gravity assist to do the slowdown or adjust the trajectory into the sun?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by Agathos on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:08PM (#21083638)
The Parker Solar Probe is using seven Venus flybys to fly pretty close to the Sun (but not into it).
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by knzhou on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:48PM (#21082798)
You could, but you could more easily use one to escape the solar system entirely.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by jcroll on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:55PM (#21083480)
This Is Why We Don't Shoot Earth's Garbage Into The Sun (Ethan Siegel): https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2019/09/20/this.... Also, is loading nuclear waste onto rockets and shooting them through our atmosphere really that great of idea? Agreed better to deal here with on earth
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by perl4ever on Saturday September 28, 2019 @07:21PM (#21103734)
Quote: "Quite to the contrary, the gravitational pull of the Sun far exceeds the gravitational pull of Earth! The only reason we don't notice it is because you, me, and the entire planet Earth are in free-fall with respect to the Sun, and so we're all accelerated by it at the same relative rate."

That seems off...googling suggests that the acceleration due to the sun at earth's orbit is a tiny fraction of 1G, and conversely, to have an acceleration of 1G would require going well inside Mercury's orbit.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by hinkley on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:03PM (#21084298)
There was an alternative plan to go the other direction.

Load the material into enclosures, bury them hundreds of feet below the sea floor near a subduction zone. Cheaper than rockets, still bloody expensive, and they may be worried about radioactive burps.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by pingyong on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:42AM (#21079512)
>definitive sink to send all of our nuclear waste

That seems like a lot of effort when you can just send it to nowhere and it will very, very, very likely never hit anything, ever.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by chronolitus on Thursday September 26, 2019 @06:19AM (#21079671)
I was wondering about the necessary delta-v to do that vs. throwing it into the sun and found this [1] interesting table.

Quite informative, it seems like the naive approach of going straight into the sun is much more expensive (dv of 24.0 km/s) than escaping the solar system (dv of 8.8 km/s).

But, it seems that there is a trick where you use 8.8km/s to almost escape the solar system, then turn around with very little dv cost and plunge into the sun.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta-v_budget#Interplanetary

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by mnw21cam on Thursday September 26, 2019 @08:54AM (#21080461)
Yes, that's basic orbital mechanics. It takes longer that way though. There are many examples in orbital mechanics where you can trade efficiency for patience.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by mannykannot on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:34PM (#21083269)
The general rule for circular orbits is that the escape velocity is √2 times the orbital velocity.

At no point on the esacape trajectory can the object's speed fall below √2 times that of a circular orbit at that distance (or else the object would not escape.) At whatever distance you decide to set the controls for the heart of the sun, you must kill its angular velocity with respect to the sun (because, if it has more than a slight angular momentum, it will follow an elliptical orbit that goes around the sun.) Therefore, at every point on the minimal escape trajectory, the delta-v to redirect the payload into the sun is the escape velocity at that distance. With your strategy, the cost of sending the payload into the sun asymptotically decreases towards the cost of sending it on an escape trajectory.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by pontifier on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:54PM (#21084212)
I was amazed the first time I heard about the Interplanetary Transport Network.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interplanetary_Transport_Net...

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:44AM (#21079526)
Well, agreed (or you can throw the trash into Sol). And what do you think about the other use, as an energy source?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by pingyong on Thursday September 26, 2019 @07:21AM (#21079902)
That makes me wonder how we would get the energy from there back to earth. I mean we already have a for current purposes infinite energy source right at our doorsteps (the sun), we just need to harvest it.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @07:34AM (#21079949)
It could be used on-place to fill some energy reservoir. Which could be sent anywhere, or also could be used for space travel for example.

Yes I agree that currently a Dyson sphere is the most sensible project humanity could ever think of!!

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by daveslash on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:55PM (#21082878)
Getting nuclear waste off the surface is extremely risky & challenging. Rockets occasionally explode and scatter their payload. Even a 0.01% (1 out of 10,000) failure rate might be considered too high a risk. I think that a lot of people would not take the risk that 1 out of every 10,000 rockets with nuclear waste will explode and scatter the contents into the upper atmosphere.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by MertsA on Thursday September 26, 2019 @08:42PM (#21087334)
Especially high level radioactive waste which is some of the only stuff you might care enough about to worry about a "permanent" solution. The existing nuclear payloads are either RTGs or occasionally fresh fuel that is only lightly radioactive compared to high level waste.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by johndunne on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:06AM (#21079365)
A /dev/null for the solor system would indeed be an awesome feature :) Though the most dangerous part of this would be the risk of loading the material onto a rocket. Sigh.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:42AM (#21079516)
Or maybe very dangerous physics experiments would be arranged to occur in space in a collision trajectory with Devnull, so that it would then be automatically annihilated if it went wrong...

Probably the more interesting use is that of an energy source!

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by qubex on Thursday September 26, 2019 @10:19AM (#21081072)
Let’s set up a petition to name the (hypothetical) primordial black hole at the nether edges of the Solar System “Devnull”!
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by Sir_Cmpwn on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:16PM (#21082452)
Use as a sink has two issues:

- getting nuclear waste out of Earth's gravity well is risky, if the rocket explodes it scatters nuclear waste throughout the atmosphere. And very energetically, given the amount of rocket fuel needed to achieve this kind of flight

- getting to planet 9 (black hole 1?) will require loads of fuel or lots (>100 years) of time. Lots of time for something to go wrong, lots of time for errors in orbital calculations to accumulate, small target to hit

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by frickinLasers on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:22PM (#21084490)
> small target to hit

Extremely small. The paper has a to-scale illustration of the hypothesized black hole.

I wonder what happens to a bus-sized object if you send that black hole through it...

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by nobrains on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:10PM (#21083653)
"definitive sink to send all of our nuclear waste" ... where it would slingshot and return back to earth like a nuclear waste comet
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by sandworm101 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:41PM (#21082725)
>> definitive sink to send all of our nuclear waste

That depends on the orientation of this thing. If it is spinning in just the right way, dumping anything into it would be like activating the death star. Even a week astrophysical jet pointed at earth would be a very bad thing. The last place you want to be standing when feeding a black hole is above/below it.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:44PM (#21084092)
So first things to know when we find it:

- how is the axis (like finding the head of a fluffy shitzu dog)

- how much is it spinning?

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by Scapeghost on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:37PM (#21082693)
> - definitive sink to send all of our nuclear waste (it would be the /dev/null of the Solar System)

Now, black holes probably aren't known to be gateways to other locations, but that comment made me wonder what if they are, and dumping our hazardous waste in them has far reaching consequences somewhere else, then that in turn made me think of what other cosmic-scale consequences of alien technology might be out there.

I mean, if a civilization has planet-spanning tech, their "waste products" could be on the scale of planets too. Somewhere, a species must be burning through solar systems like we're burning the Amazon.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by xurias on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:40PM (#21082715)
Might as well throw it into the sun if you have that much trash. Maybe they got around to building space elevators.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by Scapeghost on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:36PM (#21083281)
I don't mean just literal garbage, but more like side-effects of "exotic" technology that messes with the fabric of space and stuff like that.

Like was it The Three Body Problem or some other story where an alien species’ faster-than-light travel tech causes the universe to expand faster and faster, making it harder and harder for younger species to produce enough energy for FTL.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by ropiwqefjnpoa on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:17PM (#21083762)
I feel that once we have a method to deliver all that nuclear waste to the black hole, we'll then have a process to utilize it instead.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by lliamander on Thursday September 26, 2019 @01:30PM (#21083245)
You want to feed the beast?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @02:32PM (#21083962)
How could you not feed such an adorable tiny creature?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by lliamander on Thursday September 26, 2019 @03:16PM (#21084435)
That's the thing - if you get too close, you can't not feed it!
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Friday September 27, 2019 @02:25AM (#21089023)
He's so irresistible!
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by perseusprime11 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:35PM (#21082674)
If ever there is a space drive that needs to built for Interstellar travel, can we harvest gravitational energy from this black hole to power it?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by fsiefken on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:41AM (#21079506)
how would this sink differ from using the sun as /dev/null - other then that you might disrupt potential stellar consciousness?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by wtallis on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:53AM (#21079562)
It takes substantially more delta V to send a rocket into the sun than to send it out of the solar system entirely. Getting a rocket to a particular object in the outer solar system may take more delta V than either of those options unless you're really patient.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by lmilcin on Thursday September 26, 2019 @11:44AM (#21082038)
That's obviously false. If you send a rocket outside solar system (as in giving it exactly the escape velocity) then you just wait until it's velocity with respect to sun drops close to zero and then just nudge it back directly at the sun. This takes a lot of time of course, but it does not require you more energy than what is required to leave solar system.

I am only picking at you because you mentioned a rocket. If you said "shoot it to burn in sun" then you would be (mostly) right.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by dr_dshiv on Thursday September 26, 2019 @06:46AM (#21079766)
I don't have an intuition for why it is harder to go to the sun than leave the solar system. How do you think about that?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by Atrus6 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @07:42AM (#21079999)
Using dummy numbers. But, lets say you need to be going 100mph to escape the suns gravity. The Earth is moving around the sun at 75mph. So you only need to speed up 25mph to leave.

But to fall to the sun, you need to slow down 75mph. And speeding up and slowing down in space take the same amount of energy.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by theelous3 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @08:49AM (#21080424)
But why do we have to slow down? Can't we aim at sol, such that our velocity doesn't matter?
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by mnw21cam on Thursday September 26, 2019 @08:59AM (#21080487)
That's how an orbit works. If you think about a low orbit around the Earth, you are constantly falling towards Earth and missing, because you are going so fast around it. Likewise, the Earth is constantly falling towards the Sun, but because it is going sideways so fast it keeps going around instead. You say "aim towards sol" - but in order to do that you effectively need to stop going sideways. Once you have done that, it doesn't matter whether or not you are also travelling towards the Sun - you will be soon. That's what we mean when we say that in order to hit the Sun you need to slow down.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by ncmncm on Friday September 27, 2019 @12:54AM (#21088577)
This assumes there is no planet or moon handy to whip around, to end up going in a completely different direction, with no extra energy expenditure.

It is tricky (but possible, with cleverness and a careful schedule) to gain or lose energy this way, but it doesn't matter. If your closest approach is well within the sun's photosphere, it doesn't matter how fast you're going when you get there. So, you can do it with essentially zero delta-v, starting and ending with the same total energy as an object would have co-orbiting with earth, but on an extremely eccentric orbit.

It's not terribly rare (on a geological timeline, at least) for comets to dispose of themselves this way.

Anyway, what is so great about dropping them in the sun? Jupiter swallows comets frequently. Mars is a squalid dump, and so is Venus, at least below the clouds.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by scott_s on Thursday September 26, 2019 @10:38AM (#21081270)
Great explanation. I think many people have the wrong default intuition for what an orbit is. I don't think they realize that it means going so fast that you fall perpetually around an object rather than just eventually hitting the object.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by mirimir on Thursday September 26, 2019 @11:08AM (#21081552)
Stephenson has a great explanation of orbital mechanics in Anathem. Also in Seveneves, but not as detailed, as I recall.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by LandR on Thursday September 26, 2019 @11:05AM (#21081529)
Thanks for a great explanation of this. This idea has never made sense to me until now :)
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by logfromblammo on Thursday September 26, 2019 @11:31AM (#21081863)
The radius of Sol's gravitational influence is much larger than the radius of its coherent mass.

The sun is always at one focus of the elliptical orbit. You just can't get the orbit close enough to plasma-brake near perihelion without also pushing your aphelion way out. So you have to aim away from Sol in order to get there at lower energy. Basically, a Voyager probe that stops at the very edge of the gravity well and then plunges straight down. Spiraling down while decelerating is faster, but costs more energy. But as you get closer, you can harvest energy from the solar wind and solar radiation, with solar sails, so the amount of delta-v you have to load onto the launch rocket does not represent your entire delta-v budget.

There are ways to trade off time for delta-v, but at that scale, the ways that really make a difference mean that the person that sets them in motion will be ancient or dead before they finish.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by dr_dshiv on Thursday September 26, 2019 @08:22AM (#21080234)
THANKS! I got it now :)
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by bogcotton on Thursday September 26, 2019 @07:14AM (#21079870)
In order to get to the Sun rather than just speed past it, you have to decrease your velocity dramatically.

When you're in a stable orbit, you are actually spinning around the sun at a huge pace. To gain enough velocity to leave the solar system, you have to increase that pace by an amount that is less than the pace you already have.

As a terrible analogy, it takes less energy to overtake a car that is travelling in front of you at a higher speed than it does to slow yourself to a complete stop.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by ncmncm on Saturday September 28, 2019 @02:23PM (#21101981)
Not correct. An extremely eccentric orbit has the same energy as some circular orbit. All you need is for the aphelion to be well inside the sun itself, and the sun will take care of turning the energy into raw heat.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @07:37AM (#21079967)
Escape the huge Sun's gravity well, or only escape Earth's gravity well (but stay in Sun's well).
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:51AM (#21079554)
Agreed. Well, Sol consciousness is already disturbed by occasional comets, isn't it? :)

The use as an energy source, however, would even outlast the lifetime of the Sun as a star.

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by Chris2048 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:09AM (#21079376)
There was a story like that called "iHole", but it appears to have disappeared from the 'net..
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by xenophonf on Thursday September 26, 2019 @12:18PM (#21082480)
This is probably what you're thinking of:

https://pastebin.com/ateTJxEK

Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by henearkr on Thursday September 26, 2019 @05:39AM (#21079498)
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by Chris2048 on Thursday September 26, 2019 @07:49AM (#21080033)
I don't think so. It was about a product release by an apple-like corp that was a small personal hole that you could use as a garbage bin.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by ageofwant on Thursday September 26, 2019 @10:55AM (#21081446)
There is no such thing as nuclear waste, just unprocessed fuel. Things that can't be processed can be dumped under 50cm of sand and you build a kindergarten on top of it. It will be a lower radiation hazard than a one hour plane trip.
Re:What If Planet 9 Is a Primordial Black Hole? by kamaal on Friday September 27, 2019 @06:52AM (#21090463)
- That's Jupiter already.

- That's Sun.