News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by apercu on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @08:26AM (#20939273)
<RANT>US expatriates are the only expats in the world that have to file annual taxes (and report foreign bank accounts). It's ridiculous for most of us (99% are not tax exiles or tax evaders, we just left the USA for our own reasons). </RANT>

I wonder if Snowden files taxes?

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by dang on Thursday September 12, 2019 @02:54PM (#20955006)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20939039 and marked it off-topic.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by packet_nerd on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:28AM (#20939897)
Don't even get me started....

In many countries it's hard or near impossible for US citizens to get bank accounts and other financial services, I guess due to them not wanting to deal with reporting requirements? Europeans, Aussies, and pretty much everyone have it way easier. Makes me so mad.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by cynwoody on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @01:30PM (#20942612)
A few years ago, the IRS came after Boris Johnson, then the mayor of London, now the PM, for taxes on the gain from the sale of his house in London. He was born in NYC, you see, making him an American citizen. He ended up paying the tax and renouncing his US citizenship.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertwood/2015/02/15/savvy-lon...

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by buckminster on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @12:25PM (#20941898)
Ha. My ancient mother, who is English, was conducting some mundane transaction in an English bank the other day when the teller asked her "You're not American are you?". She was so surprised she didn't know what to say.

AIUI, it's not just reporting requirements but the potential for massive fines that's driving this.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by rendall on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:31AM (#20939922)
The astonishing thing is that foreign banks are compelled to report your banking activity to the IRS
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by teddyuk on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @08:43AM (#20939431)
Can you give up your american passport and then stop or do you have to do it for the rest of your life?
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by ummwhat on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @08:52AM (#20939513)
It costs over a grand to quit the club known as "citizenship" you're going to want citizenship in wherever you reside first when you give up US citizenship (you could choose to be stateless, but that makes more problems than it solves). Doing this does not absolve you of existing debts in the eyes of the IRS. And finally, you'll be interviewed at the consulate and if your stated reason for giving up citizenship is "the overseas tax thing", you'll be denied a visa if you ever want to visit the US again.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by mathieuh on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:20AM (#20939804)
You can choose to be stateless? I thought I've read in UK media that countries are not allowed to make a person stateless. This is in the context of ISIS fighters with dual-nationality, these people are having their British citizenship stripped.

Caused a bit of a hoohah with the Canadians.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by 317070 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:45AM (#20940120)
IIRC nationality is a human right (article 15) [0], so a state cannot strip you of your last nationality. But, it is only a right, so you can strip yourself of your last nationality and go stateless.

[0] https://www.un.org/en/udhrbook/pdf/udhr_booklet_en_web.pdf

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by InvaderFizz on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @12:33PM (#20941996)
The US will not allow you to renounce without presenting yourself in a embassy in a foreign country and they can choose to not accept your renunciation. However, statelessness is a possibility.

Here is a full rundown of the process: https://www.businessinsider.com/how-to-renounce-us-citizensh...

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by mosselman on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:05AM (#20939652)
Did you actually mean 1.000.000 (a thousand grand) or did you mean 1000.

> you'll be denied a visa if you ever want to visit the US again.

Do you have a source for this?

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by Intermernet on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:07AM (#20939682)
Apparently, you can run for any government office in a foreign state and it immediately nullifies your US citizenship. I have only heard this as rumour, and I don't have time to confirm / deny this, but it may be worth looking into.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by jonwachob91 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:17AM (#20941045)
You don't have to look that hard to find that this is not true.

Boris Johnson (the UK Prime Minister) was a US citizen until sometime in 2016. His UK political office roles until then included serving as a MP (2000-2008), Mayor of London (2008 - 2016), and UK Foreign Secretary (2016 - the time he relinquished his US citizenship). Reports indicate that he gave up his US citizenship to avoid the IRS taxing him.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by justforyou on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:33AM (#20939953)
>> I don't have time to confirm / deny this, but it may be worth looking into.

Then why take the time to post it?

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by mlrtime on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:56AM (#20940250)
Because it is a interesting avenue to investigate if someone wants to know more.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by dymk on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:23AM (#20940519)
Well you’re wrong so there’s that. You can’t give up your citizenship as a result of running for a foreign office.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by justforyou on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @04:04PM (#20944085)
>> Because it is a interesting avenue to investigate if someone wants to know more.

Seems like an assumption about the value of other people's time vs. your own.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by Keverw on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @12:27PM (#20941919)
I've heard of this too. This talks a bit more about it https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/legal/travel-lega... and also https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/legal/travel-lega... that mentions more different ways.

For some cases it sounds like only if you have the intention of giving up your citizenship, then you have to get a "Certificate of Loss of Nationality". But I'm not a expert in this area, but I can see where this idea is coming from.

  Such employment, however, will result in one's 
  expatriation only if done voluntarily with the intention 
  of relinquishing U.S. citizenship. Running for foreign 
  office, even foreign head of state, is not a potentially 
  expatriating act; only accepting, serving in, or 
  performing the duties of a foreign office are potentially 
  expatriating as described above.
  
  The Department has adopted an administrative presumption 
  that U.S. nationals intend to retain their U.S. 
  citizenship when they naturalize as nationals of a 
  foreign state, declare their allegiance to a foreign 
  state, or accept non-policy level employment with a 
  foreign government.
Also:

  The presumption that a person intends to retain U.S. nationality is not applicable when the individual:

  1. formally renounces U.S. nationality before a consular officer;
  2. serves as an officer in the armed forces of a foreign state engaged in hostilities with the United States; or
  3. takes a policy level position in a foreign state
  Cases in categories 2 and 3 will be developed carefully by a U.S. consular officer to ascertain the individual's intent toward U.S. nationality.


Kinda confusing, but sounds like if you were elected prime minister of Canada (which would be policy level), then there's the presumption you wanted to give up citizenship, while working as a employee for the Canadian government such as driving the snow plows would be ok but things are reviewed by case by case.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by yardie on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @08:59AM (#20939579)
You can renounce citizenship. There is a large multithousands dollar "fee" to do so. And if they find out you did so to avoid paying taxes (ex. renouncing citizenship and then turn around to cash out some Bitcoin) they can still go after you for taxes.

Most citizens never hit the threshold to actually pay except if you file from a known tax haven. Income up to $115k is untaxed and any other taxes you do pay are deductible.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by rahimnathwani on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:10AM (#20939714)
"Income up to $115k is untaxed and any other taxes you do pay are deductible."

It's not as simple as it first seems.

If you claim the foreign earned income exemption (FEIE) so you don't pay anything on the first $115k or whatever, then you can't claim a credit for all the taxes you paid in the country where you live. You can only claim a portion.

So, if your income goes up above some certain amount, you're better off (lower US tax bill) giving up the FEIE so you can get a credit for all foreign taxes paid.

But, if you do that, then you can't claim FEIE again within 5 years, unless you get special permission from the IRS. To apply for this permission (with no guarantee) you must pay a fee of a few thousand USD to the IRS.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by lonelappde on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:07AM (#20939680)
It costs about $400 per year in time and money to file a tax return, so a multi thousand $ lifetime exemption seems ballpark good price.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by penagwin on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:20AM (#20939810)
> $400 per year in time and money to file a tax return

That number seems pretty high unless you have very complicated income (in which case you likely have a lot of money too)

Also worth mentioning is that Foreign Income is taxed differently, so while you technically still have to pay taxes, I believe for most people who work mostly in a foreign country don't have to pay very much.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by davidw on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:45AM (#20940728)
> complicated

Yes, like, say, having an accountant that can read and understand your taxes where you live in Italy and then use that information to file US taxes. And of course they'll need to understand the tax treaty between the two countries so you don't end up paying extra. Of course it's complicated and a huge pain in the ass! And that's with a relatively normal, stable, well-established country with a lot of US citizens living in it.

I should add: $400 is also a bigger deal when you live somewhere and don't earn as much as a software developer in the US.

[dead]
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by penagwin on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:14AM (#20951659)
If you're a resident of the US with not too complicated income then this is true.

Working in a different country means you need to know _their_ tax laws, how much you need to pay the US, etc. It becomes complicated quickly, and if you're trying to minimize what you pay in taxes it's another story altogether.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by easytiger on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:10AM (#20939716)
You have to give up your passport. Boris Johnson (UK Prime Minister) did it a couple of years ago.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by mieseratte on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @08:31AM (#20939325)
> US expatriates are the only expats in the world that have to file annual taxes

Did Eritrea cleanup their act?

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by microcolonel on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:02AM (#20939609)
Yeah, it is a bit annoying, and I can imagine it is beyond a bit annoying if you are making income somewhere that doesn't have a treaty with the U.S.

I thankfully don't get double-taxed here in Canada, but I'm pretty sure it's possible to have a marginal tax rate greater than 100% between U.S. Federal income taxes and some other systems.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by navigatesol on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:41AM (#20940069)
>I thankfully don't get double-taxed here in Canada

I bet many of your fellow Canadian taxpayers (of which I am one) are not so thankful for this arrangement. Then again, I fall strictly in the "citizenship is a privilege, not a right" camp.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by icebraining on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:07AM (#20940356)
The no-double-tax scheme means they still pay all their Canadian taxes, it's the US that discounts an amount in their tax calculations.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by microcolonel on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:49AM (#20940765)
> I bet many of your fellow Canadian taxpayers (of which I am one) are not so thankful for this arrangement.

Well, I pay absolutely all Canadian taxes to the full extent, and I can't make use of TFSAs; what do my fellow Canadians have any right to complain about?

> Then again, I fall strictly in the "citizenship is a privilege, not a right" camp.

Well, I am a citizen, and I've lived in Canada my whole life.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by navigatesol on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:10AM (#20950130)
You claimed to be thankful for not being "double-taxed", from which I inferred you're a Canadian, living abroad, "thankfully" not contributing to the roads, schools and hospitals of this country from you which, once can assume, you hope to extract benefit from in the future.

If you're a Canadian who lives in Canada and pays Canadian taxes, there's no controversy.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by microcolonel on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:05AM (#20950475)
> You claimed to be thankful for not being "double-taxed", from which I inferred you're a Canadian

It's not "double-taxed", it's double-taxed. The U.S. system in fact makes it possible for the same income to be taxed twice at the full rate. And you didn't need to infer that I'm Canadian, I said it right in my comment.

I'm thankful I'm covered by the Canadian agreements, which allow me to credit my Canadian tax payments against (most of) my U.S. tax liability. I still have to file taxes in the U.S. like every other U.S. citizen, I still have to file FBARs with FinCEN like every U.S. citizen. I still have to pay Canadian taxes like everyone else who makes Canadian-source income, I still must pay the OHP like every Ontarian, I still must pay into CPP even though I may never be able to take it. Even if I didn't make Canadian-source income I would still be paying property taxes either directly or indirectly, paying sales taxes every time I bought something other than groceries, and that's where the roads and the schools get their money; though because of some combination of my personality and the quality of the schools I never did get more than primary school out of the system here before I left to work and began paying net taxes in my second year of full time employment.

I don't know why you're being so hostile. If somehow this arrangement allowed me to not pay taxes lawfully, how would that be my fault? It would be all of ours.

Frankly it's appalling that they manage to make things cost enough to justify these taxes, especially as every Canadian sees these obscene transfers of wealth from every taxpayer to Bombardier, the leniency extended to SNC Lavalin, the "equalization" process by which unproductive Canadians feast on productive ones for the privilege of living in equal comfort without ever considering moving for work; but I do pay them, you're welcome.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by rahimnathwani on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:02AM (#20939612)
That's not true. Several other countries require that their citizens file annual tax returns, and tax them on their worldwide income.

Why is it ridiculous?

And what makes you so sure that less than 1% of US citizens living outside the US evade tax?

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by typenil on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:15AM (#20939770)
The other countries that tax worldwide income: Libya, North Korea, Eritrea and the Philippines. Great company to be in.

You could call it ridiculous because it’s so unusual. But the reason most countries don’t do it is that taxes are a supposed to be a deal - the government forces you to hand over money and pays for services you use in return. Expats - they aren’t using those services.

And your point about tax evaders is moot - taxing global income only hurts law abiding expats, not evaders. Seems like you’re being hostile and skeptical for personal reasons.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by wrkronmiller on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:31AM (#20939924)
Devils-advocate: The U.S. government still provides expats services such as the State Department, potentially U.S. government intervention to help evacuate citizens from troubled areas etc...
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by thelittleone on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:36AM (#20940004)
So does Australia whilst not taxing on worldwide income.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by davidw on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:51AM (#20940184)
And Canada, Italy, Germany, Norway, New Zealand, France, UK, etc... etc.... do as well without the silly system the US has in place.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by navigatesol on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:06AM (#20940345)
>Canada...do as well without the silly system the US has in place

Perhaps you're forgetting about the evacuation of Lebanese Canadians in 2006, "Citizens of Convenience" and the associated changes in Canadian citizenship laws. It's not without controversy.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by davidw on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:42AM (#20940692)
Canada does not require its citizens abroad to file taxes.

I'm sure there are other controversies and things going on, but that's what we were talking about.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by navigatesol on Thursday September 12, 2019 @06:56AM (#20950044)
>but that's what we were talking about.

This controversy is directly related. You should inform yourself.

Canadian taxpayers spent $100MM evacuating Lebanese Canadians from Lebanon in 2006, many of whom were citizens but had never paid taxes to Canada. We now bill for extrication. Seems like a fair compromise.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by navigatesol on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:45AM (#20940112)
And in what way is that good for or fair to the citizens who contribute to the system that enables you to take advantage of these services?
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by hfdehfddhs on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:59AM (#20940276)
And if you're a Coca Cola employee, that's one of the benefits provided.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by stef25 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:39AM (#20940039)
> The other countries that tax worldwide income

When I declare my taxes here in Belgium the form always asks me if I have any income / assets abroad (I don't). I guess "tax worldwide income" refers to "if you also live abroad" ?

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by davidw on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:50AM (#20940167)
If you're a Belgian citizen, and move to, say, Canada, you'd file taxes in Canada and that'd be the end of it. If I, as a US citizen,move to Canada, I'd have to file and pay Canadian taxes, and file - and maybe pay - US taxes in addition.

What you're talking about is if, living in Belgium, you have income from other countries that needs to be reported, which seems fair enough - after all, you live and pay taxes in Belgium, not those other countries.

[dead]
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by hfdehfddhs on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:05AM (#20940340)
" safe-haven to run to if SHTF"

If S* is hitting the fan, aren't you assuming said expat lives in, to use El Jefe's words, a "S* country"? By conservation of mass, the S* comes from somewhere. Instead, most expats live in W. Europe, Canada, or Japan/Korea. Pretty safe.

" tax avoiding leeches in Silicon Valley don't feel obligated to contribute to the societies from which they extract their wealth"

Well, no. Ppl aren't complaining about paying taxes to the sovereign of where they live, even on their global income. That's another discussion. It's about paying taxes, usually mostly locally earned income, to an entity far away that has no jurisdiction and that provides nothing in return.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by navigatesol on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:11AM (#20940404)
>and that provides nothing in return.

As others have mentioned, your American passport does provide you with services. But if you truly believe it's worthless, why maintain citizenship? To save the fee to renounce citizenship, even though it will save potentially tens of thousands of dollars annually? Doesn't make sense to me.

No, it's a safety measure. And I think people are lucky to have it, at the low cost of some of your tax dollars.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by hfdehfddhs on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @03:16PM (#20943683)
"why maintain citizenship"

In fact I live in the US but haven't applied for US citizenship for this, among other, reasons("passport" being woefully misused word in this context). Anyway, that is a very poor advice since: 1. Most people have one citizenship, including expats (most return). 2. Giving up your US citizenship implies very many more things than not paying taxes. Look up ex-pat type laws.

"American passport does provide you with services" Well the passport surely doesn't. The citizenship might, but I've been an expat all of my life (started bouncing around the world at the tender age of three weeks). I've never used, no one in my family has every used, an no one I know has ever used our rich, Western countries' services [0]

I have used the services of the local police very many times.

"No, it's a safety measure"

The Special Forces aren't on a razor's edge ready to jump and come get you. That's BS from Hollywood. You get in trouble abroad, and yes, you can ask for the local consulate to send someone to see you in jail. That's, in the vast majority of cases, about it. But I try to avoid jail myself.

[0] We're not British. Apparently, Brits get into so much trouble abroad that the Brits have come up with a simple solution: charge the drunk louts for consular services!

EDIT: To be clear, when I move to another country, I take pains to declare that I'm no longer a resident lest I continue being eligible for that country's services.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by literallycancer on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @06:45PM (#20945627)
Safe haven with 5.3 homicide rate?

If you wanted an actual safe haven, you'd chose something like Andorra, Vatican, San Marino, Liechtenstein or Monaco. Those have a homicide rate of 0. Japan with 126 million people has 0.2, UAE 0.5 and South Korea 0.6.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by navigatesol on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:00AM (#20950067)
Go to those countries and get citizenship, then. What's the problem? Oh, it's harder than it looks? I wonder why.

The question no one here answers: why maintain a valueless US citizenship?

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by rahimnathwani on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:34AM (#20939967)
"Seems like you’re being hostile and skeptical for personal reasons."

You made three assertions. One was factually incorrect. One was a matter of opinion, about which I was curious to understand your reasoning. The third seemed like it was unlikely to be true and hard to get data about, so again I was curious.

I'm sorry if my pointing out an untrue statement and asking for more information about others seems hostile.

My personal reason for wanting to point out the incorrect assertion about the US being the only country: https://xkcd.com/386/

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by wil421 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @08:50AM (#20939486)
Why does it matter? My brother in law lived in Costa Rica for 10+ years. He never had to pay a single bit of tax. I know a few people in Europe with higher salaries and they have never paid a cent either.

I’ve yet to meet anyone who lived overseas and had to pay the IRS.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by gwd on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:01AM (#20939598)
> He never had to pay a single bit of tax. I know a few people in Europe with higher salaries and they have never paid a cent either.

He didn't say pay taxes; he said file taxes. Every year I have to tell the US government how much I made, and then explain why I don't owe them any money (i.e., already paid tax on it to the UK). It's a stressful hassle even if you don't end up owing anything.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by wil421 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:09AM (#20939702)
I fully understand.

I’m asking if you ever had to pay taxes? Plenty of people complain about filing paper work but I’ve never met anyone who owed anything.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by gwd on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @10:55AM (#20940823)
I pay taxes to the US (and not to the country I live in) on the small amount of passive income generated in accounts located in the US. I'm not 100% sure if this is the Right Thing to do or not, but it seems fair. But my taxes would be a lot simpler and less stressful if I only had to report this income (and on years where this was 0, not report anything at all).
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by frittig on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:47AM (#20940144)
I had to pay. I have lived abroad for several decades and when I decided to do some independent contracting I realized that now I have to pay social security. Also, while I generally pay more taxes than an American, every once in a while there is a tax break that I get that Americans don't. In that case I have to pay that amount to the US.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by davidw on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:48AM (#20940155)
You end up paying quite a bit to owe 0, because it's not easy to find a competent accountant who can, say, understand your Italian tax returns, and then file in the US based on those.
Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by rahimnathwani on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:13AM (#20939749)
"I’ve yet to meet anyone who lived overseas and had to pay the IRS."

I've met several, and can assure you they exist.

Re:Edward Snowden: Permanent Record by onetimemanytime on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @09:23AM (#20939841)
living and making a living are two different things-- when you make over a certain amount.