News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by saagarjha on Monday September 02, 2019 @04:59PM (#20861733)
Of course, inside the article it’s explained that SpaceX didn’t “refuse” to move the satellite, they were politely asked to do so and declined for reasons the author is unaware of. Possibly because they couldn’t move the satellite or had a higher collision tolerance.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by rrss on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:12PM (#20861800)
> SpaceX didn’t “refuse” to move the satellite

> they ... declined for reasons

"Declined" and "refused" are synonyms. SpaceX did refuse to move the satellite.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by tempay on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:19PM (#20861844)
Refuse does imply a certain level of impoliteness or malice. The article only states that spaceX said they wouldn’t be taking any action and later states

> Krag suspected it could be something to do with SpaceX’s electric propulsion system, which “maybe is not reacting so fast” as the chemical propulsion on board Aeolus.

Not acting because you don’t have choice doesn’t count as refusing.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by ixf on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:28PM (#20861895)
"unable to avoid existing satellites in orbit being entered into" is, in my book, worse than "we just cba"
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by manicdee on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:04PM (#20862908)
You need to update your book to reflect the reality of deorbiting a dead satellite.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by perl4ever on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:27PM (#20861893)
Well, it counts as refusing, but it doesn't have the same connotation as when you omit context.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by a3n on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:17PM (#20862975)
> Not acting because you don’t have choice doesn’t count as refusing.

It does beg the question whether you should be there at all.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by adventured on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:57PM (#20863124)
It doesn't beg that question at all.

By that premise every space organization should shut down. Nothing should ever go up again. What if something went wrong? What if every mission wasn't perfect? What if someone lost control of a satellite or space station (eg Tiangong-1)? What if people died? (NASA, Soviet Space Program)

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by greglindahl on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:57PM (#20863126)
Every deorbiting satellite passes through lower orbits. Many of them passively.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by a3n on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @02:33AM (#20864139)
They are are where they are by choice. It's a de-orbiting exercise. If they can't maneuver where they are now because of their propulsion design, they have the same problem in a normal orbit. So I wonder whether this design enables them to be a good and safe neighbor.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by saagarjha on Monday September 02, 2019 @08:09PM (#20862680)
They are synonyms with different connotations behind them.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by vvanders on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:08PM (#20861777)
The thing is that satellites are planned with a lifespan which can include a fixed amount of fuel for adjustments like this. It's not too hard to attach a dollar amount here.

I'm as big a fan of SpaceX as you'll find but considering they were the one entering an orbit they didn't previously occupy it seems like a pretty lame move on SpaceX's part.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by grecy on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:12PM (#20861798)
I suppose that's going to be a question in the coming years - does someone get the right of way to a given orbit just because they were there first?

Sounds like a fantastic barrier to entry for newcomers who don't have billions lining their pockets.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by phkahler on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:01PM (#20862049)
That is true of all finite resources, from orbits to spectrum to real estate.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by tomjakubowski on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:39PM (#20862228)
Maybe the United Nations (or future world government) could levy an Earth-orbital value tax to ensure orbits are used efficiently.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by mises on Monday September 02, 2019 @08:00PM (#20862633)
This implies that un has jurisdiction over all orbits, which it can't really enforce. Also, good luck getting any kind of int'l tax passed; no one wants to give up that kind of sovereignty. Were I a company, I'd just wait until office changed and whatever treaty this was got torn up to put up my satellites. How could the un enforce this? At the end of the day, policies are enforced with the threat of force in response to non-compliance; fact is, un has precious little of that. The only viable enforcement mechanism would be enforcement by other nations; again, sovereignty issue. Also, what if a nation decides she does not agree to such an agreement?
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by londons_explore on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:11PM (#20861795)
I bet their actions would have been different if they'd known this article would be published.

It puts them in a bad light, and that could impact their ability to get necessary licenses to operate.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by manicdee on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:07PM (#20862920)
Everyone intentionally placing their satellites in VLEO is going to be spending more fuel simply staying in orbit against atmospheric drag than they they will spend on avoidance manoeuvres.

This ESA satellite is in VLEO by design, which means every piece of space junk is going to present a threat to it.

Once ESA has secured funding for their navigation automation project (funding to be decided in November), we should hear nothing more about potential collisions with the endless rain of space junk from megaconstellations.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by sgift on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:12PM (#20861799)
> they were politely asked to do so and declined for reasons the author is unaware of.

So, they refused. That's what that word means.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by Retric on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:20PM (#20861852)
Now it’s true the article used refused, but it does not actually back that up. ESA does not have the authority to tell satellite operateors to do something.

“we informed SpaceX” They where informed of a 1/1,000 risk and declined to take action. Refused implies someone was telling them to do something rather than notifying them of the situation.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by cdubzzz on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:39PM (#20861950)
The "informed" bit really is telling here. It seems to imply that the author knows ESA didn't "ask" for anything from SpaceX. That or the author doesn't actually know what the communication was.

Either way this is sensationalist and worth a flag.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by BurningFrog on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:53PM (#20862012)
Not if they declined because (1) it was impossible for them to do it or (2) they explained it wasn't needed.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by FireBeyond on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:32PM (#20862502)
If 1, they should be absolutely liable for any damages, considering they actively moved INTO the orbit of the ESA weather satellite in the first place (for their own "testing").
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by mcguire on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:02PM (#20862056)
"...they explained it wasn't needed."

Well, somebody seems to have needed to maneuver.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by cdash on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:21PM (#20862141)
So? They have that right, what they don't have a right is to demand someone else take action. Just because one party believes something to be necessary does not actually make it so.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by ClumsyPilot on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:06PM (#20862917)
So they endanger billion dollar satellites and the space station, and not care cause their stuff is cheap?
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by aperrien on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:25PM (#20861880)
> and declined for reasons the author is unaware of.

This is such an incomplete report, it reminds me of the old adage "A lie can get halfway around the world before the truth can put it's pants on."

A proper, less sensational reporter would have waited until they knew why they declined to move the satellite before writing the piece.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by pergadad on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:05PM (#20862072)
The reason the author is unaware of the reason is because SpaceX refused to give a reason. Impotence? Incompetence? Malice? Different risk calculation? Game of chicken? Either way if they throw thousands of satellites into space they can't just say "sorry, tragedy of the commons, everyone else should shoulder the risk we created (& the costs to avoid risk)"
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:14PM (#20862113)
SpaceX might not bother giving comment to random bloggers. Especially on Labor day and regarding what they probably regard as a non-incident. There are probably a lot of such individuals asking for comment on any of thousands of different subjects.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by heavenlyblue on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:32PM (#20862500)
You are blaming someone for speculating by speculating about it yourself.

SpaceX is a company with enough money from grants and a grandiose mission “to save the planet” and they can’t afford a PR release at the right time of the week?

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Monday September 02, 2019 @08:25PM (#20862735)
I'm not blaming anyone for anything. I'm just explaining some additional datapoints might cast SpaceX's actions in a less sinister light.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by heavenlyblue on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:27AM (#20864907)
Yet you are still speculating.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @07:54PM (#20872606)
Ok? I never said it was wrong to speculate. That's all anyone in this thread is doing, and of course that is fine. As it happened, the real story was just that the message never got to the human Starlink operator. SpaceX didn't refuse, decline, whatever, they just didn't see the email. Just goes to show you that our assumptions about these types of things can be wrong.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by scarejunba on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:14PM (#20862115)
Interesting. So if I am the only one to have some information as to why I wanted to move a satellite, you should not publish anything until I tell you why, and so I can simply prevent you from publishing by just not telling you anything. Interesting system.

You could publish that I'm not telling you, but you don't know 'why' I'm not telling you, so that makes you irresponsible too.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by AndrewBissell on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:44PM (#20861974)
Yeah, then all SpaceX has to do is run their usual "we have no comment" playbook and the reporter is left with nowhere to go. Convenient for SpaceX I guess!
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by sanguy on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:25PM (#20862161)
The issue is constellations like StarLink are setup to tolerate some % of failures and still function. They launch in bulk as part of the overall plan.

So this brings up the question - if the value of your satellite is lower do you burn up precious fuel to manueveur around potential collisions? Or do you play space chicken and let the others maneuver around you?

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by Rapzid on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:13PM (#20862400)
Maybe their insurance covers them hitting a satellite Ferrari with their Kia.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by a3n on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:22PM (#20862995)
> with their Kia.

With their electrically propelled Tesla.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by marmada on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:45PM (#20862559)
Either possiblity is bad. If the satellite couldn't move, then we are now putting expensive weather satellites at risk because SpaceX has put fixed obstacles into orbit. Furthermore, other organizations have to shoulder fuel costs disproportionately since only they are moving the satellites. SpaceX doesn't have to do anything.

SpaceX has a higher collision tolerance because their satellite is cheap compared to the expensive weather satellite.

Are we really going to allow private companies to bully public institutions?

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by greglindahl on Monday September 02, 2019 @10:01PM (#20863140)
There are a lot of dead satellites passing through that altitude on their way to a fiery death.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by mises on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:57PM (#20862616)
> Are we really going to allow private companies to bully public institutions?

But on the other hand, should bureaucrats get some sort of celestial "dibs" on certain orbits? In the absence of some other kind of governing body, this is pretty much governed by the law of the jungle. Would you have the same objection if SpaceX had this issue with another company, or are you granting europe some kind of deference because of government?

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by jacquesm on Monday September 02, 2019 @08:24PM (#20862728)
> But on the other hand, should bureaucrats get some sort of celestial "dibs" on certain orbits?

Yes.

> In the absence of some other kind of governing body, this is pretty much governed by the law of the jungle.

No, we have space treaties.

> Would you have the same objection if SpaceX had this issue with another company, or are you granting europe some kind of deference because of government?

Obviously, that is not in question, it just happens to be ESA this time, it could be NASA then next, or the ISS. Stuff that was already there was not put there with the likes of SpaceX in mind and therefore it is up to the newcomer to accommodate the incumbents. Satellite reaction mass is a severely limited resource.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by mises on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @07:03AM (#20865363)
> Yes.

Why?

> space treaties

Which cover some public entities and no private ones.

> there first

But SpaceX was in a different orbit, and felt fine. If it's the europeans had a lesser tolerance for close passes, why should SpaceX move?

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by marmada on Thursday September 05, 2019 @03:21PM (#20889908)
Yes because things like European weathers satellites serve the public interesting and vital infrastructure needs (GPS, for example). Those have higher priority over a private corporation's satellites.

> If it's the europeans had a lesser tolerance for close passes, why should SpaceX move?

Did you read my first comment? I said that of course SpaceX would have a lower collision tolerance because there satellite is much cheaper/less investment of resources compared to the EU satellite.

Even if SpaceX's satellite was also expensive and SpaceX still had good data, we should prioritize the needs of public institutions that are launching satellites that serve the world over private corporations.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by mises on Thursday September 05, 2019 @05:03PM (#20890621)
> serve the public interesting

Define public interest. People pay through this through taxes; not really different than paying for spacex whatever via $$.

> less investment

So if SpaceX can do it better, maybe get the bureaucrats and the three-letter alphabet-soup agencies out of the sky, already.

> prioritize the needs of the public institutions

Public institutions have needs and wants. Why is this a need and not a want? This wasn't a military satellite. Why are bureaucrats more important? They accomplish little of significance or merit.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by pergadad on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:09PM (#20862094)
SpaceX refused to give a reason. So you can guess: Impotence? Incompetence? Malice? Different risk calculation? Game of chicken?

Either way, if they throw thousands of satellites into space they can't just say "sorry, tragedy of the commons, everyone else should shoulder the risk we created (& the costs to avoid risk)".

Will SpaceX wilfully endanger other satellites (most of which are of higher cost & societal value than an individual SpaceX constellation satellite)? If so, maybe NASA should stop allowing their launches until they offer a better answer.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by oh_sigh on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:49PM (#20862578)
These are an awful lot of leading questions for basically a breaking story with only one sided information.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by Rapzid on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:55PM (#20862308)
I think a major topic missed is this 1 in 1000. I think the only chance involved in this, practically speaking, is that the ESAs data about the orbits had enough error in it to not be sure there would be no collision.

This is a lot different than rolling dice or betting on black. Likely there was or was not going to be a collision; run it 1 million times and the results would always be the same. Perhaps Space-X had more optimistic odds.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by FireBeyond on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:33PM (#20862508)
And yet ESA's risk model said "Move the satellite if the odds are less than 1:10,000". Easy enough for you to say when it isn't your $2.3B satellite, I suppose.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by greglindahl on Monday September 02, 2019 @10:03PM (#20863154)
Do you think everyone agrees on those odds? There are other organizations that model collisions and they usually disagree.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by ricardobeat on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:18PM (#20861843)
In addition:

> the satellites, each weighing 227 kilograms, are “capable of tracking on-orbit debris and autonomously avoiding collision.” But for this incident, this system does not seem to have been used for some reason

"does not seem to have been used" - if SpaceX made no statement we can't really tell? Maybe they were confident that their collision avoidance would simply work.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by FireBeyond on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:35PM (#20862520)
They were testing their "deorbiting maneuvers". Probably got annoyed that they'd have to restart testing.

> Maybe they were confident that their collision avoidance would simply work.

Just like Tesla's? If your satellite is worth $100K and the other one is worth $2.3B, perhaps you have a little less to lose.

Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit... by ricardobeat on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @04:56AM (#20864769)
I’m pretty sure they’d have a lot more to lose by intentionally causing a crash, right before launching a whole constellation of the same satellite.